Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL expects DD18 to serve everyone

342 replies

Safarigiraffe · 24/04/2022 00:48

MIL is generally lovely woman however she expects DD18 to set table, serve everyone etc when we go round there before sitting down herself. Now DD18 can’t seem to relax or enjoy herself there as all work seems to fall onto her & now has reached a point where DD is refusing to go round at all. AIBU to think that it’s not fair to expect DD18 to do the setting up, serving of adults before being seated herself, clear away table when they are other older cousins in their late 20s there that can do this Not sure how to address this issue or whether to say something to DH (would more than likely cause a row) or whether to say something subtle to MIL (who would no doubt get very upset) Just to add DD does do little things to help out but MIL expects her to do everything without having a break

OP posts:
sadsack78 · 25/04/2022 21:15

That sounds like a nightmare for your poor DD. No wonder she doesn't want to go round any more!
it sounds like some backwards warped idea around gender etc. This is a terrible lesson to be teaching your DD- that as a woman it will be up to her to spoon out potatoes and fill glasses for perfectly capable adults, and the work will not be shared out. She is being set up for a lifetime of misery and a husband and kids who treat her badly if this is what she comes to expect.
Sod tradition. You need to explain to your MIL that she needs to cut this bullsh*t out if she wants to see her grandchild.

A580Hojas · 25/04/2022 21:01

This endless nesting quote function is doing my head in! It's so hard to work out who actually said what.

Philisophigal · 25/04/2022 20:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

Rondvassbu · 25/04/2022 20:42

Struggling to get past the fact that a whole family (yourself included) sit around the table without helping MIL. She's 85 and has cooked a meal. The least you could do is help her with some of the jobs. Why do you sit there and let DD wait on you? And by you, I mean you personally, not the whole group. You obviously think it's too much work for her so help her.
Or simply say after the meal, DD set the table and served the food so X and Y, your turn to clear the table.... and then see what happens. Or would that cause ructions?
I don't understand your family dynamic at all because something like this would never happen in our family. Everyone would pitch in to help. No one would expect one person to do the majority of the work

alexdgr8 · 25/04/2022 20:40

i don't think it's fair to totally blame the MIL for all this.
it's probably her background, and what she had to do when she was a junior member of the family.
but what about all the others,
the middle generation and the other youngers ?
they should all pitch in automatically, without making a big thing out of it, or an announcement of changing the routine, just do it.
they sound to be content to exploit the oldest and youngest woman present.
shame on them.
get up and help mother, all of you.

riceuten · 25/04/2022 20:36

Sounds like you're treading on eggshells, and the argument needs to be had.

Chica10 · 25/04/2022 20:20

cafebean · 25/04/2022 19:26

Sorry if this has been asked already, but this MIL is 85, you say - what cultural background is she from?

I'm just asking because some people of that age are very set in their ways and you won't change them now, so no point stressing it.

My husband has relatives who come over to us and it's a culture where men don't deal with food - and heaven forbid, they have to serve themselves or not be served tea within 60 seconds flat of walking through the door. Then, when you go there, it's the usual delight of all the women in the kitchen and the men droning on in another room. But they are older people and this is how they were brought up so I just go with it. So do my girls, but it would be shocking to them if my husband or sons were to so much as take a cup into the kitchen. The horror! Even in British families, I don't think this is that unusual in that generation.

When I got married, my MIL insisted on me going over on the weekends for hours so she could show me how to cook certain things from her culture that apparently her son has to have regularly. Otherwise he would cease to exist or something like that. Had it ever entered her head to have taught any of this to her son? Er, no. But this is what happened to her when she got married so, in her mind, she was apparently welcoming me into the family or some such thing. She just thought this was the done thing.

I do like the suggestion of telling the MIL that the DD can't come anymore as she has a paid job in a cafe!

But you know just because something is cultural, a tradition, doesn’t always equate to it being something good. In this case women serving men whilst they sit around doing nothing, and the women are running around them. It’s fine if they want to, but if that is an automatic expectation it’s wrong, and those traditions need to evolve and.change.

I come from a very traditional back ground and the way most men in my family behaved in regards to expecting women to serve them hand foot, was awful to witness and even as a young girl I was resentful of having to serve and clean up after these men as they sat there talking, enjoying themselves. They were like Neanderthals, in that regard. It’s embarrassing actually.

Anewdaydawns · 25/04/2022 20:11

I don't understand why you and your husband can't present a united front on this. Is he so intimidated by his relatives that he'd rather fall out with you than speak to them? All the cousins should be pitching in to help set things up and clear up afterwards, not just your daughter. If speaking to his mother is too daunting, the least you should do is raise the issue with the other adults who sit there and let your daughter do all that work on her own instead of ensuring their own children help as well. Your daughter is being treated as if she's less important than everyone else there including her peers and that's not right. I'm glad she's refusing to go now, but she still needs to see her parents stick up for her.

Chica10 · 25/04/2022 20:06

Dinoteeth · 25/04/2022 19:51

We are talking about an elderly woman 85 who wants to get the family together, it sounds like she is catering for about 9 people.
Hardly rude for her to ask her DGD to help out.

But it seems it’s always the daughter that is expected to do the running around and serving every one else - what about the other 8 people? Why are they not contributing and helping this 85 year old grandmother?

Suja1 · 25/04/2022 20:06

Familiar-sounding. As the youngest of three, I was expected to lay the table, clean the sink and other "domestic" chores. The oldest was to marry well, the middle one to be successful in business. I was the drudge. Don't let this carry on!!

A580Hojas · 25/04/2022 19:59

People are adapting the OP's question to suit their own narrative.

I honestly don't care whose culture is being offended by objecting to women and girls solely dealing with cooking and serving food to men. It's time they lived in 2022.

I had this ONCE with my (white British) father who invited a big group of family to a celebration lunch. Left all the cooking to my step mother as per and then expected me (as the only other woman in the family at the time) to clear away and make coffee. While all the men (6 of them including my husband and 3 brothers and bil) sat around the dining table drinking liqueurs. The fact that I had 2 small children at the time and had gone upstairs to change the nappy of one of them, didn't stop him. He waited until I had done that and come downstairs again and then started on about the coffee. I didn't tell him to fuck right off (as I should have done) but I did refuse. I was ashamed of my dinosaur of a father.

Dinoteeth · 25/04/2022 19:51

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/04/2022 19:28

If we invite people to eat, we serve them!

what a rude, poor host.

i’d decline further invitations until your husband makes her understand it’s not to happen again.

We are talking about an elderly woman 85 who wants to get the family together, it sounds like she is catering for about 9 people.
Hardly rude for her to ask her DGD to help out.

marktayloruk · 25/04/2022 19:44

Lol!

HikingforScenery · 25/04/2022 19:35

so everyone sitting there or pitching in? Your posts are conflicting tbh

pinkpantherpink · 25/04/2022 19:32

I'm not entirely convinced that there is an issue. Are the older cousins male, by any chance?

FortniteBoysMum · 25/04/2022 19:29

Why not step in and say no you sit down or I will do that. Or say isn't it someone else's turn as dd did it last time.

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/04/2022 19:28

If we invite people to eat, we serve them!

what a rude, poor host.

i’d decline further invitations until your husband makes her understand it’s not to happen again.

cafebean · 25/04/2022 19:26

Sorry if this has been asked already, but this MIL is 85, you say - what cultural background is she from?

I'm just asking because some people of that age are very set in their ways and you won't change them now, so no point stressing it.

My husband has relatives who come over to us and it's a culture where men don't deal with food - and heaven forbid, they have to serve themselves or not be served tea within 60 seconds flat of walking through the door. Then, when you go there, it's the usual delight of all the women in the kitchen and the men droning on in another room. But they are older people and this is how they were brought up so I just go with it. So do my girls, but it would be shocking to them if my husband or sons were to so much as take a cup into the kitchen. The horror! Even in British families, I don't think this is that unusual in that generation.

When I got married, my MIL insisted on me going over on the weekends for hours so she could show me how to cook certain things from her culture that apparently her son has to have regularly. Otherwise he would cease to exist or something like that. Had it ever entered her head to have taught any of this to her son? Er, no. But this is what happened to her when she got married so, in her mind, she was apparently welcoming me into the family or some such thing. She just thought this was the done thing.

I do like the suggestion of telling the MIL that the DD can't come anymore as she has a paid job in a cafe!

EYProvider · 25/04/2022 19:22

Unless I’ve missed an update, the OP hasn’t actually said who the various family members are, and it’s not even clear whether there are any men among them. All we know for sure is that Grandma, who is 85, has cooked the meal and asked the granddaughter, who is 18, to hand out the plates. OP is outraged by this, as she sees it as abuse, but it’s not clear why she didn’t offer to hand out the plates instead (presumably it would be ‘disrespect’ on Grandma’s part expecting it of her).

As I have zero interest in identity politics, I’m not remotely ‘ashamed’ to say that my priority in this situation would not be ‘supporting’ the 18 year old, if she was my daughter. There is no doubt that my daughter would be expected to carry the plates to the table, regardless of whether anyone offered to help her, because my expectation would be that she helped her grandmother. In fact, if my 18 year year old daughter refused to help her grandmother in this or any other situation, I would be seriously wondering where I had gone wrong with her upbringing.

PrincessPaws · 25/04/2022 19:10

My generation has a lot to answer for with the way we have raised our children. Something has gone very very wrong and the above is the result - a society that values the ‘rights’ of an entitled 18 year old and her pathetic mother over the well-being of her 85 year old grandmother, who has had the temerity to ask her to lay the table.

Completely disagree, this isn't about being asked to help, this is about the youngest female being the only one EXPECTED to help, and not just help, to actively serve everyone else.

If there is anything any previous generation has gone wrong with it's enabling this blatant sexism

Tainging99 · 25/04/2022 18:58

Honestly, tell mil and explain the impact it’s having.

theremustonlybeone · 25/04/2022 18:50

why is it your DD is the only female expected to do this. its pretty shocking and i would support her for refusing to attend any future events as she is being treated like hired help

RedHorsesAreDangerous · 25/04/2022 18:44

Dunno if anyone else grew up "oop north" but my mam used to have the perfect question for these types of situations.

It was, "What did yer last servant die of?!" And if she was in a really bad mood (or having one of her frequent - very - bad cooking days - an ability which I definitely inherited) it was sometimes followed by, "Dee it yersel for once".

SnozPoz · 25/04/2022 18:43

Could this be a cultural thing? We had a party a little while back where a South African father expected his youngest (grown and married) son to serve everyone, particularly him, all night. I found it a bit odd, but the son just expected to do it and was fine with it. I know lots of South Africans who don't do this I hasten to add! I think you need to talk to your husband maybe the youngest in the family has always done this and he thinks it's normal?

Octomore · 25/04/2022 18:41

Ultimately, it’s about girls and women being expected to run around and serve other people, especially men, whilst they sit on their arses. The grandmother clearly believes that it’s the “woman’s job” to serve others.

This 100%. The men in the room should be ashamed of themselves for not pitching in and doing their share.