Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL expects DD18 to serve everyone

342 replies

Safarigiraffe · 24/04/2022 00:48

MIL is generally lovely woman however she expects DD18 to set table, serve everyone etc when we go round there before sitting down herself. Now DD18 can’t seem to relax or enjoy herself there as all work seems to fall onto her & now has reached a point where DD is refusing to go round at all. AIBU to think that it’s not fair to expect DD18 to do the setting up, serving of adults before being seated herself, clear away table when they are other older cousins in their late 20s there that can do this Not sure how to address this issue or whether to say something to DH (would more than likely cause a row) or whether to say something subtle to MIL (who would no doubt get very upset) Just to add DD does do little things to help out but MIL expects her to do everything without having a break

OP posts:
DaisyQuakeJohnson · 24/04/2022 12:27

@TalkingCat nope OP still doesn't say that the males don't do anything. You've surmised that. You're also the only person making the leap to compare laying a table with slavery. Frankly, it's insulting hyperbole. And you don't seem to care about MIL doing all the cooking and hosting. It's almost as though it's not about potential sexism for you either. It's just about drama.

ArtVandalay · 24/04/2022 12:24

That's a ridiculous setup. Sounds very misogynistic as well as horribly archaic.

I'd be telling my daughter not to visit as she is being taken advantage of. I'd certainly be steering her away from this custom that she's doing it because she's female (as well as being the youngest). At our family meals, everyone does their bit and pitches in to help. There's absolutely no 'women's work'.

toomuchlaundry · 24/04/2022 12:22

@StoppinBy the OP says that if her DD isn’t there the adult women help. She also says her DH doesn’t stand up for her DD. And MIL does all the cooking. Not seeing anything that shows men doing anything

SmudgeButt · 24/04/2022 12:21

Smile and say "No! DD do sit down!! You did all the work last time. It's <cousin's name> turn to help this time and <another cousin's name> can do it next time!! I'm sure they will agree that's fair."

TalkingCat · 24/04/2022 12:07

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 24/04/2022 11:58

Also, there's a massive difference between being a slave and setting and clearing a table occasionally. Don't read any threads on here about chores, you'll combust! Teens and DCs do laundry, make meals, look after pets, tidy rooms, take bins out, as well as setting and clearing tables.
By your reckoning, the MIL is even more enslaved because she does all the cooking whilst OP and her DH do nothing but eat what she provides and complain that their DD is asked to help.

@DaisyQuakeJohnson You're being disingenuous, you knew what I (and almost everyone else) was saying. When you only one (1) person to do all the serving, all the setting, all the clearing then yes, you are using them as a slave.

TalkingCat · 24/04/2022 12:06

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 24/04/2022 11:54

Perhaps you should reread all OP's posts. Nowhere does she say that the male relatives didn't set the table when they were the youngest.
Then reread my post. Nowhere did I say that only female relatives do tasks. OP's DD is the youngest. Quite often in large families, certain tasks fall to the youngest. And as the families grow, it's not the same DC who is always the youngest.
You're arguing with everyone based on an idea you've created in your head about what is happening. But it's not what OP said was happening. OP said her DD did it because she was the youngest not because she was female.

@DaisyQuakeJohnson I have. Perhaps you haven't, as the OP makes it clear it is a female thing.

From what I’ve seen when I am there and DD isn’t it’s the Adult women

and

Cousins are Female and Male
DD is the youngest Female out of 3

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 24/04/2022 11:58

Also, there's a massive difference between being a slave and setting and clearing a table occasionally. Don't read any threads on here about chores, you'll combust! Teens and DCs do laundry, make meals, look after pets, tidy rooms, take bins out, as well as setting and clearing tables.
By your reckoning, the MIL is even more enslaved because she does all the cooking whilst OP and her DH do nothing but eat what she provides and complain that their DD is asked to help.

tulips27 · 24/04/2022 11:55

Let me guess, MIL is from an Iranian background?

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 24/04/2022 11:54

TalkingCat · 24/04/2022 11:49

When it's only one constantly being the slave, it is bad.

Why don't the MEN set and clear the table? Or are your family as misogynist as the grandmother in this story?

Perhaps you should reread all OP's posts. Nowhere does she say that the male relatives didn't set the table when they were the youngest.
Then reread my post. Nowhere did I say that only female relatives do tasks. OP's DD is the youngest. Quite often in large families, certain tasks fall to the youngest. And as the families grow, it's not the same DC who is always the youngest.
You're arguing with everyone based on an idea you've created in your head about what is happening. But it's not what OP said was happening. OP said her DD did it because she was the youngest not because she was female.

Dinoteeth · 24/04/2022 11:50

TalkingCat · 24/04/2022 09:50

What sort of a pathetic excuse for a 'man' are you married to, when he allows this sexist abuse of his own daughter?

You have, as is common to say on here, a DH problem. Your DH sounds absolutely worthless and repugnant.

The same sort of man who thinks if fine to sit on his fat arse with his fat lazy wife while his elderly mother runs about after them both.

Really they should all be ashamed letting it happen.

As for the a-holes on here saying its abuse no its not abuse to expect fit healthy adults to help when Granny is sorting dinner.

NippyWoowoo · 24/04/2022 11:50

TalkingCat · 24/04/2022 11:44

@EYProvider I will try a THIRD TIME. Why doesn't this poor '85 year old grandmother' who has the mouth on her to order a child into being a servant, ASK THE MEN TO HELP SERVE?

I don't know why you assume it's a man, plenty of women hold these views

TalkingCat · 24/04/2022 11:49

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 24/04/2022 11:46

Your MIL does all the cooking and as the youngest grandchild, your DD sets and then clears the table. That doesn't sound that bad to me. Presumably before DD was born or old enough to take part, the next youngest grandchild did it.
I also don't understand why you 'say stuff' instead of getting up and helping your DD set and clear the table if that seems like too big a chore for her.
I'm from a large family. The youngest setting and clearing the table is quite common. And usually it happened at every dinner not just when we visited an older relative.

When it's only one constantly being the slave, it is bad.

Why don't the MEN set and clear the table? Or are your family as misogynist as the grandmother in this story?

househogger · 24/04/2022 11:48

There are some odd posts on here. Your daughter is not a CHILD (qoute), this isn't abuse and your MIL doesn't sound like a nasty piece of work. It is, however very unfair that only your daughter is asked to help and she doesn't get to sit down.

It sounds like there are cultural and generational factors at play with your MIL and I would politely challenge them. e.g. DD is happy to help but it isn't fair that she has to do everything, perhaps male cousin could serve up.
I would also directly ask some of the cushy bums for help yourself.

Your daughter is 18, she can stay at home if she wants to and you can tell them that it's because she is never allowed to relax and it isn't fair. Some of the replies swing too far in the other direction though. I would encourage her to be helpful but not to the point that she's taken advantage of.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 24/04/2022 11:46

Your MIL does all the cooking and as the youngest grandchild, your DD sets and then clears the table. That doesn't sound that bad to me. Presumably before DD was born or old enough to take part, the next youngest grandchild did it.
I also don't understand why you 'say stuff' instead of getting up and helping your DD set and clear the table if that seems like too big a chore for her.
I'm from a large family. The youngest setting and clearing the table is quite common. And usually it happened at every dinner not just when we visited an older relative.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 24/04/2022 11:45

EYProvider · 24/04/2022 11:32

My generation has a lot to answer for with the way we have raised our children. Something has gone very very wrong and the above is the result - a society that values the ‘rights’ of an entitled 18 year old and her pathetic mother over the well-being of her 85 year old grandmother, who has had the temerity to ask her to lay the table.

Dear God, no wonder the world is in its current state.

It sounds as if this 18 year old is far from entitled. She's chosing to use her adult free time which for all we know might be very limited to visit her elderly relative and wait on that relative and her other relatives who are just as young and capable. Nowhere does it say that she expects anything from anyone. The older generation are the entitled ones if they think they have a free ticket to treat their youngsters like crap just because they share the same DNA

bringincrazyback · 24/04/2022 11:45

Reading this has produced quite a visceral reaction in me as my MIL does exactly the same thing to my adult DSD and she's already started 'training' her younger DGD (aged 10) up as well. When they visit they're expected to be constantly helping with the cooking, table setting, clearing up etc. I can guarantee 100% that no such expectations would be made if they were male.

When she visits here she pulls this act on me too. DH does most of the cooking when we have company (he enjoys it, I don't) and MIL thinks this is awful and is always saying things like 'Now, bringincrazyback, you're going to serve the food, aren't you?', telling me recipes, all sort of 'subtle' hints like that. She's never made any secret of the fact that she thinks I'm not domesticated enough. It's such a sexist thing and it makes me angry she's pulling it on her granddaughters as well.

In your shoes I wouldn't be worrying so much about ruffling feathers - yes your MIL is old and needs help, but that doesn't mean no one should ever challenge her.

TalkingCat · 24/04/2022 11:44

@EYProvider I will try a THIRD TIME. Why doesn't this poor '85 year old grandmother' who has the mouth on her to order a child into being a servant, ASK THE MEN TO HELP SERVE?

TalkingCat · 24/04/2022 11:42

EYProvider · 24/04/2022 11:32

My generation has a lot to answer for with the way we have raised our children. Something has gone very very wrong and the above is the result - a society that values the ‘rights’ of an entitled 18 year old and her pathetic mother over the well-being of her 85 year old grandmother, who has had the temerity to ask her to lay the table.

Dear God, no wonder the world is in its current state.

@EYProvider You have to be having us on here. You think it's wrong that a woman is allowed to be assertive and not be used? What century are you in? The 1800s? Your misogyny is disgraceful and you should be utterly ashamed of yourself! I notice you're too cowardly to answer the question I put to you twice. I can only presume you are a male who hates women and think we should be your slaves. Thankfully we were raised better than you were.

EYProvider · 24/04/2022 11:32

My generation has a lot to answer for with the way we have raised our children. Something has gone very very wrong and the above is the result - a society that values the ‘rights’ of an entitled 18 year old and her pathetic mother over the well-being of her 85 year old grandmother, who has had the temerity to ask her to lay the table.

Dear God, no wonder the world is in its current state.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/04/2022 11:30

Kanaloa · 24/04/2022 01:13

Although I must say I feel a bit sorry for your daughter that her whole family have allowed this to become a pattern. Why doesn’t her dad help? Why don’t her cousins? Does her dad generally see his role as sitting relaxing and her role as serving?

Precisely!
How have either of DD's parents been unable to use their 'generational seniority' (as this family seems to be ALL about the age ranking) to bark at the 20-something aged cousins "DD is not your skivvy you lazy bugger - why aren't you pulling your weight so she can sit down with everyone else for a bloody change?"

So what if there's fallout?
I wouldn't GAF about family tradition or other people's manufactured outrage at being challenged if my DD was being denigrated like this.

She's sensibly opted out because her mum's efforts at alleviating the situation are too timid (sorry OP, I know how hard intractible family custom can be to navigate - helpful link follows) & her DF either doesn't notice, or doesn't give a shit, because in his family, young women are low-ranking servants.

www.amazon.co.uk/Woman-Your-Own-Right-Assertiveness/dp/0704334208

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 24/04/2022 11:25

She's 18. Her involvement with any family member is no longer a duty it's a choice, a choice which will likely depend on how she is treated. Tell dd honestly that you feel it's unfair that she doesn't have to go there any more if it bothers her. Encourage her to tell grandma herself why (she's big enough to fight her own battles) but try and get grandma to rectify the situation first. No drama needed. Grandma can't MAKE her be her slave and she can't make her visit either. She might need to learn that the hard way...

MumW · 24/04/2022 11:18

If DD doesn't want to go, then she doesn't go
When asked why, just say she doesn't like being treated as a skivvy.

Maybe when MIL comes to your house make her do all the work, after all, it's traditional in your family that the matriarch takes on those chores. 😉🤣

NewandNotImproved · 24/04/2022 11:16

Your husband would get angry, and the granny would get ‘upset’? So fucking what? Get upset right back. Get angry right back. You don’t say how you have stepped up and advocated for your child, you mentioned dropping hints, which is useless in every scenario.
That’s good that your daughter doesn’t want those slovenly people in her life, every adult sitting on their arses letting a very elderly woman, and a teenager serve them should be ashamed of themselves.

StoppinBy · 24/04/2022 11:14

toomuchlaundry · 24/04/2022 10:54

Why don’t the people with a penis actually do something eg cook, serve before MIL has to ask for help. The people with a penis seem quite happy to be served by those without a penis

Why all the sexist tripe? Where did OP say it was only women doing the work over the years?

All the info we currently have is that OP'S daughter is the youngest and has been asked to do all the helping out while everyone else.... both Male and Female are allowed to sit on their arse's doing nothing.

How do you get 'men should get served because they are men' from that?

My PIL have a very sexist dynamic.... FIL expects men to be waited on by women and MIL allows this, it pisses me off no end but I don't see the evidence of that here.

Nanny0gg · 24/04/2022 11:11

Safarigiraffe · 24/04/2022 09:40

DD18 lays the table, clears away and helps with tea/desserts and serves the adults before she can sit down herself Yes sounds normal however ONLY DD is the one to do this every single time

But did the other cousins(inc male ones) do this in the past?

What do all the men (inc your husband) do to help?

Is this a cultural thing? Women serve whilst men sit?

And if it's once every few months, it's not very pleasant but you made it sound initially like it was frequent.

Will it be an issue in the family if your DD doesn't go? Are there any younger children waiting for their turn?