Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school uniform is a bunch of crap?

388 replies

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 24/04/2022 11:36

So to be clear, I don't think the principle of uniform itself is crap. However why are we allowing our primary aged kids especially to spend the majority of their childhood in such restrictive clothing?! It's almost always restrictive trousers/dresses at least and some in my area even proper shirts and ties. We have evidence in the importance of learning by moving in this age group. Most kids this age have a degree of sensory processing immaturity. Many even have spd and this is arguably discriminating against these kids. I do understand the importance of uniform and learning to adhere to uniform standards but can anyone give me a reason why the uniform isn't just a simple pair of leggings/joggers and a tshirt and hoodie? Maybe I've overlooked something but it seems to me it's entirely for the benefit of the school and their pockets not the children.. why do we accept this?

OP posts:
redglobox · 24/04/2022 16:28

Totally agree OP. I could rant about this for hours.

My daughter starts reception this year, doesnt like dresses or skirts and will have to wear either those or tailored trousers. She's 4! I've asked the school if she can wear leggings / jogging bottoms. I dont want her to feel pushed into wearing a dress / skirt.

And why not trainers for goodness sake? I have a professional job and spend my days barefoot in leggings! It's 2022 FGS.

yellowsuninthesky · 24/04/2022 16:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

I agree to some extent, although my son's secondary head had rather outdated ideas about what shoes were acceptable (can't see what's wrong with black trainers myself). But some schools have ridiculous policies insisting on extensive blazers and skirts of a particular length and often the uniform policies are sexist (only boys have to wear ties, for example - why does anyone have to wear one). Academies tend to have the strictest and most ridiculous policies and then put kids into isolation if their parents can't afford the specified items. Utter nonsense and goodness knows why it's even allowed.

Neverreturntoathread · 24/04/2022 16:26

YANBU. There is an argument to be made in favour of uniform (although personally I disagree with that argument) but there is NO justification for continuing to dress our children up like little Victorians while the rest of the world has moved on.

Some state schools ban children from covering their legs even in winter: boys must be in shorts year round and girls are forbidden trousers. What’s that about then?

Most uniforms are chosen by headteachers who have very narrow and prejudiced ideas about what looks ‘smart’ and who care nothing about the cost to parents or environment. In reception DC had to wear a polo shirt. In year one the shirt still fitted them fine but it was now a forbidden item and they had to wear adult buttones shirts despite being too young to manage buttons.

Our old school has a compulsory PE uniform plus a compulsory mongrammed PE kit bag. But the PE kit does not fit into the bag and they have to carry some in their hands while being told off for that. This crap is not good for children’s mental health.

Uniforms should be:


  • cotton black jogging bottoms / shorts in summer

  • cotton hoodie in a single school colour (red, blue, whatever)

  • white tshirt

  • trainers


Simple. And for primary age Pe they can just wear the same stuff with no need to waste class time and stress kids with getting changed.

Every parent I know wants this. So why can’t it happen?!

RosesAndHellebores · 24/04/2022 16:26

Mine attended a very leafy cofe primary and then very sought after London Day Schools. I found no correlation between money and lots of new clothes. In fact quite the reverse. The better off families had no compunction about passing around and older siblings outgrown stuff within or without the family.

WhiteCatmas · 24/04/2022 16:26

I agree that shirt and tie is over the top for primary and secondary aged children.
I am delighted my children have a school uniform. They all look the same at school, there is one large investment for the set up and then you just keep adding larger sizes.

When I was growing up we didn’t have school uniform and it was a massive pain in the ass as the children divided themselves into ones who had names brand clothing or clothes in a certain style and those who didn’t. It was very unpleasant.

onlyconnect · 24/04/2022 16:24

I don’t like uniform but the idea that a dress code would solve problems as suggested upthread is rubbish in secondary.
The problems would be different but unless we really say that kids can wear whatever they like, there would still be issues.

jcyclops · 24/04/2022 16:24

The government has issued compulsory guidance for school uniforms (in England) to make them affordable.

Press release from 19/11/2021 : www.gov.uk/government/news/new-rules-to-drive-down-cost-of-school-uniform-for-families

Some key points:
"Schools are expected to have taken steps to adhere to the new guidance before parents buy uniform for the academic year beginning in September 2022."
"Schools should keep branded items to a minimum and limit their use to low cost or long-lasting items. The term ‘branded item’ is not just an item with a logo. It is used to describe an item of clothing with distinctive characteristics which make it unique to the school or trust. As a general rule, if an item cannot be purchased at a range of retailers it is likely to be a branded item."
"Schools should avoid frequent changes to uniform specifications."
"Schools should ensure that arrangements are in place so that second-hand school uniforms are available for parents to acquire."

Parents should make themselves aware of the guidance and make sure their schools will comply from September.

yellowsuninthesky · 24/04/2022 16:24

I think school uniform is a good thing but only if it is simple and cost-effective - maybe a polo shirt or jumper with a logo, and then standard trousers/skirts/shirts/blouses available from anywhere.

My main issues with school uniform are:

(a) the cost of certain items; and

(b) the disproportionate time spent policing what kids wear rather than concentrating on teaching and learning.

if a uniform is cheap and simple, it will be largely be complied with.

UrslaB · 24/04/2022 16:23

All of the primary schools in my area have simplified uniform to jogging bottoms, a plain white polo shirt and a sweater with the school crest. This is for both boys and girls. Excellent uniform and when they do PE all they do is pull on shorts and pull off their jumper. Done. Very loose and easy to move in for little ones.

At secondary school, I am firmly in favour of uniforms. Working in education non-uniform days are the bane of my existence (at least 3 a year where kids pay a £1 and it goes to charity). Kids are so brand conscious. It turns into a fashion parade and inevitably some little snotty brat picks on a kid who's family couldn't afford the right brand of traniers, jeans, sports tops etc etc. I despise how non-uniform heightens the class distinction and incites bullying.

Saying this I think that the current secondary school uniforms are ridiculous. Blazers are just pointless. I worked in two schools where the kids only wore them to and from school...so parents payed £55 to £100+ for a blazer they only wore into the building, lived in their lockers and then got worn home again. When they are worn the pockets get ripped off easily and the pockets become odd hybrids of pencilcases and food cupboards.

The gender nonsence of making girls wear skirts and the time teachers have to waste as moral idiots enforcing arbitrary skirt lengths enrages me. Always some SLT idiot pushing me to bully the girls about their skirt lengths which is awkward and just ridiculous. Uniforms should be black or navy, and shirts white so that they can be bought from any generic shop allowing for cost effective purchasing. Boot or straight leg plain trousers(we have to be specific otherwise you get kids in trousers that look painted on, or have glitter etc on them)a white dress shirt, clip on tie and a jumper. The tie and the jumper with a badge should be the only two items that need to be bought somewhere specific. Job done.

The underhanded deals that schools have with local maufacturers and shops also bugs me. Currently, I work in a school where the uniform can only be bought from two shops and is a colour (a unique green with orange details) that can only be bought there. Skirts, trousers, shirts, socks, tights etc. are all such a unique colour that they have to be bought in this one place. The school gets a cut of all unifrom sales for their cosy little exclusive deal which makes the average unifrom cost the guts of £400. Daylight robbery. Sadly, with school budgets under such pressure and schools in increasing debt I see more and more schools altering their uniforms so that they are different enough they are able to create exclusive manufacturing and selling deals with local shops that nets them a hefty chunk of change that they can put towards the vast govt shortfall to buy resources.

Everyone wearing trousers removes the need for the debate of skirt lengths/socks/tights etc. Staying black or navy for trousers and white for shirt makes it purchasable just about anywhere, from a supermarket bargain rail to a high end department store. This gives parents choice.

The reason I am not in favour of 'iron on' badges is because while this can democratise jumper purchasing I have seen some seriously dodgey attempts at ironing them on. Crooked, wrong side, etc etc. This leads to teasing between kids and in the worst case I saw one school where a trend of kids competing to rip the badges off each other started.

BritWifeInUSA · 24/04/2022 16:23

Theunamedcat · 24/04/2022 11:53

Dress codes are better yes I get that people say it's to level the playing field with poor children dressed the same as rich but that's bullshit you can see the difference regardless we have children dressed in M&S best that are obviously dressed better than aldi trousers hairstyles that are not done by dads clippers shoes that are obviously falling apart or not fitting etc etc you can tell who the richer children are

Plain non badged joggers plain tshirts plain trainers its simple

But even if you had plain joggers, t-shirts, trainers as a uniform you would still have those in M&S joggers that are new every term and those in Primark ones that have been handed down from older siblings and now falling apart or completely washed out.

You’ll never avoid the rich/poor divide with uniforms unless the school provides the clothes to everyone and bulk-buys hundreds of items from the same supplier.

mumsys · 24/04/2022 16:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Natsku · 24/04/2022 16:22

I used to think school uniforms were important, for the reasons others have raised e.g. prevent bullying over clothing and suchlike, but now I live in a country that has no school uniforms and I've not seen any issues like that in DD's 6 years at school. The children all dress sensibly, and weather appropriately, pretty much all of them wear joggers/trackies/leggings and t-shirts/long sleeve shirts and hoodies, and the right footwear for the weather (trainers in summer, wellies in spring and autumn, warm boots in winter). They go up to upper school when they're 13 so potentially it gets troublesome there but whenever I see the upper school children on their way to and from school they're dressed pretty similar to the primary school kids, just a bit more jean wearing. I have never seen a single girl wearing a skirt or dress to school except when they were doing an independence day ball theme just before independence day, and the children all dressed in formal wear, so I find it especially odd the insistence in UK primary schools that little girls wear skirts and dresses, its really not the best clothing for playing in.

RosesAndHellebores · 24/04/2022 16:21

DS had to wear a suit for 6th form; dd could wear anything. On balance anything was better but the girls were not at all competitive around clothes.

tuliplover · 24/04/2022 16:18

My daughter loved her school uniform and now in sixth form misses it. No need to think about what to wear, no judgement, no trying to figure out what's in or out, no expectations etc. Movement not an issue - the skirts were pleated. And I certainly didn't see my son not being able to kick around a football during break either.
I grew up with no uniform. Can't say it made me move any more.

Ponderingwindow · 24/04/2022 16:16

My child attends a school that doesn’t require a uniform. I see the year 6-8 students coming out of that school every day in an assortment of practical, comfortable clothing. The only really inappropriate thing is that they all refuse to wear winter coats for some reason. It’s a very wealthy school, but most of the kids are just wearing clothing from the same affordable shops. The money is spent on high end backpacks and Cell phones, not shirts and leggings.

cyclamenqueen · 24/04/2022 15:51

And for the record one of the things that I find most depressing about young trainees now is their frequent need to be constantly needing to be told what to do. This comes from the fact that schools do not encourage them to us their own judgement . I expect a 16 year old to know when their body is too hot and to take their jacket off , but schools hardly let them breathe without rules. So they second guess themselves constantly. We need to reduce these petty rules and encourage young people to make decisions .

cyclamenqueen · 24/04/2022 15:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Interesting. Both dh and I have very ‘formal’ professional jobs . Neither of us wear suits regularly in the office anymore. Dh was always a fan of the suit and double cuffed shirt but even he is more likely to be in open necked shirt mode now . I am more likely to be in dress, or smart trousers and frequently white/ neutral trainers .

no one wears synthetic shiney suits and polyester shirts in the office environment

JustLyra · 24/04/2022 15:45

Smart uniform contributes to a professional environment and work ethic.

and yet schools in France, Spain and other places that don’t dress children in mini-adult uniforms manage just fine with their environment and work ethic

MindPalace · 24/04/2022 15:42

generic guidance, sorry!

MindPalace · 24/04/2022 15:38

Uniform should just have genetic guidance and be cheap, comfortable and not prescriptive.

To insist on strict uniform, ties etc, when in the real working world there is such a move towards informal dressing for adults, is crazy.

RosesAndHellebores · 24/04/2022 15:32

An interesting correlation is that the French who have no uniform are significantly better turned out as adults than the British.

Brefugee · 24/04/2022 15:31

I strongly support a strict and smart uniform. Personally, I hate polo shirts etc as uniform items- to me these are casual wear and not suitable for a work environment (which is what a school is). Smart uniform contributes to a professional environment and work ethic.

Why? What is the reasoning behind this.

Lots of pp very confidently saying it stops fashion shows etc etc (leveller, concentrate, professional). I live in a country with no school uniform. It doesn't stop them achieving good results. It doesn't confuse or worry them when they get jobs that require uniforms. Professional people who work at companies with strict dress codes aren't blindsided by this. Society isn't collapsing.

I was at a school with a very strict uniform policy but everyone knew who had money, who were bitchy, who were kind etc. The uniform was just an annoyance to everyone.. (my primary in the 70s had optional uniform, i guess about 75% of us wore it, we had a very high number of us going to grammar schools).

artisanbread · 24/04/2022 15:27

I think primary uniform is generally ok. Prefer it that both the school I teach in and my DC's school have stuck with wearing PE kit to school on PE days.

Secondary school uniform is ridiculous Nd generally enforces much stricter requirements than even the staff have to wear. My DC's school insists on ankle length skirts for the girls which is not a requirement in any workplace that I know of.

Knifer · 24/04/2022 15:20

It's just snobbery I think. Not uniform in principle, a sense of belonging and nobody (theoretically) having the piss taken out of them for their shabby or unfashionable clothes is important.

But £50 or so for a blazer? £15 for a tie? Madness. And you're right, it's always uncomfy.

Why they can't have joggers, T-shirt and a jumper is beyond me. Why they get put in isolation if they're wearing nail varnish or have the wrong sort of haircut is also beyond me! As if you can't fucking learn because someone in the class has a streak of purple manic panic or a couple of tramlines! As if it's a massive violation to have a pair of trainers on or the wrong colour of socks visible. It's not prison.

Greensleeves · 24/04/2022 15:09

I am quite passionately opposed to school uniform. I find it depressing that we are still, in 2022, factory farming children instead of educating them, and that conformity and obedience are still prized above all other attributes in our schools.

I would be in favour of a dress code for schoolchildren, which would ensure that clothes were practical, comfortable and durable - plain joggers/leggings/trousers, Tshirts, hoodies, sweaters etc would all be fine. Comfortable, practical shoes that don't restrict children's activity. Much more sensible, takes a lot of the pettiness and resentment out of the situation, and doesn't rob developing human beings of their personhood.