Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are Expectations for birthday cakes getting out of hand?

167 replies

Yellowmellow2 · 24/04/2022 16:33

More and more I see threads on social media, of people showing photos of incredible birthday cakes (castles, palaces, Disney characters etc), and asking if anyone can make one for their child? When did this become a thing? Is a normal cake not enough any more? People just put so much pressure on themselves.

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 24/04/2022 22:10

Yep

for dd 1st birthday I used a cake maker.

Think cost was about £70

it wasn’t huge

last 4 birthdays I’ve brought a large cake from Aldi. Think 3.99. Feeds 16 decent slices

even more so for parties. That kids will squash /leave cake

dont waste your money on costly cakes that are unlikely to be eaten

Hawkins001 · 24/04/2022 21:51

FangsForTheMemory · 24/04/2022 21:44

all the shit going on in the world and you're worried about birthday cakes?

There are always various events going on in the world that could be debated that are more important, beside why should daily life stop, just because of x,y, ect happening, and even then, if x event is solved what about the next event, or the one after, would you agree there will always be something else that's more important, so what are people ment to do then ? Please enlighten us, with your perspectives and analysis.

hiredandsqueak · 24/04/2022 21:50

To be truthful we don't even bother with supermarket cakes. I make a Victoria sandwich and put icing and sprinles on. It always gets eaten where, when I did buy supermarket cakes they didn't.

FangsForTheMemory · 24/04/2022 21:44

all the shit going on in the world and you're worried about birthday cakes?

PlasticineMeg · 24/04/2022 21:43

I agree it’s parents putting pressure on themselves. We get a Colin every year, as did I, it’s tasty and easy to cut up. No way am I buying into this OTT cake phenomenon - not least because it always creates a huge amount of waste

Sceptre86 · 24/04/2022 21:40

I buy them and can afford to, if I couldn't then I would buy a cheaper cake. My kids tend to have a big first birthday with both sides of the family so I will get a two or three tier cake for then. After that I either make the cake or will buy it depending on the theme. Last year my son wanted a dinosaur cake so I bought a waitrose made to order one which was delicious costing £40. This year my dd asked for a barbie cake with the doll in it and I paid £50 to a cake maker for it. Dd has had two lockdown birthdays where she has had supermarket cakes. It's only putting pressure on yourself if you can't afford it but still do so to keep up with others. Lots of people will spend money on different things, some of which I consider frivolous but it's their money.

LolaO · 24/04/2022 21:37

I love a fancy cake! I am actually good at making kids birthday cakes so, given that I think it’s fun, I make fancy elaborate cakes each time for my two DC. I don’t need to get a pro one done as while I am far slower and a bit less polished I can have a decent go at most things. (It’s my only culinary skill so I am not going to be overly modest about it! DH does all other cooking and baking in our household!)

Most of the DC’s friends either have a pro one or a parent or grandparent that has a decent go - it’s the centrepiece for a party buffet and is part of the decoration too so it is good to have a nice one (we live in an affordable area, and the DC are at a school where the majority are pretty comfortable so I don’t think anyone is at risk of financially overstretching due to cake).

Giraffesandbottom · 24/04/2022 21:27

@Yellowmellow2

if you actually think “each to their own”, why start a thread saying people spending money on cakes is because they want to show off? Do people also buy big houses for the same reason? Or is it more about preference and being able to afford it?

Yellowmellow2 · 24/04/2022 21:25

Giraffesandbottom · 24/04/2022 20:34

you and some other posters just sound jealous tbh.

I always get a cake maker to make fancy cakes for the children. I don’t post anything on social media - it has nothing to do with that and everything with enjoying creating a fun party with a theme. I like to bake and decorate but I don’t have time with 2 small children and it takes pressure off to pay a professional. How does that bother you enough to start a post unless you feel badly about not doing it yourself? Or do you just want to make fun of others/tear them down for no reason?

It’s been popular to get bakeries and cake makers eg Jane Asher to bake fancy cakes for decades, it’s not recent

No, certainly not jealous. Each to their own I guess.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 24/04/2022 21:03

Crunchymum · 24/04/2022 19:37

Maybe I shouldn't have googled "cake sitting" Shock

Cake smashes are vile on every possible level.

Professional cakes aren't for me (can't afford it, wouldn't waste it on my kids who like like crappy supermarket shite) but have no issue with others paying for it. Especially if I get a slice Grin

I can bake very basicallyand did make their cakes when they were little but mine now prefer to pick a Colin / Frozen cake.

I learned of the practice of cake sitting via the following

watched an episode of secret dairy of a call girl, and they had a sploshing party, which is food used in a messy way, then their was a csi ny episode also with a sploshing party theme, then that lead to the topic of cake sitting.

Giraffesandbottom · 24/04/2022 20:34

you and some other posters just sound jealous tbh.

I always get a cake maker to make fancy cakes for the children. I don’t post anything on social media - it has nothing to do with that and everything with enjoying creating a fun party with a theme. I like to bake and decorate but I don’t have time with 2 small children and it takes pressure off to pay a professional. How does that bother you enough to start a post unless you feel badly about not doing it yourself? Or do you just want to make fun of others/tear them down for no reason?

It’s been popular to get bakeries and cake makers eg Jane Asher to bake fancy cakes for decades, it’s not recent

UnicornPooPoo · 24/04/2022 20:26

Definitely. MiL makes lovely cakes as a hobby. DH's ex presented her with a picture of something that looked like the Disney castle with two days notice and announced she wanted that for DSD. It's the sort of thing that would take a team of professionals a couple of weeks to do, let's put it that way. MiL just used a bit of artistic licence and made something else 😆

TheYearOfSmallThings · 24/04/2022 19:38

Recently my 5 year old asked for an Encanto cake with Isabella and Mirabel hugging and the candle burning bright and they are in Isabella’s room with all the flowers. It took me hours but I enjoyed the challenge. And seeing her face light up when she saw it was just priceless.

How can you tell us this and not give us a picture?!

Crunchymum · 24/04/2022 19:37

Maybe I shouldn't have googled "cake sitting" Shock

Cake smashes are vile on every possible level.

Professional cakes aren't for me (can't afford it, wouldn't waste it on my kids who like like crappy supermarket shite) but have no issue with others paying for it. Especially if I get a slice Grin

I can bake very basicallyand did make their cakes when they were little but mine now prefer to pick a Colin / Frozen cake.

Itmustbeaproblemwithyourdoodad · 24/04/2022 19:29

I love making my kids elaborate birthday cakes, and I post them on social media every time and I’m not going to lie, it’s nice to get the appreciative comments! But I wouldn’t do it if I didn’t genuinely enjoy the creative process of coming up with the concept and then turning it into reality. I absolutely loathe the taste of fondant but it’s soooo fun to work with. Really therapeutic. I also like the fact that I can create art without adding clutter to my house, because it all gets consumed in the end. Though always feel emotional when my cakes get cut!!

Recently my 5 year old asked for an Encanto cake with Isabella and Mirabel hugging and the candle burning bright and they are in Isabella’s room with all the flowers. It took me hours but I enjoyed the challenge. And seeing her face light up when she saw it was just priceless.

Spaghag · 24/04/2022 19:28

I've only once ordered a bespoke birthday cake - for DS2's 21st.

Every other birthday has been a supermarket cake & nobody has ever complained.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/04/2022 19:23

Yellowmellow2 · 24/04/2022 19:16

Very good cakes. Well done 👍🏽

As for the cake smash, words fail me……

Well to be fair, cake smash is probably all the Costco sheet 'cake' is good for.

Hawkins001 · 24/04/2022 19:17

Op, I best not mention there is also a fetish called cake sitting with expensive cakes being used

Yellowmellow2 · 24/04/2022 19:16

ememem84 · 24/04/2022 18:35

Yep. That’s exactly it. Pay for cake. Smash it up. Take pictures.

ive made all of my kids birthday cakes. Last years efforts were a bunny. And a volcano.

took ages. I swore a lot. But the kids loved them.

Very good cakes. Well done 👍🏽

As for the cake smash, words fail me……

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 24/04/2022 19:15

I don't think professional cakes necessarily taste any better, although the standard of decoration is probably higher and more elaborate than most people can manage. Plus obviously the cost of ingredients, utilities and need to make a living makes them expensive.

But surely the main motivator isn't about performing on social media? You might have a nice cake if you want one and then show it off, but you wouldn't start from a position of 'I need a cake that looks good on Instagram' if your child prefers a Colin the caterpillar.

ArrrMeHearties · 24/04/2022 19:15

leccybill · 24/04/2022 16:37

Costco for the win every time!

I agree with getting a Costco cake but I don't get the sheet cakes I find them far too sweet. I get either the sticky toffee drizzle loaf cake or the chocolate fudge cake which is the one I got this year and it was so good

TokenGinger · 24/04/2022 19:14

Jins · 24/04/2022 18:13

I stopped buying or making cakes for parties when I spotted that it was the mums rather than the children eating them

Mini Swiss rolls went down well. Birthday cake was a big waste of money - for both DC

This is true. My son really doesn't like cake so it usually ends up being eaten by us!

hellcatspanglelalala · 24/04/2022 19:13

I used to make novelty cakes for my kids, I enjoyed the process but they weren't professional standard by any means.

Hawkins001 · 24/04/2022 19:13

Yellowmellow2 · 24/04/2022 18:30

Oops, quoted the wrong post! Still want to know what a cake mash is though!

Usually it's for people to have a party and rather than eat the cake it's obliterated.

TokenGinger · 24/04/2022 19:12

They are extortionate. But they are extortionate to make, too. I've recently taken a liking to baking and have baked cakes for my son's/family members'/close friends' birthdays as gifts or because they've asked, and they come in at around £30 to make, and more if they want a fancy cake topper or character cake.

5 blocks of butter - 2 for the cake, 3 for the butter cream - £10

Eggs - £1.50

Sugar - £1.50-£2 (usually 2 bags of brown sugar)

Flour/baking powder/bicarbonate/cocoa - £1

Cake board and box - £5

Cake topper £5 minimum

Then there's whatever you decorate it with, ie a ganache drip (needing chocolate and cream), Lindt balls, macarons, flowers, etc.

That doesn't even account for my time baking and decorating it (around 6 hours), plus electricity costs etc.

I can see why people charge so much for them, but I can't see why people would pay it! I don't think I could afford to. It's so bloody expensive.