Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No wonder there's a debt crisis

167 replies

undebted · 23/04/2022 09:47

Just read this in the guardian, made me reflect a bit. When I turned 18 I got approved for a Barclaycard with a £2.5k limit, felt like I'd hit the jackpot. It spiralled pretty quick from there as it was a perfect combination of being clueless about finances, how interest rates actually worked and long term impacts/credit scores (perhaps school could of taught me that instead of pythagorus theorem, of which I remember the name and nout else!) and a lifestyle that involved wanting to go out drinking a lot, keep up with mates and have the latest clothes and tech, a nice car. By the time I was 22 I had 2 maxxed out credit cards (6k total) and a loan of £6k I was missing payments on. I ended up royally screwed and learnt my lesson the hard way with destroyed credit rating and a 5 year debt management plan. It was of course entirely my fault, but the fact that £12k credit was available to a very young adult with a part time minimum wage job was crazy to me.

It's been a couple of years since my plan ended and all my debt was repaid in full. My credit score is improving but still not great. I got an Aqua card a year ago to use everyday then pay off in full every payday which I do, I've accepted every increase as it is supposed to help my score but I never put more on it then I can pay off the very next payday as the interest rate is 49.9% APR. They've given me £3750 now on that card with that interest rate. The rate is insanity so I've recently applied for a different credit card and been given an automatic £5k limit on one of them. My clearscore shows that I'm fully 100% pre approved for loans of up to £7k. With a credit score full of defaults!

It's just no wonder is it. If you're hard up, which unfortunately so many people are and are going to continue to be in this economy, it's only going to get worse. People need money, and are offered so much at the click of a button. How is this right?

OP posts:
Villagewaspbyke · 23/04/2022 11:54

I had some credit cards I didn’t use for years abs they were all pretty much shut down. Banks don’t tend to like to leave them dormant. I now have one I put all spending on (get points) and one for emergencies that I put a monthly bill on too ok keep open. I always pay off both in full.

RealBecca · 23/04/2022 11:52

While thing is, of you pay it off info full every month the rate doesnt matter.

I disagree it's the job for the school, money management starts at home.

I do agree with your general point that credit is immediately advertised to 18 year olds.

Personally I'd like to see the likes of Klana and clear pay gotten rid of.

Villagewaspbyke · 23/04/2022 11:50

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee there is protection available for credit card spending eg if the airline goes bust or cancels abs refuses to refund. Debit cards do sometimes provide it but not all abs it’s voluntary.

changeu123 · 23/04/2022 11:49

I had the same issue when I was young. I split from an ex-partner (financially abusive), and then I had relatives pass away, so I went off the rails. I ended up on drugs, drinking heavily, and wanting nice things but in 20k of debt within a year. My mum is always in debt, and my other relatives are, so I never knew about financial planning.

I met my partner (who is very, very sensible), and in the same week, he made me set up a Stepchange DMP. I managed to pay it off in just over three years through working and going to Uni. Although the lockdown was terrible mentally, it did help me get out of debt.

I will never get an overdraft, nor will I get a credit card. But I do have a Loqbox where I pay £20 a month, and I have seen my credit score increase. I understand that they'll take £30 off me when I ask for my funds back, but I did it more to increase credit score.

Villagewaspbyke · 23/04/2022 11:48

You don’t remember what you were taught at school so maybe you were taught about finances and interest. I certainly was.

I don’t think it’s morally wrong to offer debt to people. Banks do so affordability checks but it’s for an individual to take responsibility for themselves at the end of the day. Actually a lack of affordable debt is a big issue for poorer people which means they end up paying more than they need to for things. Eg it’s cheaper to buy a new washing machine than to go to the launderette.

I was in debt when younger as I overspent. It’s easy to do. But it was my fault and my responsibility. I learned my lesson and now am more careful. But I still have borrowings.

ultimately you have to be able to manage your own finances- it’s no one else’s responsibility.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 23/04/2022 11:46

freeandfierce · 23/04/2022 11:16

I'm struggling to get my credit limit increased! Been with my bank over 30 years, was overdrawn a couple of times in my 20's ( in my 50's now). Pay my credit card off in full every month and have a very good credit score. I earn nearly 40k but I can't get an increase above 1.5k. so annoying as I fly to Australia annually where all my family live but can't pay for my flights using my credit card as it's normally 2-3k. In the past my H (now ex H) paid on his and I transferred the money to him. Now I'm divorced I don't have that option. The credit card company won't advise me why they won't raise my limit (it's with Lloyds). Seems crazy when I have all my savings with them, a healthy current account, not been over drawn or made late payments for nearly 30 years and have very good credit rating. Guess my option is to apply for a different one?

If you have savings, why can't you just pay for the flight on a debit card?

Sandra2010 · 23/04/2022 11:45

Because our debt makes them a lot of money, obviously, they want us to be in debt. You're right though, kids need to be taught this in school. I wasn't, nor were my kids. I had to sit and explain deductions from her payslip and how income tax works to my 22 yr old this week, which I've only learned from experience, and I still couldn't fully explain credit cards and ANPR to her. I talk about good and bad debt though and how to control it.

the80sweregreat · 23/04/2022 11:45

Gambling is an interesting one as I play the lottery and in a syndicate too ( roughly ten pounds a month ) , but nothing else , but I still add up the money I've wasted on it over the years and think what else I could have done with it instead! It must run into hundreds since we started it in 1995.
How people can lose thousands in one sitting at a casino or online etc I've no idea ! I just couldn't do it , but happy to spend a few pounds on a lottery line knowing I won't win any way. Gambling causes as much heartache as people who drink or take illegal drugs too and I can see why it's addictive.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 23/04/2022 11:41

Soultrader · 23/04/2022 10:09

I've mentioned it before on here but i agree that financial planning would be a lot more useful than Pythagoras. What the fuck is that anyway? Anyway i got my arse handed to me by people here because parents should teach children that and that's not what schools are for. But that involves every child having parents who are financially savvy themselves. Very very few children do.

Yes it's a really privileged argument. Parents should also keep their children safe but we don't want to do away with safeguarding procedures do we? Sadly some parents don't or can't do everything that is needed to set a child up for a future so using that as an argument for school not to is very unhelpful. Cooking, seeing through marketing ploys and financial management would all seem to be excellent things to teach in schools.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 23/04/2022 11:37

I still have a theoretical credit card (have the account but throw the card away when it comes). That is my absolute emergency, last resort. Even then I'd have to call and get a card sent.
I have learned I'm not to be trusted. Dh has a credit card with 2.5k limit that we use for things like tickets sometimes and that is paid off.
But there is something that appeals to me about credit in general. Thank god I've never started gambling, its much the same character trait i think.

Menora · 23/04/2022 11:35

I meant to add that I taught my DC about money very early on. They got bank accounts age 11 and managed their own pocket money. They both have part time jobs now and I still give them money advice now

Menora · 23/04/2022 11:34

I got myself onto a right mess. In 90’s and 2000’s lots of shops were offering credit accounts and catalogues and I quickly started getting accounts without really understand interest when I was 19 or so. I then bought a new car on finance seemed like a great deal with ‘free’ insurance. Then I had a baby at 21 and was working part time and quickly realised I could not afford any of the repayments and the interest was very high. I honestly wasn’t taught a thing by parents about money. My ex talked me into getting a consolidation loan for my car, the credit accounts and his loan when he took his EXGF to Florida. Fucking mug me… did it. He then was a controlling unpleasant person and restricted all my money this way

well 5 years later I was homeless, skint, CCJ’s on record and took me YEARS to pay it all off, get rid of the CCJ, get back on my feet. I am scared of credit now and read everything super thoroughly and work it all out before ever committing to anything. I have 1 empty credit card with some stupid £5k limit that I never use just for an emergency which I hope never happens!

my parents never learnt though and always in money problems. The CCJ really did me a favour - I couldn’t even get a mobile contract so I had to live within my means and it meant I had to learn a lot about making your money work for you

Bellabluea · 23/04/2022 11:33

TheBatKeeper · 23/04/2022 10:53

IMO

That is arrogance.

Not arrogance at all. My DH is an accountant. We had children and not enough money to pay for them. We were young and I got into debt before we met. He took it on but even he couldn’t sort it out and keep us fed on what we were bringing in.

the80sweregreat · 23/04/2022 11:29

I tried to decrease my credit limit on my bank credit card , but they wouldn't let me and ive been a customer for decades.

Lunar27 · 23/04/2022 11:28

Soultrader · 23/04/2022 10:09

I've mentioned it before on here but i agree that financial planning would be a lot more useful than Pythagoras. What the fuck is that anyway? Anyway i got my arse handed to me by people here because parents should teach children that and that's not what schools are for. But that involves every child having parents who are financially savvy themselves. Very very few children do.

Pythagoras is useful because you wouldn't be able to post here on your phone/tablet/computer or communicate without it 😉

Ideally it'd be taught both at home and school, along with other valuable life skills. But the government wouldn't want it as the economy is propped up by us all being in massive debt.

giggbig · 23/04/2022 11:26

I still have my "uni" credit card for emergencies as it has a massive limit (12k).

DeedlessIndeed · 23/04/2022 11:24

The availability of large lines of credit to young people who haven't necessarily developed a good level of impulse control is a disaster waiting to happen. There is also so much social pressure to keep up with the latest trends and have a "perfect" and "interesting" life. And when you are that age you generally do care about what people think of you.

I was bright, academic, taught about interest, debt and finance at school (00's education). I still took out a credit card at 19 and racked up close to £5K on holidays, going out, clothes. I was repaying minimum repayments for 3 years whilst this grew and grew.

Eventually I realised this wasn't sustainable and needed to grow up. Went to uni, had an extremely tight few years and managed to pay it off by the time I was mid-twenties. I'm grateful my "Grow Up" moment happened before I'd gotten myself into more trouble.

freeandfierce · 23/04/2022 11:16

I'm struggling to get my credit limit increased! Been with my bank over 30 years, was overdrawn a couple of times in my 20's ( in my 50's now). Pay my credit card off in full every month and have a very good credit score. I earn nearly 40k but I can't get an increase above 1.5k. so annoying as I fly to Australia annually where all my family live but can't pay for my flights using my credit card as it's normally 2-3k. In the past my H (now ex H) paid on his and I transferred the money to him. Now I'm divorced I don't have that option. The credit card company won't advise me why they won't raise my limit (it's with Lloyds). Seems crazy when I have all my savings with them, a healthy current account, not been over drawn or made late payments for nearly 30 years and have very good credit rating. Guess my option is to apply for a different one?

PaperTyger · 23/04/2022 11:10

It's a huge bug bear of mine.

Children,teens struggling with maths concepts they won't ever learn or need but basic cc stuff, budgets etc... don't work.

Then they go onto low paid job with no skills on how to manage Money, budget and even invest.

MrsAmber · 23/04/2022 11:07

Extremely similar story here @undebted

I also had a credit card when I was 18, had a loan for a car, used the credit card to pay for about four holidays abroad with my then boyfriend, this spanned over a period of about four years.

Problem was I was only paying off a limited amount per month and so the interest was virtually wiping out the monthly payments. Had another loan to pay off the credit card but stupidly didn’t destroy the credit card, ended up approx £13K in debt!

I couldn’t see a way out and I had no one to turn to. My parents couldn’t have helped and I wouldn’t have expected them to so I made an appointment with The Citizen’s Advice Bureau where a payment plan was set up so that at least the interest wouldn’t keep mounting up (except initially a certain bank kept adding interest, knowing my situation for another six months, from memory).

It took a long time to pay off the debt, but I was eventually debt free and haven’t had another credit card since!

I wish I’d had more advice at school or even from my parents but at that moment in time I possibly wouldn’t have listened anyway, who knows.

It is extremely easy to get yourself into debt and it’s very tempting to get yourself into even more debt trying to consolidate the first debt. It’s an awful situation to be in and I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy.

Gatehouse77 · 23/04/2022 11:05

I totally agree that this kind of maths would be far more useful and shouldn't come under the PHSE type lessons.
I also think that parents should take some responsibility for teaching this to their children too. Which leads back to education and where it has failed those parents and so the cycle repeats itself.
I don't believe there is any single point of fault for it though. It's a collective of variables that will be different according to circumstances/experience.

We've talked to our kids about money, the value of it, what something is worth (essentially, whatever someone is willing to pay but doesn't mean you have to buy it) and thinking about long term 'planning'. I think they get a balance as I'm prone to being over cautious and DH...less so! We've talked about savings, avoiding certain types of debt but also about 'good' debt. There are aware of how we mange our money and why. And this started when they first got pocket money (obviously age appropriate).

giggbig · 23/04/2022 11:03

Don't forgot saving hasn't been very attractive for a long time as interest rates have been low.

toastofthetown · 23/04/2022 11:01

While I accept that schools could do more to educate on personal finance, there does have to be an element of personal responsibility. Just because you have access to credit, surely most would know that you’re not being given free money. It’s astonishingly easy to get a loan though. When we borrowed to buy a car I was surprised by how easy the process was.

I do absolutely hate the attitude that people have of ‘why don’t schools teach useful things like personal finance instead of rubbish like Pythagoras’ theorem?’ Schools are available to teach every child, so education must be broad spectrum so every child is exposed to a wide selection of subjects. Each child will be interested in different things and so will find different things useless. I’ve not used my knowledge on long shore drift, but it’s not a bad thing I know about it. Just because someone doesn’t use their GCSE maths in their day to day life doesn’t means there aren’t many others who do. And that’s making the assumption that the people who say they’d rather have been taught personal finance rather than boring useless subjects would have paid attention to that class at 14, rather than wishing they’d had it in hindsight.

ChiselandBits · 23/04/2022 11:01

I teach PSHE in secondary. Guess what - we DO teach this, starting in about Y10 and moving on through into Y12-13 (16-18yo) I teach the difference between a credit and debit card, what being overdrawn means, what a credit score is, how it can be affected and how it effects you if you miss a mobile phone bill. We teach them about reading contracts, how do divvy up bills in a shared student house and avoiding being liable for the whole amount, the need for insurance etc. BUT, just like when we teach about smoking, vaping, drugs, sex and relationships, health, mental health, respect, cyber issues and every other bloody thing that is apparently our job on top of getting them GCSEs and A levels, they listen, make notes, make nice posters and powerpoints and then go out and ignore it all totally. There is a disconnect between real life and what they learn in a classroom - that's why its really better if this stuff comes from their home. And just like everything else, yes some parents will be better at it than others but I'm afraid that's just life. At some point, an adult has to start taking responsibility for educating themselves. The seemingly irrelevant stuff they get taught in the academic subjects will, for some, be the foundation of their career in a related field. You can't just teach numeracy and practical maths up to 16/18 and then expect those kids to learn algebra, geometry and all the more abstract stuff at Uni. The internet provides far more expert guidance on everything under the sun than a parent or teacher can and kids know how to use that. I would like to see more regulation in the industry and banks / loan companies / retailers that offer payment plans etc be held to higher account but it can't all be down to schools.

giggbig · 23/04/2022 10:55

@TheBatKeeper in his case it was circumstances.

Swipe left for the next trending thread