Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL expects DD18 to serve everyone

342 replies

Safarigiraffe · 24/04/2022 00:48

MIL is generally lovely woman however she expects DD18 to set table, serve everyone etc when we go round there before sitting down herself. Now DD18 can’t seem to relax or enjoy herself there as all work seems to fall onto her & now has reached a point where DD is refusing to go round at all. AIBU to think that it’s not fair to expect DD18 to do the setting up, serving of adults before being seated herself, clear away table when they are other older cousins in their late 20s there that can do this Not sure how to address this issue or whether to say something to DH (would more than likely cause a row) or whether to say something subtle to MIL (who would no doubt get very upset) Just to add DD does do little things to help out but MIL expects her to do everything without having a break

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
oliviastwisted · 29/04/2022 07:49

I have read a lot of the replies here and to some extent I’ve changed my mind.

Granny is who she is and she is of her own generation but equally I don’t think it is respectful to allow her values to make your daughter feel singled out among the grandchildren unfairly.

I definitely think it is up to the rest of the family to step up here and make DDs experiences fair by taking on the workload too. You can’t change granny, DD shouldn’t be doing all the work unfairly, others stepping in would help.

bringincrazyback · 28/04/2022 20:43

tomatoandherbs · 25/04/2022 08:41

I don’t get why this thread has becomes gender issue

the op is female and she’s not being asked to help

it is about age. The DD is the youngest of the group

i suspect the MIL is seeing her as “her little helper” and hasn’t realised that her granddaughter is now 18 and probably not quite so keen to help granny as when you’re 8!

the mil only sees her 3x a year, so just hasn’t kept up with her

But if the youngest was male, do you think the same expectations would be placed on him? I don't.

alexdgr8 · 28/04/2022 17:16

nobody needs to say anything.
just arrive in time with food to share, or to do/help with cooking and wait on grandma.
everyone to step up and pamper grandma. simples.
same for clearing away, etc.

Misty333 · 28/04/2022 13:09

Where is her dad in all this. He should be saying something!!! After all it’s his mother and God only knows what his daughter must think of him. If he thinks this is okay shame on him.

EYProvider · 26/04/2022 16:08

@Neverendingmindfuck - Exactly. If it’s true, it’s mind blowing. Then again, so many people on here think Grandma is ‘abusive’, that this type of warped thinking has to represent a generational mindset. Which is pretty depressing, if not surprising given the state of the world. So many spoilt brats …

Neverendingmindfuck · 26/04/2022 15:27

Geez...
I would never expect a person of your MIL age to be cooking dinner for a large family to start with.
If they did WANT to, it would be on the understanding they had help from start to finish from their FAMILY.
Not just one person singled out for whatever reason.
If you are not ALL offering to help, you are selfish entitled arseholes tbh.

MadMadaMim · 26/04/2022 12:32

If DD doesn't want to go, her absence will speak volumes. If anyone asks, be honest and say sje didn't want to come. If anyone ask why, again, be honest. I'd say something like " she can't really relax and enjoy her time here as she feels singled out when it comes to chores. She loves seeing everyone and helping out but thinks the chore expectations are unfair".

You'll get the 'they've all don't it' response to which I'd reply - 'as they're all adults now, the grandchildren should share the tasks.'

Another option is to visit and not eat there.

Drinkingallthewine · 26/04/2022 12:20

At your MIL's age she should be the one getting cooked for, not the one doing the cooking!

DM loves to host, loves to have us all around but we each bring a dish so that she doesn't have to lift a finger. Those who don't bring a dish, get the setting the table/washing up afterwards.

That way it doesn't fall all on DM or any one person, and everyone pitches in until the place is cleared away again and we can all sit down.

AryaStarkWolf · 26/04/2022 11:38

I wouldn't blame her for not wanting to go round anymore

jsof595 · 26/04/2022 11:33

If DD is 18 she should stick upon for herself if she has an issue.

She is old enough to buy a house, mother a child, drive a car, fight for her country and much more. She should be able to have a discussion with her Nan.

Dinoteeth · 26/04/2022 08:04

tomatoandherbs · 26/04/2022 07:35

I just find puzzling that OP doesn't answer specific gamechanger questions such as "if her fam is from a different culture".

Because it will no doubt undermine the image she wants to convey which isn’t the reality

I don't think culture matters, there might be an age thing going on. Grans asking the youngest adult with no younger cousin to pass the job on to.

I don't know why the Op doesn't say after they've eaten, MIL & DD you sit down, DH and I will clear up.
Or MIL we'll host dinner next time, or we'll bring the starter / desert. Change the status quo of the MIL doing it all.

I bet she loves getting her family together but is exhausted after it.

Dinoteeth · 26/04/2022 07:56

Chica10 · 25/04/2022 20:06

But it seems it’s always the daughter that is expected to do the running around and serving every one else - what about the other 8 people? Why are they not contributing and helping this 85 year old grandmother?

I agree they should all be pitching in.
But the poster @MrsSkylerWhite seems to think the Grandma is poor, rude host, who shouldn't ask for help. She seems stays if "we invite...we serve them" totally missing Granny seems to be on her own and is 85.

Reality she shouldn't need to ask. Can you imagine the husband say "Mum don't ask DD to help" he would deserve the biggest boot up the arsenal. He should be getting of his fat arse and pitching in along with his lazy wife, who only seems to visit when she's getting fed.

I can't get over this old dear, cooking a Sunday dinner for 8 or 9 much younger and them expecting not to lift a finger.

tomatoandherbs · 26/04/2022 07:35

I just find puzzling that OP doesn't answer specific gamechanger questions such as "if her fam is from a different culture".

Because it will no doubt undermine the image she wants to convey which isn’t the reality

madamemeow · 26/04/2022 06:22

Ineedaduvetday · 26/04/2022 05:55

This. It's probably not done anymore with nuclear families but back then it was common for the matriarch to "train" younger ladies - such as it was common for the elderly grandpa to advice/train the male cousins - in whatever they thought was essential. My grandma taught me to cook (my mom refused to lol) and she also passed on her special recipe book that she had handwritten, to me. After each of these get togethers, she would gather us kids around her and tell us stories from her life, and from ancient myths and legends, and somehow teach us a lot of life lessons, all simplified of course, but they made up for some great memories....

Looks like OP isn't coming back but maybe the scenario above is more likely to be the case. It is just what MIL thinks is right and does not come from a nasty place.

I just find puzzling that OP doesn't answer specific gamechanger questions such as "if her fam is from a different culture". Her answer would help understand the situation so much better. I also veer towards the grandma being a nice person in general because OP framed the first few words of her question explaining that. It probably means that Grandma is nice most of the time but insists on OP's daughter - may be she is especially fond of her, or she thinks it's good character building exercise for young people to help elders, we don't know at this point - which is the problem with both OP and her daughter.

I do think everyone should offer to step up and help set the table, clean etc. That's what guests usually do. That the host will never articulate she needs help, culturally it is a taboo, it is up to the guests to offer help. At least that's how it's in my culture.

madamemeow · 26/04/2022 06:17

expat101 · 26/04/2022 03:47

His Son was helping move chairs and side tables about for guests to get into the lounge room. His Sister and her offspring of both genders, were sitting away in another room together not assisting in any way with the proceedings.

This. I don't know about other families but in mine, well yeah the men did not help the women who were cooking/serving, but then we women did not help the men either when they did the more physical things like arranging for extra chairs and tables, moving them around, picking up people from bus/train stations if they don't have their own vehicles (it was not culturally okay to let the guest pay his way to come to your home, if you are the host) cleaning the entire home, putting up decorations like mango leaves on top of door jamb etc.

Ineedaduvetday · 26/04/2022 05:55

This. It's probably not done anymore with nuclear families but back then it was common for the matriarch to "train" younger ladies - such as it was common for the elderly grandpa to advice/train the male cousins - in whatever they thought was essential. My grandma taught me to cook (my mom refused to lol) and she also passed on her special recipe book that she had handwritten, to me. After each of these get togethers, she would gather us kids around her and tell us stories from her life, and from ancient myths and legends, and somehow teach us a lot of life lessons, all simplified of course, but they made up for some great memories....

Looks like OP isn't coming back but maybe the scenario above is more likely to be the case. It is just what MIL thinks is right and does not come from a nasty place.

Bleachmycloths · 26/04/2022 05:13

Apologies. I have just seen that this has already been asked. Cultural or not, it is unreasonable. Things move on and change and you don’t have to put up with this nonsense.

Bleachmycloths · 26/04/2022 05:09

Sorry if this has already been asked and answered (there are a lot of posts to read) but is it a cultural issue with your MIL?

expat101 · 26/04/2022 03:47

Indicatrice · 26/04/2022 03:14

@expat101 I’m glad you said something, but why not ask FIL to get his son to help, rather than his daughter?

His Son was helping move chairs and side tables about for guests to get into the lounge room. His Sister and her offspring of both genders, were sitting away in another room together not assisting in any way with the proceedings.

Indicatrice · 26/04/2022 03:14

@expat101 I’m glad you said something, but why not ask FIL to get his son to help, rather than his daughter?

expat101 · 26/04/2022 03:09

An earlier poster reminded me of my IL's special wedding anniversary. We were there to help as was my SIL and most of her tribe of near adult offspring. Visitors had started to arrive and my FIL came quickly in the kitchen, having a shot at me (being the only one in the kitchen) that people were arriving and should be offered tea and coffee.

Well I held back on the language, but pointed out the rest of his family including his daughter were sitting in the (formal) dining room and he should go and see them about that, as I was busy making the tea and coffee, and which he did.

I never saw that family move as fast as they did that day.

OP must simply say something esp, if there are other cousins sitting around and not pulling their weight.

madamemeow · 26/04/2022 01:00

sadsack78 · 25/04/2022 21:19

having reflected on this thread, this m=is maybe what's happened to your MIL too and she doesn't see what's wrong with it, the same was expected of her, etc.
It sounds like everyone involved could do with changing their approach to things- like maybe more people present should be opting to help out your MIL because it's the gracious thing to do, everyone helps out in whatever way they can- that is a good lesson to be teaching the kids present, and is an opportunity lost the way things were being done before.

This. It's probably not done anymore with nuclear families but back then it was common for the matriarch to "train" younger ladies - such as it was common for the elderly grandpa to advice/train the male cousins - in whatever they thought was essential. My grandma taught me to cook (my mom refused to lol) and she also passed on her special recipe book that she had handwritten, to me. After each of these get togethers, she would gather us kids around her and tell us stories from her life, and from ancient myths and legends, and somehow teach us a lot of life lessons, all simplified of course, but they made up for some great memories....

of course if OP's grandma is really a nasty piece of work who is rude bossy and expects the OP's daughter to play maid, without having a good r'ship with her outside these parties, then she can take a hike.

madamemeow · 26/04/2022 00:47

I remember my grandma used to host similar get-togethers party often. Middle class asia in the 90s, massive amounts of food, lots of noise and laughter, children running from one corner to other, men in their "designated" areas smoking and playing carrom board, women gossiping in the terrace and helping out in the kitchen...

yeah, it may sound sexist and outrageous in 2022, but culturally, guests are not allowed to help out the host, it's considered a sin and an insult for the host to even articulate that she needs help. My grandma always relied on me to set the table, which I did with pleasure. She was old with joint and heart issues (this was the days before modern medical solutions) and I was very aware of the fact that she won't be with us for long and it was a joy to help her out, and also a matter of pride for me that she trusted me enough with her costly china, and set the table.

Yes there was misogyny and patriarchy at the table too, also some bitter bad blood between some of the family members which created drama but none of it eclipsed the love I had for my sweet grandma who'd painstakingly make all my fav dishes during each of this party. We saw each other only a few times a year but the blood bond between us was solid because I... don't know, she told me funny stories and she smelled comfy and motherly, and she was my grandma so I just naturally loved her, I suppose.

OP, not everything is about gender/identity/value politics and whose turn it is to help out. It looks like your daughter has said no to the parties, which is good, she has set a boundary. So just say she has classes or has a job or whatever when she is missing from the next party and don't stew too much for a 85-year old woman's actions. What I'd like to know is how is the grandma normally treat your child?

Has the grandma been close to your daughter historically, does she send gifts or is very fond of her, or is she just a distant relative vibes that your kid sees thrice a year? I want to also know more about your daughter's perspective in this, why is it so awful for her to do some light chores three time a year, for her own family, especially if its cultural and if all her other cousins did the same before it was her turn? Does she not think that it would be the right thing to do for an elderly person, her own grandmother, a few times a year when said grandma spent probably hours in the kitchen preparing a delicious spread for all of them?

The world needs people with more compassion and kindness but I am sure that by itself is an outdated opinion.

Bettyblue444 · 25/04/2022 21:39

Is your DD the oldest grandchild? The oldest girl always ends up looking after the others. It isn’t fair and you are right to be annoyed on her behalf and should nip it in the bud.

sadsack78 · 25/04/2022 21:19

having reflected on this thread, this m=is maybe what's happened to your MIL too and she doesn't see what's wrong with it, the same was expected of her, etc.
It sounds like everyone involved could do with changing their approach to things- like maybe more people present should be opting to help out your MIL because it's the gracious thing to do, everyone helps out in whatever way they can- that is a good lesson to be teaching the kids present, and is an opportunity lost the way things were being done before.