Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish we never had DC6?

310 replies

FartVandelay · 24/04/2022 18:44

We have two DC, 8 and 6.

DC8 has ADHD and while impulsive and a charterbox at times is very sweet and has a heart of gold. I worry about them being taken advantage of at school.

DC6 is a different story. Sneaky, crafty, bullies their sibling, talks back at us, lies and cheats. Yet is a completely different person at school. Their teachers are baffled when we ask how their behaviour is at school compared to home. I have constant battles with food with DC6. Evening meals take hours. They refuse to eat 90% of what I put in front of them regardless of whether they've eaten it before and professed it the best ever. They constantly defy me, hide sweets in their room. I love DC6 so so much but am at the end of my tether. I came close to telling DC6 I wish we'd never had them tonight. Feel like the worst parent. I see all these other families so happy. I was happy when DC6 was born, so happy. I thought our family was complete but if I could turn thr clock back I'm not sure what I'd do. They just make life so hard. I'm exhausted fighting these constant battles with DC6. DH is away with work until Tuesday. I just don't know if I can do two more nights of handling the DC alone. We have no family local and my friends all have their own families to deal with. Is it really this hard?

OP posts:
MooPointCowsOpinion · 24/04/2022 19:48

I’m just going to share what I’ve changed recently to reduce battles in my home. If it’s not useful please do feel free to discard.
My youngest is 7yo and I think my expectations of them are sometimes too high. My eldest is a few years older and I always know they’re going to do the right thing, whereas youngest doesn’t and will sometimes actively choose what I don’t want them to do. I think I’ve partly caused that, by jumping in with my expectations based on how eldest has always been, instead of hanging back and letting them figure it out.
I think back to when my eldest was 7 and I’m sure I didn’t hold them to such high expectations, I just loved them and let them be and didn’t try to force anything or change them. I’m trying really really hard to expect less and understand and accept more.
Tonight for bath time (huge battlefield for us) I just made it all a game and it was completely fine, over in 15 mins.
Take “should” out of your vocab. There is no morality issues here, your child isn’t deceitful, they’re just worried about being in trouble and also working out what free will they have and what rules they can break.

lottiegarbanzo · 24/04/2022 19:48

If his behaviour is good at school something must be happening at home that’s triggering the bad behaviour.

That's such rubbish. The kids to be worried about are the ones who let out all their difficult emotions at school - because they don't feel safe or able to do so at home.

I just don't know why they have the need to impress the teacher but not us.

Because you are their family, their home, their safe, let it all out place. Whereas they have a specific, limited relationship with the teacher, for a fixed time and purpose.

Ticksallboxes · 24/04/2022 19:47

Gosh. What you're describing sounds very minor IMO. You're either leaving loads of detail out of your posts or you're completely neurotic.

If it's the latter then wow, poor DC6, and I'd advise you to get a grip and grow a heart.

Rinatinabina · 24/04/2022 19:46

FartVandelay · 24/04/2022 19:04

They lie. Yesterday I said they have to eat 2 pizza crusts and then found them in the bin hidden under other rubbish. They try to get their sibling into trouble all the time. I feel like we're failing as patents because they can be so nasty. Is that just siblings? I have a brother who is a lot older than me and we are close, not like this.

I wouldn't dream of saying it. It was on the tip of my tongue but I didn't say it. I just think ba k to how happy we were when they were born and it breaks my heart

I’m 40 and still don’t eat pizza crust, I think that really isn’t a big deal, I’d probably chuck it on the sly as well if someone was insisting I eat it. I think lie is a very strong word for that.

User48751490 · 24/04/2022 19:44

I would also add that my two youngest fight like cat and dog regularly and DH and I have sometimes had to intervene.

Heliotropium · 24/04/2022 19:44

Make dinner, clear table after 45 minutes. Offer toast half hour before bed. Nothing else. Don't battle with them to eat it. Your job is to provide the food, their job is to eat it. You cannot force them. Stop making it a battle

Agree with this. Making it go on for hours is going to turn it into more of a problem.

PeekabooAtheZoo · 24/04/2022 19:42

I used to lie when my mum was overbearing and tried to force me to do things I couldn't do, like stay at the table and finish my dinner that I'd left because I had texture issues with the food and didn't have the words to explain that, or when I had nothing to drink and my mouth was too dry to eat anything. At that age for me it was because I was scared of being in trouble or being made to do the thing I couldn't do and I lied in the hope of a quiet life. When my mum did catch me she always rubbed it in "fine go to bed hungry" "well starve then" where just taking the food away would have been kinder.

I kicked my sibling when no one was watching because she kicked me first and knew how to press my buttons and she would always scream loudest and be believed. I sneaked down at night and stole raisins because I was miserable and hungry and wanted to eat something I actually could swallow without gagging.

At seven, I started stealing other kids' packed lunch snacks at school as I was hungry and knew I could eat them in the toilets before play time was over. I was secretive because I didn't want to get into trouble and couldn't stop myself as I had poor impulse control. I was also considered a model student by teachers and I never got caught about the snacks (something I feel deeply awful over now).

At that age if I could have had one wish it would have been that my mum asked me what I wanted at the supermarket. Even just my preferred breakfast cereal would have made a huge difference. Or switching Kwik Save No Frills Economy Sausages for chicken nuggets. As it was, I got two meals shoved at me every day that I hated and the only place I felt in control of what I ate was at school. I still have a difficult relationship with food and have battled with being underweight all my life.

I wasn't diagnosed with ADHD until I was 33 and had comprehensively ruined my life. You sound nothing like my mum, but your child's behaviour sounds similar to mine at that age. It's clear you obviously want to help your child, and maybe reframe that as "winning" instead of feeling like you're losing every battle of wills against them. You can't ever lose if you love them and you're doing the right thing to help them, even if that means stepping back sometimes or changing what you're doing.

JeSuisFattyGay · 24/04/2022 19:41

A lot of this is normal, if irritating, sibling stuff.

Don't use a timer as it will just add to the stress. I'm 50, and if I had to listen to a timer ticking away while I was eating my supper, I'd find it very off-putting.

You need no stress at all about meal times. Give them their dinner (involve younger DC in preparing it, if you think that might work), eat with them, clear away anything that hasn't been eaten without comment.

Behaving well at school and letting it all out at home sounds like masking to me (though could also be neurotypical behaviour - some neurotypical children are just more difficult than others, and have to find ways to rein it in at school).

Look at your older child's behaviour, too. Are they always as nice to their sibling as you think they are? Are they using their 'niceness' as a way to get at their sibling in a more subtle way - in that both children will have worked out whom you're likely to believe and of whom you are more likely to think well?

Whatever you do, don't brand your younger child "sneaky" or "deceitful", as that is what they will become if you tell them often enough that this is what they are. Especially not over something very trivial. With the pizza crusts, for example, if the alternatives are either eating something you don't want to eat, or sitting at the table for what will feel to a six-year-old like an eternity, I'd be slipping them into the bin, too.

If you don't buy sweets, nobody can "sneak" them. If you do want to buy them, give them to the DC and say they can eat them whenever they like, but when they have gone, that's that.

Spend time with them both individually. Even if just 10 or 15 minutes.

Whinge · 24/04/2022 19:40

Axahooxa · 24/04/2022 19:35

I don’t think it’s wise to reflect on bad behaviour at bedtime, or leave all the praise til the end of the day. It’s not appropriate to say ‘try again tomorrow’- this is really harsh. Can you imagine how it might feel to a child? They’d feel they weren’t god enough.

Expect some unwanted behaviour every single day- sometimes lots of it- it’s totally normal.

I agree.

Imagine ending the day hearing about how you could have done better, lying there before you sleep thinking about how you can try again tomorrow, when you've already spent the day trying your best. 😢

lassof · 24/04/2022 19:40

Watch out for the 'Perfect Peter' 'Horrid Henry' dynamic. The examples you give are of really normal sibling behaviour. I would be wary that you are setting your younger up to fail and labelling them as 'the naughty one'. As others have said, they know when you have a favourite, and will play up to your expectations.

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 24/04/2022 19:39

The way your phrasing demonises pretty normal childlike behaviour that deviates from your ideal is quite disturbing.

You come across as if your love for your children is conditional, and your younger child has somehow let you down by not remaining the ‘perfect’ blank slate they seemed to be as a new baby. And in some part of your head, you’re making them responsible for your unhappiness.

He or she will be able to tell. Children pick these things up.

duvetdayforeveryone · 24/04/2022 19:38

TinLeaf · 24/04/2022 18:46

If his behaviour is good at school something must be happening at home that’s triggering the bad behaviour

Or DC6 could be holding it all in at school and exploding when they get home?

Onlyforcake · 24/04/2022 19:37

So your older child acts impulsively but it's all OK because of a diagnosis. But your second younger, classic attention seeking second you wish you hadn't had when they probably don't understand the reason why 8 year old is special sainted child?

You fear your 8 year old is too naive but dislike the conniving (average?) skills of the six year old.

Perhaps you and your six year old just want another child a little less ordinary.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/04/2022 19:36

What had they eaten before the pizza crusts? I'm assuming as yo u said crusts not slices they'd actually eaten?

BattenburgDonkey · 24/04/2022 19:36

It sounds a little like you judge your 6 year old by your 8 year olds standards, it’s great your 8 year old is so lovely, but that isn’t ‘normal’ sibling behaviour, especially for a 6 year old, they don’t sound crafty or bad, they just have different limits. Plenty of 6 year olds would hide pizza crusts. Try not to compare the two so much, or let DC6 see how much more you appreciate their older siblings behaviour as I think it may not be helping you. Sounds like a very difficult situation though OP, especially with DH away. Hopefully some of the suggestions around meal times on here help you

User48751490 · 24/04/2022 19:36

My 6yo comes through for dinner and says "eww I don't want that for dinner!" sometimes. His loss. We all carry on eating ours and won't entice him. He can eat if he is hungry, if not there's always supper before bed.

Please choose your battles carefully OP. Pizza crusts isn't one of them! Hope things get easier for you.

whenwilliwillibefamous · 24/04/2022 19:35

Re. Your example about crafts and Kindle chargers - why wasn't it possible for both of them to have the craft they wanted (did you buy different ones not thinking that they might both want the same one?) and both charge their kindle?
Is there a larger issue of unconsciously not realising that 2 X DC means 2 X resources needed, so that there's not quite enough to go around, often, giving rise to conflict? Just something to mull over.

Your older DC got years of being the only kid, and, even now, will still be the oldest and the first to do everything - it's natural, yes, and common, to be less excited about & involved in all the doings of 2nd DC, but it's still not brilliant being that 2nd kid.

I was the oldest but in hindsight I do see how badly that phenomenon affected my younger sibling.

Axahooxa · 24/04/2022 19:35

I don’t think it’s wise to reflect on bad behaviour at bedtime, or leave all the praise til the end of the day. It’s not appropriate to say ‘try again tomorrow’- this is really harsh. Can you imagine how it might feel to a child? They’d feel they weren’t god enough.

Expect some unwanted behaviour every single day- sometimes lots of it- it’s totally normal.

MerryMarigold · 24/04/2022 19:35

On a deeper level, I think you may have got into a dynamic with dh where you 'favour' ADHD dc1 because dh finds them challenging/ prefers dc2 (is he/ she clever/ learns fast/ better at something dh values eg. sport?) and you want to compensate for dh. Either that, or dh is compensating for you favouring dc1. I think it tends to start with one parent but can develop into a very dysfunctional family dynamic over the long term. I know this because I have been there too.

Incidentally my most academic child is the one who was best behaved in school at that age (knows what to do to please teachers, and wanted to please teachers), but also knows how to manipulate and push buttons at home. He does not have any SEN (unlike his brother, who would not know how to be manipulative or devious). He needs to be engaged all the time, learning and stimulated. He's also very perceptive, so he would spot the 'favouritism' and act up.

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 24/04/2022 19:35

The behaviours you’re describing are fairly normal for close in age siblings. I think you got “lucky” with DC1 as they are v well behaved.

The dynamic with younger kids tends to be different- I love my younger sister to bits but she was definitely worse than me behaviour wise when growing up.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/04/2022 19:34

FartVandelay · 24/04/2022 19:01

Thank you for thevsuggestions re a timer for food at dinner. I'll give that a try. I do think dinner has become a battle of wills now and I do t like to think that DC6 can "win" but if I draw the lines clearly I guess they're not really. Going to bed hungry a couple of times isn't going to do any harm

You can't win food op because you can't force it down their throats. Even when they DO eat, it's because they've chosen to. Don't make it a game and then there's no losers. DS is a bad eater for diff reasons but I've had to learn to let go.

MarshaBradyo · 24/04/2022 19:34

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/04/2022 19:29

Your younger child thinks you don't love them as much as their sibling. That is where this is coming from. To be fair they are correct. I think you need to look at your own parenting first. Your older child is quite possibly the one who is manipulating you by being so nice to their sibling.

What would you do yourself if someone tried to make you eat food you didn't want? I actually don't think hiding it in the rubbish to avoid being told off and made to sit at the table for hours is such a bad strategy. In that situation just say that if they want any more pizza they need to eat the crusts, if they don't they can move onto the next course or go and play. That way the choice is theirs and no arguing is required. Making it into such a big deal that a child is hiding their unwanted food in the bin is really terrible and bordering on abuse in my opinion.

I agree if they get a sense you didn’t want them or favour their sibling it will be causing harm and they will act on that

Cuddlemuffin · 24/04/2022 19:34

Honestly I would suggest that the best thing you can do is spend some regular one to one time with this child so they are made to feel special. Being difficult with food and sleep are common ways for chn to try and gain a control/attention when they feel they don't have any. Best to be nonchalant about the food situation, no timer. If they refuse to eat then just say 'ok please wait until we've finished eating to leave the table then' or 'just rat what you can' and leave it at that. It sounds like you clearly favour your eldest child at the moment and your youngest child perhaps feels resentment towards them for this. A morning out with alone with one parent or the other each weekend doing something nice together even if it's just feeding the ducks and a walk or a cake and hot chocolate at a cafe could make all the difference to your child's self esteem. Their behaviour and your response is becoming a negative cycle that needs to be broken. Make changes by making them feel validated, special and loved unconditionally x

DoorWasAJar · 24/04/2022 19:32

Pizza crusts are devoid of nutrition but do have pesticides so not particularly good food, I don’t blame her for not eating them.

1AngelicFruitCake · 24/04/2022 19:31

i have similar problems!

my advice (doesn’t always work)


  • do my best to avoid them seeing their sibling as the good one so I reprimand eldest when needed, don’t let it go if I wouldn’t for youngest

  • each day is a new day, I tell them lots of good things about them and say how well behaved they are so their self esteem is high

  • I work with eldest to be tougher on younger one and try and stamp out any unkindness quickly but massively praise kindness to their sibling

  • I try and them feel us and them so they see their sibling as on their side e.g. you two can choose this or you two if you can help each other do this can have this treat

  • I try and make sure they have 1:1 time with both of us and make my youngest aware that just because eldest sometimes has more things on, they are just as important

Swipe left for the next trending thread