Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish we never had DC6?

310 replies

FartVandelay · 24/04/2022 18:44

We have two DC, 8 and 6.

DC8 has ADHD and while impulsive and a charterbox at times is very sweet and has a heart of gold. I worry about them being taken advantage of at school.

DC6 is a different story. Sneaky, crafty, bullies their sibling, talks back at us, lies and cheats. Yet is a completely different person at school. Their teachers are baffled when we ask how their behaviour is at school compared to home. I have constant battles with food with DC6. Evening meals take hours. They refuse to eat 90% of what I put in front of them regardless of whether they've eaten it before and professed it the best ever. They constantly defy me, hide sweets in their room. I love DC6 so so much but am at the end of my tether. I came close to telling DC6 I wish we'd never had them tonight. Feel like the worst parent. I see all these other families so happy. I was happy when DC6 was born, so happy. I thought our family was complete but if I could turn thr clock back I'm not sure what I'd do. They just make life so hard. I'm exhausted fighting these constant battles with DC6. DH is away with work until Tuesday. I just don't know if I can do two more nights of handling the DC alone. We have no family local and my friends all have their own families to deal with. Is it really this hard?

OP posts:
k1233 · 25/04/2022 00:48

The thing that jumps out at me is your adversarial language when discussing DC6.

I particularly noted this comment you made about DC6 When they've had a lovely day we reiterate this at bedtime and say see how great its been. If its been more challenging I reflect back on it with them but always tuck them in and say we can try again tomorrow.

Does DC6 ever just get to be a child without their behaviour being analysed every night and told to do better? They must feel such a disappointment to you. As you're finding, when a child feels like this any attention, good or bad is better than no attention. Why bother trying to be good when they're just going to be told it wasn't good enough.

I don't agree with suggestions (charts etc) to judge the child. Instead try being kind. Have clear rules that apply to everyone - dinner time is eg 30 mins at which point table is cleared etc Don't isolate DC6 and make them feel different to DC8. That will just reinforce to them that DC8 is the favourite and they can't do anything right. Try very hard never to compare them and accept they are individuals and embrace their individuality.

I like the suggestion of involving DC6 with meal preparation. It's something they like and would be nice 1 on 1 time with you.

stiritwithaknife · 25/04/2022 00:24

This thread is grim and depressing.

From the 'golden child'-'scapegoat' dynamic, bedtime performance reviews, and wishing one's child didn't exist because they're disobedient and unplug a kindle... to the medicalisation in replies diagnosing a child with rare neurodevelopmental disorders because they won't eat pizza crust.

Just grim.

SylvanianFrenemies · 25/04/2022 00:13

Robinni · 24/04/2022 23:56

I think possibly ASD too, maybe ODD (oppositional defiant disorder)?

three ideas to help:

  1. Naughty step: time out, one minute per year of age, no talking, no moving, no toys.
  2. Have a big chart on the wall. When DC6 eats something successfully add it (pictorial if possible) to the chart as evidence of that food being acceptable. When they refuse in future refer them to the evidence on the wall. And incentivise them - if you can eat some carrots and potato you will get a pudding/sweets/to watch an episode of fave tv show.
  3. Star charts also good given for good behaviour and taken away for bad. If they are eager to please at school this should help

This is terrible advice.

Naughty step? For what? OP describes normal behaviour. In any case, punishment of a small child without understanding or resolving the underlying drivers is pointless.
Big chart analysing food intake? With a side of anxiety and future eating disorder perhaps.
Better to focus on a secure connection rather than a star chart for an eager to please child.

Sswhinesthebest · 25/04/2022 00:10

Love bomb your youngest and give them some special youngest privileges “because they are younger”

Robinni · 24/04/2022 23:56

I think possibly ASD too, maybe ODD (oppositional defiant disorder)?

three ideas to help:

  1. Naughty step: time out, one minute per year of age, no talking, no moving, no toys.
  2. Have a big chart on the wall. When DC6 eats something successfully add it (pictorial if possible) to the chart as evidence of that food being acceptable. When they refuse in future refer them to the evidence on the wall. And incentivise them - if you can eat some carrots and potato you will get a pudding/sweets/to watch an episode of fave tv show.
  3. Star charts also good given for good behaviour and taken away for bad. If they are eager to please at school this should help
To wish we never had DC6?
AngelaRayner4PM · 24/04/2022 23:40

Yes the way that ADHD presents is different due to to sex. It's not just nature (chromosomes, sex) that impacts how ADHD is perceived, however, because gender norms do change the way we perceive certain attributes. And we often place different expectations on children according to their gender. Boys are often expected to be naughtier and more competitive, whereas girls are meant to be well behaved and more accommodating. Girls often aren better at masking not just because of neurological/biological differences but because of societal expectations and conditioning. It's not just about natal sex

Summerfun54321 · 24/04/2022 23:40

I just don’t understand why children are badgered and harassed into eating. It’s so unproductive and stressful. I wouldn’t be able to enjoy a single mouthful of food with someone breathing down my neck “eat the food, eat the food”.

ZoeCM · 24/04/2022 23:38

OP, your child is only six. He/she is not the problem here. You are. Wishing your six-year-old didn't exist because of fairly ordinary childhood behaviour is disturbing.

Overthewine · 24/04/2022 23:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

cloudcats · 24/04/2022 23:24

Oh, doesn't Mumsnet automatically create links any more?! That's rubbish!

Here's a clicky link for the fussy eater method Division of Responsibility.

www.yummytoddlerfood.com/the-division-of-responsibility/

SylvanianFrenemies · 24/04/2022 23:22

Just going to be frank for the sake of all involved.

Your child is six. Six! You need to seriously dial down they way you think and speak about them, and the golden child role you are putting DC1 in.

Regarding mealtimes.. Offer meal. Don't like it? Cheese sandwich and an apple. Done. No battles needed. No wonder they hide food/leftovers.

Also the appraisal of the day stuff... This is your child, not a probationary employee. They don't need a recap of their fuck ups and an action plan for future improvement. Just read a story and have some cuddles.

Remember how you were a child once? Try to connect with how it feels.

The family therapy suggestion is an excellent one.

cloudcats · 24/04/2022 23:17

I know friends with fussy eaters who have done this method "division of responsibilities" to take the stress out of mealtimes:

www.yummytoddlerfood.com/the-division-of-responsibility/

(That website is aimed at parents of toddlers but D.O.R. is suitable for any age.)

AngelaRayner4PM · 24/04/2022 23:16

I read this as

Masking at school
Sensory issues around food
Constant battles (defiance and/or communication issues, if it's about moving from one activity to another then problems with the transitions)
Problems with rule following and authority
Binge eating/ sugar addiction
Impulse control issues (and lying to cover the shame of their behaviour or to avoid the punishments)

That's a whole lot of neurodiversity right there! Just because you have one child with ADHD doesn't mean you won't have two (actually your more likely to if one has it) and also doesn't mean you won't have one with ADHD and one with ASD or one with ADHD and one with ADHD and ASD combo. Things like gender and where they fall in the family order can have a massive impact on kids, so I wouldn't rule out that they both have ADHD just because they are very different from each other. Also, with any of these things people can have bigger deficits in one area to another. Eg. One person with ADHD might become overwhelmed very easily in a noisy classroom whereas another has higher tolerance for noise, or one may have lots of problems with time keeping but rarely lose things, and another not struggle with that so much but instead struggle with keeping track of their things. The biggest variation IME is to do with gender/sex though.

BogRollBOGOF · 24/04/2022 23:16

Sounds like normal-ish 6yo behaviour to me.

DS1's finest moment at that age was trying to frame DS2 for biting... 1) it was out of character for DS2... 2) DS1 was missing the same teeth as the deep bite mark in his arm 😂

DS1 has ended up with ASD and dyspraxia diagnoses initiated by a variety of traits. He's very much a masker at school. He can be hard work, and more so for me. I'm there constantly. I'm forgiving. When DH is away there's the double whammy of change of routine/ dynamic and lack of back-up. At 6-7 we had some right humdinger moments when DH was out of the country.

Even before diagnosis, just getting a referal and putting all his idiosyncracies together and opening up to the possibility of him being ND made a difference. I use a lot of humour in my parenting. I don't get emotionally drawn into his moods- he's not getting personal with me, there'll be something else underlying and probably not the superficial thing he's blown over. I do lose patience sometimes, but I do well before getting to that point.

There are consequences and I pick battles that matter. 1:1 time with both DCs is important. I hope I meet the needs of both my DCs' personalities and emotions. DS1 can be a rotter to DS2, but they also love each other. DS1 can also be lovely with other children; he was recently particularly gentle and kind with a nervous new Cub and read his needs well because he identified with them.

NT or ND, you can tweak your parenting and see if it results in a happier parent-child relationship.

Overthewine · 24/04/2022 23:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

BarnacleNora · 24/04/2022 23:10

Interesting. I have two of the same sex, very similar ages and the oldest is diagnosed autistic. Very similar temperaments too by the sound of it! I would ask has your youngest always been like this? My youngest has definitely always been more of a wild child but I'm noticing that age six has definitely brought more challenges, it's quite a difficult age!

I would agree with questions over neurodiversity. It can definitely run in families and can present in different ways. My youngest is on the waiting list to be assessed for ADHD. However I'd been suspecting this for a long long time, I just had to bide my time until he was old enough to be accepted for assessment.

I'm a single parent so can't really do much tag teaming and it is difficult for sure but does your older child have any special interests they can do on their own? My older child is much more interested in the iPad than the younger one so sometimes at the weekend I'll get the older 'hooked up' to minecraft and me and the younger one will play board games for a while (he absolutely loves any kind of board or card game!) Maybe that's a possibility? Just spending a little bit of 1:1 time can make a big bit of difference.

I do get it though, it can be enormously hard and frustrating but they're not bad people or flawed in their characters. They're just small people trying to work out their place in the world and unfortunately sometimes they'll do whatever they can to get that attention, whether it's negative or positive! I'm writing as if I've got it all figured out and I definitely don't-my 6 year old and I have had some absolute battles but I am trying to make it more fun for all of us. Bloody hard work though!

Diverseopinions · 24/04/2022 23:07

MichelleScarn I'm not psychoanalysing the six-year old, I've said, on the contrary, that we respondents don't have enough information or context to judge anything at all about the child. I've said nothing about the child's behaviour. I've said the mother may have worried based on the way interactions have come across to her, or the way she has interpreted subterfuge or cunning been carried out. It's just the OP's interpretation and concerns, but they could be sincerely-founded, so don't doubt your own feelings. I'm saying, don't rule out a problem with social responsibility, and if you're still concerned in future, there's the option of speaking to a trained expert , instead of discussing it with an armchair expert.

PolitePlantPot · 24/04/2022 23:06

@pocketbunny love the sound of time in. Especially if it's available to any kid who is having an off day for any reason, and isn't monopolised by the same few. I do a version of this too, any time I feel particularly pissed off with one of my kids i make sure that I spend 2 hours (minimum) on my own with them doing something they love. It just seems to reset everyone (obviously know I'm privileged to have a supportive partner which allows this to happen and not everyone has that choice - it still takes a lot of juggling...and if necessary we abandon homework for the week to focus on wellbeing and talking). I also make sure that it evens out so they get the same time with me overall.

pocketbunny · 24/04/2022 22:56

There's a famous psychologist who says nothing should ever be a battle, everything stems from an unmet need. What is the child needing?

Can you mix up dinner time? Have a picnic inside on the floor. Just make it fun. See how your children respond in a different situation...

I'm a teacher and when we are finding children especially challenging we actually do "time in" with them - spending time one on one doing something fun or constructive to build a positive memory over a negative one. It also prevents the child from 'failing' again and repeating an unwanted behaviour because they are getting support and attention.

Diverseopinions · 24/04/2022 22:55

Daffodilsandcoffee the whole point of Mumsnet is that you canvas a range of opinions. Nobody is encouraging or egging on, they are giving their own view. The OP takes a look at a range of opinions, which gives them a balance, and the see the majority view, and they see some reasons why some posters think a particular thing.

Some posters, me, on this occasion, want to counter the consensus in order to stop the poster being swayed too far, one way. It's good to look at things in the round from all angles.

BurbageBrook · 24/04/2022 22:53

Reflecting on it further... what comes across from your post most of all is a feeling of lack of love over minor ordinary childhood behaviour. Maybe time to look at yourself, not your 'sneaky' 'crafty' child.

MichelleScarn · 24/04/2022 22:53

@Diverseopinions your opinion isn't very 'diverse' here is it? Why are you so repetitive about this 6year old having a 'conduct' disorder and psychoanalysing them?

BurbageBrook · 24/04/2022 22:47

Honestly OP your attitude sounds incredibly problematic. Most people don't like pizza crusts, hardly the 'crime' of the century not to eat them. You sound like you are trying to scapegoat a six year old, which is often the start of abusive or at the very least emotionally damaging behaviour. This is a SIX YEAR OLD you are calling 'sneaky', 'crafty', etc. Let me tell you that as a former teacher who did some time in primary schools as well as secondary schools - I never felt the need to call any child this, least of all primary age children. It's horrible how you talk about your child, and it suggests that your attitudes are the problem.

pumpkinpie01 · 24/04/2022 22:47

I haven't read everyone's responses so apologies op if this has been suggested already. But when your dc is behaving actually interrupt them and tell them there and then. ' Hey absolutely loving how well you're sharing at the moment ' or ' great jumping on the trampoline together , fantastic behaviour' . It sounds silly and you feel daft randomly interrupting them but it did actually make a difference to my sons behaviour .

Diverseopinions · 24/04/2022 22:47

MichelleScarn

Not at all. The OP is citing some examples, but what's unsettling her is a feeling, and maybe it's the way the elder child is induced to give in to the younger, not the incident itself. We are always telling posters to trust their instincts about something being wrong, where partners or nannies are concerned. Why not trust one's instincts where children are concerned. Six is young, but be prepared to seek expert parenting advice, in future.

A child psychologist would be advising the mother and father on their approach and what is the current scientific finding on the behaviour being mentioned. I think a school would need to be involved, and the GP, before a private psychologist would agree to work with the child.

There are different types of psychologists and therapists, and all trained, so, yes, I should think what they say will be worth hearing. Better than becoming unhappy as a parent and bottling it up.

Conduct disorder isn't a diagnosis which always results in an adult diagnosis of anti-social personality disorder and the latter isn't always an indicator of sociopathy. We can't make a diagnosis, nor should we wish to. But what we can do is counsel balance, and it's important to acknowledge that parents' worries can be relevant, as well as it being vital to keep a perspective and not jump to the worst interpretation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread