Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Needy Neighbour - still - again

234 replies

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 11:22

Disclosure - I have written about this situation before, and do try to keep out of it, but it keeps evolving as these things do. Note also, that I did agree to be her baby's Godmother [last minute request], but baby has now been adopted, and no more contact.

The very first time I wrote about this, I was told by some that I was over-invested and have a saviour-complex (I wish...), and as I have said above, I obviously did not succeed in creating, if not actual, at least figurative distance.

The young woman who lives next door (she in small apartments - 8 total; me in s/d house alongside) is someone I have known OF for quite a few years. I am old enough to be her mother (my own daughter is 5 years older than her); she has adoptive parents who live a little distance away (n/c with birth parents or family) but they are very very cold with her, although do help with lifts and things and (are supposed to) take care of her money (benefits are paid to them and they give hr an allowance - NOTE, I have just found out that they are not keping on top of her household bills, as agreed, as debt collectors have shown up for BG and a pre-paymet meter is going in to clear unpaid amounts).
She is relying on me very heavily and as other people cut her off, and cut her out, it is falling to me. She comes round to my friend's (where I am from about 8:45pm) apartment (he is in the same complex), usually in a distressed state over her "boyfriend" (babydaddy - he is a bit useless really) - and we are both too "nice" to turn her away ; then she justs sits or stands in the living room, going over and over the same things (she does not take advice on board, she just wants to be agreed with over this man and hear her own voice). She usually interrupts the late evening meal we might be about to eat, and does not care.

I cannot leave my house without her coming out to get me to help her with something. Or, she seems to appear when I return..... And I have been very snappish with her, but she is not deterred - and then anyway I feel terrible and cannot focus on what I was meant to be doing (which I realise is my own weakness and stupidity). I am now disproportionatey anxious over this (as, as I have tried to explain to her, her dramatics (and they CAN be - and she usually involved the Police herself....) can be on top of something else that I am trying to figure out in my own life at that time.

I cannot seem to get the balnce right - and I think I AM looking on here for someone to rant to myself (so in a way, like my neighbour....). It is just not easy to detach when there is no physical escape, and everything I think of that might help would actually result in further involevemnt, not less.
[And I do like to think that I am somewhat kind and (was) reasonably patient.]

Example, last night, we were just about tp eat - about 9:40 (very bad itself, and another issue of mine) and she appeared at the patio door (even though sheer curtains were drawn) waving her phone at me to speak to her Social Worker. She fell on the floor crying, and put her head on my knees, and was freezing cold, having been walking aroun the village (looking for the bf I think....) in her dressing gown. She didnt leave until 10:30 - and I believe she didn't settle at home even then, as her gate was open at minight (a bad sign).

For whatever advice I am seeking (and yes, I DO want to move/not easy - as this is very much a proximity issue, I don't think she respects me or my opionion or feelings at all....), please don't tell me to Get a Life, or that I am over-invested, because I do really try not to be.

But...... Heeeelp.....?
Please

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 00:15

TerenceTrentLoughborough · 24/04/2022 00:09

I am still - obviously - stuck, but not because I want to be.

What is the reason, then, do you think?

Because I have nowhere to go - and no money to do it.
And because, "Wherever you go, you take yourself with you".
and because I am Me.

OP posts:
Pigglesworth · 24/04/2022 00:10

No worries. To be clear I didn't mean that her presentation is like you as a child, but more that you mentioned others not hearing/being kind to you as a child and the impact that had on you, and now "being nice" and appearing to "hear" or "help" her is a drive that you are finding very difficult to shake. But "being kind" to her I think needs to look very different- i.e. stepping back and letting the professionals be fully aware of her needs and responsible for dealing with them, rather than reinforcing dysfunctional patterns and partially concealing her needs. And hurting yourself in the process. I'm glad that my post has been helpful, listening to Janina relate that experience was very meaningful to me. Reflecting on ourselves and our needs/drives/motivations is very painful I find but the key to a fuller, more authentic/congruent and happier life, though very challenging to shift ingrained patterns of behaviour.

TerenceTrentLoughborough · 24/04/2022 00:09

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 00:01

But I don't know who you were/are......

And am very sorry if I didn't follow your advice. Even so, am thankful for it/all advice offered previously.
I am still - obviously - stuck, but not because I want to be.

I am still - obviously - stuck, but not because I want to be.

What is the reason, then, do you think?

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 00:01

FloraPostePosts · 23/04/2022 23:56

I didn’t even have to look at my own posting history. Your stories lodged in my memory. But no, a search by anyone else won’t show posts made under your previous screen names.

I think about people with whom I engage on here often, because it’s an advice forum. I offer advice, and wonder how the people I have tried to help are getting on. That’s why people get irritated at seeing the same story posted over and over with no sign the person seeking advice has taken it on board, or attempted to move on from their problems: because they are invested in helping that person do so.

I am sure you are just as memorable to other posters, too.

But I don't know who you were/are......

And am very sorry if I didn't follow your advice. Even so, am thankful for it/all advice offered previously.
I am still - obviously - stuck, but not because I want to be.

OP posts:
FloraPostePosts · 23/04/2022 23:56

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 23:51

@FloraPostePosts Right. I understand now. Which means that you could see my previous posts through your own posting history, not mine...
Problem with that is that I don;t know who people are who have posted previously with a different name and are now a bit pissed I didn't follow through with their advice. Or it seems that I am repeating myself. (Which I am - L.O.L.)

I didn’t even have to look at my own posting history. Your stories lodged in my memory. But no, a search by anyone else won’t show posts made under your previous screen names.

I think about people with whom I engage on here often, because it’s an advice forum. I offer advice, and wonder how the people I have tried to help are getting on. That’s why people get irritated at seeing the same story posted over and over with no sign the person seeking advice has taken it on board, or attempted to move on from their problems: because they are invested in helping that person do so.

I am sure you are just as memorable to other posters, too.

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 23:53

Excuse typing/mistakes. Bloody keyboard - wants me to stop posting as well.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 23:51

@FloraPostePosts Right. I understand now. Which means that you could see my previous posts through your own posting history, not mine...
Problem with that is that I don;t know who people are who have posted previously with a different name and are now a bit pissed I didn't follow through with their advice. Or it seems that I am repeating myself. (Which I am - L.O.L.)

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 23:43

Thank you @Pigglesworth for such an informative and in-depth reply. And I see how that can have happened in the case you describe, and the similarities in my situation.

I didn't mean it to sound as though she is screaming about ending it all just when I personally don't respond to her (although on whatever Bank Holiday it was this week, she did have the Police out, and earlier I had brushed her off - but it is likely that she got herself in a state anyway; however, i did ask myself if, if I had heard her out - would she have taken it to that level. Maybe she would have, regardless. That has happened before.) - I cannot be that important. There are usually other causes that she has built up in her mind.

I do not see myself as a child in her and her behaviour. Althhough there is a common thread of rejection - and I for SURE did not have (or need, I don't think) anyone to help me the way i am helping her. EVER. So there may be a (well-hidden) maternal streak that has not been full extinguished.

She is mentally disabled, and I was/AM not. My IQ (fwiw) is double hers - not that THAT has got me far either.

I do "suffer" from what I call Inverse Narcissim, in that, I ONLY see myself how others see me (I think it is decscrinbed as an external focus of identity) and therefore I guess need people to approve of me for whatever reason, otherwise I do not apppove of myself/or eve exist. This is lifelong and deeply ingrained [but I only recently figuredit out), and does not usually hurt ayone except me. And it would never have really occured to me that the low-level help I have offered (and now resent, sadly) would be harmful. So, I do consider myself educated on that.

Sooner or later, the "woe is me" comes through, I am ashamed to say; I do try to keep a lid on it.

OP posts:
FloraPostePosts · 23/04/2022 23:33

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 23:27

I understand that much, although didn;t realise that my voice was so recognisable...... But I wondered mainly how people connected a thread with a different user name, that''s all. (And why bother changing it, if it still shows up in a search or something, rather than just to me.) Some people who have commented and advised on here, do not appear on the pevious threads, so they might have changed the user names to. Very confusing (to me).

I’ve probably name changed three or four times since I commented on your previous threads. It’s very normal to do so, regularly, on fora.

Your story, though, is so unusual that it would be impossible for anyone who had read one of your earlier threads not to connect the two. I’ve never come across anyone else who lives next door to a small block of housing association flats, keeps their piano next door with a male neighbour from whom they want to extricate themselves but can’t, and is also overly involved with a female neighbour who is mentally unwell and causes trouble all the time.

It’s not a story one encounters every day!

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 23:27

FloraPostePosts · 23/04/2022 23:21

It’s easy to recognise you from your earlier threads, because you have told us all about both your neighbours in them, and your situation is unusual, so clearly I’m not the only poster in whose mind your threads have lodged. Your voice is recognisable, too, but it’s mainly the fact that people do have memory for the contents and journey of threads, particularly those where they have gone out of their way to offer advice. Doing so takes thought and effort, and for myself, I do remember threads where I’ve done that in particular.

I understand that much, although didn;t realise that my voice was so recognisable...... But I wondered mainly how people connected a thread with a different user name, that''s all. (And why bother changing it, if it still shows up in a search or something, rather than just to me.) Some people who have commented and advised on here, do not appear on the pevious threads, so they might have changed the user names to. Very confusing (to me).

OP posts:
FloraPostePosts · 23/04/2022 23:21

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 22:56

Could I ask? When people are saying they have read my previous thread/s - are they ones with another user name (which is how I posted about at least one of these situations originally)? If so, how is that possible?

It’s easy to recognise you from your earlier threads, because you have told us all about both your neighbours in them, and your situation is unusual, so clearly I’m not the only poster in whose mind your threads have lodged. Your voice is recognisable, too, but it’s mainly the fact that people do have memory for the contents and journey of threads, particularly those where they have gone out of their way to offer advice. Doing so takes thought and effort, and for myself, I do remember threads where I’ve done that in particular.

Pigglesworth · 23/04/2022 23:20

zingally · 23/04/2022 16:28

I'm sorry if I upset you with the reference to the horse stuff. That wasn't my intention. I was more trying (perhaps clumsily) to illustrate a point that you always (certainly unintentionally) have a reason/excuse why you've continued to engage with this NDN (and the male friend - but that's a whole other thread, I know), and have not managed to act on the very consistent advice you've gotten, both on this thread, and your others.

You said in your reply to me that you "can hardly take action this second." And whilst that is true, why didn't you take the advice given, at least twice previously - say, yesterday? Last week? February? Before Christmas? Last time you posted?

I seem to remember from the previous thread (see, it stayed with me), that when others suggested you look at getting some therapy, you couldn't because your doctor wouldn't take you seriously. Commenters said get a new doctor. Have you actioned that advice?

You also discussed struggling to feed yourself and male friend with a single slow cooker/pressure cooker (I can't remember which), but there was another available in a box, that just needed a space clearing for it. Have you actioned that?

It was suggested that you distance yourself from male friend (which you wanted at the time), by returning the key to the horse yard. Have you done that?

Meant as kindly as I humanly can OP... I'm guessing the answers to all the above are a variation of "no, but..."

Do you see where people are coming from? You must surely see that every single commenter is giving you a variation of "say no", but you don't/can't/won't.

I do truly wish you the best, and I'm sure all the other commenters do as well. But you've got to take responsibility for you, and make whatever changes need making in order for you to be happy. Umpteen people have all said the same thing, and unless you are genuinely hearing us, nothing will change.

This scenario reminds me of a situation shared by an amazing, well-known, and highly regarded trauma therapist, Janina Fisher, in a podcast I listen to (The Trauma Therapist - Episode 3). She was asked about a clinical mistake she had made. She spoke about a client like this woman you are struggling with, who had Borderline Personality Disorder (I don't recall if Janina specified that diagnosis but that was the behavioural/psychological pattern). The client sought more and more help/input from Janina, for example wanting to call her out of hours for crises, wanting Janina to read her journal entries between sessions and write responses, all of which Janina did in her desire to be there for the client. Over time instead of this helping, the client got worse in terms of symptoms, demanding more, angrier with Janina for not meeting her needs sufficiently in her mind, and eventually making a formal complaint against her, resulting in Janina losing her job. A very brave thing to share. Janina's motivation was wanting to be helpful to the client, but her behaviour had the opposite effect, rewarding the client's dysfunctional behaviour/way of relating to others, and sending the message to the client that she was reliant on Janina and not able to cope on her own.

I see this same pattern here. Your misguided effort to "be kind" is not kind in its impact on this woman - you are contributing to concealing her full needs from the authorities and giving more of an impression she can cope. She needs to be screaming outside that she'll end it all (as you say she would do if you didn't respond to her) and have as many emergency service visits as are warranted, as then her full needs are more clear and the authorities will be more clear on what formal help she needs and whether or not her current living situation is tenable. You are not qualified to be her carer, social worker or therapist. By trying to fill this gap you are harming her, even if well-intentioned.

I would also be very interested in your responses to the questions of the previous poster who asked about the extent to which you acted on those previous specific bits of advice. I noticed that you did not answer this and your tone shifted, communicating helplessness and despondence and feeling misunderstood. I think you need to reflect on why you feel a need to "be nice" and why your understanding of what that means differs from others, and what needs of your own you are meeting with your behaviour. You are the steward of your own life and only you can make changes or consider/adopt more functional patterns of behaviour that will help you long term. This woman does not represent you as a child. She sounds severely mentally ill. Everyone is different and what you needed as a child is not necessarily what another person needs.

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 23:17

GettinPiggyWithIt · 23/04/2022 23:06

OP you need to toughen up.

pamic attacks over being mildly assertive?
stop being such a doormat and tell her to leave you alone

Panic attacks over "being mildly assertive" on top of other things that are bothering me....
People never know when they are the last straw for someone.
(Inlcuding on the internet.)

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 23:14

@ManateeFair Again - I am NOT dismissing the advice. I am absorbing all of it, and will follow some of it if I can.

I must have it the wrong way round then - but facing facts, no-one official is going to simply listen to her having a"moan" about bf, or her situation, are they? It escalates to them - by her - when no-one will listen to her about smaller matters, but not until.
I really did think I was just being a friend/sort of mother figure (albeit reluctantly) about some of the things - and am a bit more life-experienced. I do not infantalise her, or I didn't think I did.

OP posts:
GettinPiggyWithIt · 23/04/2022 23:06

OP you need to toughen up.

pamic attacks over being mildly assertive?
stop being such a doormat and tell her to leave you alone

ManateeFair · 23/04/2022 22:58

Even when I do assert myself (i.e. lose my temper), and tell her to leave me alone, she comes again sooner or later (usually sooner).

So tell her to go away again, FFS! Don’t lose your temper and then be there for her when she comes round again. If it continues, report her for harassment.

The more I read of your follow ups, and about your other issues, the more it becomes clear that you actually have no intention of resolving the situations you’ve got yourself into. You’ve been given a ton of good advice, repeatedly, and you just keep dismissing it or trying to think of reasons you don’t agree with it.

You know how your neighbour keeps coming round and moaning about her boyfriend over and over again but won’t actually take any advice or do anything to resolve things? Well, that is exactly what you’re doing here.

The main reason your neighbour doesn’t cope and isn’t getting the help she needs from social services etc is because you have taken it upon yourself to step in instead. Why the fuck are you liaising with her social worker and phoning her college? That’s not kindness, that’s overstepping the mark. She’s a vulnerable adult and you are not her guardian, family or carer. You’re way too involved in her life.

There are many people like your neighbour living all over the country and they all manage to get by without you. Part of the reason your neighbour isn’t getting support from elsewhere is because you are stepping in all the time and fulfilling that role yourself. You’re not actually helping at this point, you’re just exacerbating her behaviour and infantilising her.

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 22:57

OakRowan · 23/04/2022 22:08

I've read your other threads too, there is definitely a you problem, not just them as a PP has said. You are causing all your own problems here, enabling people who are vulnerable and incapable to treat you like this, by not acting appropriately yourself. But you won't change, you will keep.posting variations of this, get amazing advice that you ignore and continue suffering. What a waste of your life. You aren't helping her, at all, or yourself.

I know, you are right.
Definitely a Me problem.

And I DO appreciate all the amazing advice and points of view. I won't "keep posting", I promise.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 22:56

Could I ask? When people are saying they have read my previous thread/s - are they ones with another user name (which is how I posted about at least one of these situations originally)? If so, how is that possible?

OP posts:
Crucible · 23/04/2022 22:18

Almost the same thought as OakRowan.

Crucible · 23/04/2022 22:16

I really do think you're causing her more problems by propping her up. She isn't coping, but all the while you're patching over the cracks she will remain in the community and will deteriorate. SS don't act while she is being indirectly and directly 'helped' but -
You're not helping, you're making it worse. Sorry to be blunt. There's an air of defeat about your posts, like this is all terribly inevitable that you'll keep being put upon, 'caught' 'cornered' 'spotted'. It doesn't have to be that way and you can make moves away from both these people. When you're in a hole, stop digging. Tell social services bluntly. They will be forced to help her.

OakRowan · 23/04/2022 22:08

I've read your other threads too, there is definitely a you problem, not just them as a PP has said. You are causing all your own problems here, enabling people who are vulnerable and incapable to treat you like this, by not acting appropriately yourself. But you won't change, you will keep.posting variations of this, get amazing advice that you ignore and continue suffering. What a waste of your life. You aren't helping her, at all, or yourself.

Maurepas · 23/04/2022 22:01

Is your female neighbour actually not supposed to be on permanent medication for a ''mental condition''? I am not a doctor but time was when people like her took ''mood controlling'' drug on daily basis. I knew someone who appeared completely normal when she took her drugs but acted completely insane without them.

CPL593H · 23/04/2022 21:54

OK, you get your wish and move away ASAP (and if it will help you, I sincerely hope that you can)

What will she do then? I think you know in your heart that you are not indispensable to her, you are just making yourself available at the moment. You can say no now, and if you don't do so, you are doing neither her or yourself any favours.

I don't think this will have any plangency as pretty much everyone is saying variants of the same thing.

polarbearoverthere · 23/04/2022 21:50

Hi,

I couldn’t read and not respond. I haven’t read the whole thread but there has been some excellent advice from others, particularly around boundaries. If this lady has an attachment disorder she struggles with relationships with others and asking for help/developing closeness in appropriate and healthy ways. By working with her in the way that you are (being reactive to the crises as they happen), you may be inadvertently being much less helpful than you intend. You’re reinforcing something for her - that when she reaches out to others in chaotic ways then she is seen and heard.

From what you’ve said, there is a lot of support available to her. I’m not suggesting that you fully withdraw but have clearer, firmer, transparent boundaries for her sake as much as yours. This might involve her being able to talk to (at?) you between 10-11am each day or Wednesday afternoons, whatever works for you and allows you to reduce the guilty feelings you have. When she comes to your friend’s flat, tell her that you are eating and she cannot come in; that you are available when you have agreed. Then be available then, so she can learn that she can trust that; keep consistent. This could be really good for her and I hope better for you. She is quite capable of eliciting help from professionals in emergencies.

The second part is to deal with the challenging feelings that setting boundaries produces in you. This could be by accessing therapy or simple exercises like identifying what your brain is telling you will go wrong when the anxiety attack comes along, then weighing up whether that’s true/likely/unlikely/unhelpful.

I’m sorry to say but you cannot solve all this lady’s issues; they have developed over her whole life. You can care and support from a distance that also allows you to care for and support yourself. I really admire how much you want to help and I wish you all the best.

veronicagoldberg · 23/04/2022 21:48

Ignore her. Block her.

You're being a mug.

Swipe left for the next trending thread