Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Full time or part time and benefits?

241 replies

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 05:27

I'm currently a working full time single mum, thinking about positively of changing to part time.

I love my work, decent salary, good hours = no paid child care needed, lots of paper work done at home when DS in bed. Being committed 5 days is really taking its toll on priorities, my son and work are always sorted, which leaves me running around with every spare minute trying to clean. Having the extra days at home would creat a perfect balance, but knowing the drop in wages it was only ever a dream.

However my friend recently explained how she's retuning part time after maternity leave, as she will be entitled to x, y, z and when added together is nearly a full time wage.

If I made the change it would permanent, and to move back I would need to reapply.

Any advice? Experience?

OP posts:
gogohm · 24/04/2022 08:32

The problem is that you are only thinking about today - your pension contributions will be down and your prospects of promotion are diminished. But I doubt you will get as much anyway, uc (tax credits are being phased out and no new claimants get them) is harder to get and more complicated. If your child is over 11 you are expected to be working full time and if you are not your job coach will be expecting you to be job seeking to increase your hours - I'm assuming your child is younger than 11 but you could hard it difficult to return to full time once you drop hours.

My advice is to get a fortnightly cleaner

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 08:30

Furbaby65 · 24/04/2022 08:23

Im a single parent, work 25 hours over 3 days, bring in 1000 and get 700 in uc.i don't have a mortgage or rent so we mange ok on that. I will go full time when the dds are older but for now it works really well for us.

I would only need to work 2/2.5 days to cover £1000 a month, so I would be better dropping more days and claim benefits and additional gov help, than only 1 or two days for same money and entitled to help.. Definetly food for thought x

OP posts:
riotlady · 24/04/2022 08:29

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 08:17

I know my salary is higher so I'm expected to pay for a lot myself which I expect but I don't understand as single mum my son isn't even entitled to attend additional clubs run locally, as these are only for low income families. I just don't get why im running ragged getting no help, where as I reduce my hours, relieve stress levels, and then help is given..

I would do it. What’s the point in running yourself ragged just to save the government a few quid on a system they designed!

Barkingmadhouse · 24/04/2022 08:27

I coud be completely wrong but i thought you were expected to look for full tome employment once children reach school age? If i am right would that not stop you being entitled to claim anything long term?

Moochio · 24/04/2022 08:25

Do you think you could manage on the money for a couple of years then go back to full time easily? If so I'd do it.

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 08:24

Oldtiredfedup · 24/04/2022 08:02

I was a single parent - older child autistic, toddler, home educating, little to no outside support. Domestically abusive ex. Abusive and exhausting benefits and social care system.

I’d have given anything for the security of a decent full time job and being able to outsource the domestic futures to free up my time - couldn’t even get a carers assessment for a tiny bit of respite.
i am certainly NOT living in a glass house.

This is the part of the system that really annoys me, where you have to fight for what your entitled too.. I've been on that side, my mum is disabled (her medical conditions that impact her life is endless) these have progressly got worst as she grew up but the system reduce her money even though she was less mobile than the last visit..
My issue is I can't outsource my time,
I've always worked, that's why this would be such a big decision to make, and like u I'm unsure if I would regret it from a career point of view

OP posts:
Furbaby65 · 24/04/2022 08:23

Im a single parent, work 25 hours over 3 days, bring in 1000 and get 700 in uc.i don't have a mortgage or rent so we mange ok on that. I will go full time when the dds are older but for now it works really well for us.

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 08:17

DingleyDel · 24/04/2022 08:06

I would do it. Under the old system you would be getting working tax credits or child tax credits. Lots are still on these legacy benefits. It’s disgraceful really that they’ve lumped everything in together so they can treat everyone like scroungers for something you are entitled too. I’ve just seen your dc isn’t even school age. Even on UC you are only expected to work full time when you child is in school. Even they know working FT with young kids is impossible unless you earn enough to outsource everything.

I know my salary is higher so I'm expected to pay for a lot myself which I expect but I don't understand as single mum my son isn't even entitled to attend additional clubs run locally, as these are only for low income families. I just don't get why im running ragged getting no help, where as I reduce my hours, relieve stress levels, and then help is given..

OP posts:
kitcat15 · 24/04/2022 08:16

Brieandcamembert · 24/04/2022 07:38

much....lots of people work PT when their kids are small .....can't see what the issue is 🤷‍♀️

There is no issue if between you and your husband you can independently afford for you to work time. A fit healthy working age adult that chooses not to work then expects the state to fund it is dreadful.

Well there’s lots of ‘dreadful’ people out there then 🙄….. I personally don’t judge anyone if they want to work part time when their kids are young…..and if they can claim a few quid along the way then they must be entitled to it …..blame the government

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 08:13

ItWasTheBestOfTimes · 24/04/2022 08:04

Although I completely understand the maths and rationale behind it, I think encouraging single mums to work part time for low pay plus benefits top ups is terrible advice. Lots of women I know who are now in their 50's did this and became almost destitute when they lost entitlement to some elements when their children left full time education.

This is an excellent point. You need to have a transitional plan of action. But whilst you’re young and your kids are young, if you don’t have a career, I’d say the balance is worth it. Once they hit teenage years, it’s worth planning a way out

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 08:12

chipsnmayo · 24/04/2022 07:56

Honestly, some people have no fucking idea OP.

I am a fit and healthy person but I went down to PT for a year when my DD was at primary school, she had just been diagnosed with epilepsy. I had spent 20yrs paying tax on a FT income and I thought fuck it I am going to prioritise mine and my DC health. Do I have any regrets? No. I have been back at FT work for over a decade.

Being a single parent is hard work, especially when you have a kid with extra needs. I was emotionally and physically exhausted, and I am no use in that state if my DD is having a seizure. I had no external help as my ex died.

It was never a long term solution because I was earning less, however for that period in my life it was necessary.

This is my thoughts, something needs to go, if finances cover my bills that's fine and additional top ups and help be a bonus.
I know my circumstances will improve leading me wanting to work full time again, but to get my FT permanent position back one needs to be Available so not as easy as decided myself. Although the benefits just now might oitway that problem down the line, w

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 08:06

giggbig · 24/04/2022 07:59

Ok - what would you say if the OP continued to work full time, and whacked every penny above minimum wage into their pension?

Or what about people who earn over 100k but whack loads into their pension to get the 30 free hours & tax free childcare?

indeed! Hello! I whack the max into my pension, and salary sacrifice for a 10k bike, just to get as low as I can because I’m paying 63% effective tax as I’m in the band where my personal allowance is getting tapered.

I didn’t make the rules and nor did the OP. So I support anyone doing similar 👍

we also didn’t create policies that have disenfranchised the youth of this country re housing, and weren’t responsible for shit shows like help to buy paid by tax payers. The less I fund that sort of crap, the more I’ll have to donate to proper good causes via gift aid.

DingleyDel · 24/04/2022 08:06

I would do it. Under the old system you would be getting working tax credits or child tax credits. Lots are still on these legacy benefits. It’s disgraceful really that they’ve lumped everything in together so they can treat everyone like scroungers for something you are entitled too. I’ve just seen your dc isn’t even school age. Even on UC you are only expected to work full time when you child is in school. Even they know working FT with young kids is impossible unless you earn enough to outsource everything.

WilmaFlintstone1 · 24/04/2022 08:06

giggbig · 24/04/2022 06:57

Thats why keeping your hand in the career path is useful, you’re keeping up to date and you’re still earning with the opportunity of progressing.

the OP wants to drop 1 day a week not give up work completely

Please re-read my posts, absolutely no judgement from me . The OP needs to do what best suits her family. I was just giving my experience of having to do that.

ItWasTheBestOfTimes · 24/04/2022 08:04

Although I completely understand the maths and rationale behind it, I think encouraging single mums to work part time for low pay plus benefits top ups is terrible advice. Lots of women I know who are now in their 50's did this and became almost destitute when they lost entitlement to some elements when their children left full time education.

Oldtiredfedup · 24/04/2022 08:02

I was a single parent - older child autistic, toddler, home educating, little to no outside support. Domestically abusive ex. Abusive and exhausting benefits and social care system.

I’d have given anything for the security of a decent full time job and being able to outsource the domestic futures to free up my time - couldn’t even get a carers assessment for a tiny bit of respite.
i am certainly NOT living in a glass house.

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 08:02

Booboobagins · 24/04/2022 07:48

Most people who were furlough didn't notice the difference between 80% and 100% wages, but then we were in lockdown for periods during this time (I wasn't furlough btw I worked throughout, didn't even take my holidays!) Anyways, getting one extra day a week can be fairly easy - could you work an extra hour a day? If so you'd just lose 0.5day pay per week but still only work 4 days a week. It seriously can be the diff between being pulled apart and enjoying your life. Losing 0.5 day pay really won't make a big difference to your income and your employer probably won't bat an eyelid! Talk to them.

Ref benefits question as a tax payer paying almost as much in tax as I earn the whole benefits system needs a overhaul. My main issue is life style benefit takers, like your friend - they're the ones tipping the country into shortfall. Why should I - a single parent - fund other people to work part time so they can claim benefits? Work what you can and if you need a top up fine, but don't stack it so you know you'll get a top up.

We all need to be adults in the society for society to work, after all if people like me who work remotely want to, we can all foff to the Bahamas and take our tax with us but where would that leave the UK.

I worked aswell through it all. Furlough was a joke, they took average of wage during a set time. This did benefit my dad as they to his busiest month and received double his Normal wage but the select few that continued to work, received standard 35 hour week.. how's that fair? They make up own rules and don't actually check it makes sense.

I don't understand how she's doing anything.. she's on maternity leave, and was always returning to work part time, as she will struggle to arrange child care for a full working week, it just so happens by doing this she will be entitled to help.

I've been on both sides of the system, disabled mother and two children living off about £100 every fortnight because, where as now I'm deducted greatly by tax and NI and not one bit of help. So if using the system helps my situation too right I'm going to do it

OP posts:
giggbig · 24/04/2022 07:59

Ok - what would you say if the OP continued to work full time, and whacked every penny above minimum wage into their pension?

Or what about people who earn over 100k but whack loads into their pension to get the 30 free hours & tax free childcare?

giggbig · 24/04/2022 07:57

@Brieandcamembert there will be loads of women who get pension credit because the either chose to stay home with the kids or had little choice. But benefits aren't really assessed on that basis are they?

We are not entitled to any benefits not even child benefit & I work p/t. If my marriage broke down I would claim benefits if entitled without increasing my hours. Why shouldn't I? I've paid enough bloody tax over the years.

chipsnmayo · 24/04/2022 07:56

Honestly, some people have no fucking idea OP.

I am a fit and healthy person but I went down to PT for a year when my DD was at primary school, she had just been diagnosed with epilepsy. I had spent 20yrs paying tax on a FT income and I thought fuck it I am going to prioritise mine and my DC health. Do I have any regrets? No. I have been back at FT work for over a decade.

Being a single parent is hard work, especially when you have a kid with extra needs. I was emotionally and physically exhausted, and I am no use in that state if my DD is having a seizure. I had no external help as my ex died.

It was never a long term solution because I was earning less, however for that period in my life it was necessary.

EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter · 24/04/2022 07:55

Single mum here. Sounds to me like those in their glass houses (avec un homme) have absolutely zero idea about the endless crushing grind being the sole responsible for EVERYTHING.

Interestingly enough, I’ve just run my figures through entitled to as I startled a new ft low-paid wfh job last month. I’ll still be getting nearly as many tax credits now as I did LAST month and the job’s a doddle. I hadn’t done the figures until now expecting a big fat zero…

I have 2 SEN children, am autistic myself, burned out, fed up and don’t give a flying fuck if I need to be careful when I retire.

Time is so valuable.

SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:55

Brieandcamembert · 24/04/2022 07:52

giggbig · 24/04/2022 07:43
@Brieandcamembert do you have a problem with pension credit?

If you chose to be on benefits/ low wage/ part time and didn't save for a pension then yes I object. If you did everything in life to work hard, make sensible decisions about what you could afford, save up and pay into a pension and then life sent you a curve ball and circumstances out of your control happened then you shod have enough money to live on.

Ok - what would you say if the OP continued to work full time, and whacked every penny above minimum wage into their pension?

this would increase their entitlement to benefits in the here and now, and be very financially prudent. They would still be artificially reducing their current income, but at the same time reducing their likelihood of dependency on the state in retirement.

Im interested to know where you think the balancing point is.

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 07:53

AllOfUsAreDead · 24/04/2022 07:48

I don't think it will be positive for you to do this. It sounds like your friend from other posts was already on a low income. It's easy to top up to low income with benefits. But if you're earning well and I'd assume that's 30k+, topping up to 30k is going to be harder and I don't think you'll get it. You'd be earning less very likely even with benefits, and you'd lose out on a proper pension.

Up to you I guess, if you're stressed it might work out, but you'll be likely working for more of your life than you anticipated, past retirement basically.

Yes I make more than 30k but also get a great chunk of that deducted. Moneys not everything when you literally have no time to enjoy it, something need to change so im trying to find best option

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 24/04/2022 07:53

*benefit entitlement, not entertainment 😂

Brieandcamembert · 24/04/2022 07:52

giggbig · 24/04/2022 07:43
@Brieandcamembert do you have a problem with pension credit?

If you chose to be on benefits/ low wage/ part time and didn't save for a pension then yes I object. If you did everything in life to work hard, make sensible decisions about what you could afford, save up and pay into a pension and then life sent you a curve ball and circumstances out of your control happened then you shod have enough money to live on.