Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Herbs and spices?

67 replies

Rabbitheadlights · 24/04/2022 08:53

Firstly I'm aware there are much more important things occuring in the world right now and that there is also a cost of living crisis.

However I subscribe to several cookery forums and recently it seems to be a popular opinion that herbs and spices are a luxury? For me they are an integral part of cooking and any meal, they are in fact what makes food joyful and I don't consider them a luxury at all.

Aibu??

OP posts:
sweeneytoddsrazor · 24/04/2022 12:13

But you don't need to buy them all at once do you? Buy one or two basic ones then add one or two with your weekly shop. They last for ages and if you are using different ones they won't all run out at the same time.

ImInStealthMode · 24/04/2022 12:13

@thebeespyjamas Or you just eat the food plain without seasoning. It won't kill you. Many people eat this way because it would be ridiculous to spend even £1 on herbs or spices if you only have £10 to feed yourself for the week.

JudgeRindersMinder · 24/04/2022 12:06

This thread is hilarious and peak mumsnet. If I was down to my last quid I’d be spending it on half a dozen eggs not a jar of chilli!

BarbaraofSeville · 24/04/2022 11:59

The big tubs of Thai curry pastes are also good value, especially when combined with block coconut (cost about £1, equivalent to 4 cans of coconut milk).

The paste costs £2-3 but there's enough for 10-15 batches of Thai curry, which you could make with chick peas and cheaper vegetables like carrots, potatoes, frozen green beans, broccoli, mushrooms if on a budget.

You would normally add fish sauce, but the paste has so much flavour that I don't think it would be noticeable if this was missed out, and it's really quick and easy to do.

Libertaire · 24/04/2022 11:49

I agree, spices are a normal part of everyday cooking. They are what enable you to turn an onion, a tin of chickpeas and a bunch of spinach, or whatever, into a cheap tasty nutritious family meal. I buy the 100g packs (Rajah or East End brands) from the Indian supermarket or the World Foods aisle at big Tesco/ Asda rather than the little glass jars. It works out much, much cheaper.

ImInStealthMode · 24/04/2022 11:46

YAB (a bit) U. Herbs and spices really do make a difference, but if someone is already on such a tight budget that they're skipping meals themselves to feed the kids then they're an enormous luxury.

A bowl of pasta and chopped tomatoes can be much improved with onion, garlic, basil, chilli flakes etc, but eating it without won't do any harm and the additions bring no more nutritional value.

I grew up in single parent family on benefits and salt and pepper were the extent of the seasonings and condiments we had in the house at any time. My Grandparents, despite being a bit better off, were the same. They were gifted a nice spice rack once and we threw it out, unopened and long out of date after they'd died.

Because I didn't grow up with them I struggle now to know what goes with what aside from the real basics and am quite happy with relatively plain food. Thankfully DP is a keen cook and we're in a position to buy whatever groceries take our fancy. He has dozens and dozens of herbs and spices.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/04/2022 11:36

cumin
coriander
turmeric
chilli powder
curry powder
garam masala
smoked paprika (possibly)

With the above (and frozen garlic and ginger) you'll be able to make a wide range of Indian/Pakistani and Mexican type meals, which allows you to use pulses and veg to make tasty food.

For example 100 g of chilli powder for 70 p.

Once open I keep them in old jars from jam, pasta sauce, pickle, olives, capers etc.

RampantIvy · 24/04/2022 11:27

curry powder
oregano
garlic powder
chilli powder

gillybean2 · 24/04/2022 11:25

Not to derail the thread but which dried herbs and spices would be considered basic that everyone should have even if cooking on a very limited budget?

I’ve been adding black pepper and mixed herbs to my food bank donations this year. They always ask for tinned tomatoes but I figured whatever they are being used for (pasta sauce or soup base maybe?) would need some flavour to be palatable.

RampantIvy · 24/04/2022 11:06

Certainly since I moved down south (now in London) the availability of a huge range of cheap spices is incredible

I think you must have lived in a bit of a backwater to not be able to get herbs and spices easily. I used to buy all my spices from Asian supermarkets in Bradford. I now get my South East Asian spices and pastes from a brilliant Chinese supermarket in Sheffield, and my Indian spices from an excellent Asian supermarket in Rotherham.

ifonly4 · 24/04/2022 10:26

We've got herbs and spices, luckily DD bought half of them do not our expense. I use them a lot for adding extra/different taste to recipes and also cheap meals I do. I guess if you're really struggling, they're not fillers/a major source of nutrition so one of the first things to go from your shop though.

I've discovered Lidl sell some of them for half the price of my usual source, so will be trying those in an effort to keep bills down.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/04/2022 10:23

It's not just London/SE, but the same in the cities and mill towns of northern England. There's probably not much that you can't get cheaply in larger supermarkets and independent grocers.

But you don't need a huge variety. Probably half a dozen common spices, frozen garlic and ginger, and coriander, parsley and basil growing on the window sill, couple of bottles of chilli and soy sauce and you've massively expanded your repertoire. You can even start small and just get one or two a week until you have everything.

thebeespyjamas · 24/04/2022 10:21

luxxlisbon · 24/04/2022 09:15

Well they are ‘extras’ so of course they are going to be a luxury for someone on a limited budget.
They are an integral part for you because you can afford it.
Per portion it doesn’t add much but you obviously need to buy much more than you need for a meal and unfortunately some people can’t justify that.

No, they're not extras, they're staples that enable you to eat very cheaply. Without them you either eat stodge or you eat things pre-seasoned which cost a lot more.

Thatswhyimacat · 24/04/2022 10:14

Certainly since I moved down south (now in London) the availability of a huge range of cheap spices is incredible. However, I come from a family that recently were really excited to tell me about this new thing they'd discovered that makes pasta taste amazing - parmesan.

thebeespyjamas · 24/04/2022 10:14

Rabbitheadlights · 24/04/2022 08:53

Firstly I'm aware there are much more important things occuring in the world right now and that there is also a cost of living crisis.

However I subscribe to several cookery forums and recently it seems to be a popular opinion that herbs and spices are a luxury? For me they are an integral part of cooking and any meal, they are in fact what makes food joyful and I don't consider them a luxury at all.

Aibu??

They are the very opposite. I cook all our meals from scratch and we have a low food budget. We are plant-based and eat very healthily, it's a real focus of our family. Health isn't a luxury.

I can turn half a bag of lentils, an onion and a tin of tomatoes (so £1.50 for three people and leftovers/a work meal) into a delicious meal IF and only if I have spices. So obviously spices are a stable that’s kept in the cupboard ready to turn a quid or so into something more than edible, delicious in fact.

What's the alternative? Eating tasteless meals and living in misery? Spending/i.e. wasting more money?

Neither of these are sensible. You know what is sensible? Keeping spices in your cupboard so your family can eat a nutritious meal that doesn't make you feel like a monk.

Those people sound like they are prioritising the wrong things.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/04/2022 10:13

I do think having a full spice rack with all the cloves and smoked paprika and rosemary etc is quite a middle class thing

In the UK perhaps. This is something I find quite hard to get my head around. In many countries 'cooking' and use of herbs and spices is what everyone does, because we all have to eat.

Many common dishes are very cheap and easy to make with easily available ingredients, often that don't require any refrigeration, ie traditional methods of food preservation from before a time when everyone had fridges.

I'm now thinking of something like pasta putanesca, made from dried pasta and canned tomatoes and anchovies and capers and olives from a jar. Quick, easy, cheap, tasty, adaptable, filling, relatively healthy, no fresh ingredients required, yet this sort of thing is commonly written off as 'too aspirational' for people on lower incomes in the UK.

Thatswhyimacat · 24/04/2022 10:12

@RewildingAmbridge that sounds great, but it's very different from my northern upbringing where there weren't many people from other cultures in our area and dinner would be a tin of supermarket value ravioli!

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 24/04/2022 10:05

Thatswhyimacat · 24/04/2022 09:27

I suppose when I was a student I would only have a few very basic things like chilli powder, curry powder, black pepper and maybe some Italian herbs. It isn't just the cost aspect but also that many people like me from poor backgrounds were just never given any education on spices in food and grew up eating bland and got used to it. I do think having a full spice rack with all the cloves and smoked paprika and rosemary etc is quite a middle class thing.

Food education is disgraceful in the UK, has been for a long time because parents and schools are working so hard to just meet the basic levels that there isn't any time for passing on skills, if indeed the skills are there.

Justyouwaitandseeagain · 24/04/2022 09:52

It's all relative. Herbs and spices are expensive to buy - expensive by quantity if you buy small supermarket packets, expensive in the outlay if you opt to buy in bulk.
when I got my first flat, Me and my partner had a £20 budget for food/household products per week and I asked for herbs and spices for my Christmas presents. I still remember which family member bought me savoury herbs and spices, the person who bought me sweet baking spices and and other expensive bits (eg a bottle of posh vanilla essence). If you've never had to worry about the cost of things like herbs and spices then you are lucky.

RewildingAmbridge · 24/04/2022 09:51

@Thatswhyimacat I don't agree with that I grew up in the East end of London before gentrification, parents both left school at 14 without qualifications dad worked 60 weeks all his life in manual jobs, mum worked in nurseries or retail with cleaning jobs on top. Spices are cheap and cooking in bulk from scratch (often cheap cuts of meat that need slow cooking) is more affordable than buying processed foods. If you're poor you've got to be creative and spices help that. I learned to cook the most amazing dishes from India, Pakistan, West Indies, Africa from neighbours and friends of our family. All cooking for large families on tight budgets.

ScaldedBy · 24/04/2022 09:49

They're a part of most recipes and last a while. They're not even that expensive especially compared to how many things you can do with one packet/bottle. Even on a low income budget we had herbs and spiced...wouldn't classify that as a luxury just expected of anyone who had a kitchen to have.

CounsellorTroi · 24/04/2022 09:48

Herbs and spices are not a luxury, they are what makes food enjoyable rather than just fuel. As someone said upthread, buying spices from the World Foods aisle, or from an Asian supermarket if you have one locally, is much cheaper than buying the little jars from Schwarz!

what’s happened to the refill boxes for herb/spice jars? Supermarkets don’t seem to stock them now.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/04/2022 09:45

Rabbitheadlights · 24/04/2022 09:04

@Alittlenonsensenowandthen I agree that the purchasing of several at once could be expensive and thus considered a luxury however the thought train seems to be for example, a bolognaise is fine with just garlic. Basil, oregano, chili etc are not necessary and frivolous even. Maybe it's just because lots of people are cutting back and this is one small way if doing that?

Well to be fair, bolognese traditionally doesn't include any of garlic, chili, basil or oregano, but I would always put garlic in and maybe some oregano if I had some.

But you can add lots of flavour using herbs and spices without it costing a lot and it's not a luxury because they're generally the gateway to making tasty food for hardly any money, eg if you can make something like a dhal, and use turmeric, chilli powder, garlic and coriander leaf, it will taste great and cost pennies per portion for something really nutrious.

Instead of buying small Schwartz jars you can get Asian branded larger packs for well under a pound that last for ages, so the cost per recipe is almost nothing.

I buy the potted herbs from the cheaper supermarkets (about 50 p in Asda, Aldi or Lidl instead of 2 or 3 times that price in Sainsburys or Waitrose and repot them into a bigger pot to try and get them to grow a bit and last longer doesn't always work though.

For garlic and ginger, I get the big packs of frozen cubes that last ages, which is easier and far cheaper than fresh.

AlisonDonut · 24/04/2022 09:42

AlohaMolly · 24/04/2022 09:25

Would anyone be able to recommend any forums? I cook for my family but I’m not a good cook or a natural one. My food is on the tasty side of bland, but only just! I tend to use salt, pepper, mixed herbs and smoked paprika and that’s about it. I’ve got a little garden space and an allotment to grow herbs - I’ve got parsley in the garden and rosemary and oregano in the allotment, but I don’t use them!

id love to be able to learn and pick up ideas through a forum.

Parsley - add to any pasta dishes whilst cooking onions, add to soups and stews, and anything that needs some green in it.

Rosemary - sprinkle onto flatbreads, or onto roast potatoes.

oregano, chop and add to pasta dishes and especially on pzzas.

FusionChefGeoff · 24/04/2022 09:41

Ridiculous notion.

The 'price per use' is tiny.