Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask wwyd about this work situation?

181 replies

justexisting22 · 24/04/2022 21:25

I've been angry for a few days following a recent salary review at work and I can't stop thinking over it in my head. I really need advice on how to handle the situation as I feel like I've been really undervalued and I'm seriously wondering now whether or not I should look for a new position at a totally different company.

For some background, my "new" salary for this year was my base salary last year, however this was pro rata to £Xk a year, as I worked part time but then changed to full time when I started a new role. So I'm wondering if is that even correct? Should this not have increased when I went back full time?

I've been at this company for 6 years, have qualifications experience etc, yet I'm still only on the starting salary for my position. It just doesn't seem right to me and to be honest I've been so upset and angry about it

AIBU to think I should just look elsewhere?

OP posts:
Jmaho · 25/04/2022 12:15

A 10% payrise is the same based on FTE as it is on Pro rata
My job pays £40000 FTE and I work 0.6 FTE over 3 days so my actual salary is £24000
If I get a 5% payrise that takes my FTE to £42000 and my pro rata to £25200 but if you worked out a 5% payrise on my pro rata salary its the same -
£24000 x 5% = £1200 so end salary is £25200 each way
I'm so confused

Sunnysideup · 25/04/2022 12:04

Exactly, ten percent on full time is exactly the same as ten percent on part time. It’s the same number. Because the increase is prorated when it comes to actual pay.

op I think you are thinking you should get the whole full time increase. You would not. You get the pro rated amount of that increase based on how much you work.

do not go to management and say it should be ten percent of the full amount, because it’s identical and it is ten percent of the full amount, it’s just you work part time so your pay is pro rated accordingly.

as for the colleague, unless their role is identical and you know what their base salary is, then it’s irrelevant. They may have had lower pay last year so got a bigger increase to bring it up.

it’s taken you a very long time to explain this to everyone, and it was so confused.

but the bottom line is, ten percent on part time hours is the exact same as ten percent on full time hours. You do not get the whole increase on the full time wage becayse you do not work full time. You are still only entitled to the pro rated pay for what you work.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 25/04/2022 11:53

This is why transparency regarding salaries and grades are important.

Well, I think transparency is a good thing because it helps show discrimination. But in cases like this it makes things worse; the OP is aggrieved because she thinks she works harder than other people, which is very subjective and also isn't particularly relevant to salary levels. It's not the same as finding out your three male colleagues in the same role as you but with less experience are all earning £10k more.

burnoutbabe · 25/04/2022 11:19

Merryoldgoat · 25/04/2022 10:55

But a 10% (say pay rise) would work out the same whichever it was calculated on.

10% fte pay rise then prorated to your hours is the same as 10% of your normal prorated salary.

the only thing I can imagine therefore is you expect the 10% increase calculated at the fte and then the actual amount added to your prorated salary which is not the same and not a 10% increase.

in which case it’s largely moot - you think you should have an increase of a specific amount so that’s what you need to discuss

Yes I sgeee.

I get a 10% rise based on me working one day a week. If I went back to 5 days I'd just get 5 times the new base.
It works out the same either way.

sillysmiles · 25/04/2022 11:17

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 24/04/2022 22:56

Again, this isn't unusual or surprising. People negotiate differently, have different levels of experience, and different skills. Salary is rarely proportional to effort but instead to skills and value.

You seem very naive about employment and how things work and you're pretty incoherent. I wouldn't bring any of this up with your manager or HR until you've calmed down, gathered your thoughts, and talked to some more experienced people.

This is why transparency regarding salaries and grades are important.

Evilcountspatula · 25/04/2022 11:16

@Merryoldgoat I agree and give up. Each time I think I’ve grasped what’s going on something else comes up that appears to change everything. OP in the kindest way, I suggest that you work on how you communicate. Whatever has actually gone on, you’re clearly aggrieved at your lack of progress up the pay scale. If your communication style is similar at work to how it has come across on here, it could very well be holding you back.

titchy · 25/04/2022 11:14

All I want to know is whether or not the increase should be based on the FTE base salary but there seems to be conflicted responses about that

It won't make any bloody difference! You'll still get exactly the same. It's basic bloody primary level numeracy - you can multiply numbers in whatever order you want - the outcome is the same.

ChateauMargaux · 25/04/2022 11:12

Is it possible that there is a miscommunication? Say your last year gross salary FTE was £19.000, because your hours are 2.5 hours less per week, you get paid £17,733 (assuming 35 out of 37.5 hours per week). If your increase as stated was 8% which would have increased your base salary to £20,520, the reduction to account for your reduced hours would take it to £19,145.

I think you need to clarify with your manager, work out what you think your rise should be based on the percentage increase that was communicated to you.

I also think you have another question:

Dear Manager, I have worked here for 6 years, have taken on additional responsibilities and have been rated highly, but it has come to my attention that I am paid significantly less than colleagues that have fewer responsibilities and have a lower rating. As you can imagine, this has left me feeling demotivated and undervalued. In advance of the pay rises being processed this year, I would like to discuss this with you with a view to revising this year's pay rise.

Kindly yours
Underpaid staff member!

titchy · 25/04/2022 11:12

@NoSquirrels it makes no difference - the maths is the same either way.

OP it doesn't matter if the 10% pay rise is calculated on your actual PT salary, or your FTE salary and then pro-rated down - you've still got 10%.

Work on your communication and numeracy skills.

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 11:08

NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 11:07

Name change and start a new thread in Employment Matters with all the details as simply laid out as possible, actual numbers.

HR or your manager isn’t going to see it or care, especially if you’re just keep to the facts and don’t say anything about being undervalued, other colleagues etc.

All I want to know is whether or not the increase should be based on the FTE base salary but there seems to be conflicted responses about that

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 11:07

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 11:05

I think I’m going to leave it to my manager, as I don’t want to go to HR and make a fool of myself. I don’t actually know what’s right or what’s wrong here.

Name change and start a new thread in Employment Matters with all the details as simply laid out as possible, actual numbers.

HR or your manager isn’t going to see it or care, especially if you’re just keep to the facts and don’t say anything about being undervalued, other colleagues etc.

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 11:05

I think I’m going to leave it to my manager, as I don’t want to go to HR and make a fool of myself. I don’t actually know what’s right or what’s wrong here.

OP posts:
Sunnysideup · 25/04/2022 10:57

Actually it’s even more bonkers than it looks. Becayse ten percent pay rise on the part time salary is absolutely identical to 10 percent increase on the full time salary, as the part time salary is pro rated. The op gets the same amount either way.

op are you thinking that if the full time salary went up by say 1500 you’d get 1500. Becayse you wouldn’t. You’d only get the pro rated amount for the hours you work, which will be the equivalent of the ten percent on your actuals

what I am saying is ten percent on the full time salary and ten percent on the part time salary is the exact same thing. You get the same amount either way. Because you still work the same hours.

so..

pay is twenty grand.
ten percent increase makes it 22 grand
you work 90 percent
means your pay is 19800
your salary increase is 1800. It will never be the full two grand.becayse you only work 90 percent, so you get ninety percent of the increase.

so last year full time pay was

20 grand
you worked ninety percent.
so your pay was 18000
ten percent of 18000 is 1800.
which is your increase above. Either way it is 1800.

so ten percent of the increase on full time pay versus part time pay is identical. You don’t get the full two grand increase, because your pay is prorated for the hours you work.

BobLemon · 25/04/2022 10:55

I’d go to manager, rather than HR.

Merryoldgoat · 25/04/2022 10:55

But a 10% (say pay rise) would work out the same whichever it was calculated on.

10% fte pay rise then prorated to your hours is the same as 10% of your normal prorated salary.

the only thing I can imagine therefore is you expect the 10% increase calculated at the fte and then the actual amount added to your prorated salary which is not the same and not a 10% increase.

in which case it’s largely moot - you think you should have an increase of a specific amount so that’s what you need to discuss

KrisAkabusi · 25/04/2022 10:53

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:47

@NoSquirrels Yeah I thought the rise would be based on base salary then new pro rata amount

That would have been appropriate if you were working full-time hours, but you're not. You're working the same hours as last year, so you've got a 10% increase in last year's pay.

You can't compare it to your full time pay because you're working two and a half hours less per week compared to then. You're upset with all of this is because you're comparing now with a couple of years ago and only seeing the financial difference. You're ignoring that you're working less hours for the same money.

NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 10:49

What I think the OP is saying is that her 30 hours role was clearly based on a FTE salary.

Now they’ve tried to imply that the 30 hours salary was never based on a FTE.

If they’d done it that way from the start, fine. But you can’t just change your accounting basis and the pay scale etc because it suits. They’ve either made a mistake or they’re pulling a fast one.

PainterMummy · 25/04/2022 10:48

If you’re under market rate for your job, move. You have years of experience, training etc, you have already brought this up to your manager that your pay is it correct and still nothing has been done. If your manager really valued you, they would look in to that right away. A simple email would be enough.

id both raise it with HR for clarification on the pay, including clarification per hour so you can advise them if the hours you have been working full time but not receiving full time pay. I would also look for another job.

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:47

@NoSquirrels Yeah I thought the rise would be based on base salary then new pro rata amount

OP posts:
justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:46

@Merryoldgoat I’ve given a clear example and @Yellownightmare summed up what I was trying to get across, so it’s really not that confusing

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 10:46

If she works for a company that does it any other way than I’ve outlined, sunny, then she should definitely look for a better job!

Sunnysideup · 25/04/2022 10:44

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:43

@Sunnysideup I see your point here. I just thought pay rises would go off the base salary, not the pro rata one

Op, it’s up to them, they can do it on any base they want, they don’t even need to give you a pay rise.

Merryoldgoat · 25/04/2022 10:44

Is it just me or is this thread utterly bonkers? It’s one of the most confusing threads I’ve read simply because entirely mundane details could be ‘outing’.

tgis could be cleared up in 10 minutes if you put down actual hours, FTE hours and the various salaries.

instead no one can advise you properly because with every second post you change your mind or add something new or contradictory.

there are people on here who do this for a living. Why not actually use them?

Sunnysideup · 25/04/2022 10:44

NoSquirrels · 25/04/2022 10:43

No.

The pay rise of 10% is calculated on the FTE. Then that new higher amount is pro-rated.

FTE £20,000
Pro-rated 90% = £18,000

Pay rise of 10% calculated on the FTE for the role.

FTE £22,000
Pro-rated 90% = £19,800

That’s how it works.

It clearly doesn’t. They are free to give the increase in her actuals.

justexisting22 · 25/04/2022 10:43

@Sunnysideup I see your point here. I just thought pay rises would go off the base salary, not the pro rata one

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread