Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school uniform is a bunch of crap?

388 replies

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 24/04/2022 11:36

So to be clear, I don't think the principle of uniform itself is crap. However why are we allowing our primary aged kids especially to spend the majority of their childhood in such restrictive clothing?! It's almost always restrictive trousers/dresses at least and some in my area even proper shirts and ties. We have evidence in the importance of learning by moving in this age group. Most kids this age have a degree of sensory processing immaturity. Many even have spd and this is arguably discriminating against these kids. I do understand the importance of uniform and learning to adhere to uniform standards but can anyone give me a reason why the uniform isn't just a simple pair of leggings/joggers and a tshirt and hoodie? Maybe I've overlooked something but it seems to me it's entirely for the benefit of the school and their pockets not the children.. why do we accept this?

OP posts:
CarmenThePanda · 24/04/2022 19:11

I loved our uniform-free primary.

The kids were used to it, so just wore ‘their clothes’ just like for a play date or a day out or a family visit.

There was none of the fuss people describe or fear amongst my D.C. or any friends Dc.

mumsys · 24/04/2022 18:30

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Changechangychange · 24/04/2022 18:18

I think your proposed uniform would be a disaster- tracksuit bottoms are for lounging around at home, not for a work or education environment. I’d hate to have to work in tracksuit bottoms

I wouldn’t want to wear a dinosaur tshirt or spend my lunchtime hanging upside down on a climbing frame, but I’m not 5. I think clothing expectations in primary school and an office should be pretty different, no?

And plenty of work environments wear polo shirts and chinos - NHS (physios, doctors), IT (even pre-pandemic, DH wouldn’t hire somebody who turned up to interview in a full suit “because they clearly don’t understand industry norms”), and plenty of people in serious professional jobs like advertising only put a jacket on when they are meeting clients. Finance is the only sector I can think of that expects people in suits every day.

BogRollBOGOF · 24/04/2022 18:11

I used to buy into the clichés about uniform, but then worked in a non-uniform school and loved it. The pupils were comfortable, and had nothing to prove and were less stressed. Zero time wasted on issues like when is a black lace-up shoe a trainer, or is that skirt rolled up. Clothes were decent and pupils respected the sensible boundaries and I lost not one second of teaching time on policing clothes.

I have an autistic sensory child and fortunately our local primary school has a relaxed uniform where as long as it's uniform items of school colours, it's fine. He's been comfortable in shorts and polo shirts. Every secondary school in the area is a sensory nightmare of blazer, tie, stiff collar and trousers with no shorts options for boys.
Secondary uniforms are uncomfortable, impractical, and hopelessly out of date (unless you have a burning desire to work in Sales). Many high earning, creative/ technical industries have become far less formal. Most businesses requiring uniform are of the more practical end with polo shirts. Young people don't need training for years to wear clothes.

I haven't worn a blazer or tie since leaving school... well maybe not so much on blazers as I did own a suit for a while but quickly stopped wearing it as I was never comfortable in it and that did reflect in my personal presentation. I wore it in a stunt to try to look grown-up and professional, but I actually felt smarter in dresses and cardigans.

Fairislefandango · 24/04/2022 17:57

It is no coincidence that the above is the expectation at many of the best schools in the country.

That's not cause and effect. The uniform is window-dressing and has nothing to do with making them the best schools in the country. I've worked in everything from inner city comps to a top private girls' day school. Believe me, the latter would have been just as excellent if the girls had been wearing jeans and r-shirts. Conversely, putting kids in a bad school in smart blazers is not going to solve anything.

Fairislefandango · 24/04/2022 17:51

Well quite. Formal uniform appeals to aspirational parents (that's why schools have it) and to keen new Year 7s for the first few weeks. That's about it. It's an absolute pain in the arse to enforce, and parents soon tire of it once they have had to fork out for it and their dc lose bits of it or are given detentions for not wearing it properly!

BeanCounterBabe · 24/04/2022 17:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Could it be that the best schools in the country have small class sizes, amazing facilities, can attract better teachers, have pupils from stable well off homes with parents who invest in their education? Poor performing state schools cannot replicate this just be sticking their pupils in ties and blazers. It's a distraction from the real issues preventing their potential in state schools.

And you might not want to work in tracksuits but millions of professionals have WFH in their comfy clothes for two years plus now. I work in the NHS with consultants who don't wear uniform. Are you suggesting it is not possible to be professional unless you wear uniform/tailored office wear??

Rosehugger · 24/04/2022 17:49

It used to be that uniforms were cheap and hard wearing, but now they are expensive and crap, and far worse quality than regular cheap clothing. Plus it makes you do more washing to ensure specific items are ready. And kids would be better in cheap trainers than expensive school shoes that scuff and are grown out of quickly.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/04/2022 17:47

If anything being forced to wear a blazer would make me think "fuck this" and want to leave quicker. It didn't make me think oh I must try harder.

Fairislefandango · 24/04/2022 17:45

I voted YANBU based on your title, then read your OP and I actually disagree - I don't think there's anything particularly physically restrictive about what kids generally wear to primary school.

But I do think uniform is a load of crap, because it's totally unnecessary and as a teacher of many years' standing I very strongly disagree with the theory that it in any way improves behaviour or attainment, or that it makes kids identify with the ethos of their school. Utter bollocks. How do people think that other countries manage perfectly well without it?

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/04/2022 17:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It probably is coincidence.

What you wear has no relation to your intelligence or your ability to remember.

I'd rather teachers taught, instead of wasted time checking the colour of socks. It makes no difference.

Fwiw I've never had to wear a blazer at work, it's probably even less common since COVID. I bet a lot of people have worn tracksuit bottoms to work frequently in the last couple of years!

Tolson · 24/04/2022 17:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

C152 · 24/04/2022 16:54

AndAsIfByMagic · 24/04/2022 11:48

School uniforms should be abolished. I hated them as a parent and a teacher.

Teachers have better things to do with their time than police how children dress. A dress code is all that is needed.

This isn't the 1950s

Totally agree with this. My primary school had a uniform (which was the generic stuff available in supermarkets), but it was optional. Most kids didn't wear it and no one was teased because of the clothes they chose to wear. High school did have an incredibly strict uniform policy (including ties for the girls), and the principle used to stand in the corridor and check we all had the "regulation" coloured hair elastic in our hair! Big bollocking and detention if not.

Celendine · 24/04/2022 16:54

I think uniforms can be useful, but some uniforms could do with updating. Ties are old-fashioned and blazers don't add to learning. I notice now that some school uniforms can only be bought from one supplier and there are crests on everything. I wore a school uniform, we didn't wear blazers and it didn't stop anybody from being educated. The uniform should enhance and encourage education and serve a practical purpose.

MintJulia · 24/04/2022 16:53

5 seconds to dress and done. No bullying.
practical, and convenient. Works for us.

DappledShade · 24/04/2022 16:52

I agree some uniform is too rigid and too expensive. However, it's a difficult one to win as I wouldn't be happy to dress my child in jogging bottoms except for sport. Leggings, if not see through may be just about okay, but I'd prefer just comfy versions of trousers/skirts/dresses. I think polo shirts are better than shirts and often don't need ironing etc if hung straight after washing.

MintJulia · 24/04/2022 16:51

I love school uniforms. As a working mum, Monday morning there are 5 clean shirts, trousers, socks, sweaters, blazer. No thought, no fuss required. No agonising over brand, colour etc. 5 sec

SummerLove2306 · 24/04/2022 16:48

I'm in the top of Scotland where uniform is much more relaxed. Primary school uniform for my dc was a logoed sweatshirt, and you had the option of logo'd or plain polo shirt. Navy or black trousers. No restriction on shoes.

Secondary school was a plain or logo'd hoodie/T-shirt/polo shirt/cardigan. In school colours (grey white black). Also had option of shirt and tie (compulsory for elder years).

Needmorelego · 24/04/2022 16:47

@mumsys I think you must live in a parallel universe UK to pretty much everyone else. "Affordable" and "practical" Er...no. Those 50 quid blazers which are too hot to wear in summer (but pupils have too), not warm enough in winter (and too bulky to wear an actual coat over).
Kilt skirts that are £35 a skirt so you want to make it last but the style is short to start with so as soon as the wearer has a growth spurt then they are pretty much indecent.
"Options for summer". Primary schools maybe have those check dresses (my daughter's school didn't) but for many schools it's the blazer, jumper, tie combo whether it's heatwave July or blizzard snow January.
I am curious where you live !!

42isthemeaning · 24/04/2022 16:39

We should follow the rest of Europe and get rid of it. It causes issues for behaviour, SEND, etc. with many a pointless confrontation over skirt length, etc. Of course, some of these latter issues could still occur, but I do think we need to step into the 21st century and I'm a teacher myself. I have ASD dc and the uniform has been problematic at times for both of them. It's too hot in summer and impractical in winter, plus itchy seams and generally ill-fitting whether you buy items from marks and Spencer's or Lidl. I've tried both. The blazer is from the school outfitter and it is the biggest rip off imaginable. Rubbish quality but it costs £££££££!
My main concern about ditching school uniforms is that kids feel pressured into wearing the 'uniform' of their peers, e.g. expensive designer gear, though our blazer cost would cover a few designer t shirts!

Moonface123 · 24/04/2022 16:35

The whole of the school system is so outdated, as is the uniform, but nothing will change because the minute they try it creates mass hysteria.

redglobox · 24/04/2022 16:32

Agree with your suggestion (and all your other comments) NeverReturnToAThread... but not sure you'll be back here to see this 😂 I think I'll email the school to ask them. Presumably it needs parents pushing for this for things to change.

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 24/04/2022 16:31

I was thinking about it few months ago, and it occurs to me every school holidays.

during half terms etc I often see children dress inadequately, looking scruffy but not due to cheap clothes but because they’re not clean,different shoes, hair that haven’t been brushed.

It makes me think that if it wasn’t for school uniforms, some parents would be unable to dress their children appropriately, and those children would certainly be judged by their peers.

as long as you see parents taking kids
our in their pj/dressing gowns, they’ll have to be some sort of uniform standards of how to dress your children.

KatherineJaneway · 24/04/2022 16:30

As a child growing up I was glad of a school uniform however gross it was. As a child my parents didn't think clothes were important so I was clothed from jumble sales etc. Other kids still took the piss out of of the school uniform 'Oh Katherine, you still have the A line skirt? I have the latest one, it is straighter and much more fashionable'. It would have been worse with a 'guideline' for what to wear.

yellowsuninthesky · 24/04/2022 16:28

expensive blazers. not extensive.