Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that if you're cornered and hit someone, you're ok (in law)?

109 replies

JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:00

Is it justifiable?
As a means to escape?

OP posts:
DaphneSprucesPippasClack · 24/04/2022 13:49

There is nowhere near enough information in this post for anyone to help you. If you have been kept against your will then you have reported it to the police, yes?

And why would you go back again?

Lockheart · 24/04/2022 13:48

OP, your post history suggests you're suffering from several things and you've spent some time in hospital recently.

If this is in a healthcare context then no it is not acceptable to assault a doctor or nurse who is keeping you in hospital for your own safety. If you believe they are acting unprofessionally or you are being held unlawfully then you need to speak to PALS or contact the police.

Xpologog · 24/04/2022 13:43

AFAIK a security guard could only detain you long enough for police to arrive. And they have to state why you are being detained. If the scenario was female detained on suspicion of shoplifting and there were only male security people they cannot search her do have to detain the person until police arrive, which could take time.
Of the person is in a position of authority ( security, store manager e.g.) and you believe they detained you for their entertainment or on some pretence then it’s essential you speak with a solicitor or senior police and do not go back to wherever it is alone.
Best I can offer on info you’ve given.

BlanketsBanned · 24/04/2022 13:31

No its not ok to hit a health professional who is legally doing their job in the patients best interest but it happens all the time and few people get charged, if you are mentally unwell or under the influence then they take all that into consideration . .

Butfirstcoffees · 24/04/2022 13:23

I am also guessing op was held for her own or others safety. Which is why she is being cagey, changing details but is insisting she needs to go back.

She wants MN to advise her its ok the attack the person doing their job.

NerrSnerr · 24/04/2022 13:16

You need more context. Is it a healthcare professional? I can't think of any other scenario where you wouldn't just call the police as you've said it wasn't a security guard after shop lifting.

BlanketsBanned · 24/04/2022 13:12

Georgeskitchen · 24/04/2022 13:00

Nobody can detain you for 4 or 5 hours except the police:, and even they need a reason. Are you saying they held you in a room with no explanation? That's called false imprisonment and is a crime

Thats not true, a registered mental health nurse can detain you on a section 5.4 for up to 6 hours and the police for upmto 24hrs if they feel you are a danger to yourself or others and a health professional may feel it appropriate to keep you in hospital if you are acutely unwell and unable to keep yourself safe

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 24/04/2022 13:05

Georgeskitchen · 24/04/2022 13:00

Nobody can detain you for 4 or 5 hours except the police:, and even they need a reason. Are you saying they held you in a room with no explanation? That's called false imprisonment and is a crime

That might be technically true, but if you went to your GP or counsellor or other medical appointment and told them you were going to kill yourself, and they detained you whilst seeking help for you then I dont think that GP would be arrested for false imprisonment, do you?

The way the OP writes, this sounds like she was detained because she was a risk to herself or others and needed help. If she assaulted a medical professional to get away then it would just make her look even more mentally unwell.

Toottooot · 24/04/2022 13:05

Why have you nae reported this individual to the polis?

Georgeskitchen · 24/04/2022 13:00

Nobody can detain you for 4 or 5 hours except the police:, and even they need a reason. Are you saying they held you in a room with no explanation? That's called false imprisonment and is a crime

Bayleaf25 · 24/04/2022 12:46

Agree with @SpindleInTheWind unless the OP offers a different and specific scenario.

SpindleInTheWind · 24/04/2022 12:44

I think it's a hospital setting and the OP has been asked/told to come back today. She probably needs to go back, but doesn't want a repeat of being kept there in a manner which feel like detainment.

MadeForThis · 24/04/2022 12:42

Were you considered a risk to yourself or someone else?

whynotwhatknot · 24/04/2022 12:39

If its a security thing yes they can hold you so to speak till the police get there

if is for your own mh wellbeing theyre just trying to help you

either way i dont think you can hit someone

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 24/04/2022 12:38

You could be held in a hospital if you were a risk to yourself or others but they'd need to follow proper procedure for putting a hold on you.

Look, this is an anonymous forum. Just post the full story and you might get proper responses.

me4real · 24/04/2022 12:37

If it's self defence/ you think they will physically harm you.

WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 24/04/2022 12:35

SmudgeButt · 24/04/2022 12:31

I'm wondering if the OP was very very drunk/drugged up and someone was preventing them from running out into traffic. If only because there's absolutely no details. And today they plan on getting very very very drunk/drugged up and attempt to run into traffic again at the same location with the same people hanging about.

I would have thought if it was a domestic abuse situation or something happening at work then there would be a bit of background so that we could offer some practical advice.

Yes it does sound like op was detained for her own safety and is looking for permission to assault the person who helped the first time.

SmudgeButt · 24/04/2022 12:31

I'm wondering if the OP was very very drunk/drugged up and someone was preventing them from running out into traffic. If only because there's absolutely no details. And today they plan on getting very very very drunk/drugged up and attempt to run into traffic again at the same location with the same people hanging about.

I would have thought if it was a domestic abuse situation or something happening at work then there would be a bit of background so that we could offer some practical advice.

AchillesPoirot · 24/04/2022 12:28

JetTail · 24/04/2022 11:00

Is it justifiable?
As a means to escape?

It depends on the specific circumstances

worraliberty · 24/04/2022 12:28

Toottooot · 24/04/2022 12:22

Right so ‘someone’ held you captive for 4-5 hours without any sort of explanation and you need to return to this mysterious place. Doubt it happened like that darling.

It started off about '3' hours then went to 4 and then 5 got a chance Confused

Russell19 · 24/04/2022 12:27

Hope you are ok OP. If you feel like you might be in that situation again is there no way you can avoid this place? Was the person who cornered you known to you?

worraliberty · 24/04/2022 12:26

This is like pulling teeth with a plastic spoon.

Toottooot · 24/04/2022 12:22

Right so ‘someone’ held you captive for 4-5 hours without any sort of explanation and you need to return to this mysterious place. Doubt it happened like that darling.

User12398712 · 24/04/2022 12:22

Your very cagey, defensive/aggressive answers remind me of a couple of previous posts I've seen where the OP has been in a mental health crisis.

If your question is hospital or mental health related OP, please seek help. If it is something entirely unrelated, then I apologise unreservedly.

supertedious · 24/04/2022 12:20

You can be detained and held under the MH act if you are deemed a danger to yourself or others. For example of if you are visiting a MH hospital for treatment and are not currently on section or a CTO the hospital could still section you of on arrival if they deem it necessary.

Again more context is needed.