Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make a constructive complaint about the breastfeeding midwife 4 months on?

157 replies

PinkFing · 24/04/2022 10:20

I feel unreasonable even typing this as she was so nice and really tried to help, but….

when my dad was born it was noted he had a tongue tie. She came to the postnatal ward to help and also cut the tongue tie in a week in the clinic. Things still didn’t improve and I had sore bleeding nipples and cried every time he latched on.

after a few weeks I was still going to her clinics and she sat me down and took my hand saying “it’s ok to stop. You’re not enjoying this time with him and ultimately it’s not where the milk comes from but how you bond with your baby when feeding him etc”. She said that it was fine to use some formula and if I stopped breastfeeding entirely then it was okay. Obviously all the words a stress out mum wants to hear! But looking back I wish she’d encouraged me more and told me not to give up. That’s her job right?! I’m now combo feeding but wish someone had pushed me not to give bottles and I can’t help blaming her for not putting the pressure on. AIBU?

OP posts:
sayanythingelse · 24/04/2022 10:40

You should have tried having the midwife I had for DD. She was born just before Christmas, so pretty much all children's centres and support had closed. My midwife had retired, so I had a temporary one who couldn't get out of my house quick enough to get to a family event.
DD was only 5lb and her words were "I suggest you go to Asda and buy some formula otherwise you're going to spend Christmas Day in hospital with a poorly baby who is failing to thrive".
She was my first baby that took us 6 years to conceive. I was bloody terrified of losing her, so I just formula fed. I'm still annoyed at the lack of support but atleast DD is healthy.

KarmaStar · 24/04/2022 10:39

She sounds lovely,professional yet understanding your pain.She sought to help you and YOU WANT TO COMPLAIN ?
words fail me at your terrible,horrible attitude.

Hallibob · 24/04/2022 10:39

Yes YABU.

She was giving you options. It would have been wrong for her to see a struggling mother and railroad you down the ebf route if it was making you miserable.

I was left in tears by a midwife telling me I was starving my newborn because I didn't lie naked with him in bed for a full weekend and feed him constantly. What she failed to realise was I was recovering from a huge PPH and my body just wasn't producing enough milk. At that pointed I needed someone to tell me it was ok to switch to formula. No one did and instead I was left feeling like a complete failure and the first 5 weeks of my sons life were completely miserable.

LisaSimpson73 · 24/04/2022 10:38

PinkFing · 24/04/2022 10:31

Thanks for all your honest replies. I don’t actually think I’d get to the point of typing a complaint. Looking back I just feel I needed a voice of authority and not a friend saying the right words iyswim.

That's a really odd thing to say thinking about it.
She's there to support you she's not "in authority" over you. You are an adult and a mum now, your decisions matter and somebody can't make them for you.
You wish that somebody had taken it out of your hands and forced you to keep going?
I strongly suspect you'd be even more unhappy than you are now if that had been the case.

Tee20x · 24/04/2022 10:38

A voice of authority? So should she have listed all the benefits of breastfeeding and shamed you into continuing even though you were struggling?

Of course YABU and she gave you compassionate advice.

Runaway1 · 24/04/2022 10:37

YABU. I needed to be told this and wasn’t and I deeply regret how much I hated feeding due to the pain. It really affected our bond and I feel guilty about that to this day.

Moomeh · 24/04/2022 10:37

Ps and I'm still breastfeeding at 20 months now. I never thought I would be when dd was first born - I was very ill after haemorrhage and sepsis. But I just kept feeding on demand and latching constantly. Feeding to sleep, feeding for comfort, bf after bottle, and my supply increased naturally.

SJ179 · 24/04/2022 10:36

YABU I can’t help but think they can’t win what ever they say. I’ve seen so many posts complaining about feeling pressured to BF by midwives and how they had wished they would have been told it’s okay to stop. Obviously people not happy when the opposite happens either.

Georgeskitchen · 24/04/2022 10:36

She gave you advice. You took it. Many stories I have heard of mothers feeling pressured into carrying on breastfeeding when it's not working for them. .
Why put a blot on the career of a caring dedicated individual for no reason?

Efortyjive · 24/04/2022 10:36

PinkFing · 24/04/2022 10:31

Thanks for all your honest replies. I don’t actually think I’d get to the point of typing a complaint. Looking back I just feel I needed a voice of authority and not a friend saying the right words iyswim.

Can you imagine the opposite? I was really struggling, my midwife had been supporting me in clinics but put the pressure on me to keep going.

WindowsSmindows · 24/04/2022 10:36

Women are emotionally bullied all the time into sticking with breast feeding when it's not working out. They miss those lovely bonding months with baby, and baby goes hungry and everyone is sleep deprived.
She gave you amazing advice, as a professional who can see both sides. She wasn't being "your friend". Her advice was amazing well done to her. I wish someone had spoken to me with such effortless honesty and neutral perspective.

3WildOnes · 24/04/2022 10:35

I dont understand why you think it would have been better if you had persevered? What do you think is better for your son, having breastmilk or having a mum who isn’t crying when he is being fed? I think it is much better for his emotional health that he has a happy relaxed mum.

WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 24/04/2022 10:35

Can you imagine if she was a 'voice of authority' and told you that you must struggle on despite crying at every feed.

She absolutely did the right thing.

Karwomannghia · 24/04/2022 10:34

You were visiting the clinic repeatedly and crying every time your ds latched on! You were clearly very distressed and looking for help- one option she suggested was ff which she did without judgement or pushing and that’s completely valid!! It would have been the wrong thing not to mention that as an option but try to force you to continue.

don’t feel about about ff it’s fine!!

Moomeh · 24/04/2022 10:34

Yabu. Just gradually phase out the formula. i started combo feeding as i was very ill after my c section - probably 70% formula. Gradually phased it out till I was essentially ebf by 4 months. No pumping required, just feed, feed, feed.

It's a huge myth that bf can only reduce not increase. "Nipple confusion" is also extremely rare. I recommend the book breastfeeding made easy by Geraldine miskin

Scottishskifun · 24/04/2022 10:34

Yes your being unreasonable.
Her job is to support mothers and babies yes with bf but also with mothers well being. It's not to be a bf warrior at any cost and for some women bf just doesn't work out and makes them miserable which isn't in the interests of the mum. She was simply saying it's OK to feed a different way if it would be better for you. Some women will push themselves ridiculously and feel guilted into it.

It's good that your bf journey is working out but that's not the same for all women. You can reduce the number of bottles and switch to ebf over a few weeks if you so wish I suggest contacting a lactation consultant

LisaSimpson73 · 24/04/2022 10:34

Right so she offered you practical support and advice on breastfeeding then when it was still difficult she was kind and sympathetic and told you that your ds would be just fine if you chose to stop... yeah what a bitch, stick a complaint in immediately, these things need to be stopped Hmm

Seriously though op, it looks as if you're a bit unhappy with things and looking to lash out at somebody else. Please don't, look forward to your and your ds' future and try not to obsess over what's already happened.

Clymene · 24/04/2022 10:33

Please don't complain. She was saying the truth.

NewtoHolland · 24/04/2022 10:33

YABVU. It isn't her job to put the pressure on, quite the opposite. It's her job to support your choice, which it sounds like she did. If you're not happy with your decision you could choose to try to relactate?

drpet49 · 24/04/2022 10:32

You are just looking for someone to blame. It was your decision and your decision alone. Take some responsibility.

KristalBall90 · 24/04/2022 10:32

I was made to feel like a total failure by midwives at hospital and in the community for being unable to breastfeed my first child and it had a huge impact on my mental health and my bond with DC. We would have benefited hugely from a professional telling me the things your midwife said to you tbh.

PinkFing · 24/04/2022 10:31

Thanks for all your honest replies. I don’t actually think I’d get to the point of typing a complaint. Looking back I just feel I needed a voice of authority and not a friend saying the right words iyswim.

OP posts:
Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 24/04/2022 10:31

Yabu when she was giving you adivce that she felt was best for you at the time. If you are in tears she was likely worrying it would have had a negative impact on your mental health if you continued. A midwife isn't there to pressure anyone, they are there to support and advise. It sounds like she did her job.

robocracker · 24/04/2022 10:31

Yanbu. That being said I always advise people to get in touch with a lactation consultant, La leche league or a community advisor (we have nct ones in our town as well as trained peer supporters who help)

If you're still doing breast feeds and would like to do it more than bottles then I would advise looking for something like this now so you can increase breast and reduce bottles.

Fwiw I never had good bf advice from a mw, even with my 3rd the mw told me I was holding her wrong 🤷🏻‍♀️ I was holding her in a great position for a fast let down, my husband told her I knew what I was doing lol. As a result of that I trained as a peer supporter.

InTheNightWeWillWish · 24/04/2022 10:28

Yes, YABU. There is no point pushing yourself to the point that you’re crying every time you’re feeding your baby. You are still able to breastfeed, just not exclusively. I stopped breastfeeding at 5 weeks because she was screaming and I was crying every time. It was horrible and made me hate being a mum. I think if I hadn’t stopped it wouldn’t have been very long before I was dealing with PND. The midwives and health visitors kept asking if it was sustainable (I was breastfeeding, topping up with formula and then pumping to build up supply) and the reason they kept asking is because it wasn’t sustainable. It was exhausting and impacting my mental health. They needed to look after me as well my DD. That midwife was looking after you by taking the pressure off you.