Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school uniform is a bunch of crap?

388 replies

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 24/04/2022 11:36

So to be clear, I don't think the principle of uniform itself is crap. However why are we allowing our primary aged kids especially to spend the majority of their childhood in such restrictive clothing?! It's almost always restrictive trousers/dresses at least and some in my area even proper shirts and ties. We have evidence in the importance of learning by moving in this age group. Most kids this age have a degree of sensory processing immaturity. Many even have spd and this is arguably discriminating against these kids. I do understand the importance of uniform and learning to adhere to uniform standards but can anyone give me a reason why the uniform isn't just a simple pair of leggings/joggers and a tshirt and hoodie? Maybe I've overlooked something but it seems to me it's entirely for the benefit of the school and their pockets not the children.. why do we accept this?

OP posts:
Murdoch1949 · 07/05/2022 22:37

My teenagers all went to a comprehensive where there was no uniform and teachers were all called by their first names. As new to the area my children were in shock .... for a day! Actually there was a self-imposed uniform, (late 80s/90s) of joggers, sweatshirts/hoodies (XXL), and jeans, boys & girls. As a teacher I was anti uniform, all that 'tuck your shirt in, unfold your skirt waistband. Those who say it's a leveller, it's not. The poorer kids have one set, the richer kids multiple sets. The poorer kids had Tesco, the richer kids John Lewis. You can tell the difference. The poorer kids wore their uniforms at weekends too, their only trousers etc. As a parent I never had to police my children as they left the house, there were no rules. It did not affect their attainment, they all got into universities of their choice, good careers etc. Ofsted are keen in uniform, especially blazers, all this take pride in your appearance take pride in your work propaganda. If, IF, we have to have uniform it should be available from supermarkets at minimum cost. No badged items, the school to sell badges & ties if they must. Yes, people will still buy John Lewis gear, but at least the rest of the parents aren't having to spend a fortune, not when we're looking down the sofa for any farthing to put the central heating on.

Needmorelego · 07/05/2022 22:04

@JustLyra perhaps there should be the option of wearing what the head suggested OR a full on blazer/tie/kilt/logo on trousers combo. If a child or their parent really wants them to wear that nonsense then let them do it. But for those that don't want to have the more casual uniform.
It would still be uniform rules to follow. The children couldn't just turn up in any old thing but it would take away the pressure (and time consuming waste of teachers time) of "where is your tie", "why aren't you wearing your blazer", "your trousers are clearly from Asda - they should have the logo" etc.
Just have a long list of a variety of 'school' style clothes to choose from - which can include a blazer and tie if people are really that desperate for one.

JustLyra · 07/05/2022 21:10

pointythings · 07/05/2022 13:37

The alternative is to have no uniform so that teachers and schools can put their energies into managing actual behaviour. Like they do in other countries.

My DDs' 6th form had (and still has) no uniform, and a very relaxed dress code - clothes have to be clean, not ripped and free of bad language. That's it. Behaviour is excellent. Academics are excellent. It can be done - so why aren't all schools doing it?

I'm finding it interesting at the moment with DD's school - more specifically some of the parents.

During lockdown the HT told parents not to buy the full-on uniform for the next year. Just to buy black trousers/skirt/shorts that were comfortable (joggers, thick leggings or others) and either white, black or red plain tshirt or poloshirt, plus black or red hoodie or cardi so that if there were more lockdowns there wasn't expensive uniform sat in a cupboard being outgrown without any use. Just to get comfortable stuff that kids would get wear out of.

Once they went back she reiterated the same as there was no guarantee of more lockdowns, or closures due to covid.

She's quite openly said that she's considering pushing for that level of 'uniform' to be all that is needed because she (and other staff) believe it's been much less hassle and that the children are more comfortable, which has had a positive effect on behaviour.

Quite a number of parents are up in arms about it. They want a proper uniform.

Parker231 · 07/05/2022 13:38

The UK needs to wake up and stop wasting time and money enforcing an outdated and impractical school uniform policy. Children look ridiculous in polyester school blazers when it’s more comfortable to be in a hoodie.
Worse are the schools making summer and winter school uniform mandatory on a given date regardless of the weather or individual preferences

pointythings · 07/05/2022 13:37

The alternative is to have no uniform so that teachers and schools can put their energies into managing actual behaviour. Like they do in other countries.

My DDs' 6th form had (and still has) no uniform, and a very relaxed dress code - clothes have to be clean, not ripped and free of bad language. That's it. Behaviour is excellent. Academics are excellent. It can be done - so why aren't all schools doing it?

pointythings · 07/05/2022 13:35

If people believe that uniform makes schools better, then that is true. Perception is reality.

Perception is reality? What world are you living in?

If uniforms make schools better, then why

  • are there reams of countries with no school uniform which outperform the UK both economically and in education?
  • are there excellent non uniform schools in the UK?
  • are there absolute hell hole schools with uniform in the UK?
  • is there no body of properly conducted research that backs up your statement?
If perception is reality, I could get stoned, hallucinate a rainbow unicorn and that would make it real.

There isn't a conspiracy of schools forcing uniform on parents (though there are absolutely schools practicing stealth exclusion of poorer pupils by making uniform prohibitively expensive). What there is in the UK is a belief that appearance is more important than achievement. And that is tragic.

Florenz · 07/05/2022 12:40

I do not think there is some vast conspiracy of schools forcing uniform on pupils against the wishes of parents, pupils and everybody else. If people believe that uniform makes schools better, then that is true. Perception is reality. What is the alternative?

BordoisAgain · 07/05/2022 12:01

My sons primary is fairly relaxed on uniform - black trousers, white shirt and school branded jumper and tie but you can still spot the difference between the "haves" and "have nots".

BordoisAgain · 07/05/2022 12:00

even in cities where there are plenty of schools to choose from...

...you still don't actually get to choose which school admits your child and so its not really a choice at all.

Changechangychange · 07/05/2022 10:46

Florenz · 07/05/2022 10:29

But even in cities where there are plenty of schools to choose from, they nearly all have uniforms. If there was a great demand for non-uniform schools, one school would have no uniforms, they'd get their pick of pupils due to demand, they'd shoot up the rankings and other schools would follow suit in order to compete. This hasn't happened.

You understand that having lots of school doesn’t mean that individual parents get any choice of schools?

I’d far rather send DS to a non-uniform school, but realistically where I live in south London I have a choice of three boot-camp style Harris academies, or going private. Or moving, but not everyone has that option.

pointythings · 07/05/2022 10:40

Florenz that is because of the UK cult of uniform. Ultimately the problem is that people genuinely believe that uniform makes schools better, despite the fact that there is zero evidence (other than a study sponsored by a schoolwear company, which can be readily dismissed). No matter how many people recount their experiences of perfectly functional schools and societies in countries where there is no uniform, the cult persists. It's some kind of weird delusion.

Florenz · 07/05/2022 10:29

But even in cities where there are plenty of schools to choose from, they nearly all have uniforms. If there was a great demand for non-uniform schools, one school would have no uniforms, they'd get their pick of pupils due to demand, they'd shoot up the rankings and other schools would follow suit in order to compete. This hasn't happened.

pointythings · 07/05/2022 09:20

Florenz · 07/05/2022 08:59

I don't understand why people choose to send their children to school which requires uniforms, and then moan about their children having to wear uniforms.

I don't understand why people don't know that the vast majority of schools in the UK have uniforms and that the vast majority of parents don't actually have a real choice about which school their children go to.

Whatwouldscullydo · 07/05/2022 09:02

Choose? Ha ha that's the funniest thing I've heard. 🤣

Florenz · 07/05/2022 08:59

I don't understand why people choose to send their children to school which requires uniforms, and then moan about their children having to wear uniforms.

pointythings · 06/05/2022 18:14

Confusedcatlady1 · 06/05/2022 17:13

The government introduced a bill last year to reduce the cost of school uniforms (it recommended limiting uniform with school logos on and restricting the use of one uniform shop as a supplier so that parents could shop around) but those rules do not seem to be filtering through to schools yet. I like a school uniform but the cost for my child’s (state) school uniform is ridiculously high - she has 11 compulsory items that have logos on - even down to logo PE socks that costs £11 a pair.

Thing is, that bill has no teeth. It's still only guidance. There's no provision in it for schools who break the guidance to be tackled, and until there is, schools will continue to take the mick. Part of it is financial desperation - which is down to government and its funding formulas - but part of it is also corruption - sweet deals with uniform suppliers. There's a reason why academies are worst for this sort of thing.

Until this kind of behaviour from schools is punished by an instant downgrade to special measures for any school caught breaking the uniform rules, nothing will change.

And ultimately, parents need to give their head a wobble and think more rationally about this belief that strict uniform = good school. Because it's bollocks.

Littleoakhorn · 06/05/2022 17:41

Kids here in Germany don’t wear uniforms, and basically clothes just tend to be weather-appropriate. There’s far less emphasis on what children wear and widespread use of second hand clothes.

Why does the government have to spend time on the cost of uniforms when they’re completely unnecessary? Seems like a waste to me.

Confusedcatlady1 · 06/05/2022 17:13

The government introduced a bill last year to reduce the cost of school uniforms (it recommended limiting uniform with school logos on and restricting the use of one uniform shop as a supplier so that parents could shop around) but those rules do not seem to be filtering through to schools yet. I like a school uniform but the cost for my child’s (state) school uniform is ridiculously high - she has 11 compulsory items that have logos on - even down to logo PE socks that costs £11 a pair.

UndertheCedartree · 28/04/2022 21:34

Needmorelego · 28/04/2022 19:52

@Tolson the problem is if the parents have to provide the uniform and for some reason (and there could be dozens) they can't, schools shouldn't be punishing the children. It's nothing to do with questioning rules - it's about life and the fact that sometimes a pair of trackies in a certain colour just can't always be obtained.
On a local Facebook group I am on a woman was trying to get hold of secondhand uniform for her children.
It seems they had moved to the town unexpectedly and quickly and the child obviously had to change to the local school. This is a school that has branded blazer, branded jumper, kilt skirts etc (this is a bog standard not that great academy - not some fancy Grammar).It can only be bought at one supplier. The supplier had none in stock. It was the middle of the school year and they simply didn't have any. There were some secondhand bits at the school but none in the sizes needed.
The school would not let the children start until they had the correct uniform. Their poor Mum was having to cobble the uniforms together from strangers on the internet.
The children probably still had uniforms from their old school. Why couldn't they have worn those? Why couldn't they have worn non uniform. Two children were denied education because their mother couldn't get hold of a stupid blazer and stupid skirt.
That made me feel very angry.

That's truly awful and goes to show where their priorities lie. I remember feeling so reassured, when my DD started school for the first time mid way through Y1, when they insisted her bright sparkly trainers were fine and to not waste money on school shoes. They put together a couple of sets of uniform from the secondhand shop and p.e kit and gave them to us for free, as well as a water bottle.

UndertheCedartree · 28/04/2022 21:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Then the uniform rules need to be less strict. My DD's school request dark coloured bottoms for P.E. Can be green, grey, black, navy, tracksuit bottoms or leggings. It makes no difference to P.E if they don't look identical!

Parker231 · 28/04/2022 20:22

@LadyMonicaBaddingham - why do they all need to look the same? DT’s managed to get all A’s wearing jeans and a hoodie.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 28/04/2022 20:04

Im a TA and i genuinely think that a generic coloured polo shirt and trousers or a skirt is adequate uniform. The important thing with uniform is to encourage an identity withn and without the school. Too much emphasis is put on badged stuff (which, generally, earns the school and communities nothing financially)
The priority should be on young people who are learning to be presentable and who are engaged with learning.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 28/04/2022 20:03

Im a TA and i genuinely think that a generic coloured polo shirt and trousers or a skirt is adequate uniform. The important thing with uniform is to encourage an identity withn and without the school. Too much emphasis is put on badged stuff (which, generally, earns the school and communities nothing financially)
The priority should be on young people who are learning to be presentable and who are engaged with learning.

Needmorelego · 28/04/2022 19:52

@Tolson the problem is if the parents have to provide the uniform and for some reason (and there could be dozens) they can't, schools shouldn't be punishing the children. It's nothing to do with questioning rules - it's about life and the fact that sometimes a pair of trackies in a certain colour just can't always be obtained.
On a local Facebook group I am on a woman was trying to get hold of secondhand uniform for her children.
It seems they had moved to the town unexpectedly and quickly and the child obviously had to change to the local school. This is a school that has branded blazer, branded jumper, kilt skirts etc (this is a bog standard not that great academy - not some fancy Grammar).It can only be bought at one supplier. The supplier had none in stock. It was the middle of the school year and they simply didn't have any. There were some secondhand bits at the school but none in the sizes needed.
The school would not let the children start until they had the correct uniform. Their poor Mum was having to cobble the uniforms together from strangers on the internet.
The children probably still had uniforms from their old school. Why couldn't they have worn those? Why couldn't they have worn non uniform. Two children were denied education because their mother couldn't get hold of a stupid blazer and stupid skirt.
That made me feel very angry.

pointythings · 28/04/2022 18:31

@Parker231 my kids went through the UK system, fortunately in schools that were not draconian nitpicky hellholes obsessed with style over substance. They've managed to turn out pretty damn good nevertheless.