Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that some people just don't get poverty?

555 replies

Ohsoworried · 24/04/2022 22:04

I've seen a few posts recently where people earning a fair bit of money (think around 100k a year) are complaining that they're struggling with money, don't have enough etc. I DO understand that it is all relative but equally, for people like me on a low low wage, in insecure housing, wondering how I'm going to pay rent, having to stop paying in to my pension for the extra £30 a month etc it does make me cringe a little. Things are a little better for me at the moment but it has been hard and my secondment is up soon so back down to low pay. When I left my abusive ex I was living in poverty. And when I mean poverty I mean in a refuge, no job because I had to relocate, no money for a deposit to rent etc. It's the choice between being able to downsize your house, not go on holiday for a couple of years, make sacrifices but still live comfortably etc, compared with not knowing if you'll be able to afford your bills. Of course I'm generalising and I'm sure there are people out there who are genuinely on high wages but have high mortgage payments etc who are struggling. I do sympathise. But I don't always think this is the case...

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 25/04/2022 08:01

I think some people dont realise that they are poor as a result of the choices they have made. They have chosen to max out the mortgage on an expensive home which is also expensive to run, chosen to send the children to private school, chosen to go on expensive holidays.

These people frustrate me.

newnamethanks · 25/04/2022 07:51

A few years ago I saw 3 people leave the food bank with a carrier bag. They sat together on a bench and ate a raw, unwashed carrot each, then broke up a cauliflower and started to eat that. I doubt they were worrying about their annual holiday.

Snoken · 25/04/2022 07:42

Oblomov22 · 25/04/2022 07:16

I don't know what you are expecting here. No, some people just don't get poverty because they've never experienced it. But they can be empathetic.

And yet with reference to feminist threads you say: "getting it off your chest and talking about it is oft better than bottling it up".

And I completely disagree with pp :
50shadesofcatholic.

"No it is not a “genuine concern” to have to skip a holiday, it is a discussion that an intelligent person would keep to an appropriate audience not plaster across the internet when there is a pandemic, a war and a climate crisis literally destroying lives in front of us."

Mn you can post any question in any time, it's allowed. Say, you had a huge inheritance recently, or a huge pay rise, you'd still be allowed to ask questions about it.

I agree with this. I have never lived in poverty, and although I can comprehend what poverty entails, I cannot fully "get it". I have also never been Kim Kardashian, and I can guess what that is like, but I cannot fully "get it". As long as people a sympathetic I don't think we can expect everyone to get every situation.

forinborin · 25/04/2022 07:36

Being poor as the adult responsible for paying the bills is different to growing up in poverty.
I meant real poverty, as in the third world poverty. Say, when you have to look after family cow from the age of 6, bring water from a well, and lots of your free time is spent subsistence farming, that kind of stuff.

ChoiceMummy · 25/04/2022 07:36

Poverty is relative.
It's not a continuum.
It's not only those on low incomes in poverty.
It's not only those in insecure homes in poverty.
It's across all ages, social strata, regions.
The differences are how you perceive it.
I know plenty of people who have lived in poverty in their "big homes" (not even talking naice big homes either just sufficient bedrooms for their needs) which were going to be bankrupted.

What does irk me, and we all know them, is the person complaining about their situations, when really it's just priorities. They're opting to still do xyz when I'm not, so I'm apparently better off than them... Whereas I prefer to save and do more for less. Eg I take out a tea in a flask, they want to have coffees out. So I save there and over the course of time, can afford to take my child somewhere, so I'm then rolling in it as a result of taking picnics with us etc, whilst they've paid Starbucks and Costs etc!

Oblomov22 · 25/04/2022 07:36

Some of the people who experience poverty, not all, have made very bad choices. They need to take personal responsibility for that.

Just as an example, Yesterday there was a thread from a woman complaining that banks give credit cards to people too easily and saying by aged 21 she spent 6K credit card, on fancy clothes and going out drinking. That's her choice. Why should a 21 year old who didn't do that feel ashamed of the fact they themselves didn't make those choices?

ChiswickFlo · 25/04/2022 07:27

Ah, yes.

Cheap credit too!

ChiswickFlo · 25/04/2022 07:26

As I tell my son...money won't mag8cally make you happier but it will give you choices.

THATS what poverty truly is.

No choices. No hope.

ChiswickFlo · 25/04/2022 07:25

forinborin · 25/04/2022 07:22

What about people who grew up really poor and now are on those magic six digits salaries, do you think they "get" poverty?

That would be me.

Yes. I think I "get" poverty.

More importantly, how many of this group help those less fortunate than themselves??

The psychology of poverty is an interesting one.

AchillesPoirot · 25/04/2022 07:25

forinborin · 25/04/2022 07:22

What about people who grew up really poor and now are on those magic six digits salaries, do you think they "get" poverty?

Being poor as the adult responsible for paying the bills is different to growing up in poverty.

I've done both. Does that mean I doubly get it?

I agree op. I've been really really poor as an adult (and as a child) and some people do not and never will, get it.

ChiefInspectorParker · 25/04/2022 07:23

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ChiswickFlo · 25/04/2022 07:23

For anyone who needs help:

www.acts435.org.uk
www.capuk.org
www.trusselltrust.org

forinborin · 25/04/2022 07:22

What about people who grew up really poor and now are on those magic six digits salaries, do you think they "get" poverty?

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/04/2022 07:21

People on mn I think live in an alternate reality, or are just lying, so I wouldn't trust what they say as the actual truth. But some do just seem completely oblivious too and cannot see past their own existence, they think everyone lives like them. It's really just a way for them to show that they are actually stupid and are likely only rich thanks to generous parents or have somehow managed to talk their way into an easy, overpaid job. No one that stupid could actually be doing anything worthwhile.

I would pity them op. They live secluded, deluded lives. They actually know nothing about the world. They will live and die in ignorance.

ChiswickFlo · 25/04/2022 07:16

I find it really offensive when people say "oh, rich people have problems too"

Rich people don't lose all their teeth at 38 because they've never been able to afford private dentistry and no access to nhs dentists.

Rich people don't get sicker because they cant afford otc medicines (and, no the nhs won't prescribe common otc medicines)

Rich people don't wear thin, poorly made clothes in the depths of winter. They have coats and boots and hats and gloves.

Rich people can heat their homes and feed their kids nutrious food.

They can buy their kids uniforms, decent shoes, schoolbag, toiletries, San Pro, provide extra curricular activities and enrichment.

They can save for their kids futures.

I cannot and will not feel sympathy for someone who is sad because they will only have 2 holidays abroad this year.

And suggesting that I should is exactly what's wrong with this country. People should be on the streets about what tory governments since 2010 have done to this country and its most vulnerable.

But...no.

The sheer effort needed to constantly cheek prices, check bank balances, find things to sell on ebay etc is exhausting.

Having to take a calculator to the shops so you don't overspend.

Only ever buying the smartprice version of everything. No treats. No splurging on a takeaway.

Only being able to afford the cheapest shoes so thwy wear out and have to be purchased again within 6 months...

Check out the #vimesbootsindex

Oblomov22 · 25/04/2022 07:16

I don't know what you are expecting here. No, some people just don't get poverty because they've never experienced it. But they can be empathetic.

And yet with reference to feminist threads you say: "getting it off your chest and talking about it is oft better than bottling it up".

And I completely disagree with pp :
50shadesofcatholic.

"No it is not a “genuine concern” to have to skip a holiday, it is a discussion that an intelligent person would keep to an appropriate audience not plaster across the internet when there is a pandemic, a war and a climate crisis literally destroying lives in front of us."

Mn you can post any question in any time, it's allowed. Say, you had a huge inheritance recently, or a huge pay rise, you'd still be allowed to ask questions about it.

WhatsHoppening · 25/04/2022 07:06

I agree OP although there is a lot of people struggling in their own way that weren’t before.
We have a lovely house purchased with some inheritance and a large mortgage we could easily afford pre kids.
I now work part and have 2 kids in childcare. Things were tight but manageable before covid but are now tight and uncomfortable. We have cancelled also extra curricular including swimming for our eldest and things are tight. Savings are gone (thanks lockdown…) and we live month to month. No fancy car, no private school etc but from the outside we look like a well to do middle class family. Others wouldn’t expect us to be unable to afford any extras and our income is above any help (which I agree with to be fair).
yes it would be worse in temporary accommodation, it would be so much worse if this wasn’t temporary due to extortionate childcare but in the here and now it’s still difficult.
I would never complain to someone I knew in true poverty and I always keep perspective but I do allow myself a moan to friends in a similar/better position!

grapewines · 25/04/2022 06:58

Rich people are allowed to have problems. The difference is poor people often have similar problems on top of having to find money for food and hot water.

HandlebarLadyTash · 25/04/2022 06:43

Our leaders don't understand poverty, they are all old friends from elite schools & are more concerned with protecting their wealth than improving the country.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 25/04/2022 06:37

BlusteryLake · 25/04/2022 06:11

I think it's true, but also think that it goes both ways. It's always harder to "get" any situation if you've never lived it personally. It's quite common for the less well off to scoff and minimise the problems of those wealthier than them because they mistakenly believe that having money is some kind of silver bullet that prevents any other stresses and difficulties. Like rich people aren't allowed to have problems that they don't understand, having never been in that situation themselves.

I don’t think it can go both ways at all, rich people never have the poverty issue whereas poor people have poverty and all the other shit to deal with.

UsernameInTheTown · 25/04/2022 06:31

Made me chuckle when a certain customer who used to frequent my tattoo studio for, you know, £60 p/h tattoos used to claim he was skint and "struggling to shoe (his) horses this month".

BlusteryLake · 25/04/2022 06:11

I think it's true, but also think that it goes both ways. It's always harder to "get" any situation if you've never lived it personally. It's quite common for the less well off to scoff and minimise the problems of those wealthier than them because they mistakenly believe that having money is some kind of silver bullet that prevents any other stresses and difficulties. Like rich people aren't allowed to have problems that they don't understand, having never been in that situation themselves.

Lex345 · 25/04/2022 05:58

I agree some dont get it and will never get it. On some of the threads about energy prices rising, a lot of the suggestions were things like replace appliances for more efficient ones-even after an OP saying "I dont have money to replace them". Or worse, making our using your waahing machine or oven is some kind of luxury you can stop doing to help yourself .

The absolute worst thing for me is having to say no to the children. The guilt of that is all consuming. Its not even frivolous things, its small things I should be able to give them. I was able to give them.

When COVID happened, I was successful in my field earning 45k a year. We werent loaded but I could pay all my bills, afford a few treats and an unexpected medium sized expense was easy enough to sort. I was managing an independent care home. The stress and trauma of what I had to deal with caused me to have a breakdown and I have lost my career. I am genuinely broken by what I had to see and deal with. I was a really good nurse and a successful turnaround manager. I tried working for myself for a year, was making half decent money-then that dried up with the cost of living crisis, no one had money for the things I was selling. For the first time in my life, I was forced to claim benefits. Despite having a first class degree, no one would even offer me an interview-I applied for office work, cleaning, shop assistant-hundreds of jobs. I have finally been offered a NMW job back in the sector I desperately needed to leave to protect my own mental health-I feel like I have to because I wont be offered anything else. For every £1 I earn, I will have 45p of my universal credit reduced, so although I will be a little better off, I will be no where near where I was in 2020.

I feel sad. Life is joyless sometimes with no treats to look forward to.

Cubangal · 25/04/2022 05:17

I'm living below the poverty line and an unable to work due to I'll health. My GP knows this yet suggested I employ a cleaner.

PyongyangKipperbang · 25/04/2022 04:15

SnakesHaveNoEyelids · 25/04/2022 03:58

These threads really get at me as I see both sides (having lived both) and I think there is a huge lack of empathy in both directions.

We shouldn't be engaging in the misery olympics. It it stupid.

Obviously it's far worse having no heating and no food than it is to be worrying about your mortgage payments. I lived like that for years, electric often cutting off. No food many days. But, it's also equally stressful being a lone parent with a "decent" income that's all sucked up by childcare/ rent and mortgage for example. It can leave you in a very similar situation now wrt. heating and food.

I think every situation is different and it's unhelpful to try to divide people as there are so many different factors involved in anyone's situation. It's counterproductive. We should focus on persuading as many people as possible on supporting things that can be done to make things better for more people, rather than "othering" people.

I get what you're saying but there is a massive difference between facing having to downsize a mortgage and having literally nothing left to sell. You can't pawn the tv as that went months ago, you cant sell your jewellery as you dont have any, you cant price check broadband as you dont have that either and you are stuck on prepayment meters for gas and electric which cost so much more.

You get the kids school shoes from Asda because they cost less but need replacing more often..... it goes on.
Being truly poor is very expensive.