Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Needy Neighbour - still - again

234 replies

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 11:22

Disclosure - I have written about this situation before, and do try to keep out of it, but it keeps evolving as these things do. Note also, that I did agree to be her baby's Godmother [last minute request], but baby has now been adopted, and no more contact.

The very first time I wrote about this, I was told by some that I was over-invested and have a saviour-complex (I wish...), and as I have said above, I obviously did not succeed in creating, if not actual, at least figurative distance.

The young woman who lives next door (she in small apartments - 8 total; me in s/d house alongside) is someone I have known OF for quite a few years. I am old enough to be her mother (my own daughter is 5 years older than her); she has adoptive parents who live a little distance away (n/c with birth parents or family) but they are very very cold with her, although do help with lifts and things and (are supposed to) take care of her money (benefits are paid to them and they give hr an allowance - NOTE, I have just found out that they are not keping on top of her household bills, as agreed, as debt collectors have shown up for BG and a pre-paymet meter is going in to clear unpaid amounts).
She is relying on me very heavily and as other people cut her off, and cut her out, it is falling to me. She comes round to my friend's (where I am from about 8:45pm) apartment (he is in the same complex), usually in a distressed state over her "boyfriend" (babydaddy - he is a bit useless really) - and we are both too "nice" to turn her away ; then she justs sits or stands in the living room, going over and over the same things (she does not take advice on board, she just wants to be agreed with over this man and hear her own voice). She usually interrupts the late evening meal we might be about to eat, and does not care.

I cannot leave my house without her coming out to get me to help her with something. Or, she seems to appear when I return..... And I have been very snappish with her, but she is not deterred - and then anyway I feel terrible and cannot focus on what I was meant to be doing (which I realise is my own weakness and stupidity). I am now disproportionatey anxious over this (as, as I have tried to explain to her, her dramatics (and they CAN be - and she usually involved the Police herself....) can be on top of something else that I am trying to figure out in my own life at that time.

I cannot seem to get the balnce right - and I think I AM looking on here for someone to rant to myself (so in a way, like my neighbour....). It is just not easy to detach when there is no physical escape, and everything I think of that might help would actually result in further involevemnt, not less.
[And I do like to think that I am somewhat kind and (was) reasonably patient.]

Example, last night, we were just about tp eat - about 9:40 (very bad itself, and another issue of mine) and she appeared at the patio door (even though sheer curtains were drawn) waving her phone at me to speak to her Social Worker. She fell on the floor crying, and put her head on my knees, and was freezing cold, having been walking aroun the village (looking for the bf I think....) in her dressing gown. She didnt leave until 10:30 - and I believe she didn't settle at home even then, as her gate was open at minight (a bad sign).

For whatever advice I am seeking (and yes, I DO want to move/not easy - as this is very much a proximity issue, I don't think she respects me or my opionion or feelings at all....), please don't tell me to Get a Life, or that I am over-invested, because I do really try not to be.

But...... Heeeelp.....?
Please

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 10:13

BluKorner · 24/04/2022 10:04

My story is all over MN; people seem keen on searching my posts out, so maybe someone can refer you

Well no, no one is searching your posts out. You have posted about this same situation several times, and it’s so unique, that of course we are going to remember you.

And each previous thread was long with several pages of advice, yet however months later, you’re in the same situation asking for advice again.

That’s why PPs are now becoming harsh with you.

Actually, I did think that they were sort of different situations, but connected, so yes there is a common theme (me, of course.....). First, issues with my friend and how trying to "help" him/myself; then (or first) needy neighbour, maybe once or twice, and certainly around the time of her baby being Christened (January this year) - and I have also posted about family issues and background - which itself has cropped up in the other threads. I suppose I must seem to be prolific. And boring.

Maybe I wasn't even technically asking for advice (despite the use of the word "Help" (rolleyes), I just needed someone/many someones to talk to. It does kind of serve me right, when I have remained stuck, and am still complaining about it.

OP posts:
FloraPostePosts · 24/04/2022 10:12

@LoveMyPiano It’s clear that you have multiple issues here, for which you need and deserve some help. That’s why I gave you details yesterday of counselling services. Getting help is really very easy. I know you might be reluctant, because while you are intelligent enough to know that your behaviours need to change, but you are probably afraid of giving them up, because you feel they keep you safe at the moment. But the way you live is wearing you down, and isn’t sustainable.

If you can muster up the courage to take the first step towards talking to someone, your life will be infinitely better for it. But you need professional help to get better, as clearly an advice board isn’t helping you. All that is happening is that you are taking the comments here as another stick to beat yourself with, another bit of evidence that you don’t deserve to live better than this, and that’s not going to do you any good.

godmum56 · 24/04/2022 10:11

" I WILLtry tp get them to help ME with this,"

can you not see that that statement puts you in between the person and the statutory services who should be supplying those service to her?
The more normal phraseology would be "I will get them to help her" with no mention of yourself.
I also remember the godmother post and now we see the the backstory you left out.
I suspect tht you are not posting here for advice but for approval.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/04/2022 10:10

Believe me, I really really, really did not want to become enbroiled in this

If this is so, I'm wondering why you're "making lists" of what she can do, allowing her to "fling herself through the door" and the rest? You mentioned that she'll just escalate the drama if you don't respond, but surely that matters less if she's not doing it inside yours or your friend's home?

There seems no answer to this if you're not prepared to step right back, and whether to do that or not is a choice

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 10:07

PonyPatter44 · 24/04/2022 09:46

Its the piano, isn't it? Its the piano stopping you moving, because its hard to find somewhere cheap to rent that has enough space for a piano, but also becase moving a piano is expensive and tricky.

I have a book about pre-war Germany, that mentions a tiny number of well-off families in Berlin refused to flee when the true horror of Nazism arose, because they had a piano, and it was impossible to leave with it.

Obviously you're not at risk to that degree, but there is still something stopping you moving on. I think it can be very difficult if you have previously been quite emotionally isolated, to suddenly have people who want to be with you, or "need" you. Perhaps its not just the piano, but it is your neighbours who are an additional emotional piano, if you like.

Someone upthread suggested you find a different way of helping. You are clearly someone with a great deal of compassion and empathy, but who might benefit from having a third party to help you set boundaries. Could you volunteer with a homeless charity, or a hospice, or a food bank?

I don't know if you answered this question before, but why do you and your friend eat so late at night? Do you actually work odd hours, and he relies on you to cook for him?

Thank you for understanding... But no, it isn't the piano. although I have a sentimental attachment to it. When I first was going through divorce, I had a plan to live in a windmill (tower) and there was an issue the, because not enough of a straight wall. But the piano would not have stopped me then, or now. (Back story/boring re. my grandmother....)

I have never - apart from when I was a mother - eaten well (quantity, not type of food), or at the right time (posted recently about ED rearing it's head again, if it ever went away). I probably would not eat at all, were it not for making food for someone else, whoever they might be. It must be what remains of my caring side, and I believe my friend would not eat well, due to having a very long day, with work bracketed by seeing to his horse in the morning and evenining, until around 8:30pm.

OP posts:
BluKorner · 24/04/2022 10:04

My story is all over MN; people seem keen on searching my posts out, so maybe someone can refer you

Well no, no one is searching your posts out. You have posted about this same situation several times, and it’s so unique, that of course we are going to remember you.

And each previous thread was long with several pages of advice, yet however months later, you’re in the same situation asking for advice again.

That’s why PPs are now becoming harsh with you.

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 09:56

FlowerArranger · 24/04/2022 09:26

You are now becoming defensive - almost passively agressive!

Instead of hitting out at posters, why not tell us WHAT is actually stopping you from following the advice that you asked for?

For all I know, someone may post wanting me to babble on about my "tragic" past (already referenced - to my eternal shame) - and they may be someone i have offended by not taking their advice (but they have a different username on this thread....) previously. And then I will be told, "by umpteen people"/"everyone" that my "lelngthy explananations" are just going over the same ground, with no forward motion. I am wary of that, still do it, like the fool I am, but I forgive myself for being defensive.
But I cannot go into my boring and ugly backstory, to have that handwaved away.
The advice - greatly welcome and taking on board - WILL be (selectively) acted on; I have not said that it won't. I dont know why people seem to want to believe that, because I have found it difficult/impossible until now - and yes, have created another boring post for people to CHOOSE to read and comment - does not mean that I won't try to do what I can, "going forward".

I have never wanted, nor sought out, involvement with her. Nor have I made more than one or two calls about or for her. It is one-way only - and I fully admit, I am NOT good at shutting peple down, and that comes from my own miserable start and childhood, unfortunately.

But I will not be the last straw for her - I have to believe the threats she makes to harm herself, even if it is (and by and large it IS) manipulation.

Despite posters telling me to not make contact with SW/SS, I WILLtry tp get them to help ME with this, and fulfil their obligations to her, leaving m out of it.

I have said that I cannot MOVE house, that does not mean that I can not and will not take (some of) the appreaciated advice, no-one is giving me much of a chance, given that I posted yesterday (and yes, before....) and I have at NO point, dimissed opinions, but have responded in my tedious and lengthy manner, which I suppose is seen as reluctance and dimissiveness. I promise - it has not. It has not really helped my mood, but is terrifically motivating!

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 24/04/2022 09:46

Its the piano, isn't it? Its the piano stopping you moving, because its hard to find somewhere cheap to rent that has enough space for a piano, but also becase moving a piano is expensive and tricky.

I have a book about pre-war Germany, that mentions a tiny number of well-off families in Berlin refused to flee when the true horror of Nazism arose, because they had a piano, and it was impossible to leave with it.

Obviously you're not at risk to that degree, but there is still something stopping you moving on. I think it can be very difficult if you have previously been quite emotionally isolated, to suddenly have people who want to be with you, or "need" you. Perhaps its not just the piano, but it is your neighbours who are an additional emotional piano, if you like.

Someone upthread suggested you find a different way of helping. You are clearly someone with a great deal of compassion and empathy, but who might benefit from having a third party to help you set boundaries. Could you volunteer with a homeless charity, or a hospice, or a food bank?

I don't know if you answered this question before, but why do you and your friend eat so late at night? Do you actually work odd hours, and he relies on you to cook for him?

bluegreygreen · 24/04/2022 09:41

@LoveMyPiano

OP, I also remember your posts, though I don't believe I have previously contributed to your threads. The story in itself is unique, and you have a distinctive writing style.

I have little to add in the way of advice to the helpful comments you have already had. As others have said, the situation will not change until you change your own behaviour in relation to it.

Your writing makes me suspect you enjoy words, and may enjoy reading. There is a book you may find helpful - 'Games People Play' by Eric Berne. You were upset when @zingally suggested that you were being given advice but were refusing to accept it, challenging her to 'quote' where you had done that. Someone other than you (and possibly you if you are able to read back with a little distance) can recognise in many of your posts a pattern: initial acceptance followed by overt objection (but, however) or more detailed reasoning why that advice could not be followed, despite it working well in parallel circumstances.

I wish you all the best - finding patterns in our own behaviours can be the first step in working out the way forward.

FlowerArranger · 24/04/2022 09:26

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 08:52

(Hopefully) - if you knew my "story", and you knew my mother, you wouldn't agree withh her.
My story is all over MN; people seem keen on searching my posts out, so maybe someone can refer you.

You are now becoming defensive - almost passively agressive!

Instead of hitting out at posters, why not tell us WHAT is actually stopping you from following the advice that you asked for?

OakRowan · 24/04/2022 09:26

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 08:50

No. "We" are not.
I understand why you might (choose to) think that, but you are vey wrong.

Get some help for yourself then, this isn't normal, or healthy and you are causing this woman immense harm. Leave her alone and get yourself some mental health support and treatment instead. No one is seeking out your posts, that's paranoid, you have been writing the same things over and over for a long time and its so memorable and visible. You are reinforcing your own problems by continuing to post on here for validation and support that you don't act on, that you ignore, you are literally making your own life worse, yourself, not just your neighbours. You are doing it to yourself and expecting help and sympathy and even admiration at your selfless rescuing of this woman and that's not ok.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 24/04/2022 09:19

I didn't realise ndn girl and messy kitchen man were both involved in your life.

I'm going to be harsh but honest. You need therapy, you do have a saviour complex or at best a pathological desire to disadvantage yourself. Why do you not value yourself?

You are also preventing ndn girl from getting more help, every time you crisis councel her you are obscuring how she isn't coping, and probably also male neighbour.

You can't change or help those that don't wish to change or be helped.

AchillesPoirot · 24/04/2022 09:01

Get therapy for yourself to enable you to put stronger boundaries in place.

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 08:52

Wantosleep39 · 24/04/2022 08:18

Op sounds like you are not capable to take necessary actions to make any changes. Unfortunately I am agree with your mum saying about your life.
I am interested to hear how did you become like this. What is your story?

(Hopefully) - if you knew my "story", and you knew my mother, you wouldn't agree withh her.
My story is all over MN; people seem keen on searching my posts out, so maybe someone can refer you.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 08:50

OakRowan · 24/04/2022 04:11

What is really going on here OP, are you all adults with mental health problems living in supported accommodation, next door to each other but living as independently as you can in the community? Do you work, have family near by or have a support worker of your own? Who is helping you and looking after you? That's starting to be the only explanation I can think of for this extraordinary, long running situation.

No. "We" are not.
I understand why you might (choose to) think that, but you are vey wrong.

OP posts:
AngelaRayner4PM · 24/04/2022 08:26

Don't you have a child of your own? You say that living this way isn't harming anyone but if you have poor boundaries and are having very dysfunctional people around you and your child that could be a safeguarding issue in itself
As much as this woman does sound like she is crying out for help and really needs support, I think you do need to have clear boundaries (which may seem harsh) in this situation. It is not kindness to not give people boundaries, often it contributes to a pattern of negative behaviour for them and blurs the lines and make them think you have a different role in their life than to do. I would ring adult social services for advice on how to deal with this individual, and please heed it. This is making you and your possible child very vulnerable and in a difficult situation, and is not the kindness you think it is to this damaged traumatised young woman

Wantosleep39 · 24/04/2022 08:18

Op sounds like you are not capable to take necessary actions to make any changes. Unfortunately I am agree with your mum saying about your life.
I am interested to hear how did you become like this. What is your story?

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 24/04/2022 04:58

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 12:52

Yes (and I did disclose in my OP, but didn't want to retell it all....), I AM the one who posted about both her, and the situation with my friend. Both of which, to be honest, I truly want to escape, or at the very least change. I just - my own issues I guess - don't seem able to, I do hate it, by the way - and have little to no support, which is why I identify with and feel sorry for NDN.

My writing style must be qute recognisable, I guess. I can't seem to change that either though (a bit wordy probably).

It has taken mental toll over the last year, and I had just taken the resolve to protect my own mind - so of course, have failed at that as well.

My fear IS that the SWs think I can take this on, when quite the opposite is true. And I am certainly not qualified for it, so they should not push it onto me either....

I did not intend to drag my friend into it (and the issues wrt him/me remain, as he is the ultimate "stick in the mud" - there are things that he could change about his life, and does not) but she would have done anyway, as she has one by one involved herself with other people in the apartments.... Two out of the eight have actually moved out BECAUSE of her, and she is causing problems for two of those who have moved in since - one directly above.

I am resurrecting a plan (wish, more like) that I had over five years ago - which unfortnately WILL need money, and a little more than I have - that will I hope mean that I can live out my life in a more peaceful and suitable (for me) setting. Otherwise, I cannot see a way forward.

What a difficult situation!

I think regardless of what has happened- social services believe that all her neighbours are being very supportive... Essentially, however aversive, you're mopping up the care.

I would write/ call ssd.. On your own behalf...
Tell them things have become so bad for your health that you're looking to move ... 'as other neighbours have done'..

And give some examples of some incidences...

Tell them formally....
Otherwise you/other helpful neighbours are just papering over the cracks...

I think most communities have people like this... Who insist they can manage, and but their managing is recruiting large numbers of neighbours to support their mental health.

Sadly nothing much will change til you make a stand....

TerenceTrentLoughborough · 24/04/2022 04:35

@LoveMyPiano
Because I have nowhere to go - and no money to do it.
And because, "Wherever you go, you take yourself with you".
and because I am Me.

So you've decided that nothing will ever change. Okay. So why create threads and ask for advice you know you won't take? For what purpose are you posting on Mumsnet? Posters are not validating your current position; they are telling you you're wrong to believe you're helpless. Why does that cause you so much cognitive dissonance? Think about it.

Ring the duty social worker for your area (Google it) about this woman.

Make a GP appointment to discuss your mental health and support needs.

Or, don't. Carry on as you are. Its up to you, not strangers online. Nothing will change unless you change it. You have the power and the agency to change things, however much you tell yourself and the world that you don't. You do. You are in control.

I wish you well.

OakRowan · 24/04/2022 04:11

What is really going on here OP, are you all adults with mental health problems living in supported accommodation, next door to each other but living as independently as you can in the community? Do you work, have family near by or have a support worker of your own? Who is helping you and looking after you? That's starting to be the only explanation I can think of for this extraordinary, long running situation.

OakRowan · 24/04/2022 02:31

Crucible · 23/04/2022 22:16

I really do think you're causing her more problems by propping her up. She isn't coping, but all the while you're patching over the cracks she will remain in the community and will deteriorate. SS don't act while she is being indirectly and directly 'helped' but -
You're not helping, you're making it worse. Sorry to be blunt. There's an air of defeat about your posts, like this is all terribly inevitable that you'll keep being put upon, 'caught' 'cornered' 'spotted'. It doesn't have to be that way and you can make moves away from both these people. When you're in a hole, stop digging. Tell social services bluntly. They will be forced to help her.

I agree with Crucible, you are trapping this woman from being able to meet the higher thresholds of accessing better care for herself, because of 'helping' her. Everything you write sets yourself up as powerless and a victim, you will try, you will give it a go, you are so grateful and are listening but its sooo hard. For you. I can guarantee its harder for her and you are hurting her. But you aren't listening, or helping, you are choosing to behave and interact with a mentally ill woman who is much, much more vulnerable than you and its cruel, that you have no boundaries. And you think that's helpful, supportive kind, its isn't, its all about you. Because of you and your contact with the staff/services around her she is perceived as having more support than is real, because of what you do, it is wildly inappropriate, she lacks capacity but you do not, you are actively choosing this.

Inverse narcissism? Give over. You are preventing working professional people from being able to do their jobs and her from accessing a pathway where she could potentially be admitted as an in patient for treatment, which might help her, might change her life, or may not tbh, but you are that barrier, you are causing harm to her and honestly after all this time I think your behaviour is appalling. She needs keeping safe, from you, enabling her and prolonging, deepening and strengthening her disfunction and unhappiness. Leave her alone, you are not a victim here.

HairyMuttttt · 24/04/2022 01:33

Not read all the thread. However in your shoes I would be polite, firm and consistently and immediately (without knowing full details) direct her to ring her social worker, duty social worker, parents or police there and then. Don't make the call on her behalf and don’t touch her phone (even if she attempts to put it in your hands). Simply redirect consistently to SW or police and politely say you’re very sorry to rush off but you’ve a lot on. Keep moving and don’t stop walking! I suspect the SW really should be coordinating a few hours of daily support for the young woman, particularly during evening hours when she regularly becomes upset. However you’re presently plugging this gap!!. Removing your support will likely mean things will temporarily spiral downwards for her and hit rock bottom, however it’s likely that things will need to fall apart first for her to gain the support she really needs. This will be hard for you and her. Potentially much higher levels of police involvement and her feeling upset. To preempt this I would inform both the SW and young woman that you feel bombarded are stepping back for your own health. Then keep blinds consistently down, doors consistently locked and wear headphones or be busy on the phone wile exiting the house over the next few weeks

BluKorner · 24/04/2022 00:56

I too remember your previous threads…because you have posted about this situation several times and it’s highly unlikely there’s another MN user going through the same thing. So I haven’t looked for or dug out your old posts - I just remember them and remember all the advice you got, which is the same advice here.

You have two options - cut contact or contact SS. These were the same options given to you in your other threads, and the advice isn’t going to change every time you create a new thread about the same situation.

WhereWasThatFrom · 24/04/2022 00:35

OP, what else do you do with your time? Being 'nice' is a wonderful characteristic to have but you are being nice to the wrong people. Is there a local church, charity or organisation where you could help? I don't know if it's a possibility or not but it would give you something else to do and give you an opportunity to meet new people.

By the way I recognised you from your other posts. I feel so sorry for you but you really really need to start listening to people advice. You want things to change but don't seem willing to change anything you are doing. It's only going to get worse and you are not helping.

FlowerArranger · 24/04/2022 00:24

fwiw, I too remember your story from at least one of your previous threads, OP. Even though I didn't offer advice myself but simply because of the utter craziness of it all. Your whole situation, and your attitude and constant excuses, are totally and extraordinarily exasperating. And impossible to forget...

You need to ignore the mentally ill NDN.
You need to get your piano back and cut the male 'friend' out of your life.

Live your own life, in your own home, and stop trying to be 'kind' to people who are making you utterly miserable and who are robbing you of your life.
And get counselling for yourself. This is essential.

Swipe left for the next trending thread