Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that some people just don't get poverty?

555 replies

Ohsoworried · 24/04/2022 22:04

I've seen a few posts recently where people earning a fair bit of money (think around 100k a year) are complaining that they're struggling with money, don't have enough etc. I DO understand that it is all relative but equally, for people like me on a low low wage, in insecure housing, wondering how I'm going to pay rent, having to stop paying in to my pension for the extra £30 a month etc it does make me cringe a little. Things are a little better for me at the moment but it has been hard and my secondment is up soon so back down to low pay. When I left my abusive ex I was living in poverty. And when I mean poverty I mean in a refuge, no job because I had to relocate, no money for a deposit to rent etc. It's the choice between being able to downsize your house, not go on holiday for a couple of years, make sacrifices but still live comfortably etc, compared with not knowing if you'll be able to afford your bills. Of course I'm generalising and I'm sure there are people out there who are genuinely on high wages but have high mortgage payments etc who are struggling. I do sympathise. But I don't always think this is the case...

OP posts:
FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 09:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Duplicate post

sueelleker · 26/04/2022 09:38

@Fizbosshoes; I always think of this quote by Terry Pratchett.
www.goodreads.com/quotes/72745-the-reason-that-the-rich-were-so-rich-vimes-reasoned

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 09:37

This reply has been withdrawn

Duplicate post

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 09:36

This reply has been withdrawn

Duplicate post

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 09:36

This reply has been withdrawn

Duplicate post

forinborin · 26/04/2022 09:35

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:21

Besides, I can't believe I'm ever getting into this. Are people seriously arguing that the only people living in poverty in the world are destitute in Africa and everyone else is lucky?

No, not only in Africa, there are many more locations in the world with a similar, or worse, conditions.

The OP complained about how unempathetic "rich" British people are to her and not understanding her struggles, and my (and other posters) point was that people like her are similarly not understanding the struggles of many, many people around the globe who are light years away from her lifestyle.

Ironically, the thread got flooded by posters stating that it is a false equivalence as they were lucky to be born in a 6th rich country and therefore deserve better just by the virtue of the birthplace lottery. And in any case, they have it worse than everyone else.

forinborin · 26/04/2022 09:31

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:21

Besides, I can't believe I'm ever getting into this. Are people seriously arguing that the only people living in poverty in the world are destitute in Africa and everyone else is lucky?

No, not only in Africa, there are many more locations in the world with a similar, or worse, conditions.

The OP complained about how unempathetic "rich" British people are to her and not understanding her struggles, and my point was that people like her are similarly not understanding the struggles of many, many people around the globe who are light years away from her lifestyle.

Ironically, the thread got flooded by posters stating that it is a false equivalence as they were lucky to be born in a 6th rich country and therefore deserve better just by the virtue of the birthplace lottery.

forinborin · 26/04/2022 09:31

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:21

Besides, I can't believe I'm ever getting into this. Are people seriously arguing that the only people living in poverty in the world are destitute in Africa and everyone else is lucky?

No, not only in Africa, there are many more locations in the world with a similar, or worse, conditions.

The OP complained about how unempathetic "rich" British people are to her and not understanding her struggles, and my point was that people like her are similarly not understanding the struggles of many, many people around the globe who are light years away from her lifestyle.

Ironically, the thread got flooded by posters stating that it is a false equivalence as they were lucky to be born in a 6th rich country and therefore deserve better just by the virtue of the birthplace lottery.

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:28

Seriously, someone street homeless for years could just decide to become a doctor one day and do it?

My very middle class A* student daughter wants to be a doctor, we've been looking into it and only 25% of applications to medical school get places. Maybe it's street homeless getting the other 75% of places?

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:28

Seriously, someone street homeless for years could just decide to become a doctor one day and do it?

My very middle class A* student daughter wants to be a doctor, we've been looking into it and only 25% of applications to medical school get places. Maybe it's street homeless getting the other 75% of places?

JustAnotherPoster00 · 26/04/2022 09:22

DownNative · 26/04/2022 08:47

Speak for yourself! Disabled people are not a monolith , including in this experience. As a person with a lifelong disability, I had no problem getting DLA at 16and my transition to PIP wasn't a problem. My PIP has just increased recently too.

I really don't see the dehumanising or danger here. In fact, I worked out I've received more money under the Conservatives than I ever did under Labour. As a result, I now have at least 6 months worth of emergency savings as savings recommended by Martin Lewis.

I think most disabled people are able to claim without much bother. Especially since most have lifelong conditions that won't change. Rest are in employment Like myself.

Demonstrably false

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/dwp-pip-disabled-benefit-uk-b2009256.html

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:21

Besides, I can't believe I'm ever getting into this. Are people seriously arguing that the only people living in poverty in the world are destitute in Africa and everyone else is lucky?

forinborin · 26/04/2022 09:20

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:13

Anyway, back to my question. Do you describe someone living on the street with almost no possessions and no money as living in extreme poverty? And if not, then who is?

Yes, this is extreme poverty. But I would argue this is through choice rather than necessity. If tomorrow one of them suddenly decided to turn their life around and become say a software developer or a doctor, there's a clear way how they could do that and they will be supported at every step of the way.
There's no such chance for a bright kid from an African village.

What you describe (completely free managed shelters, free to come and go) is exactly what they do in Germany, I think. And there's still street homelessness.

DownNative · 26/04/2022 09:19

Most countries in Africa have between 25% and 50% of the population in extreme poverty. Some have up to 75% in extreme poverty.

Europe? Between 0.01% and 1% of the population is classed as in poverty. Statistics show that there's no extreme poverty in Europe like there is in Africa.

The West has various measures which African countries don't have due to being in debt to us.

DownNative · 26/04/2022 09:19

Most countries in Africa have between 25% and 50% of the population in extreme poverty. Some have up to 75% in extreme poverty.

Europe? Between 0.01% and 1% of the population is classed as in poverty. Statistics show that there's no extreme poverty in Europe like there is in Africa.

The West has various measures which African countries don't have due to being in debt to us.

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:13

Anyway, back to my question. Do you describe someone living on the street with almost no possessions and no money as living in extreme poverty? And if not, then who is?

DownNative · 26/04/2022 09:13

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 08:47

And there's absolutely no way out of this street poverty?
Apparently not.
We see the same faces year after year and they die something like 40 years younger that average.
Are you saying these people ARE NOT in extreme poverty?
And if not, what do you describe as extreme poverty?

Look again at the chart I posted showing where extreme poverty is located in the world today.

It's not surprising it's located in the African continent.....is it? Those countries are in debt to us and cannot adequately help their own poor as a result.

The poor we have in the West do have options those in Africa don't have.

Due to the high social cost of homelessness, right across Europe there are programmes and initiatives to tackle homelessness. This is not the same on the African continent.

It's better to be poor in Europe than in African countries. That's a reality borne out by statistics.

It shows poverty is NOT the same anywhere.

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 09:10

Not that work for them, no. They just can't manage the life admin it takes.
My view if that we should just provide free homes for these people. Build blocks of studio flats, the 24 hours reception, no bills. So they have shelter. Instead we try to force them into managing rent and bill payments, skills interviews etc. A minority of people just can't do it.

forinborin · 26/04/2022 08:55

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 08:47

And there's absolutely no way out of this street poverty?
Apparently not.
We see the same faces year after year and they die something like 40 years younger that average.
Are you saying these people ARE NOT in extreme poverty?
And if not, what do you describe as extreme poverty?

Is that because there's genuinely no way out? No shelter programmes, no welfare support, no training opportunities?

I know a few people who professionally work (-ed) with homeless. They all seem to be of an opinion that it is not a problem that is solved by throwing money at it, and that it will persist in the richest of societies.

DownNative · 26/04/2022 08:47

JustAnotherPoster00 · 25/04/2022 15:26

There are many benefits for disabled people if they claim all they are entitled to and rightly so.

To the pp who posted this nonsense, because of people with similar viewpoints as yours decided that unless your head was hanging off and youre either terminal and non verbal (which if you ask the DWP you will get better) claiming disability benefits is a demoralising and de humanising experience, you clearly have no idea what having a disability is like and clearly have no idea how lethal being disabled in Tory UK is

Speak for yourself! Disabled people are not a monolith , including in this experience. As a person with a lifelong disability, I had no problem getting DLA at 16and my transition to PIP wasn't a problem. My PIP has just increased recently too.

I really don't see the dehumanising or danger here. In fact, I worked out I've received more money under the Conservatives than I ever did under Labour. As a result, I now have at least 6 months worth of emergency savings as savings recommended by Martin Lewis.

I think most disabled people are able to claim without much bother. Especially since most have lifelong conditions that won't change. Rest are in employment Like myself.

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 08:47

And there's absolutely no way out of this street poverty?
Apparently not.
We see the same faces year after year and they die something like 40 years younger that average.
Are you saying these people ARE NOT in extreme poverty?
And if not, what do you describe as extreme poverty?

forinborin · 26/04/2022 08:31

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 08:14

Extreme poverty isn't located in Europe.

I disagree.
I volunteer at a soup kitchen for on street homeless. Would you not describe living on the streets in the middle of winter, owning nothing more than the contents of a small bag and with zero money extreme poverty? I would.

And there's absolutely no way out of this street poverty? No government programs to support homeless, no way of getting free housing or education if they wish so, no welfare system, no volunteers in the society who can afford to spend their time in soup kitchens instead of working every hour under the sun for money to feed their own children?

forinborin · 26/04/2022 08:25

You can’t compare the 6th richest country in the world to a developing one.
In the same way as you cannot compare the income level of someone who spent a decade getting professional qualifications vs someone who was solidly on drugs with a couple of criminal convictions by the end of secondary school. My sympathy goes to a teacher in an African village, to be honest, rather than to some poor people I met in the UK. In general, I find the sense of entitlement to something just because due to a random draw of luck you were born on a certain territory quite bizarre.

DownNative · 26/04/2022 08:25

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 08:14

Extreme poverty isn't located in Europe.

I disagree.
I volunteer at a soup kitchen for on street homeless. Would you not describe living on the streets in the middle of winter, owning nothing more than the contents of a small bag and with zero money extreme poverty? I would.

No, that's just rhetoric. What I posted is actual evidence of where in the world extreme poverty is located.

Europe and other Western countries are in green for a reason.

Africa, where extreme poverty truly exists, is NOT in green apart from one country north of the Sahara.

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 08:14

Extreme poverty isn't located in Europe.

I disagree.
I volunteer at a soup kitchen for on street homeless. Would you not describe living on the streets in the middle of winter, owning nothing more than the contents of a small bag and with zero money extreme poverty? I would.