Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Needy Neighbour - still - again

234 replies

LoveMyPiano · 23/04/2022 11:22

Disclosure - I have written about this situation before, and do try to keep out of it, but it keeps evolving as these things do. Note also, that I did agree to be her baby's Godmother [last minute request], but baby has now been adopted, and no more contact.

The very first time I wrote about this, I was told by some that I was over-invested and have a saviour-complex (I wish...), and as I have said above, I obviously did not succeed in creating, if not actual, at least figurative distance.

The young woman who lives next door (she in small apartments - 8 total; me in s/d house alongside) is someone I have known OF for quite a few years. I am old enough to be her mother (my own daughter is 5 years older than her); she has adoptive parents who live a little distance away (n/c with birth parents or family) but they are very very cold with her, although do help with lifts and things and (are supposed to) take care of her money (benefits are paid to them and they give hr an allowance - NOTE, I have just found out that they are not keping on top of her household bills, as agreed, as debt collectors have shown up for BG and a pre-paymet meter is going in to clear unpaid amounts).
She is relying on me very heavily and as other people cut her off, and cut her out, it is falling to me. She comes round to my friend's (where I am from about 8:45pm) apartment (he is in the same complex), usually in a distressed state over her "boyfriend" (babydaddy - he is a bit useless really) - and we are both too "nice" to turn her away ; then she justs sits or stands in the living room, going over and over the same things (she does not take advice on board, she just wants to be agreed with over this man and hear her own voice). She usually interrupts the late evening meal we might be about to eat, and does not care.

I cannot leave my house without her coming out to get me to help her with something. Or, she seems to appear when I return..... And I have been very snappish with her, but she is not deterred - and then anyway I feel terrible and cannot focus on what I was meant to be doing (which I realise is my own weakness and stupidity). I am now disproportionatey anxious over this (as, as I have tried to explain to her, her dramatics (and they CAN be - and she usually involved the Police herself....) can be on top of something else that I am trying to figure out in my own life at that time.

I cannot seem to get the balnce right - and I think I AM looking on here for someone to rant to myself (so in a way, like my neighbour....). It is just not easy to detach when there is no physical escape, and everything I think of that might help would actually result in further involevemnt, not less.
[And I do like to think that I am somewhat kind and (was) reasonably patient.]

Example, last night, we were just about tp eat - about 9:40 (very bad itself, and another issue of mine) and she appeared at the patio door (even though sheer curtains were drawn) waving her phone at me to speak to her Social Worker. She fell on the floor crying, and put her head on my knees, and was freezing cold, having been walking aroun the village (looking for the bf I think....) in her dressing gown. She didnt leave until 10:30 - and I believe she didn't settle at home even then, as her gate was open at minight (a bad sign).

For whatever advice I am seeking (and yes, I DO want to move/not easy - as this is very much a proximity issue, I don't think she respects me or my opionion or feelings at all....), please don't tell me to Get a Life, or that I am over-invested, because I do really try not to be.

But...... Heeeelp.....?
Please

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Throckmorton · 25/04/2022 20:11

Fair enough! In that case the "something urgent" is useful, or even something like "I really can't stop right now, very sorry, bye". And it's true too - you have an urgent mission to take care of yourself, because right now YOU are the most deserving one!

LoveMyPiano · 25/04/2022 19:47

Throckmorton · 25/04/2022 19:21

Given the difficulty of dealing with these two, I would also suggest, like the poster above, keeping a low profile. You are far too busy to visit Mr Neighbour due to whatever reason you feel like giving (sudden influx of work, unspecified bout of illness, etc), and if you see Ms Neighbour out and about just look very distracted and say you're sorry but you really can't stop as something urgent has come up. It will feel rude and awkward the first time, but remember doing this is best for them too - if they are leaning on you they are not having to reach for the professional help they really need.

Thanks - great advice.

One thing I never lie/fib about thoughm is illness..... Stems from Sunday School days,, when - having told a fib about feeling ill to get out of going, I would invariably feel sick (guilt) and have to miss a riding lesson on Sunday afternoon.

I am sure I can try to become a better liar than I was aged 10 though 😏

OP posts:
Throckmorton · 25/04/2022 19:21

Given the difficulty of dealing with these two, I would also suggest, like the poster above, keeping a low profile. You are far too busy to visit Mr Neighbour due to whatever reason you feel like giving (sudden influx of work, unspecified bout of illness, etc), and if you see Ms Neighbour out and about just look very distracted and say you're sorry but you really can't stop as something urgent has come up. It will feel rude and awkward the first time, but remember doing this is best for them too - if they are leaning on you they are not having to reach for the professional help they really need.

LoveMyPiano · 25/04/2022 18:33

FlowerArranger · 25/04/2022 18:14

Your 'friend' is as unhealthy for you as your neighbour!
Stop going to your friend's every night. Don't see him more than once a fortnight, if at all.
If you do encounter the NDN, do not engage. Either rush off to some place you have to be, or go back to your house and shut the door.
Stay in and listen to Barenboim and/or Martha Algerich playing piano sonatas on Youtube.
Google for local piano moving services so you can get yours back. And start playing again.
And follow that link for counsellors that someone posted earlier - because your life would improve immeasurably if you were to undergo counselling.

Thank you - Great suggestions 💐

OP posts:
FlowerArranger · 25/04/2022 18:14

Your 'friend' is as unhealthy for you as your neighbour!
Stop going to your friend's every night. Don't see him more than once a fortnight, if at all.
If you do encounter the NDN, do not engage. Either rush off to some place you have to be, or go back to your house and shut the door.
Stay in and listen to Barenboim and/or Martha Algerich playing piano sonatas on Youtube.
Google for local piano moving services so you can get yours back. And start playing again.
And follow that link for counsellors that someone posted earlier - because your life would improve immeasurably if you were to undergo counselling.

LoveMyPiano · 25/04/2022 18:01

Hont1986 · 25/04/2022 10:34

Someone commented earlier about you sounding like you think of yourself as the heroine. I think there's a lot of truth to that. It's like watching a bad horror movie and you just think "why are the characters doing this? This is so easy to fix. Just leave the house and call the police".

You could fix 80% of these encounters overnight by just locking the door, drawing the curtains, putting a lock on the side gate, not answering the doorbell, etc. You could fix 100% of them by directly communicating your desire to stop helping to this lady, then following through by cutting all contact.

But if you did that, it would break the narrative of the bildungsroman. You can't be the main character if there is no drama, after all.

OK....

She does not have access to my house, and has always respected that boundary, it is very rare for her to knock on my door or go through the gate (which is left unlocked for the gardener and milkman anyway).

The calling round is to my friend's apartment - as she knows I will be there (but if not, she asks him about stuff) - where she has (as I have already explained) free access, due to living in the same small apartment complex.
The complex is gated, and opened electronically - but of course, she has a gate opener for all gates and there is therefore no possibility of restricting her access to his patio doors. Why the heck he/we should sit behind closed curtains in daylight is beyond me.

She will look out for and catch me, as I leave or return to my house tomy car, or on my bike or foot, or out and about in the village; where the measures you suggest are of no use - and actually where she can be most irritating due to her incredibly short attention span. (You will see people do a u-turn when they see her heading their way, and she is banned from qite a few shops.)

I do not want to be a heroine, so your agreement wth the PP(s) is not really relevant. But the Power of the Plural usually makes people fel bettter, doesn't it? I really dislike it when people jump on a bandwagon.

Thank you for your input.... Bu it really is being allowed to die a death now.

OP posts:
TerenceTrentLoughborough · 25/04/2022 10:36

LoveMyPiano · 25/04/2022 10:04

Thank you so much
@Throckmorton
@CarmenThePanda
@kittensinthekitchen
@Snog
💕
Such good advice, and I really DO need to work on my boundaries, yes.
(And yes, I understand where it comes from, in me - and in my neighbour.)

I also - haha - need to work on how much I reveal on a forum, and my writing style, it seems.

I have to be off to do some things, but a call to GP, and to SW are on ToDo list.

Thank you again.
xx

You've got this. Onward!

Hont1986 · 25/04/2022 10:34

Someone commented earlier about you sounding like you think of yourself as the heroine. I think there's a lot of truth to that. It's like watching a bad horror movie and you just think "why are the characters doing this? This is so easy to fix. Just leave the house and call the police".

You could fix 80% of these encounters overnight by just locking the door, drawing the curtains, putting a lock on the side gate, not answering the doorbell, etc. You could fix 100% of them by directly communicating your desire to stop helping to this lady, then following through by cutting all contact.

But if you did that, it would break the narrative of the bildungsroman. You can't be the main character if there is no drama, after all.

LoveMyPiano · 25/04/2022 10:04

Thank you so much
@Throckmorton
@CarmenThePanda
@kittensinthekitchen
@Snog
💕
Such good advice, and I really DO need to work on my boundaries, yes.
(And yes, I understand where it comes from, in me - and in my neighbour.)

I also - haha - need to work on how much I reveal on a forum, and my writing style, it seems.

I have to be off to do some things, but a call to GP, and to SW are on ToDo list.

Thank you again.
xx

OP posts:
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 25/04/2022 09:43

Snog · 25/04/2022 07:46

This is primarily an issue about your own boundaries OP

It's very common to struggle with boundaries if you have suffered abuse in your childhood.

There is a lot you can read online and in books about how to set and maintain good boundaries for yourself but if you can it's best to learn the skills with a therapist.

If you just move then you will take yourself with you and likely encounter similar problems again.

This...

I'd say to your GP how much your immediate environment is impacting negatively on your MH and ED.

I'd ask for an onward referral to IAPT this is a free NHS psychology service.

I'd be very clear when you reach this service... What you need.
As in issues with holding boundaries...

When folk have difficult childhoods /early attachments... They MAY be able to try some boundary behaviors... But will find it much more difficult holding these boundaries... And are much more likely to collapse in the face of people really pushing these boundaries... As in what has happened when you were a child.

I would definitely recommend practising assertiveness type skills with a therapist... So much about this... Is the saying no... And FEELING OK ABOUT IT!

kittensinthekitchen · 25/04/2022 08:38

@LoveMyPiano

I know you are NC with parents, but have you any other family, or friends, you can make yourself busy with? You have a daughter I think? Is she still living at home with you? Or close enough by to make arrangements with? Any hobbies that can take you out of the house/street?

You've suggested yourself you might be too available to her, so maybe keeping busy and unavailable is an easy way for reducing that contact, if you can manage that.

Snog · 25/04/2022 08:36

Really good advice from Carmenthepanda

CarmenThePanda · 25/04/2022 08:28

Losing your temper is not assertiveness.

Firmly and calmly saying the same thing every single time is assertively maintaining your boundaries. If you engage, ‘be nice’, even just once you are confusing her and giving her the mixed messages that mean she thinks she can keep coming back to you.

it isn’t unkind because she doesn’t benefit from your ‘help’ anyway. She just carries on. So all that has happened is that you end up stressed, bothered, disturbed.

Tell your friend to make his apartment off limits to her too. And support each other.

CarmenThePanda · 25/04/2022 08:08

You now no you cannot help her. You have tried, it goes nowhere. But she is in the habit / is fixated on asking you.

You now need to do grey rock / stuck record.

Every single time she approaches say the exact same thing: I am not able to help you, call your social worker. Do not engage.not one further comment other than ‘I cannot help, call your social worker’. Get proper curtains, do not answer the door. Put a lock on your side gate.

As well as telling SS about her.

Snog · 25/04/2022 07:46

This is primarily an issue about your own boundaries OP

It's very common to struggle with boundaries if you have suffered abuse in your childhood.

There is a lot you can read online and in books about how to set and maintain good boundaries for yourself but if you can it's best to learn the skills with a therapist.

If you just move then you will take yourself with you and likely encounter similar problems again.

Throckmorton · 25/04/2022 00:10

OP - there are three people in this situation. Two of them appear to take and not give much back. You could regard support for them as pouring water into a sieve. The other one of the three gives a lot of support, is arguably the one most in need of support, but is the one not getting any. They may be a bowl that can hold water, to follow the metaphor. That person is you. Might I suggest that you should lavish your caring nature on yourself, not either of those other two. I would turn off your doorbell, advise the bloke you will be too busy for meals wuth him just now, and ignore the woman. That will be hard, but remember you have someone who needs you more right now - you! You need to be cooking for you, reading a nice book for you, watching TV with a cuppa for you.

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 22:23

GlamorousHeifer · 24/04/2022 20:41

Something comes across a little off to me with your writing style.
It's almost as if you have cast yourself as the old fashioned heroine in your life story.
You keep thanking people for noticing you write well however you completely ignore or skim over less congratulatory posts.
A few people have asked if you are working or doing something else to fill your time, I could have missed it but I can't see that you have answered the question?
Perhaps finding something else that takes up the hours you devote TO NDN would be a good idea.

OK. You are free to do that.

I have thanked one person anout my writing, maybe two. Not many have complimented my style at all, so "keep" is not quite correct.

It would be hard to answer every post - especially when of the same theme, or tone. But I believe I mainly acknowledged all, some in more detailed way than others. My overwhelming feeling, and message, is of appreciation (I hope - with a small number of exceptions).

I have not intentioanlly cast myself in any kind of "role"; how daft. And OakRowan was wrong to say that I "enjoy" writing about this topic. I have not at all, but have tried to be polite an acknowledge people's interest and time.
For me personally, it has been a horrible way to spend (most of) the day.

I am not revealing any more about me, my life or circumstances. Would you, if you were me? 😏
I have done enough damage.

OP posts:
zingally · 24/04/2022 20:42

Thank you for your response OP.

For what it's worth, I saw the most recent post from OakRowan, and thought it pretty harsh, all things considered.
And also, for what it's worth, I can see from your posts that you are a good person, who has meant well, but it really has just backfired on you massively. And the issues you have now, with NDN AND with Male Friend, are largely because you missed (and chose to miss) opportunities to extract yourself from them and help yourself. And despite your "explanations", the reasons why you appear to have made no progress, don't really add up to a whole lot in the eyes of strangers.

I'm sorry if you found any of my comments hurtful. It wasn't intended to cause you pain, but merely to steer you towards making some forwards steps, as it appears you have stagnated rather, in handling this on your own.

I am making the decision to withdraw from this thread at this point, for the sake of my own mental health. However OP, please be assured that I DO wish you nothing but the best. That hasn't changed since the messy kitchen thread. I have thought of you often since then, and will continue to send you my good thoughts into the months ahead.

And if, at some point in the future, you manage to make positive steps towards resolving these issues, please do get in touch and let us know about them.

GlamorousHeifer · 24/04/2022 20:41

Something comes across a little off to me with your writing style.
It's almost as if you have cast yourself as the old fashioned heroine in your life story.
You keep thanking people for noticing you write well however you completely ignore or skim over less congratulatory posts.
A few people have asked if you are working or doing something else to fill your time, I could have missed it but I can't see that you have answered the question?
Perhaps finding something else that takes up the hours you devote TO NDN would be a good idea.

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 20:16

@WhereWasThatFrom
🤗x

OP posts:
WhereWasThatFrom · 24/04/2022 20:03

@OakRowan Your post is brutal and very unkind. If you genuinely believe the OP has mental health issues as you have stated then why on earth would you then lay into her like that. Some of what you write might be true but the way you are saying it is extremely snide and nasty. This is a chat forum, if you don't want to give advice then don't.

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 19:33

OK - bizarre now.... Thank you for that 😏
In caps, which are not a lot, it's just for emphasis, I do back and italicise but forget sometimes. Please - feel free not to read/comment x
Boundaries - check
Therapy - check.
Thank you for your wonderful suggestions x

OP posts:
Therealjudgejudy · 24/04/2022 19:21

I find it quite hard to read your posts op as your writing style is quite bizarre... (All the words in caps, ha ha's ect)

It seems that what you really need are boundaries. You know what you need to do but are full of excuses as to why you won't or can't follow the great advice you have been given.

You need some therapy for yourself and for your own mental health, you need to step away from these people.

LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 19:21

zingally · 24/04/2022 11:46

You seem really bemused that people remember your old threads. But your situation is unique enough to be memorable.

I've never changed my username, and I posted a few long responses to you in the messy neighbours kitchen thread. I remember writing you a step-by-step guide of how you could distance yourself from the horse yard, and - by proxy - male friend.

I don't think that individual commenters are annoyed that you haven't followed THEIR advice personally, but more that you haven't followed ANYONES.

Further back in the thread you said that therapy would be very hard to get when it was suggested (multiple times), and a poster came back with a link and a clear how-to. Another commenter said maybe you could get involved in horses again? And that was shot down by you.

I've also noticed you seem reluctant to reveal much about your current situation, such as your job and rough age. People have suggested finding something to fill your days, but that gets ignored. I can't even really get close to pinning an age on you. Some elements of your story and your writing style suggest someone really quite elderly (70+) who has practically finished with life. But then other elements, like your own mother still being alive (as far as you know), and you - I seem to recall - having a young(ish) adult daughter, doesn't really tally with someone that age. If you said you were only late 40s, I wouldn't be that surprised.

In my previous comment on here, I asked if you had actioned some VERY specific advice from the previous messy kitchen thread (and not even advice from me personally), and you ignored my questions. And when another poster asked why you hadn't answered me? They were ignored as well.

That is a clear example of the pattern of your behaviours.

You ask for advice and get two different responses in virtually every instance:
1: Distance yourself from this woman (generally from people who perhaps haven't read the whole thread, or have not seen your previous threads)
2: Here is some very specific, actionable advice for this coming week.

Your response to comment type 1 seems to be roundly ignore it until another commenter gets a bit aggravated with you, and THEN you're all "yes it's very useful! I'll definitely do it!"
And your response to comment type 2 is to either completely blank it, or come back with a reason/excuse WHY that can't/won't. But never with any element of, "but I could do related thing tweaked to my specific situation."

And then, when commenters get frustrated with your deflections and excuses, it's all "I do want to try but woe is me, I'm so useless/pathetic and here's 5 reasons why." THAT is interesting in itself. That your response to criticism, from strangers no less, is to default to passive-aggressive negative talk about yourself. In the type of "so and so is angry at me, I'll deflect that anger by making them feel sorry for me, and I'll do that by talking out loud to myself about how crap I am, and I'll slip my shitty mother and my ED in there, that'll work."
That's ^ prime "I should get a therapist" behaviour, if not for anything else. The way you talk about, and TO, yourself, is sad to see. But you do it, because it has always worked for you.

I appreciate that you took the time and effort to write this, and I have gone back to the other thread (helped by knowing that you do have the same user name). I did take some of your advice back then, so thank you for that. I am so sorry that you think that I was ignorant then; or now.

I am probably utterly repeating myself, but cannot say enough (it seems) that I appreciate the input from everyone, and THIS TIME, I will try to do what I can - bearing in mind that she is vulnerable, and I myself, am fragile - to follow elements of the advice I have been kindly given. I explained to the person who posted about horses - and that is genuine and my reasoning. I can't jump up and down gleefully at everything someone puts to me....There are quite understandble reasons for things being neither easy, nor straighforward, you see that surely?
I have not been rude , or dismissive - but certainly boring and verbose, even to myself - and definitely repetitive... So anyone who doesn't like that might choose to not involve themselves.
I have tried to answer as much as I can, even if it is with further explanation - which must have come across as negative, or hopeless - when not truly meant that way. I personally do not see this as an easy situation to resolve and work out for the best, but might were I not embroiled in it. Again, largely against my wishes - and it is NOT easy (for someone like me) to be as cold-blooded as may be needed.

I do see that the way in which I respond changes through a thread, but it must seem to you, by your description, that it is more calculated than it actually is. When it is brought to my attention like this (and again, easier on the outside looking in....), I am truly motified, and believe me, have wished so many times for the chance to edit or delete.

By blurting out more about myself, or my circumstances, i am opening up to more judgement/criticism - and I am not in the market for that these days (if I ever was). But put it this way, regardless of my parents/backgound, I AM a complete and utter disappointmnent to myself. And there we are. (There is more on one or another of the threads I made some time ago ---- yawn.)

I am not 70 yet though, athough guess my style of writing maymake me seem, oh I don't know, quaint or old-fashioned or something. I even punctuate tex messages 😏
(At least one person found my writing style, engaging, which is quite nice.)

I thought about not coming back to respond to you - in the light of the post made @OakRowan, and their very similar take on this, and on me. But that would have allowed that post to trump yours, and that would be wrong. So, if matters have been out of your mind about this, I apologise for refreshing (if you read this). Besides, I do want to (sigh) defend myself - there just wasn't the need (from my pov) for the attack from you, or them. Theirs was worse though.

Thank you so much for you advice "back then", and your input this time, apart from the horse remarks. You went to a lot of trouble. Thank you.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 24/04/2022 18:29

ComeOnNow21 · 24/04/2022 18:19

Gosh some of the replies youve received have been very harsh... particularly with regards to what your mother said. You've had good advice though in amongst it though.
It's clear you're a kind person (I remember the thread about the baptism) but that this current situation isn't working for you. Your needs as are as important as everyone elses around you. Like so many people have said, I think you'd find therapy useful. I myself resisted it for a long time but it was a great investment of time and money... helped me work on my boundaries and work out what I needed to do to create a life I enjoyed. Change doesn't happen overnight. I wish you well.

Ah, thank you.
I didn't - and won't, now - offer a clear enough picture of what my Mother said, and the context. We are NC - and she has several other daughters, so is fine as she can be, I imagine. Oh, and she was wrong.
I feel sure I would benefit from Therapy of some sort (Group didn't work - haha), you are right. It must be very helpful. I am glad it helped you x

OP posts: