Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that if you're cornered and hit someone, you're ok (in law)?

109 replies

JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:00

Is it justifiable?
As a means to escape?

OP posts:
GeorgesMarvelousCalpol · 24/04/2022 11:58

Too many questions here to answer, which the op is unwilling to clarify.
How did you eventually escape?

PonyPatter44 · 24/04/2022 11:54

Were you suspected of shoplifting and detained in a managers office? And then you pushed him/her to try and get out of the office?

The simple answer is, none of us know. If someone is buying drugs and the dealer holds them captive because theyve run up a massive debt, yes of course its a crime, and there are men serving hefty prison sentences for exactly that. If it was a security guard or a police officer who believed they had reason to detain you, then it is a lot less clear cut.

ZebraInaTeapot · 24/04/2022 11:54

Was the person someone you know or a stranger or someone with a position of authority (eg security guard)

WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 24/04/2022 11:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What a shitty response.

You can't give very vague information and expect an answer.

Your attitude speaks volumes though.

ZebraInaTeapot · 24/04/2022 11:53

Where did this happen OP? A shop? A venue?
how did they approach you initially?

SilverHairedCat · 24/04/2022 11:52

Right OP, you need to be a LOT more clear.

Were you being held captive by your abusive partner / relative or were you detained by security who were waiting for police to arrive? Or another scenario?

There is an enormous variation here on risk to you before you use physical assault to escape.

Law on self defence in the UK is very simple. Reasonable IN THE CIRCUMSTANCES. But you're too vague on the circumstances.

Have you been charged with a criminal offence?

5foot5 · 24/04/2022 11:52

Sorry just realised I misunderstood your thread title. When you said (in law) I thought you meant one of your DHs family had held you, hence my reference to other family members . Now I realise you were asking about the legal position. My bad.

Did you know this person at all?

SocksAndTheCity · 24/04/2022 11:50

Nobody here is your 'darling', and cunty responses to posters who are just trying to find out what happened so they can try to offer help don't exactly cover you in glory.

Your OP and subsequent posts are vague and give no context. You were detained by somebody - whom? Where? Why? Were you suspected of some misdemeanour? Mistaken identity? Was this a domestic situation or in your/their workplace?

TabithaTittlemouse · 24/04/2022 11:50

so a security guard stops you from leaving and you ask if it’s ok to hit him/her?

It’s really hard to advise on such little information but with the information you’ve provided, no it’s not it’s not a proportionate reaction.

blacksax · 24/04/2022 11:48

If someone, as part of their job, is legitimately detaining you (for whatever reason) then no, you shouldn't be fighting back, so you won't have a leg to stand on.

KatherineJaneway · 24/04/2022 11:48

The long and the short answer is that I do not know why.

You must have some inkling?

5foot5 · 24/04/2022 11:47

Well if they are so much bigger than you it sounds like any attempt to take them on physically might not work or might result in you being hurt.
If you are safe now could you go to the police and report what happened. Refuse to be in this person's vompsny again. Alert other family members to the incident. Are any of these options?

sweeneytoddsrazor · 24/04/2022 11:45

As a general rule a security guard would not stop you from leaving for 4 or 5 hours. Neither would they stop you without reason. And they would most likely explain why they are doing so.

SpindleInTheWind · 24/04/2022 11:44

Maybe set out the details on the Legal Matters board?

SpindleInTheWind · 24/04/2022 11:43

I'm afraid that I don't know why either.

JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:40

5foot5 · 24/04/2022 11:38

But they simply held me for about 4 hours

WHY? Not trying to excuse it just want done background* *

The long and the short answer is that I do not know why.

OP posts:
JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

5foot5 · 24/04/2022 11:38

But they simply held me for about 4 hours

WHY? Not trying to excuse it just want done background* *

JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:38

and I have no idea how long as you may have gathered. I'm trying to get a timetable based on texts and phonecalls made before and after. Anything between 3 and 5 hours I would say.

OP posts:
5foot5 · 24/04/2022 11:36

Still not really enough context. Tantalising hints by using words like "captive" and "flee" but I just have a feeling you are trying to build up and draw people in without setting your situation out properly

JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:36

If you can think of it like a security guard or something blocking you in somewhere. The laws that I've googled tells me they have no power unless they think you may have committed a crime (never a question in this case) in which case they can make a sort of citizens arrest. But they simply held me for about 4 hours.

I am in England.

OP posts:
WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 24/04/2022 11:34

Its impossible to say without knowing the full circumstances. There are so many variables.

JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:34

Hont1986 · 24/04/2022 11:21

You can use necessary and reasonable force to defend yourself, in any situation. But there is no situation that gives you a green light to use whatever force you want. The circumstances at the time would have to be considered, e.g. could you have walked away? Could you just have pushed them away? Did you only hit them once, or multiple times? Etc.

I couldn't have walked away as they blocked my exit. I tried to push past them but they were at least double my size. I didn't hit try anything else as I was afraid of repercussions so I was held hostage for about 3 hours.

OP posts:
5foot5 · 24/04/2022 11:33

No point speculating on this anymore until OP comes back with more context

JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:31

I suppose is it reasonable to incapacitate your captor in order to flee?

OP posts: