Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Needy Neighbour - still - again

234 replies

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 11:22

Disclosure - I have written about this situation before, and do try to keep out of it, but it keeps evolving as these things do. Note also, that I did agree to be her baby's Godmother [last minute request], but baby has now been adopted, and no more contact.

The very first time I wrote about this, I was told by some that I was over-invested and have a saviour-complex (I wish...), and as I have said above, I obviously did not succeed in creating, if not actual, at least figurative distance.

The young woman who lives next door (she in small apartments - 8 total; me in s/d house alongside) is someone I have known OF for quite a few years. I am old enough to be her mother (my own daughter is 5 years older than her); she has adoptive parents who live a little distance away (n/c with birth parents or family) but they are very very cold with her, although do help with lifts and things and (are supposed to) take care of her money (benefits are paid to them and they give hr an allowance - NOTE, I have just found out that they are not keping on top of her household bills, as agreed, as debt collectors have shown up for BG and a pre-paymet meter is going in to clear unpaid amounts).
She is relying on me very heavily and as other people cut her off, and cut her out, it is falling to me. She comes round to my friend's (where I am from about 8:45pm) apartment (he is in the same complex), usually in a distressed state over her "boyfriend" (babydaddy - he is a bit useless really) - and we are both too "nice" to turn her away ; then she justs sits or stands in the living room, going over and over the same things (she does not take advice on board, she just wants to be agreed with over this man and hear her own voice). She usually interrupts the late evening meal we might be about to eat, and does not care.

I cannot leave my house without her coming out to get me to help her with something. Or, she seems to appear when I return..... And I have been very snappish with her, but she is not deterred - and then anyway I feel terrible and cannot focus on what I was meant to be doing (which I realise is my own weakness and stupidity). I am now disproportionatey anxious over this (as, as I have tried to explain to her, her dramatics (and they CAN be - and she usually involved the Police herself....) can be on top of something else that I am trying to figure out in my own life at that time.

I cannot seem to get the balnce right - and I think I AM looking on here for someone to rant to myself (so in a way, like my neighbour....). It is just not easy to detach when there is no physical escape, and everything I think of that might help would actually result in further involevemnt, not less.
[And I do like to think that I am somewhat kind and (was) reasonably patient.]

Example, last night, we were just about tp eat - about 9:40 (very bad itself, and another issue of mine) and she appeared at the patio door (even though sheer curtains were drawn) waving her phone at me to speak to her Social Worker. She fell on the floor crying, and put her head on my knees, and was freezing cold, having been walking aroun the village (looking for the bf I think....) in her dressing gown. She didnt leave until 10:30 - and I believe she didn't settle at home even then, as her gate was open at minight (a bad sign).

For whatever advice I am seeking (and yes, I DO want to move/not easy - as this is very much a proximity issue, I don't think she respects me or my opionion or feelings at all....), please don't tell me to Get a Life, or that I am over-invested, because I do really try not to be.

But...... Heeeelp.....?
Please

OP posts:
apricotlane · 23/04/2022 21:44

@LoveMyPiano Can you give her a time when it's ok for her to bother you? Maybe an hour once a week? Would that still be too much? If she comes to your door you must stand at the door, listen for a short time. and then when you've had enough say that you have to go. You've got to stop letting her in I suppose. If she has a mind like a child then you've got to be firm and consistent like you would be with a child. Help her by giving her boundaries and structures.

VodselForDinner · 23/04/2022 21:41

OP, in my life I’ve learned that people who continually demonstrate a behaviour do so because they get something out of it, no matter how much they protest.

I think you need to speak to a therapist to understand why you need what you need from your interactions with this woman, and also your friend.

reallyworriedjobhunter · 23/04/2022 21:20

Oh op. This sounds very tough.

I would be shutting the two things down. Hurrying past with a cheery hello, sorry, can't stop and not answering the door.

I'd also get my piano back and stop spending all my time taking care of other people. It's time to take care of yourself.

FloraPostePosts · 23/04/2022 21:19

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 21:11

I see what you ar both saying - and it is probably quite quite true. For long-standing reasons, I am a bit of a pushover/people-pleaser, due in no small part to abandonment issues. Counselling would be very hard to access, and probably futile now, at this late stage.
Life has come full circle, but when i felt this way as a child (and the reasons were valid then, despite relevant parties dismissing and diminishing them), there was more life ahead. Now it is all in the rear view mirror and my mother was right when she said, the last time I saw her, which is now seven years ago, "You have fucked up your life, and it is all your own doing".
And she didn't even know the full story herself.

She is still alive - somewhere, I think.

Counselling isn’t hard to come by. There are thousands of therapists who work in dozens of ways, and you can search for people in your area on the BACP register. You could click on this link and send an email to a counsellor now, this evening, in the next fifteen minutes, then speak to them to see if they think they could help you.

www.bacp.co.uk/about-therapy/how-to-find-a-therapist/

You would be very surprised about the help they can offer. You are not a lost cause, and you deserve to have your own fulfilled life, not one where you only exist in terms of what you do for other people. But it will take work to get you to the point where you believe this, and a counsellor will help you to get there.

You are the only person who can do this, and you have to take the first steps. I hope this thread might give you the additional push you need.

Do you really want to be back posting the same thread again in another six months, or six years? Do it for you: for the child you who had such a hard time; for the lost adult you; for the happy future you that you deserve.

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 21:11

godmum56 · 23/04/2022 21:03

this absolutely. See I don't think moving will help you because you seem to me to be a catastrophe magnet. I am betting that LOADS of people on here have had a similar "starter" experience of a needy neighbour, a demanding friend, accosted by a stranger in need or something similar. Its a part of life. The difference is that most people will help immediately then back away or, if they are concerned, they will decline to help (I know a bloke, fellow clinician who was attacked because he didn't listen to his gut) I think it might be worth getting some help to see what you get from these circumstances....because you may not redcognise it and what you are getting may be toxic but you sure as heck are getting something or you wouldn't do it.

I see what you ar both saying - and it is probably quite quite true. For long-standing reasons, I am a bit of a pushover/people-pleaser, due in no small part to abandonment issues. Counselling would be very hard to access, and probably futile now, at this late stage.
Life has come full circle, but when i felt this way as a child (and the reasons were valid then, despite relevant parties dismissing and diminishing them), there was more life ahead. Now it is all in the rear view mirror and my mother was right when she said, the last time I saw her, which is now seven years ago, "You have fucked up your life, and it is all your own doing".
And she didn't even know the full story herself.

She is still alive - somewhere, I think.

OP posts:
godmum56 · 23/04/2022 21:03

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

this absolutely. See I don't think moving will help you because you seem to me to be a catastrophe magnet. I am betting that LOADS of people on here have had a similar "starter" experience of a needy neighbour, a demanding friend, accosted by a stranger in need or something similar. Its a part of life. The difference is that most people will help immediately then back away or, if they are concerned, they will decline to help (I know a bloke, fellow clinician who was attacked because he didn't listen to his gut) I think it might be worth getting some help to see what you get from these circumstances....because you may not redcognise it and what you are getting may be toxic but you sure as heck are getting something or you wouldn't do it.

Ionlydomassiveones · 23/04/2022 20:47

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

RJnomore1 · 23/04/2022 20:45

@LoveMyPiano sorry I had to go do stuff. You need to report it to the housing staff as well it’s antisocial behaviour at best.

Hoghedge10 · 23/04/2022 20:21

I wonder if 'helping' these people is fulfilling some need within you OP?

It reads like you surround yourself with people that have issues, does that ring true for you at all?

You want to be kind and help people, but no matter how much that might come from a good place you are not helping these people only adding to the drama whether meaning to or not.

You are perpetuating these toxic situations, I wonder if you have really thought about why? I don't think it's just that you are trying to be kind I think there is a deeper issue (maybe more than one) at play here.

I really hope you look at some counselling for yourself I think it would really be beneficial for you.

You deserve to live a happy life and without some sort of support (such as therapy) to look into the bigger issues surrounding all of this I'm not sure that'll be possible.

winterchills · 23/04/2022 20:17

What a sad situation for her as she clearly isn't coping but sad also for you because I can tell you do genuinely care for her. She definitely needs assessing capacity/mental health wise and having some kind of supported living.

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 19:49

I am despondent though. Because of the situation/s, and also because I feel a bit misunderstood.

She has been or connected to "the system" all her life, but because she wants to live independently, most agencies have backed off, until she reels them in in some way - obviously most recently by having a baby and having the baby taken away from her/them. Official support and intervention seems to be minimal, except when she kicks off dramatically (can be as much as three times or more in a week, but sometimes a few weeks go by without police involvement - as far as I know....) - but I AM NOT trying to make up for that..... I was just being a friend (sort of) and by her own admission, if she is given an inch, she takes a mile.

I don't think my "help" is the cause of lack of input from SS etc, and nor do I think my not "helping" would mean that they stepped up again. It is unfair of posters on here to say that, as I do little to nothing that is official (College was a one-off, and I told them that she needed help from them, not me). I have all of her stuff dumped on me like emptying a waste paper basket of her thoughts. One reason I do take it on board is because the phrase "Don't tell me your problems, I've got problems of my own" - as much as I am feeling it, is an absolute trigger to me, and I refuse to be a person who says that, wrongly or rightly.

I wish with all my heart, that I could move away (and did have a plan, that turned out be a pipe dream....) and let my friend especially be free of me and how I probably screw up his life. It is just not very easy - never would be for someone like me, but more so in the light of the current state of the economy.

I cannot keep ("over-")explaining when, even though I have asked for the help of MNers, I am being met with The Power of The Plural terminology, which I struggle with.
This is, however, a "good" kick up the backside, so that's something.

OP posts:
sonjadog · 23/04/2022 19:42

Have you considered getting some help for yourself? Maybe some counselling in how to set boundaries and not be used by other people? You seem to have got into a mindset where being kind and helpful consists of letting people do whatever they want with you. The guilt over saying no suggest this too.

My impression from reading your posts here is that you are still looking for a way to make this all their problem and if only they would do x/y then everything would be okay, while you will continue on just the way you have been. That isn't going to happen. How they behave is not something that you control and it is working for them - they are getting the attention from you that they want. The only thing you can control if your own behaviour. If you really want to change the situation, then you need to work on that, with professional help if needed.

Ukholidaysaregreat · 23/04/2022 19:32

I read your previous thread. I thought you were being very nice and supportive to this woman who obviously has loads of personal issues going on for herself. The social worker has no right to sound bored with you. She is getting paid to work a night shift helping people. Yes ring in office hours and try to speak to someone senior in the department. Social services are so under funded at the moment they are probably delighted that you are helping this person so much so that they don't have to step up. I don't like the sounds of the cold foster family budgeting for her either. They may be getting money for supporting her. Maybe if they are giving her lifts etc. they are more helpful than you think. You sound very nice but don't give more than you have. You can't pour from an empty cup. At 9.40 eating my tea I would open the window to say I am just eating my tea and then shut the window again. Don't bring her in for a rant. Good Luck with this. It sounds very difficult an you are very nice and supportive.

CPL593H · 23/04/2022 19:24

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 19:15

Thnk you all SO much for appreciated and welcome advice. None of which is ognored, nor disregarded. All taken on board.

I realise that my replies are "lengthy". They are not intended as excuses, but are trying to show more of a picture, or about what I think , for what that matters.

I don't, by now, think I can answer anything else, because it will probably seem like more of the same. No doubt, I am creating as many problems as I am trying to solve - and as I am the common denominator, it must all be down to me.

Being despondent won't change anything. As others have said, and I firmly believe, you may well actually be stopping her from getting the level of help she needs from authorities who are Not You. Things are so stretched at the moment that if it is felt a family member/neighbour/whoever will pick up the slack, they will be left to do so. As others have also said, you really are choosing to do all this, whether you want to face that or not. Sorry, but that is the truth as I see it.

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 19:15

Thnk you all SO much for appreciated and welcome advice. None of which is ognored, nor disregarded. All taken on board.

I realise that my replies are "lengthy". They are not intended as excuses, but are trying to show more of a picture, or about what I think , for what that matters.

I don't, by now, think I can answer anything else, because it will probably seem like more of the same. No doubt, I am creating as many problems as I am trying to solve - and as I am the common denominator, it must all be down to me.

OP posts:
PussInBin20 · 23/04/2022 19:04

Well you can’t change what she does but you can change how you respond. If you don’t start saying “No” or ignoring her then you will just have to put up with it 🤷‍♀️

Put yourself first for a change, you don’t owe her anything. So what if she screams, bangs the door or calls the police? Let them deal with her.

Only you can resolve this!

grxxxx · 23/04/2022 17:15

I think you are well meaning but you really are not doing yourself or either neighbour any favours .
Both these people are not your problem and by ‘helping’ them you are increasing both their and your own problems
you are not equipped with the specialist training that is required for this girls complex needs yet you are inhibiting her accessing the real help she requires by blundering in with the help you are giving her
please for everyone’s sake back away and leave her to get proper help
when she asks you for anything say NO firmly, tell her she must talk to her SW not you and leave it at that .
You are saying in your op that she just talks at you and won’t listen yet reading down this thread it seems very much that is what you are doing here , you are coming up with an excuse not to follow any of the suggestions of a way forwards , you too need to listen and follow some of the excellent advise given

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 23/04/2022 16:43

If she engages you going to or from your home " sorry can't stop I'm busy"
If she screams, causes a scene or phones the police or whatever.
Not your problem.
If she comes around while at your other friends.
Ignore.
If she causes a scene. Not your problem.
Do not engage in any of it. At all.
It's not your problem.

TerenceTrentLoughborough · 23/04/2022 16:40

I voted YABU because it is unreasonable for you to reinforce & facilitate her behaviour, and it is unreasonable for you to find holes in every piece of advice again & again. You say you're kind, but it's not kind to carry on like this. Do you have some unmet mental health needs of your own? You cannot 'fix' this person, it's not your job, but you can and you should formally record your concerns to relevant statutory bodies (sw) and then literally close the door and walk away.

Please also look in to getting some counselling for yourself to work on boundaries. You deserve to be happy, calm and content in life. I am sorry for the stern tone I've taken but you really must take action now!

zingally · 23/04/2022 16:28

I'm sorry if I upset you with the reference to the horse stuff. That wasn't my intention. I was more trying (perhaps clumsily) to illustrate a point that you always (certainly unintentionally) have a reason/excuse why you've continued to engage with this NDN (and the male friend - but that's a whole other thread, I know), and have not managed to act on the very consistent advice you've gotten, both on this thread, and your others.

You said in your reply to me that you "can hardly take action this second." And whilst that is true, why didn't you take the advice given, at least twice previously - say, yesterday? Last week? February? Before Christmas? Last time you posted?

I seem to remember from the previous thread (see, it stayed with me), that when others suggested you look at getting some therapy, you couldn't because your doctor wouldn't take you seriously. Commenters said get a new doctor. Have you actioned that advice?

You also discussed struggling to feed yourself and male friend with a single slow cooker/pressure cooker (I can't remember which), but there was another available in a box, that just needed a space clearing for it. Have you actioned that?

It was suggested that you distance yourself from male friend (which you wanted at the time), by returning the key to the horse yard. Have you done that?

Meant as kindly as I humanly can OP... I'm guessing the answers to all the above are a variation of "no, but..."

Do you see where people are coming from? You must surely see that every single commenter is giving you a variation of "say no", but you don't/can't/won't.

I do truly wish you the best, and I'm sure all the other commenters do as well. But you've got to take responsibility for you, and make whatever changes need making in order for you to be happy. Umpteen people have all said the same thing, and unless you are genuinely hearing us, nothing will change.

Gazelda · 23/04/2022 16:18

OP, you seem to be involved with 2 people who aren't good for you in one way or another. You seem intrinsically linked.

For,your own sake, please seek help to extricate yourself from both. Find your own life to enjoy.

With the woman, decide on boundaries that you want her to keep to. Then, you need to keep to them too. It's no good saying she shouldn't come to yours, then opening the door when she does.

With the man, do you go round to his every day for food and to play your piano? Do you enjoy his company? Do you think he takes advantage of your need to play your piano, or do you think you are taking advantage of him for allowing you do to so? Who pays for the food? Why doesn't he ever come to yours? Is there anything (eg sex) expected of either of you?

Is there a Mencap local to you? Perhaps give them a call to explain how you've got entangled with the woman and ask for help in handling the situation. I know for a fact that if they were providing support to her, they'd be laying down clear boundaries which they'd expect her to respect for her own good ie future relationships, friendships, professional boundaries etc.

Shannith · 23/04/2022 16:15

OP you are very similar to your neighbour. You say she won't listen to you/take your advice/do anything differently- can you see you are exactly the same?

I know someone me like you - drama follows them around because they have no boundaries and are a chronic people pleaser.

It's not normal - whatever issues from the past that cause the behaviour. People on here are getting frustrated because many of us would never be in this situation in the first place. We don't have a false idea of what being "kind" or "nice" is and we do not get involved in other peoples drama because we know it 1. Doesn't help that person and 2. Would damage our mental health.

So us all giving you advice is a bit pointless. Because, like your neighbour, you won't take it.

What if I tell you that your behaviour is neither "nice" or "kind"?

You are enabling a sick person in the same way as if you were buying drugs for an addict.

If you want to be nice and kind - back off, butt out and had this over to SS/police.

If you put 10% of the effort into contacting and chasing SS repeatedly via all possible channels as you do posting here/worrying about the situation you'd have a solution.

I know I sound unkind/not nice but perhaps you need to hear it.

Beelezebub · 23/04/2022 16:13

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 14:04

You are right. I do. Always have had, and there are reasons.

But I also try to be kind, or at least, not UNkind. It shouldn't need to become, whatever "this" is though.

Even when I do assert myself (i.e. lose my temper), and tell her to leave me alone, she comes again sooner or later (usually sooner). I was once told - by a parent actually - that I was like the ball in swingball,; kept coming back even though I wasn't wanted. I see that in her. But I''m not going to say anything out loud.

Saying “no” isn’t being UNkind.

Refusing to engage isn’t being UNkind.

in many ways, continuing to do what you are doing and not changing anything is actually unkind because you allow both of these people to perpetuate deeply damaging cycles of behaviour and prevent them getting to the point where they will receive appropriate intervention from people who are qualified to do so.

You’ve asked here more than once for advice that is essentially the same regardless of the scenario.

It’s only you who can choose to take it.

Maurepas · 23/04/2022 15:58

OP there is a 2 letter word in the English language - it starts with 'N'.

MrsClatterbuck · 23/04/2022 15:57

You are trying to be kind, but you are getting in the way of the help she actually needs.

This in spades.