Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are Expectations for birthday cakes getting out of hand?

167 replies

Yellowmellow2 · 24/04/2022 16:33

More and more I see threads on social media, of people showing photos of incredible birthday cakes (castles, palaces, Disney characters etc), and asking if anyone can make one for their child? When did this become a thing? Is a normal cake not enough any more? People just put so much pressure on themselves.

OP posts:
OfstedOffred · 24/04/2022 17:34

Woodhill I think lots of them were Jane Asher, we always had (home made) novelty cakes.

GlumyGloomer · 24/04/2022 17:34

I wanted to always make my kids cakes. Now dd is expecting a unicorn cake and I am sweating a bit 😅

OfstedOffred · 24/04/2022 17:33

I don't mind making a simple themed cake but I bake and decorate it myself at home. I use cutters etc, last year I made a simple spiderman cake. Standard victoria sponge inside.

The fancy ones I've noticed often include cheats like printed icing, plastic toppers etc and I often find that the cake inside isnt that nice. They are extortionately expensive.

DS is happy with what I make.

woodhill · 24/04/2022 17:32

jay55 · 24/04/2022 17:13

It was normal in the 80s to have a castle, train or character cake. My sister had Dougal one year and I had a tea set cake.
I think the cost of professional cakes has gone a bit crazy, but then so has the cost of butter and rent etc.

Or a football pitch

Don't forget the pudding basin cake with a China lady figure so it looked like a skirtSmile

SillySallySassySausage · 24/04/2022 17:31

yellowsuninthesky · 24/04/2022 16:35

Some people might put pressure on themselves. I never did. I bought a cake from the supermarket every year (just off the shelf like a Colin the Caterpillar cake, one year we got one in the shape of a Tardis for example). DS is now 19 and has never said he felt hard done by. You don't need to buy into this nonsense (and maybe with the cost of living increases people will just buy supermarket cakes).

I do, and think, exactly the same.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 24/04/2022 17:29

Professional cakes just taste far superior

Oh I MASSIVELY disagree. I generally find that homemade cakes taste way better (I slink into the Methodist church once a week purely to buy homemade cakes, since I am lazy). Professional cakes definitely look better, but the taste rarely lives up.

OctopusSay · 24/04/2022 17:29

I make a tray are and "decorate" it with small toys of the character of the moment. DC get a cake and toys for a fraction of the price of a professionally made cake.

catsonahottinroof · 24/04/2022 17:28

I think people have different priorities and it also depends on the size of the party - so it might be justified if your child was having a big party, but most children would be happy with shop bought, whatever. It often seems that no one really eats the cake and it can often be dry and disappointing.
There is a cake maker local to me who does really delicious moist cakes, they're in really tall, deep layers and mostly in the 'drip' style. If my child was having a big party I would consider using them. Otherwise, I like either homemade cake (tastes good but I'm useless at decorating) or M&S I found to be the best for shop bought.

Calmdown14 · 24/04/2022 17:27

I was questioning this the other day too. An £80 plus cake and a balloon arch come to more than I spend on the entire birthday for mine!

Like most things it seems to be very much about the photo op.

We do a combination of supermarket and making your own based on a low skill level! You can order edible icing photos so I've put those on home made or supermarket cakes. Also done the very simple train tracks on cupcakes using KitKat's (that is still the favourite for my Thomas fan) and a Rubble digger with falling smarties that covered my baking inadequacy as one side had dipped unintentionally!

knowinglesseveryday · 24/04/2022 17:26

It's lovely to have that as a hobby, but sort of odd to scour the net and pay a fortune to buy similar if it isn't a hobby of yours.

Bananarama21 · 24/04/2022 17:25

Professional cakes just taste far superior, I've done a mixture fo both for dc and homemade wins. My own dm was a cake decorator.

Countdownis35 · 24/04/2022 17:24

modgepodge · 24/04/2022 17:20

I don’t think it’s necessarily a new thing - my mum was amazing at cakes and always made us cakes in the shape of power rangers, bambi, a hockey pitch, castles etc - whatever we wanted. She used to do it for friends and friend did friends as a little business for a while when I was young but gave up because as above, people expected an amazing handmade personalised cake for what they’d pay for a supermarket cake. So people have always done it, but maybe you didn’t see as we didn’t have social media? Not all just friends had fancy cakes, some did, some hand supermarket ones, it was all fine then and still is now!

im trying to learn how to decorate cakes so I can sort of carry on the family tradition. This year I copped out and bought a character topper made of rice cake for £5 and put it on a plain iced cake though, personalised cakes that my toddler loved and it was cheap and easy! Might be an option if people feel under pressure.

If your mum bakes fancy cakes it's different because she won't be spend £150 on cake ingredients. 90s child here and I don't remember people having fancy cupcakes and birthday cakes at all.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 24/04/2022 17:24

I don't make them, I buy them! I've never made a birthday cake for DS in my life. I can afford to buy one from a professional cake maker, so that's my choice.

realsavagelike · 24/04/2022 17:23

@DockOTheBay , I don't even have a photo of my big and fancy cake - not everything is for show.

Yummymummy2020 · 24/04/2022 17:23

I just make a simple chocolate biscuit cake and whack on some fondent to suit😂😂😂 cheap and cheerful always well received with young and old. I couldn’t justify some of the extravagant cakes people get made as fabulous as they look!

modgepodge · 24/04/2022 17:20

I don’t think it’s necessarily a new thing - my mum was amazing at cakes and always made us cakes in the shape of power rangers, bambi, a hockey pitch, castles etc - whatever we wanted. She used to do it for friends and friend did friends as a little business for a while when I was young but gave up because as above, people expected an amazing handmade personalised cake for what they’d pay for a supermarket cake. So people have always done it, but maybe you didn’t see as we didn’t have social media? Not all just friends had fancy cakes, some did, some hand supermarket ones, it was all fine then and still is now!

im trying to learn how to decorate cakes so I can sort of carry on the family tradition. This year I copped out and bought a character topper made of rice cake for £5 and put it on a plain iced cake though, personalised cakes that my toddler loved and it was cheap and easy! Might be an option if people feel under pressure.

Yellowmellow2 · 24/04/2022 17:18

Threetulips · 24/04/2022 16:58

£80 my friend paid for a group of 10 children! On top of decorations balloons, new outfit, ball park hire, KFC food boxes party bags, sweets, near £1000 spent in 2 hours and no she can’t afford it really! All for show, all for social media!

It’s just awful to hear that people feel they have to do that just for affect. I can’t imagine the kids enjoy it more than a bog standard party.

Glad to hear that most of us still go for a Colin type cake or bake our own!

OP posts:
OctopusSay · 24/04/2022 17:17

Whose expectations?

Here you've gone fancy if mum's had a go at a character cake. The vast majority are from Tesco or Asda.

My DS1 would be very disappointed with anything but a caterpillar cake, not necessarily Colin Grin

Sunnierdays · 24/04/2022 17:16

We made a fancy cheesecake for my son’s 14th birthday last week but I did get a professional cake for my daughter’s 18th. The cake maker is amazing but only takes a few orders a year . Probably won’t get another made unless it’s a landmark birthday.

Lovinglife45 · 24/04/2022 17:15

I have always bought supermarket cakes for my dcs, usually from M&S. I could not justify several hundred pounds for a cake. I have seen some elaborate birthday cakes at birthday parties, one child had three. They seem to be a standard thing these days and used as a back drop for photographs. Social media has fueled the need for expensive and elaborate parties.

jay55 · 24/04/2022 17:13

It was normal in the 80s to have a castle, train or character cake. My sister had Dougal one year and I had a tea set cake.
I think the cost of professional cakes has gone a bit crazy, but then so has the cost of butter and rent etc.

DockOTheBay · 24/04/2022 17:11

Most people just have a normal cake. The ones who buy or make a huge cake are the ones who show it off on social media. The vast majority who buy a colin the Caterpillar or make a Victoria sponge just don't make a fuss so you wouldn't know.

MajorCarolDanvers · 24/04/2022 17:08

My mum bakes a lovely cake. That's always done for us.

seven201 · 24/04/2022 17:08

I buy a supermarket one for the party and do a fancy ish homemade one for a family party. I do enjoy making it though. I think I'd feel like I was showing off if I did it for a friends party. Whoever says it's supporting a local business makes a good point. I could just never bring myself to spend that much on a cake. Different priories I suppose.

Oneborneverydecade · 24/04/2022 17:06

My DD turns 4 on Tues and DH is planning an Aunt Bessie covered in fudge icing, Smarties and chocolate fingers - she'll love it!
With my older DCs we've started buying Colin.
When they were class party age we were lucky that my MIL is really good at cake decorating.
Haven't chosen to buy a bakery cake yet but never say never!