Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that some people just don't get poverty?

555 replies

Ohsoworried · 24/04/2022 22:04

I've seen a few posts recently where people earning a fair bit of money (think around 100k a year) are complaining that they're struggling with money, don't have enough etc. I DO understand that it is all relative but equally, for people like me on a low low wage, in insecure housing, wondering how I'm going to pay rent, having to stop paying in to my pension for the extra £30 a month etc it does make me cringe a little. Things are a little better for me at the moment but it has been hard and my secondment is up soon so back down to low pay. When I left my abusive ex I was living in poverty. And when I mean poverty I mean in a refuge, no job because I had to relocate, no money for a deposit to rent etc. It's the choice between being able to downsize your house, not go on holiday for a couple of years, make sacrifices but still live comfortably etc, compared with not knowing if you'll be able to afford your bills. Of course I'm generalising and I'm sure there are people out there who are genuinely on high wages but have high mortgage payments etc who are struggling. I do sympathise. But I don't always think this is the case...

OP posts:
50ShadesOfCatholic · 27/04/2022 05:20

SideEyeSally · 27/04/2022 00:30

People in the UK have no concept of poverty. Even for the poorest your children have free access to education, health care, a roof over their head, clean water and will never starve even if the food comes from food banks. The poorest in the UK live a life of unimaginable luxury to a huge chunk of the world population and yet they complain on a website accessed by their little hand held computers about how bad they have it in comparison to those in the UK on higher incomes.

That is very far from the truth. Hundreds of thousands of people do not in fact have a roof over their heads, but move from shelter to car and so on. Food instability is huge, the fact that you are unaware of this speaks to your ignorance rather than any fact. And no, not all children have access to education or healthcare, you can’t get either of those things if you’re moving constantly or not have no one to take you.

maybe read up a little before you make such wild claims.

SideEyeSally · 27/04/2022 00:30

People in the UK have no concept of poverty. Even for the poorest your children have free access to education, health care, a roof over their head, clean water and will never starve even if the food comes from food banks. The poorest in the UK live a life of unimaginable luxury to a huge chunk of the world population and yet they complain on a website accessed by their little hand held computers about how bad they have it in comparison to those in the UK on higher incomes.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 26/04/2022 23:39

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 23:27

Or they completely understand your situation and reasoning and stated they had to do things differently as a result. They didn't say we are in poverty and have to change our cars to economy. This is the thing. People who state their issue, struggle or changes they had to make due to costs doesn't equal they are saying they're in poverty or their issues outweigh yours or you don't have it as bad as them... You can completely understand someone's reasoning and give your own experience with a situation without it being a slight against your circumstances.

What should they have said back? Clearly it was a discussion between you all and their situation is different but they made changes not that they're worse off than you.. I can't see what they said was wrong by giving their own perspective during the conversation.

This sums it up really. So many people unable to listen, they just want to talk about how they would have managed better.

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 23:27

Or they completely understand your situation and reasoning and stated they had to do things differently as a result. They didn't say we are in poverty and have to change our cars to economy. This is the thing. People who state their issue, struggle or changes they had to make due to costs doesn't equal they are saying they're in poverty or their issues outweigh yours or you don't have it as bad as them... You can completely understand someone's reasoning and give your own experience with a situation without it being a slight against your circumstances.

What should they have said back? Clearly it was a discussion between you all and their situation is different but they made changes not that they're worse off than you.. I can't see what they said was wrong by giving their own perspective during the conversation.

Ifeelsuchafool · 26/04/2022 23:20

YANBU I am 62 years old and, as a result of a long marriage to a knob who didn't want me to work when the children were small and then left when they became teenagers, leaving me in my early 50s, I, having not worked outside the home for nearly two decades (used to do the knob's books and general admin for his sole trader business) found myself in the position of only being able to secure low grade administration jobs and, at the age I was, not finding any employer willing to train me or help me to maximise my chances of advancement. I now find myself still on only £20000 per year which I supplement by working a second job at the weekends to bring my income up to around £23000. I have RA and Fibromyalgia and have been unable to afford to have any heating on at home since the end of February. I have recently given my notice on my present job as, though I absolutely love it and it is my dream job in many ways, I can no longer afford the long commute which is about to become even longer as the office is relocating next month. When asked my reasons for leaving I cited the fact that I couldn't afford to take on board the move as I am struggling to pay the bills as it is and both my line manager (Company Director) and the HR Coordinator in the meeting immediately said that they "understood completely" as they had had to turn their cars onto economy mode which was something they'd neither of them ever had to consider doing before this massive uplift in fuel costs. I sat there totally gobsmacked, not knowing how to react to their idea of "complete understanding". I just went home, put on several layers of clothes, filled a hot water bottle and cuddled under a blanket to read my book by candle light as usual!

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 22:46

People in poverty wouldn't have the option to spend money on life saving medical treatment, so there's the difference right there.

That's why I put the part in about if they didn't have the money for the medical treatment the person would be dead and they'd still have just as much to live off but you just pick out the parts you like to try and prove your point instead of reading the whole post.

yes, I can make a blanket statement

Knock yourself out. I've tried to explain some variables as simply as I can for those having trouble working out why people who are well off in their mind may not really be depending on their situation and circumstances. But along comes the competition of life again where people are trying to prove they had it worse than the last poster.

Those people who post about not being able to afford a holiday this year or are struggling to pay extra curricular activities don't say they're in poverty. I've never seen it mentioned by these threads about struggling that they're labelling themselves in poverty. They've been accused of that on this thread.

5128gap · 26/04/2022 22:37

WTAFhappened123 · 26/04/2022 22:08

It’s all relative though. You still have to pay your rent or mortgage/gas/electric which has all gone up - if you live in a bigger house this still means your bills have gone up above the cost of wages rises and inflation. those that live within their means are suddenly finding that this is becoming impossible because the cost of living rise affects everyone!
my husband is in the high earning tax bracket but is now £85 a month worse off for NI, our utility bills has gone up by £200 a month and our weekly shop at tesco as gone up by £20 a week (we aren’t splurgers). We don’t get a takeaway on Saturday anymore but I know people on universal credit who are still taking kids to McDonald’s after school which we feel we can’t afford to do at the moment… you can’t tar one set of earners with one brush

If your H is the sole earner and has only just squeezed into the higher bracket, maybe. But the OP is talking about £100k salaries, which should be able to easily absorb an extra £3600 per year costs without tipping into poverty. You would have to be servicing a very high level of over indebtedness or have incredibly poor financial literacy if you couldn't afford McDonalds on that income.

BeerLoas · 26/04/2022 22:30

Empathy is different to what’s being expressed by some on this thread which is unless you’ve lived it you can’t know.

Believeitornot · 26/04/2022 22:26

BeerLoas · 26/04/2022 22:24

there’s lots of reasons why Rishi shouldn’t be chancellor but just because he has never known poverty isn’t one of them. And to be clear people on £100k aren’t struggling, relatively or otherwise. They have made choices that are making them struggle.

It is relevant if he isn’t able to empathise with those in different situations. For someone who claims to be interested in facts and data, he’s very ignorant.

Pinkfluff76 · 26/04/2022 22:25

I hear you and get what you’re saying and agree with you, but… there seem to unfortunately be plenty of poor people who have enough money for sky, Amazon prime, getting their hair, nails and eyelashes done. They give very poor people a bad name.

BeerLoas · 26/04/2022 22:24

there’s lots of reasons why Rishi shouldn’t be chancellor but just because he has never known poverty isn’t one of them. And to be clear people on £100k aren’t struggling, relatively or otherwise. They have made choices that are making them struggle.

Herbarium · 26/04/2022 22:22

well people keep voting for this, opining that we 'don't have a viable opposition'.

I am not a true fan of labour, but ffs!

strange how most of us in the 90's managed really well, eh?

I think we need to change things up. What on earth have these cunts offered us or given to us in 12 long years of utter SHIT?

MummyGummy · 26/04/2022 22:19

This is exactly why someone worth £400 million should not be chancellor. How on earth can they have any understanding of what it’s like for people in this country living in poverty if those on £100k struggle to.

lightand · 26/04/2022 22:12

No they dont op.
I was on a thread this week. By the way the woman was talking I knew she was reasonably well off, and also someone who "wasnt getting it".
She was saying "Britain will be ok because as a country, we have more money to buy food than poorer countries.
Completely not cottoning on that, so what if the price is too high for some of British citizens to be able to afford the higher prices? She just couldnt see the problem.

WTAFhappened123 · 26/04/2022 22:08

It’s all relative though. You still have to pay your rent or mortgage/gas/electric which has all gone up - if you live in a bigger house this still means your bills have gone up above the cost of wages rises and inflation. those that live within their means are suddenly finding that this is becoming impossible because the cost of living rise affects everyone!
my husband is in the high earning tax bracket but is now £85 a month worse off for NI, our utility bills has gone up by £200 a month and our weekly shop at tesco as gone up by £20 a week (we aren’t splurgers). We don’t get a takeaway on Saturday anymore but I know people on universal credit who are still taking kids to McDonald’s after school which we feel we can’t afford to do at the moment… you can’t tar one set of earners with one brush

pixie5121 · 26/04/2022 21:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

pixie5121 · 26/04/2022 21:36

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

SecretVictoria · 26/04/2022 21:21

Kendodd · 25/04/2022 08:51

Oh and the other thing that pisses me off is when posters complain others aren't poor enough. Example the care worker who buys herself s takeaway coffee. Loads of posters than insisting that's her problem right there. If she didn't speak £3 twice a week on a cappuccino she wouldn't be poor. It's a fucking cup of coffee! What do you want? For the people who do these jobs to have absolutely nothing except bread and water.
Poverty in the UK is absolutely shameful and we shouldn't but up with it. Instead it seems we're grateful for food banks when we should be demanding the end of such levels of poverty.

God, my mum was like this. Our family were never well off by any stretch. However, my parents were gifted 50% of the purchase price of their first house by my DGM from my DGD’s life insurance. Now, to be fair, they did still struggle in the early years of their marriage but my DM especially would NEVER acknowledge that this was a huge leg-up for them.

I was in crappy paying jobs forever and really couldn’t afford to rent even in my shitty hometown. DM would say things like “Well, if you gave up having your nails done…”. Like, yeah I’m sure that £30 per month (roughly - it was a long time ago now) would have gone so far helping me save a deposit for a 2 bed terrace; about £60k so would have needed to spend nothing for 20 years to be able to get a 10% deposit. It’s like she thought I didn’t deserve to spend my wage on anything that just gives you a little smile for a while.

I didn’t go to uni as they couldn’t afford it and the loan wouldn’t have covered my costs. I was in a bit of a weird paradox with them (parents) that I was only allowed to do certain jobs, while they’d moan at me asking for money 🤔. When I was about 13 my friend asked me if I wanted to waitress for her relatives catering company; my dad refused as it was ‘illegal’ 🙄and got me a paper round instead. So while my friend was earning about £30-£40 pw (a fortune in the early 1990s), I was getting about a tenth (seriously) of that. So by the time we’d have been going to uni, everyone already had more experience in the type of jobs students typically get.

I moved away ten years ago, but unfortunately redundancy forced me back. We live comfortably now, but only because DH had a decent salary and now has a good pension. My wage is less than his pension. I can only afford to get to work because he subsides my fuel and parking (work shifts 30 miles away so have to drive, employer does not provide parking).

I dread losing my job, as there is very high unemployment here with no career jobs to speak of. I’m also restricted and can’t do manual work due to an accident a few years ago. We’d have to move somewhere else for me to be able to find work. Again, not possible for the vast majority in low-paid roles.

5128gap · 26/04/2022 21:07

While no one is suggesting that people with high incomes have perfect lives, there are vanishingly few problems that can't be resolved or considerably eased if you throw enough money at them. Few of us sail through life without suffering bereavement, health problems, relationship issues, dashed hopes. Money helps to manage these issues, while poverty exacerbates them.

Grrrrdarling · 26/04/2022 20:51

YANBU. Some people really don’t understand what actual poverty is & will never experience it.
They will claim to be ‘poor’ or ‘on the verge of poverty’ despite having 2 cars, going on holiday a few times a year, having a secure roof over head & no worries as to where their next meal is coming from or how they are going to pay their bills but in these cases their view of what poverty is is based on their experience. They think poverty/being poor is having less than £5000 in the bank at the end of the month & that is not even adding their savings, that they never touch.
What people can do though is not judge others & do what they can to support community projects that help those less fortunate than themselves.
I have a friend who was literally sobbing down the phone to me as to how much her & her partner were struggling financially one week then the next they had booked & paid for their wedding, booked & paid for their honeymoon, booked 2 other holidays for later in the year ‘so they had something to look forward to’ while they were struggling financially & they were still putting £1000 a month into their savings!
Clearly her idea of struggling financially is very different to mine.
At the moment if I have 50p left after paying my bills & buying food I’m doing good. Already sacrificing trips out in the car & only did a trip to the cinema over the half term as I had a free ticket. We are struggling but we are not poor things are just tight right now.

707smile · 26/04/2022 20:21

Kendodd · 26/04/2022 08:14

Extreme poverty isn't located in Europe.

I disagree.
I volunteer at a soup kitchen for on street homeless. Would you not describe living on the streets in the middle of winter, owning nothing more than the contents of a small bag and with zero money extreme poverty? I would.

Yes exactly or families unable to eat or heat food... there definitely is absolute poverty in the UK.

venus7 · 26/04/2022 20:03

Oblomov22 · 25/04/2022 07:36

Some of the people who experience poverty, not all, have made very bad choices. They need to take personal responsibility for that.

Just as an example, Yesterday there was a thread from a woman complaining that banks give credit cards to people too easily and saying by aged 21 she spent 6K credit card, on fancy clothes and going out drinking. That's her choice. Why should a 21 year old who didn't do that feel ashamed of the fact they themselves didn't make those choices?

Not all poverty....actually most poverty...is not caused by debt.

venus7 · 26/04/2022 19:50

BritWifeInUSA · 24/04/2022 23:40

Of course some people don’t “get it”. They’ve never had to. Just as others have never had to ”get it” what is like to be childless-not-by-choice, widowed in their 20s, paralyzed, deaf, facing terminal illness. And many more. Yet there seems to be an extra level of vitriol reserved for those who’ve never experienced poverty (usually through no “fault” of their own) than there is for those who have never experienced many of life’s other hardships.

It’s not my fault you have less money than me. Just as it’s not your fault I can’t have children. Money isn’t everything. Please don’t be so shallow to assume those of us on high salaries are happier or have a better life than you. It’s not necessarily the case. There are some things no amount of money can buy.

But poverty can be changed; there are things that could be done, other policies which could be undone, whereas infertility, illness, bereavement are part of life, not a result of government.

venus7 · 26/04/2022 19:47

Ohsoworried · 24/04/2022 23:36

Tone deaf post

I like you OP; you understand.

Crikeyalmighty · 26/04/2022 19:47

@venus7 My mum when on her second marriage always said 'don't marry someone with low prospects -- it's a lot easier to be miserable in comfort- '

A cheery thought!!