Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Homework club for a Year 4, AIBU to say no?

56 replies

SickofHomework · 23/04/2022 10:48

DD is currently Year 3 (7 almost 8 years old). We’re in a 3-tier system so she has 1 more year left after she finishes Year 3 of Primary/First School before Middle School (midlands before anyone asks).

DD has some SN and because of that I had to get rid of her tablet and laptop. She was just too attached to them, refused to come off or use them just for homework, tried to take it to bed with her (never managed it) and would refuse to do anything else at all until I promised her tablet time.

When I got rid (when she was in Year 2) I told school she would need paper copies of any homework, I told them I was happy to pay for printing costs, or if they’d prefer, they could email it to me and I’d use the printer at work (with permission). They refused, told me I needed to give the tablet back as they use apps only for homework. I have repeatedly explained why I got rid of the tablet (I kept the laptop and occasionally use it although I have a work laptop if I need to work), and I am sticking with that decision as when DD goes round to friends or family she asks if they have a tablet and will sit on that for the whole time, we’re there rather than play with family and it’s a battle to get her off it. School told me she needs to learn to self-regulate it but she just won’t, she’d sit all day and do nothing else.

I have asked both the teachers since I got rid of the tablet and mentioned it to the SENCo all of whom made the right noises and said they’d sort it then came back to me and said it’s apps onluy.

(For context her SN is dyslexia, Developmental Co-ordination Disorder/Dyspraxia and an eye condition – tablet is not good for her eye condition either).

School is now saying that as she’s done no homework this year and got 0/0 on every spelling test (yep even spelling practice is an app) that when she gets to Year 4, she’ll have to go to homework club on 2 nights a week, these will be the 2 nights her teacher runs the club and she will just be kept back and not released to me. They’ve said the children will be given the school ipads to work on their homework.

DD does activities on some nights, which she loves. She also hates school so keeping her there longer may tip her over the edge, we already get violent meltdowns. I also try and make appointments for her eye condition after school but they aren’t on a set night as I will go to whichever clinic her consultant is at (he runs it at 1 local hospital but also runs clinics in the 2 next counties along and will just fit patients in wherever there’s a gap rather than say we must be seen at X hospital).

AIBU to say no they can’t keep her as I’ve repeatedly asked for paper copies of the homework? They’ve told me she’ll fail the year (whatever that means) if she doesn’t do homework and she will “not be prepared for Year 5 and the independence needed”.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SickofHomework · 29/04/2022 08:11

Update:

Have been doing the spellings as suggested here, so DD writing them down and me inputting the spellings into app via my phone. It's still not 100% but I'm using the Year 2 and 3 spellings and I'd say matching 90-95% so at least there's some benefit.

I've agreed DD can go to homework club 1 night a week if this isn't good enough, but I want it to be a night she'd be at wraparound anyway. School haven't got back to me on that yet.

OP posts:
Omega33 · 25/04/2022 00:01

The school shouldn't try to force homework club or use it as a punishment, but do you think it could actually be useful? At least if you could choose the days so that it didn't conflict with other activities.

It would allow her to get homework done and use tablets only at school, hopefully meaning she will understand that there's no screen time at home. And if that doesn't work, the school will be able to see her reactions to the end of screen time themselves.

FWIW I regularly attended the homework club at secondary school because my family couldn't afford a computer (although less homework required computers then). I never particularly saw it as a punishment - it was the same amount of homework whether I did it at home or at school.

helloitsnotmeanymore · 24/04/2022 23:44

I thinks it pretty normal for kids not to self regulate iPad time. Mine don't and I give a 5 minute warning, when time is up, then I say turn off. They very rarely do, so I say I will be taking the iPad in 5 4 3 2 1 and I take it. My youngest on occasions cries and throws a wobbly, sometimes rolls about and has a rage and I ignore it for a bit. And then I distract with something else and she's over it. She is very feisty. Generally l would say she is improving on this every time. My older DC just gives a sad face then he's onto the next thing.

I have set my own limit and it generally is the same per session, but I'm flexible and they don't notice exactly.

The homework club sounds ideal really. When the club ends so does screen time, let them manage it a bit. Take the pressure off you.

Soontobe60 · 24/04/2022 16:10

apps is incredibly lazy as there is no work involved for the the teacher and no marking and no support from the teacher
duh! That’s the whole point!!!

they could of given you all spellings at the start of the year and tested her every half term
They could indeed have given the spellings out at the start of the year. My school uses a spelling app and we hand out the termly spellings on paper.

FairyCakeWings · 24/04/2022 15:58

I’m quite torn on this because I can see where you’re coming from, but from the school’s perspective, you are being quite difficult.

Your daughter doesn’t need paper copies of homework because of her SEN, she needs them because of your parenting choice. It’s a reasonable choice, but it’s not one that should become the teachers problem and cost them extra time and energy. If your dd weren’t capable of doing the homework on the apps, then the extra work would be fine to expect from the teacher, but she can.

Understandably, you don’t want to give her a tablet at home but that creates the problem that the homework doesn’t get done, so the school have offered a solution to that problem by inviting her to homework club. But that still isn’t good enough for you, so it is you that is being obstructive here.

Forget asking for paper versions of homework, the school clearly aren’t willing to provide them and nor should they have to. Choose one of the options they have given you, or just accept that your dd won’t be doing homework and if there’s consequences of that then so be it.

quietnightmare · 24/04/2022 15:40

Say NO

SickofHomework · 24/04/2022 15:25

Our school really don't use technology as often a people think, for a start they only have 1 class set of ipads (30) and half a classes worth of laptops (16), there's 3 classes per year so each class probably only uses the computers once per half term if they're lucky - they also loan the laptops out to another local school for parts of the year. There's interactive whiteboards in every classroom though.

OP posts:
FrenchFancie · 24/04/2022 14:00

By year 3 there is usually a fair amount of tablet use in the school curriculum- how does she cope with this at school? Have they found difficulties with her stopping activities?

whilst I understand your frustration, the use of ice is embedded into the curriculum and, at the end of year 4 there is a tables check done using an app either on the computer with a mouse or a tablet - she will need regular practice during year 4. How to you envisage managing that?

Ponderingwindow · 24/04/2022 13:57

If the school is tech heavy, aren’t they also using tech in the classroom? Is she having these meltdowns there?

Right now you are fighting about an app, but as you advance, the curriculum at many schools is completely integrated with technology. It’s not as simple as printing a worksheet. Our school issues every student either an tablet or a laptop depending on year.

if you truly believe your dd needs a screen free education, then you are going to need to get a doctor to sign off on it and get it out into an education plan. Good grades and behavior at school are not enough to stop her from getting accommodations it just makes it much harder to achieve. The school won’t provide testing so you are going to need to try your GP and impress upon them the severity of the meltdowns or go private.

TraceyLacey · 24/04/2022 12:48

Surely you just need to set some limits in the tablet settings? Ours only has school apps and a few websites which school use (White Rose etc). I've set it to stop functioning at 7pm. I could also set a time limit on daily use.

toomuchlaundry · 24/04/2022 12:40

How will she do the Y4 times table test if you won’t use technology. I assume she uses tech at school, how does that go?

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 24/04/2022 12:34

And also, dyslexia and dyspraxia dont come with "meltdowns".

That is again, just bad behaviour which, instead of managing, you're blaming on SEN. But she doesnt have SEN that would cause any of that.

She doesnt need an EHCP or any additional stuff in school. She is getting what she needs already.

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 24/04/2022 12:32

*and dyspraxic

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 24/04/2022 12:30

Sorry OP, but I think you're handling this all wrong.

She is dyslexic and dyslexic. Neither of those things have anything to do with her behaviour on a tablet. In fact, kids with dyslexia are often given a tablet to allow them to complete work without the addition challenge of spelling holding them back.

Her SEN have no impact on her behaviour around tablets. She is just a child who isnt doing what she is told and is obsessed with screens. There are millions of them. You just need to parent through.

You should be giving her a tabler for homework time, with nothing else loaded onto it at all. She does her homework and then you remove the tablet.

Sorry, but she needs to learn. And you're holding her back because you would rather avoid it than teach her to regulate and manage this.

KarmaComma · 24/04/2022 12:22

Seashor · 23/04/2022 21:41

Unbelievable! How very dare teachers try to support your child’s education in their own time! How dare they suggest that to help their workload and support students that learning is on electronic devices! Yes, best you start complaining to governors and Ofsted asap.
I truly wish that ALL parents had to pay for education, it’s only then that parents might value it’s worth.

Ridiculous comment. Ensuring that every child can access the curriculum in a way that suits their individual needs is a cornerstone of the education system and enshrined in law. OP is clearly not refusing to do homework; she has sought to work with the school to find an alternative to everything being on screen. The school has been completely unreasonable in being so rigid in its homework policy and refusal to find a workable alternative.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/04/2022 11:17

So it's providing IT facilities for those who wish to use them but do not have access. Which is fine, probably funded by the PPG for those who aren't paying wraparound.

But they cannot make it compulsory, as it then becomes a punishment/detention, which is not legal. And it goes directly against your DD's HCP. And is potentially being used as a reason for refusal to look at getting an EHCP. Which is not legal, either.

SickofHomework · 24/04/2022 10:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

@mumsys on point 2 they've told me it's not a help club, it is for the kids who don't do homework to do it, those who use the school wraparound still have to pay for wraparound at full price while they're at homework club, it's literally for them to do homework at while being supervised by a teacher.

OP posts:
SickofHomework · 24/04/2022 10:40

user1471505494 · 24/04/2022 10:13

You need to go straight back to the school about the EHCP as it is not about behaviour and all about a child’s need to be educated

@user1471505494 I've applied anyway but school are saying she won't get an EHCP due to her needs being met and the extra help she get being expected and her behaviour is fine so there's no unmet need.

To me there is though as even without the tablet there is still meltdowns after school.

OP posts:
user1471505494 · 24/04/2022 10:13

SickofHomework · 23/04/2022 14:18

It's automatic in the sense that most DC from this first school and two others go to X Middle School but I still have to apply through the usual admissions process so it's not 100% guarenteed.

She doesn't have an EHCP yet, in the process of getting one but no support from school for that either, told that she won't get one as she behaves herself and all the support she gets in school would be expected.

You need to go straight back to the school about the EHCP as it is not about behaviour and all about a child’s need to be educated

mumsys · 24/04/2022 09:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

LittleMG · 24/04/2022 08:25

Just thinking.. might it be an idea to let them see what she like when they try and take it off her? Takes the pressure off of you and she gets her hw done?

OnlyLittleMissOrganised · 24/04/2022 07:32

@SickofHomework so I was just randomly scrolling through my Facebook and I saw all this info on why paper is better than screens. So I thought of you and I'd copy and paste. There is research to back up what they say.
Happy #WorldBookDay: here is why you should ditch digital devices for good old-fashioned paper. 👀📖

✔ We read (at least) 10% slower on screens. (Research by UX research leader Nielsen Norman Group, 2010)

✔ We understand and remember less when we read texts on screens than on paper: psychologists call this the screen inferiority effect. 📱📉

✔ Although we may grasp the gist while reading on both mediums, more details are missed when reading in digital formats. This is true especially for longer and more complex texts (Singer & Alexander, 2016).

✔ Scrolling down 👆 instead of turning pages affects our ability to construct a cognitive map of the text: which makes us less able to locate a piece of information in the book and less motivated to look for it if needed. (Hou, Rashid & Lee, 2017)

✔ Print provides sensory & tactile information that enhances cognitive processing: seeing the words, feeling the pages, even smelling the paper 👃 are sensory cues that help us understand texts faster.

In one study, two groups of people were presented with a story on a Kindle e-reader and in a book and were asked to locate events in the text and reconstruct the plot of the story. Results showed those who had read in the book were better in defining the chronology and temporality in the story. (Mangen, 2019)

Learn more 🧠👉 bit.ly/ReadingAcrossMediums

KyieveMii · 23/04/2022 22:11

Spelling as a compromise since it’s quick can you test in paper then enter them into the app as she spelt them. Only suggesting this as it may lead to practical support and a record of difficulty. Be clear this is how it’s done.
It is though fine and a valid choice not to parent with tablets. One of mine was similar, though not as extreme and I limited severely. He’s growing into a teen than can regulate himself now and can programme phyton and use most of the Adobe suite confidently.

Rno3gfr · 23/04/2022 22:09

Honestly, I would be absolutely fuming if the school overstepped my boundaries as a parent and tried to insist on the table being used. It’s nuts. Don’t they realise that hand written homework is better for the child’s development and coordination at this age? As for the homework club, it’s only something I would agree to if I thought it would benefit my child. Op, if you think it will tip her over the edge then don’t send her!! Kids spend long enough days in school, she’ll only be 8 for goodness sake. You can practice her spelling with her at home, with games, reading and practice.

Cally70 · 23/04/2022 22:08

As an aside, does she receive the same spellings as the rest of the class? My DS has dyslexia & dyspraxia. He has spellings that are tailored for him (Y4).

As part of the recovery plan, he was also offered an additional reading group, outside of normal school hours. He tried it but as it was causing him so much stress, the senco agreed it was better to focus on his mental health than reading.