Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Full time or part time and benefits?

241 replies

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 05:27

I'm currently a working full time single mum, thinking about positively of changing to part time.

I love my work, decent salary, good hours = no paid child care needed, lots of paper work done at home when DS in bed. Being committed 5 days is really taking its toll on priorities, my son and work are always sorted, which leaves me running around with every spare minute trying to clean. Having the extra days at home would creat a perfect balance, but knowing the drop in wages it was only ever a dream.

However my friend recently explained how she's retuning part time after maternity leave, as she will be entitled to x, y, z and when added together is nearly a full time wage.

If I made the change it would permanent, and to move back I would need to reapply.

Any advice? Experience?

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:51

AllOfUsAreDead · 24/04/2022 07:48

I don't think it will be positive for you to do this. It sounds like your friend from other posts was already on a low income. It's easy to top up to low income with benefits. But if you're earning well and I'd assume that's 30k+, topping up to 30k is going to be harder and I don't think you'll get it. You'd be earning less very likely even with benefits, and you'd lose out on a proper pension.

Up to you I guess, if you're stressed it might work out, but you'll be likely working for more of your life than you anticipated, past retirement basically.

The maths is very individual and can be quite complicated. Earning 30k can be f**k all as far as benefit entertainment goes if you rent and have kids. You can easily be entitled to benefits way higher than that.

Oldtiredfedup · 24/04/2022 07:50

I wouldn’t - not if it meant reapplying, not when it seems the only issue is domestic chores.

I’d outsource.

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:48

Final point on this. You often get people - including very high earners like me - blithering on about how we pay too much tax (not all, some happily hand over their income for Government vanity projects).

but the dirty secret?

it’s people on the lowest end of the income spectrum who have the highest effective marginal tax rate. Oh and they are also the most affected by inflation in essential goods. It’s Insanity.

So if anyone wants to make their own rational decisions around time vs money, and you want to argue with them, have a think about how the system works in practice and what you would do in their actual position.

Booboobagins · 24/04/2022 07:48

Most people who were furlough didn't notice the difference between 80% and 100% wages, but then we were in lockdown for periods during this time (I wasn't furlough btw I worked throughout, didn't even take my holidays!) Anyways, getting one extra day a week can be fairly easy - could you work an extra hour a day? If so you'd just lose 0.5day pay per week but still only work 4 days a week. It seriously can be the diff between being pulled apart and enjoying your life. Losing 0.5 day pay really won't make a big difference to your income and your employer probably won't bat an eyelid! Talk to them.

Ref benefits question as a tax payer paying almost as much in tax as I earn the whole benefits system needs a overhaul. My main issue is life style benefit takers, like your friend - they're the ones tipping the country into shortfall. Why should I - a single parent - fund other people to work part time so they can claim benefits? Work what you can and if you need a top up fine, but don't stack it so you know you'll get a top up.

We all need to be adults in the society for society to work, after all if people like me who work remotely want to, we can all foff to the Bahamas and take our tax with us but where would that leave the UK.

AllOfUsAreDead · 24/04/2022 07:48

I don't think it will be positive for you to do this. It sounds like your friend from other posts was already on a low income. It's easy to top up to low income with benefits. But if you're earning well and I'd assume that's 30k+, topping up to 30k is going to be harder and I don't think you'll get it. You'd be earning less very likely even with benefits, and you'd lose out on a proper pension.

Up to you I guess, if you're stressed it might work out, but you'll be likely working for more of your life than you anticipated, past retirement basically.

Brieandcamembert · 24/04/2022 07:47

Sorry I'm confused who this reply is aimed towards because it certainly isn't me. Take your time to read the comments, understand the situation and then post your snide comment but without the husband or healthy part

It was aimed at the person that said it's normal to work part time. I know you personally don't have a husband but you can work full time.

I'm genuinely sorry things are hard right now.

**
**
**
**

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:47

HairyMuttttt · 24/04/2022 07:38

You clearly have no work life balance at the moment sandwiched between caring for younger and older generation plus full time job. With everything solely on your shoulders it’s incredibly important you don’t burn out or make yourself ill. Seems sensible to drop to three or four days a week. Workout what you can drop to cover your pension and a small financial cushion. You can always increase your hours when things are easier.

This is exactly what's happening, we're literally just getting by the now, but I see it getting worst my son starts school, my mum will slowly get worse, and my issue is i dont have enough time to do everything, which is affecting my mental health, so a day or two off would create that time. My bills etc are budgeted to my wage so I would need wrk out what I could afford. However my main reason for post was to seek advise from those who also done this, and was it worth it

OP posts:
giggbig · 24/04/2022 07:46

A very good point from one of the articles you linked @SwanBuster

"We assume that the wealthy will stop working if taxed at 50 per cent, so why do we expect others to work for much less?"

giggbig · 24/04/2022 07:43

@Brieandcamembert do you have a problem with pension credit?

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:42

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:39

Oh I've never heard of that but will definitely read through it.

The government don't tell u what u are entitled to and make it hard for those that require it. I get by just now going at 100 mile an hour but it's not sustainable and I know it will get worst so it interesting to see there are practical options for us

The very best of luck 👍 do plenty of research,, knock up some spreadsheets and you’ll find a way 😁

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:42

Brieandcamembert · 24/04/2022 07:38

much....lots of people work PT when their kids are small .....can't see what the issue is 🤷‍♀️

There is no issue if between you and your husband you can independently afford for you to work time. A fit healthy working age adult that chooses not to work then expects the state to fund it is dreadful.

Sorry I'm confused who this reply is aimed towards because it certainly isn't me. Take your time to read the comments, understand the situation and then post your snide comment but without the husband or healthy part

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:40

Brieandcamembert · 24/04/2022 07:38

much....lots of people work PT when their kids are small .....can't see what the issue is 🤷‍♀️

There is no issue if between you and your husband you can independently afford for you to work time. A fit healthy working age adult that chooses not to work then expects the state to fund it is dreadful.

Ridiculous effective marginal tax rates were not her creation.

If the system is set up in this way, you cannot blame people one bit for having a lightbulb moment when they discover how it all really works.

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:39

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:30

Because I’m going to get beaten up on here for posting, here are two articles explaining what I said, one directly from the Gov.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/reducing-the-universal-credit-taper-rate-and-the-effect-on-incomes/

policyinpractice.co.uk/93-tax-effective-tax-rates-explained/

Oh I've never heard of that but will definitely read through it.

The government don't tell u what u are entitled to and make it hard for those that require it. I get by just now going at 100 mile an hour but it's not sustainable and I know it will get worst so it interesting to see there are practical options for us

OP posts:
Brieandcamembert · 24/04/2022 07:38

much....lots of people work PT when their kids are small .....can't see what the issue is 🤷‍♀️

There is no issue if between you and your husband you can independently afford for you to work time. A fit healthy working age adult that chooses not to work then expects the state to fund it is dreadful.

HairyMuttttt · 24/04/2022 07:38

You clearly have no work life balance at the moment sandwiched between caring for younger and older generation plus full time job. With everything solely on your shoulders it’s incredibly important you don’t burn out or make yourself ill. Seems sensible to drop to three or four days a week. Workout what you can drop to cover your pension and a small financial cushion. You can always increase your hours when things are easier.

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:35

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:31

Exactly, our discussion was around how she done less days, more time with her daughter and the gov added money in a number of ways to help her, where I work full time, get crazy amount deductions, and absolutely no help in other areas.

I will have to take finances into account but it was mainly if people found the change positive or negative etc

I work part time, but have an extraordinarily high income, so I can’t avoid paying huge amounts of tax. But yeah - it’s well worth it! You can’t buy time 👍

I’d never go back to full time work at my primary career - and it hasn’t hurt me one iota. Plenty of massive pay rises and promotions and even a job switch since I did. But it’s a career - if I was doing a job with no prospect of massive income rises, you better believe I’d be doing exactly what you proposed 👍👍👍

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:31

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:23

That should have said - entitlement to benefits can go quite high into the income spectrum - it’s quite possible to still be entitled to Tax Credits at 60k (let’s say 4 kids, one disabled with severe) - so that marginal rate can go as higher than 100% if you’re earning in the 50-60k bracket.

40% inc tax
3% NI
41p tax credits taper
33p child benefit taper.

You can be worse off earning 60k than 50k in this bracket!! In that case, of course it makes sense to drop working a day, or sheltering the income in a pension. UC is not much different.

Exactly, our discussion was around how she done less days, more time with her daughter and the gov added money in a number of ways to help her, where I work full time, get crazy amount deductions, and absolutely no help in other areas.

I will have to take finances into account but it was mainly if people found the change positive or negative etc

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:30

Because I’m going to get beaten up on here for posting, here are two articles explaining what I said, one directly from the Gov.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/reducing-the-universal-credit-taper-rate-and-the-effect-on-incomes/

policyinpractice.co.uk/93-tax-effective-tax-rates-explained/

Theresamagicalplace · 24/04/2022 07:27

Billandben444 · 24/04/2022 07:06

Agreed but choosing to drop a day at work is totally different to being unable to find enough paid work. The OP earns enough to live on apparently so why should she be supported financially to have a day off to do the cleaning?

Did you totally miss the mental health part of my comment? Which the op then confirmed to be the case? Ah yes of course you did because then you can't criticise her or others who chose to do the same 🙄.

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:25

Floofyfoofy · 24/04/2022 07:17

You want to claim benefits so you can have a cleaner house?

How about you leave the benefits claiming to those who need it to put a roof over their heads?

It’s ridiculous that this is even an option. Or should always pay to work.

Fact is - it doesn’t always pay to work. Because of the taper rate on benefits, lower in the income spectrum if you add the ‘costs of going to work’ etc into the mix, you can end up with minuscule amounts extra or even - as I posted above - be worse off because of the effective marginal rate.

Each individual has to make their own rational decisions.

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:23

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:17

Despite the outcry on here, Your friend is absolutely right about there being little difference. especially under the old tax credits system. Same basically applies for UC but with a couple of caveats.

What people on low wages (this means under 40k ish typically - but entitlement can with kids and who rent don’t realise is that they have a very high effective marginal tax rate. Meaning for every extra £ they earn, they are paying income tax, NI and crucially money they are entitled to in benefits is being tapered.

Under Tax credits this meant a 73% marginal rate typically, and it’s similar under UC.

Tax credits was particularly astonishing, because you were also not means tested on savings. You could have millions and provided you weren’t earning cash interest on it (I.e. it was fully invested in stock market or similar), you were entitled. UC starts tapering at 6k savings and disappears at 16k - so if you have that, it changes the equation somewhat.

Quite frankly - if you are in a job, not a career with no prospect of high earning potential then yes - it’s probably not a bad idea. People can gasp, but it’s a fairly rational decision to maximise time spent with family etc if you can cut your cloth accordingly to the smaller than you might think drop in income.

Alternatively, you could work full time and whack a shed load in your pension. That will have the same affect on increasing the likelihood of your entitlement to benefits.

None of this is financial advice and you should do your own research.

Thank you for being so informated, I'm going to work out exact finances first.

She is factoring all the additional grants and payments from gov for low income families, this may help add up a little

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:23

That should have said - entitlement to benefits can go quite high into the income spectrum - it’s quite possible to still be entitled to Tax Credits at 60k (let’s say 4 kids, one disabled with severe) - so that marginal rate can go as higher than 100% if you’re earning in the 50-60k bracket.

40% inc tax
3% NI
41p tax credits taper
33p child benefit taper.

You can be worse off earning 60k than 50k in this bracket!! In that case, of course it makes sense to drop working a day, or sheltering the income in a pension. UC is not much different.

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:19

Floofyfoofy · 24/04/2022 07:17

You want to claim benefits so you can have a cleaner house?

How about you leave the benefits claiming to those who need it to put a roof over their heads?

It’s ridiculous that this is even an option. Or should always pay to work.

Have u actually read all the replies?

OP posts:
Floofyfoofy · 24/04/2022 07:17

You want to claim benefits so you can have a cleaner house?

How about you leave the benefits claiming to those who need it to put a roof over their heads?

It’s ridiculous that this is even an option. Or should always pay to work.

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:17

Despite the outcry on here, Your friend is absolutely right about there being little difference. especially under the old tax credits system. Same basically applies for UC but with a couple of caveats.

What people on low wages (this means under 40k ish typically - but entitlement can with kids and who rent don’t realise is that they have a very high effective marginal tax rate. Meaning for every extra £ they earn, they are paying income tax, NI and crucially money they are entitled to in benefits is being tapered.

Under Tax credits this meant a 73% marginal rate typically, and it’s similar under UC.

Tax credits was particularly astonishing, because you were also not means tested on savings. You could have millions and provided you weren’t earning cash interest on it (I.e. it was fully invested in stock market or similar), you were entitled. UC starts tapering at 6k savings and disappears at 16k - so if you have that, it changes the equation somewhat.

Quite frankly - if you are in a job, not a career with no prospect of high earning potential then yes - it’s probably not a bad idea. People can gasp, but it’s a fairly rational decision to maximise time spent with family etc if you can cut your cloth accordingly to the smaller than you might think drop in income.

Alternatively, you could work full time and whack a shed load in your pension. That will have the same affect on increasing the likelihood of your entitlement to benefits.

None of this is financial advice and you should do your own research.