Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that some people just don't get poverty?

555 replies

Ohsoworried · 24/04/2022 22:04

I've seen a few posts recently where people earning a fair bit of money (think around 100k a year) are complaining that they're struggling with money, don't have enough etc. I DO understand that it is all relative but equally, for people like me on a low low wage, in insecure housing, wondering how I'm going to pay rent, having to stop paying in to my pension for the extra £30 a month etc it does make me cringe a little. Things are a little better for me at the moment but it has been hard and my secondment is up soon so back down to low pay. When I left my abusive ex I was living in poverty. And when I mean poverty I mean in a refuge, no job because I had to relocate, no money for a deposit to rent etc. It's the choice between being able to downsize your house, not go on holiday for a couple of years, make sacrifices but still live comfortably etc, compared with not knowing if you'll be able to afford your bills. Of course I'm generalising and I'm sure there are people out there who are genuinely on high wages but have high mortgage payments etc who are struggling. I do sympathise. But I don't always think this is the case...

OP posts:
LindaEllen · 25/04/2022 10:27

The thing is though, it's all relative. I sometimes feel pretty miserable about how little we have - but realise that there are lots of people worse off.

It's the same in your situation. You might be in a refuge - but you have food, water and shelter. There are plenty homeless, on the streets - and plenty in third world countries to whom being homeless in the UK would be a vast improvement.

I know none of that makes you feel better, but you have to keep perspective and have gratitude for what you have, even if your situation is far from perfect.

HesterShaw1 · 25/04/2022 10:27

YANBU I've mentioned this before but I remember a poster with young kids who was living in damp rented accommodation one wet winter, who was in despair about getting her washing dry. She had no radiators, nowhere to hang it. One genius suggestion was "Can't you hang it in the garage?"

FFS 🙄

Villagewaspbyke · 25/04/2022 10:26

Poppins2016 · 25/04/2022 10:10

I agree with everything you've just said.

I've often said that being wealthy is more about luck and connections than hard work.

I think most people work just as hard, if not harder, than wealthy people. They just get less (monetary) reward for their efforts.

It’s not at all as simple as any of that. Luck, privilege and skill plays a part in acquiring wealth but so does hard work. There are very few people who have made their own money (ie not been given it by others) who have not had to work hard.

hard work definitely is an important factor in acquiring wealth. It’s not the only one but it’s important.

we are lucky in the uk that we have free education and relatively good opportunities for everyone. It’s not perfect but I was able to go from a state school and council estate to being a wealthy professional. There was a lot of hard work involved!

HelloCanYouHearMe · 25/04/2022 10:24

saggyhairyass · 24/04/2022 22:44

DH grew up in poverty in London in the 1980s. His dad lost his job and couldn't get another, despite being a skilled engineer. His mum was a SAHP. She would skip meals, saying she ate earlier, so her kids could have a good dinner. Sometimes the coin meter would run out, and they'd sit in darkness. They never had holidays, or even days out. Free school meals, uniform vouchers, even milk tokens for DH's baby brother. His dad would be at the Job Centre most days looking for work, and would get the odd labouring job or shift at the Royal Mail as a casual but it only made the family break even...then the temporary job would dry up and he'd be back on the dole again. Back then, they used loan sharks, and would sometimes have to hide when they came knocking for their money. It got paid back eventually but the interest was silly high.

An uncle would often help them out because he worked abroad for an oil company and his salary was tax free.

It affects DH now. He's always worried we haven't got enough money (we do, plus a bit left over for luxuries). He frets about inflation and will stock up the cupboards on basics to try and beat it. The freezer is bursting. He also tells DD we haven't got enough so she in turn sometimes gers disappointed when he says we can't go away (but we can't go away because my leave is allocated and I can't swap it sometimes for the summer holidays, not because we're skint). My daughter actually believes we are poor compared to her friends. I push back, constantly, on that point. He worries constantly about the electricity bill. I keep telling him we're coping but he doesn't believe me.

I have no idea where he's coming from because although my dad did lose a few jobs over the years he always found a new one. We liked frugally but went camping as a holiday or went to my uncle's caravan. My mum retrained in the late 80s and found a job in an office. It's a vastly different set-up.

I know exactly where your DH is coming from as my own experience as a child in the 80s was almost identical.

My DF lost his job and stuggled for years to get another. DM working 3hrs 3 days a week as a cleaner as thats all the work she could get.

DM would also skip meals to ensure my brother and I were fed. There were days when all we could have for dinner was a few slices of toast because we had no food in. Free school meals, second hand poor fitting uniform and shoes. Minimal heating in winter (if we were lucky), and the debt collector rocking up every Friday for his money..

My parents did their best to shield us from it all, but my DB and I were very aware.

I now find myself getting anxious if I have to do a top up shop in the week and I'm constantly looking at the smart meter to see what our fuel usage is like... It drives my DP insane because right now, we're ok.

I sat down with him and told him about my childhood and why I get annoyed with the kids wasting food, leaving lights on etc. He says he understands where i'm coming from, but I think you're right OP. Unless you've actually been there, you have no idea.

desiringonlychild2022 · 25/04/2022 10:18

ancientgran · 25/04/2022 10:05

A big mortgage is relative to what you earn.

We couldn't have afforded a shoebox in London but it was a big mortgage for us. Back then the standard for lending was 3 times annual earnings for the higher paid (normally the man) in a couple or 2.5 times the higher salary plus 1 time of the lower paid. The big difference was the interest rate so although in capital terms in would have seemed low compared to now (allowing for inflation) the repayments were very heavy. We bought at the time interest rates were high, we got offered a mortgage, the interest rate increased before we completed and we paid one month at that rate and then it went up again and again before the end of the year so we were in a position that what we could just afford became crippling in the space of six months.

You couldn't get a fixed rate at that time, alot of building societies had been burned by people getting a fixed rate for life in the 60s and rates were high and rising in the 70s. I worked with someone who was offered a decent lump sum by her building society to end her fixed rate deal.

I mean, my mortgage is £1020 now for a 2 bed flat in London so I am in a better position than renters who have seen their rent for a room increase from £636 to in excess of £800 in a space of a few months. I have been making £1k overpayments so theoretically could manage an interest rate of up to 8 %. Most recent mortgages have been stress-tested in this way.

So while the mortgages given seem 'big' and crazy, the reality is that the lower income people have not been able to get a mortgage since the financial crisis and are in rentals where ironically the sky is the limit.

Villagewaspbyke · 25/04/2022 10:16

I’ve been on benefits (both before and after being a single mum) and I’ve earned a six figure salary. I certainly know what it’s like to be poor but also to be reasonably well off. My experience of being poor though means I never feel comfortable spending. I’m always watching the cash.

i think some people will never understand being poor. But I do think too that just because you are better off doesn’t mean you can’t post your money worries on mn. Everyone’s problems are important to them and pretty much everyone can compare themselves favourably or negatively to someone else.

I have family in the developing world op. To some of them, the poor in the uk have great lives and opportunities. But ofc that’s not the reality when you’re living it.

Zilla1 · 25/04/2022 10:14

Because for some people, the joke 'Enough of me talking all about me and how wonderful I am, let's hear what you've got to say... about how wonderful I am' is true and for them, they must centre every issue and experience about them. If they can't then they are uninterested.

DownNative · 25/04/2022 10:12

Fizbosshoes · 25/04/2022 09:16

But someone struggling to choose between buying enough food for the week, or whether to pay the electricity bill shouldn't feel grateful or lucky because in a developing country they'd practically be a millionaire??Confused

The irony between places like the African continent is that THEY are in perpetual debt to US.

In other words, the global poor are paying back a lot of debt to the global rich which is our Western countries. Our countries, in turn, use this income to provide financial support to those in our society who need it.

In short, extreme poverty does NOT exist in the West.

But it does exist in places like the African continent. After all, they're in perpetual debt to our countries.

The point of the entire issue is that poverty IS relative.

ancientgran · 25/04/2022 10:12

ancientgran · 25/04/2022 10:05

A big mortgage is relative to what you earn.

We couldn't have afforded a shoebox in London but it was a big mortgage for us. Back then the standard for lending was 3 times annual earnings for the higher paid (normally the man) in a couple or 2.5 times the higher salary plus 1 time of the lower paid. The big difference was the interest rate so although in capital terms in would have seemed low compared to now (allowing for inflation) the repayments were very heavy. We bought at the time interest rates were high, we got offered a mortgage, the interest rate increased before we completed and we paid one month at that rate and then it went up again and again before the end of the year so we were in a position that what we could just afford became crippling in the space of six months.

You couldn't get a fixed rate at that time, alot of building societies had been burned by people getting a fixed rate for life in the 60s and rates were high and rising in the 70s. I worked with someone who was offered a decent lump sum by her building society to end her fixed rate deal.

Just had a look on rightmove and a 2 up 2 down in the area I was living in is now £185,000. The only difference is that is has double glazing, central heating and a lovely kitchen, I think they have extended the kitchen, plus a conservatory. We had rotten window frames, a gas fire and a sink unit and cooker in the kitchen.

House prices do vary across the country and always have.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 25/04/2022 10:10

A bit off topic but I found this chart interesting & a bit of an explanation as to why high income people are complaining about money worries.

This will be the first government in 50 years to have every income level see a reduction in their disposable income.

In 2005 when there was lots of 'squeezed middle' talk, people were seeing less growth in income but now it's actual decline.

to think that some people just don't get poverty?
Poppins2016 · 25/04/2022 10:10

Maverickess · 25/04/2022 10:02

This brings two realisations to me, one, that poor people are always the architect of their own destiny, if they choose to work in a low skilled and paid job, if they choose to have low aspirations, if they choose to spend some of their limited income on a treat then they have only themselves to blame. They have not tried or worked hard enough. They lack responsibility, they lack something that makes them less able, less willing to change their destiny.

But if someone is earning more in a professional job, chooses a large mortgage, chooses a decent car, chooses two or 3 holidays abroad each year - they feel as though they deserve these things as well as having money in the bank, it then isn't about their choices it's then about things being unfair, being taxed too much, the cost of living being too high etc. They feel that they 'work hard' and always have and assume that anyone who doesn't have what they do just hasn't done the same.

My thought is that somehow, admitting that someone can work just as hard for little is worrying, because it may draw the conclusion that it's not all about the hard work element, it's about being valued, about your starting point in life and going deeper, about realising that as a society we need all levels of job for it to work, there is no one for a manager to manage, no matter how hard they work, if those beneath them are not there to be managed.
It's easier to write off people as irresponsible, lazy and uninspired to justify why they're poor, than to admit that actually they are very much a part of the whole chain that keeps society afloat and should have as much value as those earning more.

And two, a smaller but vocal and respected group actively use the lower paid people in society for their own gain, they are making money off the back of other people's hard work, and are celebrated for it, held up as examples of what hard work can do - but baulk at the idea that it's other people's hard work and their use of that, that gets them where they are.
As we're seeing in some industries now, when the people at the bottom of the ladder remove their contribution, the whole thing starts to collapse.

I agree with everything you've just said.

I've often said that being wealthy is more about luck and connections than hard work.

I think most people work just as hard, if not harder, than wealthy people. They just get less (monetary) reward for their efforts.

ancientgran · 25/04/2022 10:05

desiringonlychild2022 · 25/04/2022 09:54

@ancientgran right now someone with a big mortgage would generally be someone who is at least of middle income due to affordability criteria. I mean a lot of the people with huge mortgages on million pound houses have at least £70k per annum salaries as they can often borrow 5 X of income which is basically 10X if it is a couple.

I mean a 2 up 2 down in my area is £600k-700k so someone who bought that recently would be at least middle income even in a London context.

A big mortgage is relative to what you earn.

We couldn't have afforded a shoebox in London but it was a big mortgage for us. Back then the standard for lending was 3 times annual earnings for the higher paid (normally the man) in a couple or 2.5 times the higher salary plus 1 time of the lower paid. The big difference was the interest rate so although in capital terms in would have seemed low compared to now (allowing for inflation) the repayments were very heavy. We bought at the time interest rates were high, we got offered a mortgage, the interest rate increased before we completed and we paid one month at that rate and then it went up again and again before the end of the year so we were in a position that what we could just afford became crippling in the space of six months.

You couldn't get a fixed rate at that time, alot of building societies had been burned by people getting a fixed rate for life in the 60s and rates were high and rising in the 70s. I worked with someone who was offered a decent lump sum by her building society to end her fixed rate deal.

Poppins2016 · 25/04/2022 10:03

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

I think there are some situations where some people are so far removed that they just can't imagine themselves in the 'opposite' position.

I once had to advocate for someone because the company I worked for made a mistake with a number of salary payments and my boss proposed asking for the amount (about £500) back in one go because "it's not a lot of money". I pointed out that might be true for him (earning 6 figures a year) but for people like her (earning an average salary, single mother) it was a large sum of money to have to account for out of the blue.

Maverickess · 25/04/2022 10:02

Kendodd · 25/04/2022 08:51

Oh and the other thing that pisses me off is when posters complain others aren't poor enough. Example the care worker who buys herself s takeaway coffee. Loads of posters than insisting that's her problem right there. If she didn't speak £3 twice a week on a cappuccino she wouldn't be poor. It's a fucking cup of coffee! What do you want? For the people who do these jobs to have absolutely nothing except bread and water.
Poverty in the UK is absolutely shameful and we shouldn't but up with it. Instead it seems we're grateful for food banks when we should be demanding the end of such levels of poverty.

This brings two realisations to me, one, that poor people are always the architect of their own destiny, if they choose to work in a low skilled and paid job, if they choose to have low aspirations, if they choose to spend some of their limited income on a treat then they have only themselves to blame. They have not tried or worked hard enough. They lack responsibility, they lack something that makes them less able, less willing to change their destiny.

But if someone is earning more in a professional job, chooses a large mortgage, chooses a decent car, chooses two or 3 holidays abroad each year - they feel as though they deserve these things as well as having money in the bank, it then isn't about their choices it's then about things being unfair, being taxed too much, the cost of living being too high etc. They feel that they 'work hard' and always have and assume that anyone who doesn't have what they do just hasn't done the same.

My thought is that somehow, admitting that someone can work just as hard for little is worrying, because it may draw the conclusion that it's not all about the hard work element, it's about being valued, about your starting point in life and going deeper, about realising that as a society we need all levels of job for it to work, there is no one for a manager to manage, no matter how hard they work, if those beneath them are not there to be managed.
It's easier to write off people as irresponsible, lazy and uninspired to justify why they're poor, than to admit that actually they are very much a part of the whole chain that keeps society afloat and should have as much value as those earning more.

And two, a smaller but vocal and respected group actively use the lower paid people in society for their own gain, they are making money off the back of other people's hard work, and are celebrated for it, held up as examples of what hard work can do - but baulk at the idea that it's other people's hard work and their use of that, that gets them where they are.
As we're seeing in some industries now, when the people at the bottom of the ladder remove their contribution, the whole thing starts to collapse.

MayBeee · 25/04/2022 09:58

I'm lucky enough not to have experienced poverty as an adult , low on money yes , unable to heat the house at all times , yes , but have always managed to feed and clothe our kids .
Poverty for me as a child meant no home phone , no car , no fire lit until the evening. As a small child in the winter / school holidays going to bed to read or try to sleep to keep warm in the afternoons . Having very cheap meals to fill us up like baked beans and boiled rice.

desiringonlychild2022 · 25/04/2022 09:56

bellebeautifu1 · 25/04/2022 09:51

Yes I agree, from experience at the other end of the spectrum. I mean if you dont go abroad for five years, another year is insignifcant, you get use to shopping from Aldi, not Waitrose, it becomes usual to never go out for dinner but batch cook etc. Its depressing but its normalised that you live on next to nothing.

I am no longer a single mum anymore (DD left home) and I have recently inherited. It still feels odd that I have money left over at the end of the month, for the first time in over a decade I have actually had a disposable income to spend. I recently splurged on fine dining with DD and have paid for a trip abroad for us, for us its a lot when every penny you spend for years goes on the necessities.

to be fair, these people are more likely to be tory voters so their anger is much more useful than someone who has been struggling since 2011 and who lives in a solid labour constituency (so the tories don't care about their votes).

I do enjoy their moaning much more, i hope they redirect their anger in a productive fashion!

HardyBuckette · 25/04/2022 09:55

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 25/04/2022 09:43

It's strange how DP can arrive here with nothing, just a bag, and make a life that isn't it.
I just think a lot of Brits are moaning bastards, my brother and his wife for one are just financially inept.

Not really. The societal equivalents of the people you disparage here will also exist in your DPs home country, they just won't have been the ones with the skills, experiences and indeed luck to be able to emigrate and make a success of themselves. Healthy young people who have a lot of get up and go have always existed and there are always some people who beat the odds. Their existence doesn't add anything much to this discussion.

desiringonlychild2022 · 25/04/2022 09:54

@ancientgran right now someone with a big mortgage would generally be someone who is at least of middle income due to affordability criteria. I mean a lot of the people with huge mortgages on million pound houses have at least £70k per annum salaries as they can often borrow 5 X of income which is basically 10X if it is a couple.

I mean a 2 up 2 down in my area is £600k-700k so someone who bought that recently would be at least middle income even in a London context.

bellebeautifu1 · 25/04/2022 09:51

BlackeyedSusan · 25/04/2022 09:14

Saw something similar just yesterday.

People get used to a level of income. Anything less feels like struggling despite being many times above others income.

Yes I agree, from experience at the other end of the spectrum. I mean if you dont go abroad for five years, another year is insignifcant, you get use to shopping from Aldi, not Waitrose, it becomes usual to never go out for dinner but batch cook etc. Its depressing but its normalised that you live on next to nothing.

I am no longer a single mum anymore (DD left home) and I have recently inherited. It still feels odd that I have money left over at the end of the month, for the first time in over a decade I have actually had a disposable income to spend. I recently splurged on fine dining with DD and have paid for a trip abroad for us, for us its a lot when every penny you spend for years goes on the necessities.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 25/04/2022 09:46

I think you're right, in some ways. But I also think that it's unrealistic to expect people to exhibit bottomless capacity for empathy over things that they haven't personally experienced.

Whatever the disadvantage or struggle is - whether it's poverty, ill health, bereavement, social exclusion, estrangement from family, infertility - I feel it's important to remember that not having personally experienced it doesn't make someone a bad person.

ancientgran · 25/04/2022 09:46

The other thing that makes a difference is if you have someone to back you up. I was poor in the 70s. Two young children, high mortgage (for a two up two down Coronation St type house) and inflation running riot. But and it is a big but I knew if I was destitute I could go to my mum and get help. I didn't do it but it was good to know. I never thought was a difference this made until I was talking to someone from a single parent home and their mother died when she was a teenager. No extended family, no parents to turn to. It must have made it so much harder

desiringonlychild2022 · 25/04/2022 09:45

well i guess the people moaning about not being able to afford holidays have mixed up the definition, they are not in poverty,they are the squeezed middle.

The thing is middle class (whether in UK/US definition) encompasses quite a wide class from a family on 40k to a family on 150k. Also cost of living can differ quite a bit. i.e. DH and I are average in London but top 9-15% in the country according to income (for a couple). i am talking about the economic definition, which is unrelated to the UK definition of class which is based on background/education.

I understand that its quite grating for the truly poor to hear about the grouses of the middle income, but they are the majority of the population, though with the heating bills, the poor will probably be about 30% of the population (up from 20%)

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 25/04/2022 09:43

NotQuiteUsual · 25/04/2022 09:39

I can totally see how if you've been comfortable all your life, but not wealthy you would think you understood poverty.

We went from poverty to comfortable through an inheritance and luck. It's been a few years since we were poor and every now and then I find myself at the end of the month trying to stretch what I have left to manage groceries and a little day out with the kids and feel a bit hard done by. Which is ridiculous, obviously. But if I'd never had that period of poverty in my life, I probably would be moaning to friends about feeling skint.

I really don't think you can get it if you haven't been through it. The boredom, the constant level of stress. The amount of time everything takes because there's no shortcuts you can afford. Checking every single supermarket before you buy anything. The fear as you watch your children grow and you don't know how you'll clothe them. Constant mental arithmetic as you try to manage your utilities. The panic when post arrives or the door knocks. The lack of self worth. If you haven't felt the pressure of poverty 24/7 for months or years on end then you cannot know how it destroys you.

It's strange how DP can arrive here with nothing, just a bag, and make a life that isn't it.
I just think a lot of Brits are moaning bastards, my brother and his wife for one are just financially inept.

ChiswickFlo · 25/04/2022 09:42

work not week

ChiswickFlo · 25/04/2022 09:42

Jack Monroe is working on a #vimesbootsindex

Check out her twitter feed

Her week on food poverty is impressive