Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask wwyd about this work situation?

181 replies

justexisting22 · 24/04/2022 21:25

I've been angry for a few days following a recent salary review at work and I can't stop thinking over it in my head. I really need advice on how to handle the situation as I feel like I've been really undervalued and I'm seriously wondering now whether or not I should look for a new position at a totally different company.

For some background, my "new" salary for this year was my base salary last year, however this was pro rata to £Xk a year, as I worked part time but then changed to full time when I started a new role. So I'm wondering if is that even correct? Should this not have increased when I went back full time?

I've been at this company for 6 years, have qualifications experience etc, yet I'm still only on the starting salary for my position. It just doesn't seem right to me and to be honest I've been so upset and angry about it

AIBU to think I should just look elsewhere?

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 10:43

Sunnysideup · 25/04/2022 10:38

Ok So you haven’t went full time. Your hours have not changed.

so they said they have given you a ten percent pay rise. They have done ten percent off your total actual part time wage.

but you want ten percent increase on the full time wage.

why would they give you ten percent on the full wage as you don’t work that ? As your hours have stayed rhe same then what they have done is valid.

No.

The pay rise of 10% is calculated on the FTE. Then that new higher amount is pro-rated.

FTE £20,000
Pro-rated 90% = £18,000

Pay rise of 10% calculated on the FTE for the role.

FTE £22,000
Pro-rated 90% = £19,800

That’s how it works.

Sunnysideup · 25/04/2022 10:41

Also op your colleague who got a larger raise, is their job the same and is their base salary the same as yours?

Sunnysideup · 25/04/2022 10:38

Ok So you haven’t went full time. Your hours have not changed.

so they said they have given you a ten percent pay rise. They have done ten percent off your total actual part time wage.

but you want ten percent increase on the full time wage.

why would they give you ten percent on the full wage as you don’t work that ? As your hours have stayed rhe same then what they have done is valid.

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:38

@reesewithoutaspoon As far as I am aware, the colleague who has a lower rating but a higher pay raise hasn’t done any sort of negotiation

OP posts:
reesewithoutaspoon · 25/04/2022 10:35

Apart from the salary confusion. You say other colleagues are paid more for lesser performance. Have you ever actually negotiated a raise? It's something I think a lot of people aren't taught. Companies won't just give yearly raises if you don't ask for them. They will pay the least they have to for the job, it's just business.
You need to give them evidence of why you deserve a raise. show what value you bring to the company. not just go in and say it's not fair.
Are your performance indicators better. Did you negotiate extra business for the company bringing extra income in. do you consistently get good customer feedback compared to your colleagues. Do you have a bigger workload? Start with a higher figure than you are willing to accept and negotiate down.

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:30

should I go back to my manager again with this or go straight to HR? I want to make sure I approach this correctly

OP posts:
Yellownightmare · 25/04/2022 10:30

Oh and as NoSquirrels says, don't say it's not fair, or it's personal. It weakens your case. Just make it all about the business and your contribution.

NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 10:28

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:23

My pay rise definitely isn’t based on the FTE salary, so I’m right to think this is a mistake than should be rectified?

Yes.

Yellownightmare · 25/04/2022 10:27

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:23

My pay rise definitely isn’t based on the FTE salary, so I’m right to think this is a mistake than should be rectified?

Definitely. But sit down with someone who's good at figures before you go into see your boss and write it all down. The uplift should definitely be based on FTE. You can point out that in effect you've had a pay cut over the last few years, taking into account inflation.

Also, make a business case as to why you deserve the full 10% uplift, because it's always good to back up your case. If you've got a friend who's very confident, get them to help you put your case together and practise role playing your discussion with your boss.

Good luck!

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:23

My pay rise definitely isn’t based on the FTE salary, so I’m right to think this is a mistake than should be rectified?

OP posts:
justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:20

@Yellownightmare Thanks, you’ve been so helpful. You’ve understood my situation exactly. I think I was right in thinking there’s been a mistake with the figures, because it honestly doesn’t seem logical. I think my new salary should be the £19,500 + 10%, when actually they’ve gone off last years pro rata’d salary

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 10:19

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:16

@NoSquirrels So don’t mention anything to do with pro rata? I don’t understand though why that was mentioned by them last year but not this year

Your pay rise should be based on the FTE.

That’s it. Start there.

Did that happen? If not, they made a mistake they can immediately rectify.

But your real issue is are you paid enough for the job? Is the FTE fair?

If not, make your case.

BobLemon · 25/04/2022 10:18

YellowNightmare’s advice about making your business case is really good. Feel free to add in that you’re aware of other positions paying x. You’ll find out one way or another what your manager thinks of you.

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:16

@NoSquirrels So don’t mention anything to do with pro rata? I don’t understand though why that was mentioned by them last year but not this year

OP posts:
Yellownightmare · 25/04/2022 10:16

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:09

yes @Yellownightmare, that’s exactly right. You’ve understood what I’ve been trying to get across

In that case I'd point this out to them. Write the figures down and say this is exactly what has happened. Don't accuse them of deliberately misleading you (although I suspect this might be the case), just point out that with a 10% pay increase, which is what they say they're giving you, it should be £11k + 10%.

You feel you deserve the 10% pay rise because of all your positive reviews, then give the other reasons why you think you deserve it, based on your skills, experience and achievements (be very specific here). It's worth getting this anyway, even if you decide to leave. And ask for it to be backdated because you think they made a mistake with the figures, by basing it on the wrong base figure.

NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 10:15

I know they could have paid me more, the fact that they haven’t makes me really think maybe I shouldn’t even bother to fight this and just begin to look elsewhere. It feels personal to me

This isn’t going to be a helpful attitude. Most business isn’t personal.
Most employers pay what they can get away with.
Many employees put up with it.
Some don’t and therefore get paid more.

Ask for a discussion, state your case (excellent customer service, commitment to the company, increased responsibilities, how much you like working there but needing to consider your position in light of cost of living increases…)

See what they say.
But don’t get all confused about pro-rata!

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:09

yes @Yellownightmare, that’s exactly right. You’ve understood what I’ve been trying to get across

OP posts:
justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:08

@badgermushrooms Thank you, I appreciate your advice its extremely helpful. I enjoy the job, the commute is easy and has other really good perks. However, the most important thing to me is salary and this is where I feel they fall short. I know they could have paid me more, the fact that they haven’t makes me really think maybe I shouldn’t even bother to fight this and just begin to look elsewhere. It feels personal to me

OP posts:
Yellownightmare · 25/04/2022 10:08

I'm just going to try to understand. Are you saying that your company has claimed that they've given you a pay rise based on your pro-rata'd pay, as opposed to your pay based on the full amount? So if you got £10k pro-rata'd amount but the full pay would have been £11k and now they're giving you £11,100 but claiming they've given you a 10%+ pay rise, when they've actually only given you £100, which is less than 1%?

In any event, it sounds like you're unhappy with the pay you've been offered. Are you not very assertive? Maybe others who are getting paid more are better at stating their case.

You need to make a business case: how you have reached your targets; how you have contributed to making your department reach its targets; any processes you have streamlined or improved in some way; how you greater experience has made you a more effective employee; how you've taken on additional responsibilities. Anything that can be objectively measured. Meanwhile, if you feel you're not being valued by your company, look around for other jobs. It might do wonders for your confidence to move on.

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:06

@badgermushrooms Thank you, I appreciate your advice its extremely helpful. I enjoy the job, the commute is easy and has other really good perks. However, the most important thing to me is salary and this is where I feel they fall short. I know they could have paid me more, the fact that they haven’t makes me really think maybe I shouldn’t even bother to fight this and just begin to look elsewhere. It feels personal to me

OP posts:
endofthelinefinally · 25/04/2022 10:04

You do need to look at your tax code and the amount of tax you are paying. I worked with an excellent P/T colleague and we wanted her to do more hours, but when she looked at the figures she would have been working extra hours for almost nothing because her tax bill would increase.
Have you checked all the figures on your contract and your payslip?

Starlia · 25/04/2022 10:03

So is this really a performance issue rather than the number of hours worked issue?
Your co worker got a substantial raise despite a lower performance rating (presuming co-worker isn't making stuff up?).
Perhaps the conversation should be framed around your performance rating and what/how you will be rewarded for good performance.
If that's the case, the number of hours you actually work is not relevant to the discussion.

badgermushrooms · 25/04/2022 10:02

The pro rata thing has obviously complicated matters but it just sounds as though you've received a really tiny pay rise, and that you know the company had the money for a better one as your colleagues got more.

If that's the case your first step should be to look around at similar jobs elsewhere to see what you could be paid if you moved - this means you know how much of a bargain your current employer is getting from you and so how much of a fuss you should be making. You might find that you're already being paid really well for your role and location. You might find that they're taking the piss so much that you might as well just start applying for other jobs straight away.

If you could be earning more elsewhere, go to your manager, sit down with them somewhere private and make your case case: "I was disappointed to only get a whatever% pay rise this year when my performance review said [all the good things it said] and the company is doing well (if it is). Is there any room to reconsider my salary for this year?" Then, and this is really important, stop talking. See what they say. If there's an awkward silence wait for them to fill it.

It might well be that they won't pay you any more, but isn't it worth trying, if you're otherwise happy there? If you're not happy and they're underpaying you then just skip this step and look for another job, obviously. But you will feel so good about yourself for having asked, I promise.

Cervinia · 25/04/2022 09:54

Hi Manager,

My full time salary in currently £10,100 right? so how come in 2016 I was on £10,000 but I now have more responsibilities and the cost of living has increased 20% ?

then take it from there.

NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 09:50

The info you need is

  1. FTE for your previous role
  2. FTE for your new role
  3. Evidence you do a great job and deserve a more significant pay rise because…
If none of that leads to a satisfactory outcome on pay rise, then you need to
  1. Look around at equivalent jobs to apply for
  2. Evaluate if these are better all-round (flexible working, salary, commute etc)
  3. Decide whether to stay or go.
Swipe left for the next trending thread