Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make a constructive complaint about the breastfeeding midwife 4 months on?

157 replies

PinkFing · 24/04/2022 10:20

I feel unreasonable even typing this as she was so nice and really tried to help, but….

when my dad was born it was noted he had a tongue tie. She came to the postnatal ward to help and also cut the tongue tie in a week in the clinic. Things still didn’t improve and I had sore bleeding nipples and cried every time he latched on.

after a few weeks I was still going to her clinics and she sat me down and took my hand saying “it’s ok to stop. You’re not enjoying this time with him and ultimately it’s not where the milk comes from but how you bond with your baby when feeding him etc”. She said that it was fine to use some formula and if I stopped breastfeeding entirely then it was okay. Obviously all the words a stress out mum wants to hear! But looking back I wish she’d encouraged me more and told me not to give up. That’s her job right?! I’m now combo feeding but wish someone had pushed me not to give bottles and I can’t help blaming her for not putting the pressure on. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TooManyPJs · 25/04/2022 13:37

PinkFing · 24/04/2022 10:31

Thanks for all your honest replies. I don’t actually think I’d get to the point of typing a complaint. Looking back I just feel I needed a voice of authority and not a friend saying the right words iyswim.

It's not her job to tell you what to do. She should be supporting and guiding, not being the "voice of authority".

TooManyPJs · 25/04/2022 13:36

YABVVVVVU

I wish to god someone had said that to me with my DS a few weeks in. I battled on for months and months to the detriment of him (he ended up in hospital as he was losing weight), me and our bond. Not one health professional said "maybe you should stop now" at any point. Someone should have said this to me. I needed to hear it. I was in some weird post natal hormonal breastfeeding tunnel and couldn't see the wood for the trees.

No you definitely should NOT complain.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 25/04/2022 13:17

It would have been really inappropriate for her to put pressure on you to continue breastfeeding. Encouragement is one thing, pressure is another.

But I feel for you because feeding your baby can bring up some very intense and complex emotions and they can be really hard to process. Please don’t project them onto a woman who was just doing her job.

Not that there’s anything wrong with combi feeding, but if you want to move to exclusive breastfeeding I’m sure you can with the right support?

PlayGIBluff · 25/04/2022 13:07

@Frazzledmum123 I’m sorry you feel it’s tearing you down just because I think it’s not a good idea to be ‘devastated’ by something that may have had absolutely no relevance to why you had a c-section. It doesn’t seem healthy and maybe you would benefit by talking to a professional about this. Far too much illogical pressure put on mothers by themselves like you and op. I just feel sorry for you both tbh.

Frazzledmum123 · 25/04/2022 12:46

@PlayGIBluff OK, I'm really not sure why you are obsessing about my birth when I only came on to offer some support to the OP but I was brought up to believe that happy people don't feel the need to tear a complete stranger down for no apparent reason so I will stop arguing now💐

GiltEdges · 25/04/2022 12:26

imisscashmere · 24/04/2022 10:59

I can scarcely believe this post is real.

Poor midwives - they can’t win!

Indeed! Some people will find anything to complain about.

OP, you're a parent now. You'll have to make lots of decisions in the course of raising your DC, which will impact their life in one way or another. Sometimes, the decisions you make will ultimately be ones you later regret; we're all human afterall. Looking outwards for someone else to blame all the time really isn't going to help you.

TheKeatingFive · 25/04/2022 10:59

OP, I do feel for you as you're clearly processing some complex emotions.

These aren't the midwife's fault though.

Fandangofran · 25/04/2022 10:56

Absolutely not! Why would you potentially damage someone's career for that - WHY???

So many women feel pressured into continuing breast feeding no matter what.

You were bleeding and sore to the point of crying and you think she should have encouraged you to continue??? That would have been completely irresponsible.

When you're feeling low already even "gentle encouragement" can feel like massive judgment

I was made to feel absolutely worthless by several midwives for not being able to feed. I'd fed my first for 12m but when I had my twins no milk came in at all. I wanted to do it but despite doing everything I was told and even hiring a breastpump it just didn't happen and we weren't allowed to leave hospital as they were losing weight - despite that they STILL tried to bully me and make me feel like shit constantly.

Sunds like that midwife did exactly the right thing - if you complain and she gets in trouble that means the next person that needs support might not get it as the midwife may be more nervous about further complaints.

10HailMarys · 25/04/2022 10:53

I'll be blunt here: I know this isn't something you're doing consciously, but basically, you feel guilty about your breastfeeding experience, and you're trying to make yourself feel better by shifting that to the midwife. Deep down, I think you know the midwife did the right thing.

A lot of women really struggle psychologically when breastfeeding is difficult/impossible for them, and your son is still only a few months old. Your breastfeeding journey was quite traumatic for you, and it's understandable that you're looking for ways to process that. You're very much still at the post-natal stage and I think maybe you've got some feelings you need to work through.

mubarak86 · 25/04/2022 10:53

YABVU. First time around I had severe, cracked bleeding nipples, I was constantly in tears and my baby was screaming in hunger and my midwife said I couldn't even try expressing as it would interfere with my milk supply. I was made to feel like a complete failure for trying formula. She even said there was a correlation between lower socioeconomic groups and early formula feeding to put me off Hmm
OP I'm so glad to hear midwives have moved on now and recognize that breastfeeding simply doesn't work well for some mums and babies.

GooglyEyeballs · 25/04/2022 10:52

Can't believe you'd even consider making a complaint about this midwife. 'voice of authority'? BS! She gave you good, appropriate advice but in the end it was your decision and ultimately your responsibility to decide. She helped you and was kind to you and your reaction is to want to lash out and make a complaint about her. I think you should have a good think about how to treat others.

SexyPortugese · 25/04/2022 10:44

You know, if I'd had someone like you in those early weeks, then I might have felt able to forgive myself for starving my newborn and give myself permission to stop trying to force breastfeeding.

In the end, I had endless encouragement from all angles to 'keep going! It gets better! It's the best for him!' and I triple fed, on strong prescribed drugs, for nine long months. I never, ever produced enough milk for my child, and he spent the first ten days of his life in hospital being treated for starvation. We almost brought home a baby with brain damage because he was starving but not one single midwife would believe me when I wasn't producing milk.

Breastfeeding support NEEDS to be like you received: they meet you where you're at, and empower you to make the decision to stop if you need to. She couldn't make you stop, just like the people I spoke to couldn't make me keep going. I made that choice, yes there was pressure but ultimately it was on me. But having someone say to you it's okay if you can't make it work can save mums and babies an enormous amount of suffering.

There is nothing in breast milk that is more valuable than the wellbeing of the mother. You were extremely lucky to have such a wonderful experience, and I can't help but feel that your own sense of resentment towards yourself for not continuing with breastfeeding is being transferred onto her, as if it's her fault you didn't continue.

SexyPortugese · 25/04/2022 10:41

You're being incredibly unreasonable.

SherbetDips · 25/04/2022 10:27

I think you had a lovely supportive lady helping you. Honestly I hear so many stories of pushy midwives making new mums feel like rubbish when they can’t breastfeed and you want to complain about one that supported you and helped you…

ComeOnNow21 · 25/04/2022 09:19

Complaint?! You should be sending a note into the hospital to thank her for her support and kindness.

sugarcoatedsp · 25/04/2022 07:21

Honestly, as a midwife this is what we have to deal with day in and day out- whatever we do is wrong. Every emotion is projecting back as blame.
You're called the 'breastfeeding Mafia' if you try to encourage women on. You're not authoritative if you don't push them on.

And this is why we are leaving in absolute drives, because we are normal people with feelings, generally working like absolute dogs in appalling conditions to try to do our best for families, but it's never enough. Absolutely soul destroying.

CurlyBurley · 25/04/2022 07:10

OP, I wish I had had your midwife. Mine told me I would feel terrible guilt if I stopped, and that she was only visiting to promote breast feeding. It made me feel even worse, so I carried on even though it was painful and I hated it. Now my child is 9. He's always been anxious and I do worry that it's because he could feel how unhappy I was at that time.

houseargh · 25/04/2022 07:03

YABU. In your own words, you wanted her to 'put the pressure on' and 'be a voice of authority.' Firstly, there is no law requiring women to EBF, so authority has nothing to do with it. And do you honestly think that being pressurised is what women need at this stage? If your baby is healthy and happy AND benefitting from the advantages of breast milk because you're combi feeding, what are you not ok with? Might be worth doing some examination of that rather than putting your energy towards this.

Toddlerteaplease · 25/04/2022 06:55

I wish more midwives would take that approach. She's quite right.

TheOnlyAletheia · 25/04/2022 06:30

Oh ffs. No you shouldn’t. Several reasons

  1. your boobs, your baby, your choice. Take some responsibility.
  2. She was professional and compassionate and gave the right advice.
  3. stupid complaints undermine the confidence of professionals giving the right advice.
JennyAnn1982 · 25/04/2022 06:00

KristalBall90 · 24/04/2022 10:32

I was made to feel like a total failure by midwives at hospital and in the community for being unable to breastfeed my first child and it had a huge impact on my mental health and my bond with DC. We would have benefited hugely from a professional telling me the things your midwife said to you tbh.

This.

PlayGIBluff · 25/04/2022 05:55

Yes I agree you are like op @Frazzledmum123 Pick something that happened during labour, decide it’s the reason you needed a c-section. Op picks something that happened when breastfeeding. Decides that’s the reason she is not EBF.

Bizawit · 24/04/2022 23:56

Ya what??? This is the most unreasonable Aibu I think I’ve ever read! you say needed a “voice of authority to say the right thing”? She absolutely did exactly that. She told you that it was ok to give the baby formula. It was. She told you that enjoying time with your baby is more important than where the
milk comes from, that’s true! If you felt pressured or encouraged to stop breastfeeding that would be different , but this doesn’t sound like that at all. She gave you permission to choose , to think about your own well-being and your bond with your baby. You
made your own choice which is exactly how it should be.

shreddednips · 24/04/2022 23:41

What she said was fine, because it's absolutely true. She didn't say you should stop breastfeeding, or that you must stop. She just said that it was a valid choice to move to formula if that's what you wanted to do.

And she sounds kind. Nobody should be pressuring women to either breastfeed or formula feed. It's your baby- all she can do is try to help you feel empowered to choose the right path for you, but she can't be 'authoritative' and push you one way or the other.

tiktokontheclock · 24/04/2022 23:11

YABU. You needed a "voice of authority" to make decisions about how to feed your own child? Oh love. I've had one and I know how hard it is and am expecting another, but that's YOUR job. Only you can decide how to feed your kid. She did the right thing and countless other women would have been saved from PND/anxiety just because of her words.

Swipe left for the next trending thread