Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Herbs and spices?

67 replies

Rabbitheadlights · 24/04/2022 08:53

Firstly I'm aware there are much more important things occuring in the world right now and that there is also a cost of living crisis.

However I subscribe to several cookery forums and recently it seems to be a popular opinion that herbs and spices are a luxury? For me they are an integral part of cooking and any meal, they are in fact what makes food joyful and I don't consider them a luxury at all.

Aibu??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
reshetima · 24/04/2022 14:27

AlohaMolly · 24/04/2022 09:25

Would anyone be able to recommend any forums? I cook for my family but I’m not a good cook or a natural one. My food is on the tasty side of bland, but only just! I tend to use salt, pepper, mixed herbs and smoked paprika and that’s about it. I’ve got a little garden space and an allotment to grow herbs - I’ve got parsley in the garden and rosemary and oregano in the allotment, but I don’t use them!

id love to be able to learn and pick up ideas through a forum.

AlohaMolly I enjoy the one-pot suppers from Spicery, which has introduced me to things like Jerk Chicken, and Tagine. You can filter out hotter recipes if you like (medium is fine if you don't like heat). What's nice is they give you the recipe for the spice mix to make it again. They sell the spices as well, great quality.

https://www.thespicery.com/easy-kits-shop?cat=134

skybluee · 24/04/2022 14:14

The cost per use may be tiny and herbs and spices are really good value in that respect, but the initial outlay is what's the issue. I guess salt and pepper can be quite cheap but beyond that, depending on where you're shopping, they can be quite expensive.

Where I live there's an initiative that grows herbs in the park and anyone from the general public is allowed to come and pick them. I think this is a brilliant idea. Although what I like about herbs is that they can be grown on a windowsill and don't require a garden.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 24/04/2022 14:13

Of course it makes sense that if you can spend your last 85p on a jar of mixed herbs from Tesco OR a bag of pasta that will make all your meals go further, then the pasta it is.

But PPs are quite right when they’ve said that herbs and spices can be what makes cheap cooking much more enjoyable. And to say that spices are an unnecessary luxury is disingenuous - because all those people living well below the poverty line in places like India and who cook with spices are what, profligate money wasters? Hmm

If you don’t like flavour then you’re free to have bland food. But for people trying to eat food they like but on a tight budget, herbs and spices can make a huge difference.

sst1234 · 24/04/2022 14:10

Unfortunately Northern European food is traditionally so bland and tasteless that there that the default position at times of hardship is to consider herbs and spices a luxury. Does not happen in cultures where herbs and spices are widely used. I mean let’s face it, some people in this country still think Garlic is a seasoning.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 24/04/2022 14:01

thebeespyjamas · 24/04/2022 13:52

That would be unwise.

If you had even a pinch of a few spices you could spend it on a tin of tomatoes and a potato and eat a nutritious meal that will fill you up and also go further.

It would also be unwise because scrambled eggs with dried mixed herbs would be disgusting. DMH need long slow cooking to bring out the flavour. You might as well sharpen a pencil over your scrambled eggs...

OctopusSay · 24/04/2022 13:59

Surely if you'd spent your last pound on eggs and found another you'd be much better advised to spend it on some bread or potatoes, maybe some veg to go with them, than a jar or dried herbs?

PonyPatter44 · 24/04/2022 13:59

Flatandhappy · 24/04/2022 13:45

It is such an Anglo-centric thing to say that the intrinsic ingredients of many cultures’ food is a luxury!

Precisely. Do people think that all Indian / Pakistani / Chinese / African / Caribbean people in this country are loaded and live in luxury? Hardly - rates of poverty are high among BAME populations as well. Yet their food is interesting and flavourful, precisely because they use plenty of different herbs and spices. If you asked an Indian mum if spices are a luxury, she'd laugh at the idea.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 24/04/2022 13:53

Chilli in a bolognese? Doesn't that make it more of a chilli?

I've had times when I can't afford herbs and spices. I've got a well stocked rack, but sometimes can't afford to replace things. If its a choice between potatoes and spice I'm picking potatoes.

BeerLoas · 24/04/2022 13:52

I grow most herbs so that’s not an expense and spices/sauces are my guilty pleasure. I might have a dedicated cupboard 😊Then when I’m foraging for dinner and using leftovers, always something tasty.

Second others who say big larger packs not Schwartz jars and go to Asian etc. supermarkets for good deals.

thebeespyjamas · 24/04/2022 13:52

PonyPatter44 · 24/04/2022 12:14

Not everyone is on the bones of their arse. Some people are genuinely clueless and glad of the advice.

If you'd spent your last pound on 6 eggs, and then you found another pound in a coin return or on the pavement, using it to buy a jar of mixed herbs would make your scrambled egg or omelette a bit nicer. Being poor doesn't mean you have to eat like a 19th century pauper. Sometimes people just don't know.

That would be unwise.

If you had even a pinch of a few spices you could spend it on a tin of tomatoes and a potato and eat a nutritious meal that will fill you up and also go further.

ImInStealthMode · 24/04/2022 13:46

Eating bland every day won't kill you but it will make your life pretty damn miserable

But that's in your opinion and your taste @thebeespyjamas! Plenty of people do just fine with unseasoned food and therefore would obviously class herbs as a luxury. I like flavourful food but I can manage just fine with plain things too. My Grandparents as mentioned upthread never had anything other than salt and pepper in the house and had plenty fulfilled and happy lives.

I would be pretty miserable without shellfish and blue cheese as occasional parts of my diet but to others they are the very last thing they'd ever want to eat. My friend can barely go a meal without ketchup but it turns my stomach. Each to their own.

Flatandhappy · 24/04/2022 13:45

It is such an Anglo-centric thing to say that the intrinsic ingredients of many cultures’ food is a luxury!

OfstedOffred · 24/04/2022 13:40

bolognaise is fine with just garlic. Basil, oregano, chili etc are not necessary

Proper bolognese in fact contains none of these things.

OctopusSay · 24/04/2022 13:40

In a life where you're having to live on absolute basics, of course anything you buy "just" to add flavour, rather than calories is a luxury.

If you're not in such desperate straits, not so much.

thebeespyjamas · 24/04/2022 13:37

ImInStealthMode · 24/04/2022 12:13

@thebeespyjamas Or you just eat the food plain without seasoning. It won't kill you. Many people eat this way because it would be ridiculous to spend even £1 on herbs or spices if you only have £10 to feed yourself for the week.

Not really, because they are about 50p and that provides for around 20 meals.

Eating bland every day won't kill you but it will make your life pretty damn miserable.

Spices also invariably have health benefits so it's win win and very worth it.

Justyouwaitandseeagain · 24/04/2022 13:20

The original question asked if herbs and spices could really be considered a luxury and yes, for some they can and are.

worth reading some of the brilliant articles by Jack Monroe which highlights just why life and food shopping / meal prep are so difficult for those living in real poverty.

Even working with people in poverty and having lived on tight budgets myself, Jack's insight opened my eyes to so many more factors which I am lucky enough never to have personally experienced.

cookingonabootstrap.com/2022/04/12/its-not-about-the-pasta-kevin-jack-monroe/?amp=1

Thatswhyimacat · 24/04/2022 13:19

@RampantIvy that's really interesting how life experiences differ, because as I say, I'm the opposite where my parents' generation only ate curries from the takeaway and a tikka masala was an unusual food!

OctopusSay · 24/04/2022 13:19

When I was growing up my mum considered salt an unnecessary expense. She had mint in the garden, that was the only herb ever used and curry powder for spices.

Almost all commercially produced food tastes over salted to me, although I do use small amounts i cooking myself, I expect it's very bland to others.

RampantIvy · 24/04/2022 13:17

Sorry @Thatswhyimacat I didn't mean to sound rude. I was just surprised. I live rurally, so it is a 30 mile round trip for me to stock up on spices.

RampantIvy · 24/04/2022 13:14

My MIL is only now in her 60s being introduced to paprika and cumin and eating 'foreign' food.

I think that is pretty unusual. I am in my 60s and have been making curries ever since Madhur Jaffrey hit our screens in the 1980s, and I am not alone. All my friends are a similar age and are used to eating a wide range of cuisines.

Thatswhyimacat · 24/04/2022 13:08

@RampantIvy bit rude. No I didn't grow up in a 'backwater' but I didn't grow up somewhere like Bradford where there is obviously tons of cultural diversity. I never said we couldn't get spices, just that there was no culture of eating food that used them. My MIL is only now in her 60s being introduced to paprika and cumin and eating 'foreign' food. My dear old nan certainly didn't put a herb or a spice on anything except maybe some mint on a lamb roast. And I grew up with a mum whose cooking extended to toasting bread or putting something from a tin to a bowl and into the microwave.

It's odd that the UK is so famous for its bland unseasoned food and yet everyone on MN is seemingly horrified at hearing about people without a comprehensive spice rack. Yes it's great to have, no it is not the norm, even though it is becoming more so which is a good thing!

HRTQueen · 24/04/2022 12:33

When I was really struggling for money I wouldn’t have been able to follow some recipes that have a number of herbs or spices I don’t regularly use

pots or bags of chilli, oregano, bay leaves, cumin, garam masala and ginger go a long way and can be bought cheaply

i now use frozen herbs, chilli, ginger and garlic but the cost around £1.99 each I couldn’t afford that at one point it would have seemed frivolous

now I also buy tins of ready made spice mixes then at times add extra ginger or chilli it saves on throwing away stale spices but again not something I could afford to do before

BarbaraofSeville · 24/04/2022 12:31

But if people are literally 'down to their last quid' then obviously half a dozen eggs is a sensible purchase. Then sorting out a referral to a food bank.

But realistically, a box of eggs is only going to make one light meal for 2-3 people, so is only a very short term solution. Although eggs are great for making healthy low cost, quick meals that don't need much cooking so good to always have in.

What this thread is about is whether it's possible to use herbs and spices on a low budget and with food in general, there does need to be a degree of thinking ahead, because once you've bought your herbs and spices, you're much less likely to find yourself in a position where you've nothing in and no money or ideas what to make.

It's more about doing what you can to avoid finding yourself in a position when you have no food, no money, no storecupboard basics, no cooking skills, no equipment and a family used to eating convenience food so they won't eat chick pea curry. Because then, when you have little money, you could buy a tin of chick peas and a couple of potatoes and make a big curry in the slow cooker with the spices you already have.

Apart from very young adults just starting out, the people who have run out of food and have a family to feed have years of experience of feeding themselves, so it's about making the most of that time to know how to feed yourself well on a low budget, so if the shit hits the fan, you can cope without relying on unhealthy convenience food which is almost always more expensive than cooking with basic spices.

ImInStealthMode · 24/04/2022 12:19

@PonyPatter44 Alternatively, spending the bonus £1 on some cherry tomatoes or spinach to put in your scrambled eggs would make them more nutritionally valuable, which herbs don't.

Being comfortable doesn't mean you need to eat like a cordon bleu chef either. Plenty of people are quite happy eating unseasoned food. Each to their own.

PonyPatter44 · 24/04/2022 12:14

JudgeRindersMinder · 24/04/2022 12:06

This thread is hilarious and peak mumsnet. If I was down to my last quid I’d be spending it on half a dozen eggs not a jar of chilli!

Not everyone is on the bones of their arse. Some people are genuinely clueless and glad of the advice.

If you'd spent your last pound on 6 eggs, and then you found another pound in a coin return or on the pavement, using it to buy a jar of mixed herbs would make your scrambled egg or omelette a bit nicer. Being poor doesn't mean you have to eat like a 19th century pauper. Sometimes people just don't know.