Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Full time or part time and benefits?

241 replies

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 05:27

I'm currently a working full time single mum, thinking about positively of changing to part time.

I love my work, decent salary, good hours = no paid child care needed, lots of paper work done at home when DS in bed. Being committed 5 days is really taking its toll on priorities, my son and work are always sorted, which leaves me running around with every spare minute trying to clean. Having the extra days at home would creat a perfect balance, but knowing the drop in wages it was only ever a dream.

However my friend recently explained how she's retuning part time after maternity leave, as she will be entitled to x, y, z and when added together is nearly a full time wage.

If I made the change it would permanent, and to move back I would need to reapply.

Any advice? Experience?

OP posts:
LegMeChicken · 24/04/2022 09:57

Also OP IME you experience depends on how ‘part-time’ you go and the office environment.
Theres no reason to expect your ‘PT’ hours to be respected if you’re working unpaid hours full-time. You may not have to reply to emails, or join meetings. But you still have to complete your ‘work’ no matter how many hours it takes you.
Working at least 3 days, I find is a challenge as companies don’t bother to organise cover for the remaining 2 days.

My current company has many part-timers but it takes a lot of management will and ability, coordination and suitable work. Some jobs (like sales) where face time etc is important really doesn’t suit it.

Lipsandlashes · 24/04/2022 09:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Justkeeppedaling · 24/04/2022 09:53

JustATomCat · 24/04/2022 06:10

I don't understand, you're perfectly capable of working full time without paying for childcare, yet you'd rather work part time so you can claim benefits? Why would you take from the system like that when you aren't in desperate need?

This.

Why should I have to pay for you to be a part time SAHM when I am working full time myself to support my own children?

How do you think it would work if we all took the attitude of dropping some hours/days and expecting the state (by which I mean working people) to pick up people's financial
slack?

millymollymoomoo · 24/04/2022 09:52

And this is exactly why the benefits system in this country is a joke and needs a complete overhaul

Clymene · 24/04/2022 09:50

Is that how benefits work? Can you decide to work part time and apply for benefits to make up the difference?

LegMeChicken · 24/04/2022 09:49

@sst1234 it’s really not that simple.

With spiralling costs and stagnant wages a lot of people are actually paying to work. Some can afford to ‘take the hit’ for a few years, but many can’t’!

The OP’s opening post is disingenuous and certainly got people’s backs up (no time to clean?!?!?) but there’s apparently more to the story as stated in her later posts. All of the caring that she’ll be doing for an elderly parent is something that the government would otherwise have to pay for, no? Especially as said parent deteriorates.

I suppose though that someone in the OP’s position, with no need for paid childcare could be taking advantage by going part-time + benefits if the elderly parent issue wasn’t there.

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 09:48

dustandroses · 24/04/2022 09:37

Taking the emotion out of the question.
Benefits wise you would be better off speaking to an experienced benefit adviser about the bigger picture including your DM's circumstances. It also depends on your earnings now and part time and whether you rent or have a mortgage whether UC would be beneficial. Complete the online calculators and they can give you an idea but not the detail.

How much of the help that you need can you buy in whilst working full time, what would free you up? On paper it sounds great when you can wfh or partially from home but it can be hard to get that work life balance when there is less structure. It often results in trying to fit more in and actually being less productive.

How easy would it be to reapply for full time at a later date? I took a career break when my DC's were small, I traded those years at home for working longer now for my occupational pension and I have no regrets it was absolutely the right decision. As for your state pension currently working part time would not change your entitlement, barring other changes that we are all subject to.

Does reducing your hours actually reduce your workload? I would have to change jobs to go part time or I would just struggle doing a similar amount of work in less time. Would you actually benefit from and enjoy those extra hours or would they simply be sucked up by other demands (some as yet unseen).

Do you find it difficult to say no? It is not possible to be or do everything, work full time, raise a child, run a home, care for family. Add socialising into the equation and we are fucked 🤔

Your questions are exactly what goes round in my head, budgeting etc is on first priority.
The lack of structure on those days is biggest fear, during pandemic working from home was torture, I couldn't wait to back In the building. However I would be In part the week so hopefuy wouldn't feel the same as before.
Careers breaks only work for us if completely off, they used to do flexible working for things like this, but now u can reduce contractual hours anytime but can only increase if there is availability. Don't get me wrong that is possible just not gaurenteed. Yes I would be expected to do work for the dayd I work.

OP posts:
DingleyDel · 24/04/2022 09:44

This is why the public has become hardened towards the welfare culture and why welfare has been cut back in the last 12 years. A vast number of people use it a lifestyle choice. No getting away from that.

What a load of tosh. A vast number of parents can’t sustain full time work and childcare costs (or even part time) and a vast number of people need their wages topped up because wages in this country are so low. The taxpayer is subsidising big business, not individuals. Living on nothing but UC is not pretty!

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 09:38

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

There's a post early on that highlights a little more of my situation. Long story short working a full week, single mum, and a DisAbled it's becoming near impossible if I want any quality time with my family. So baring in mind my sons in nursery I would be entitled to help if I worked part time, however I've worked full for last 9 trash and unsure if I could commit to the change

OP posts:
dustandroses · 24/04/2022 09:37

Taking the emotion out of the question.
Benefits wise you would be better off speaking to an experienced benefit adviser about the bigger picture including your DM's circumstances. It also depends on your earnings now and part time and whether you rent or have a mortgage whether UC would be beneficial. Complete the online calculators and they can give you an idea but not the detail.

How much of the help that you need can you buy in whilst working full time, what would free you up? On paper it sounds great when you can wfh or partially from home but it can be hard to get that work life balance when there is less structure. It often results in trying to fit more in and actually being less productive.

How easy would it be to reapply for full time at a later date? I took a career break when my DC's were small, I traded those years at home for working longer now for my occupational pension and I have no regrets it was absolutely the right decision. As for your state pension currently working part time would not change your entitlement, barring other changes that we are all subject to.

Does reducing your hours actually reduce your workload? I would have to change jobs to go part time or I would just struggle doing a similar amount of work in less time. Would you actually benefit from and enjoy those extra hours or would they simply be sucked up by other demands (some as yet unseen).

Do you find it difficult to say no? It is not possible to be or do everything, work full time, raise a child, run a home, care for family. Add socialising into the equation and we are fucked 🤔

HandlebarLadyTash · 24/04/2022 09:36

Your pension will be massively effected, something you will regret when you hit 45/50.

Oldtiredfedup · 24/04/2022 09:35

sst1234 · 24/04/2022 09:33

OP, you have been honest in asking a question that is playing on your mind. So this is not aimed at you. But this question shows everything that is wrong with the benefits system. You friend, presumably an able bodied adult, is having the tax payer fund her lifestyle choices while she chooses to do the bare minimum to support herself and this has inspired you to do the same.

This is why the public has become hardened towards the welfare culture and why welfare has been cut back in the last 12 years. A vast number of people use it a lifestyle choice. No getting away from that.

A vast number?

Could you show me where you’re getting your information from?

sst1234 · 24/04/2022 09:33

OP, you have been honest in asking a question that is playing on your mind. So this is not aimed at you. But this question shows everything that is wrong with the benefits system. You friend, presumably an able bodied adult, is having the tax payer fund her lifestyle choices while she chooses to do the bare minimum to support herself and this has inspired you to do the same.

This is why the public has become hardened towards the welfare culture and why welfare has been cut back in the last 12 years. A vast number of people use it a lifestyle choice. No getting away from that.

AnotherEmma · 24/04/2022 09:29

"UC they simply reduce your award for each and every pound you earn"
is that not what you meant?

DingleyDel · 24/04/2022 09:29

AnotherEmma · 24/04/2022 09:13

This comment is very telling:
"It's disgraceful really that they've lumped everything in together so they can treat everyone like scroungers"
You are clearly not alone in thinking that some benefit claimants are "scroungers" and others are not; it's the same age-old trope of the "deserving" v "undeserving" poor.

Also, with a school age child under 13 you are expecting to earn the equivalent of 25h/w at NMW. It only increases to 35h/w once they turn 13. Also, specific circumstances such as SEND and caring responsibilities should be considered.

Sorry to clarify that’s not what I think at all. I don’t believe the vast majority of people claiming benefits are scroungers, that’s what the government thinks! They’ve always made jobseekers go for employment interviews, fair enough as they are jobseekers. Under UC everyone is now treated as though they are ‘under employed’ (I know as I’ve recently come off it as I wasn’t hitting the magical 16 hours per week, so now I do and extra 10 hours work per week and I’m about £100 per month better off!) Even if you have main caring responsibilities. In the past parents and single parents would have been eligible for a bit of CTC/WTC without having to go to ridiculous weekly meetings, when it’s clear the vast majority of jobs will not pay because of childcare costs.

liveforsummer · 24/04/2022 09:29

And yes I k ie people on uc are better off working then not working but that's irrelevant to what's being discussed here.

liveforsummer · 24/04/2022 09:28

@AnotherEmma where did I say pound for pound? I said award is reduced, which it is. I didn't give the figure as I know it's changed and can't remember if the tip of my head. I know plenty people who are still being nagged to work although they earn over the threshold. Their benefits are not dependent on them doing so but they still have to listen to it. I've done a calculation thanks. Worked out about £13 per month better off - not worth it for me right now as I'd have to take an advance so would be a while before I saw that small benefit.

Ireolu · 24/04/2022 09:23

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

AnotherEmma · 24/04/2022 09:19

liveforsummer · 24/04/2022 08:58

Assume you're on the old tax credits system. The same is not the case for UC and they will harass you to apply for full time work even if you meet the minimum income threshold. You certainly don't get full benefits either. I work just a little more than you on tax credits and still have to pay £400 of my rent, get no council tax benefit and do not qualify for free school meals therefor all the extra benefits that award brings. UC they simply reduce your award for each and every pound you earn so far from full benefits under that system either. I work 5 days a week term time and supplement with a second job at weekends and during holidays as simply cannot survive on the part time wage alone. In a job that's so flexible that you enjoy I think you'd be crazy to change that. We'd all love a day off in the house to clean but for the majority it's not an option.

You are woefully misinformed about Universal Credit. Firstly people are not pressured to increase their working hours if they are earning the expected amount for their circumstances. Secondly earnings are not deducted pound-for-pound (where did you get that idea?!). UC claimants keep a significant amount of their earnings before their UC is deducted. The whole system is designed to ensure people are better off in work, and it's more generous to working people than the old tax credits system. If you are are on tax credits, I strongly advise you to do a benefit calculation to see if you would be better off on UC. You can do it yourself using entitledto or Turn2Us, or contact Citizens Advice and ask them.

FYI and anyone else who's interested, you can see how UC is calculated (including how much they deduct for earnings) at www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/universal-credit/on-universal-credit/check-how-much-universal-credit-youll-get/

DancingintheDark17 · 24/04/2022 09:17

Billandben444 · 24/04/2022 09:04

I would only need to work 2/2.5 days to cover £1000 a month, so I would be better dropping more days and claim benefits and additional gov help, than only 1 or two days for same money and entitled to help.

You've talked yourself into it. Despite me disagreeing with the ethos of 'taking money from the government just because I'm entitled', I hope it works out well for you and I'm sure your mum will appreciate seeing more of you.

I never ever thought it would be possible so I'm pleasantly surprised by my findings, and is definitely something I need to look further into for accurate information. But if I was able to get the visit and actually have quality time together rather than me I running around checking things or exhausted and falling asleep on her couch x

OP posts:
Stuffin · 24/04/2022 09:16

Your comment about why prioritise pension when you may not live that long. Most people do live long enough to be an issue especially if they decided to be part time over contributions and it makes much more difference contributing in the early years. For some it might mean not being able to survive until state pension age when they really can't work any more but can't manage on benefits etc. if your comfortable with that and accept if that happens it was your choice then I wouldn't judge.

But also I wouldn't rely on a certain level of benefits staying the same with inflation as I personally think we are going to be hit for a very hard time for many years economically which means less money going into the state.

Tumbleweed101 · 24/04/2022 09:14

I'm contemplating a career change which would reduce my contracted hours. On paper it makes sense to stay where I am but I'm a single parent, both of my parents have significant health issues that need care (cancer and COPD) with lots of medical appointments to help with. I feel like between work, home, children and parents I'm running on empty.

It is very tough when a lot of responsibility falls on you and you have nobody to share the strain with. Time is as valuable as money at certain points in our lives and it's worth looking at how you can support your own health and Well being.

AnotherEmma · 24/04/2022 09:13

*expected

liveforsummer · 24/04/2022 09:13

Do you rent or have a mortgage? Not sure I go you've said already and I've missed it.

AnotherEmma · 24/04/2022 09:13

DingleyDel · 24/04/2022 08:06

I would do it. Under the old system you would be getting working tax credits or child tax credits. Lots are still on these legacy benefits. It’s disgraceful really that they’ve lumped everything in together so they can treat everyone like scroungers for something you are entitled too. I’ve just seen your dc isn’t even school age. Even on UC you are only expected to work full time when you child is in school. Even they know working FT with young kids is impossible unless you earn enough to outsource everything.

This comment is very telling:
"It's disgraceful really that they've lumped everything in together so they can treat everyone like scroungers"
You are clearly not alone in thinking that some benefit claimants are "scroungers" and others are not; it's the same age-old trope of the "deserving" v "undeserving" poor.

Also, with a school age child under 13 you are expecting to earn the equivalent of 25h/w at NMW. It only increases to 35h/w once they turn 13. Also, specific circumstances such as SEND and caring responsibilities should be considered.