Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No wonder there's a debt crisis

167 replies

undebted · 23/04/2022 09:47

Just read this in the guardian, made me reflect a bit. When I turned 18 I got approved for a Barclaycard with a £2.5k limit, felt like I'd hit the jackpot. It spiralled pretty quick from there as it was a perfect combination of being clueless about finances, how interest rates actually worked and long term impacts/credit scores (perhaps school could of taught me that instead of pythagorus theorem, of which I remember the name and nout else!) and a lifestyle that involved wanting to go out drinking a lot, keep up with mates and have the latest clothes and tech, a nice car. By the time I was 22 I had 2 maxxed out credit cards (6k total) and a loan of £6k I was missing payments on. I ended up royally screwed and learnt my lesson the hard way with destroyed credit rating and a 5 year debt management plan. It was of course entirely my fault, but the fact that £12k credit was available to a very young adult with a part time minimum wage job was crazy to me.

It's been a couple of years since my plan ended and all my debt was repaid in full. My credit score is improving but still not great. I got an Aqua card a year ago to use everyday then pay off in full every payday which I do, I've accepted every increase as it is supposed to help my score but I never put more on it then I can pay off the very next payday as the interest rate is 49.9% APR. They've given me £3750 now on that card with that interest rate. The rate is insanity so I've recently applied for a different credit card and been given an automatic £5k limit on one of them. My clearscore shows that I'm fully 100% pre approved for loans of up to £7k. With a credit score full of defaults!

It's just no wonder is it. If you're hard up, which unfortunately so many people are and are going to continue to be in this economy, it's only going to get worse. People need money, and are offered so much at the click of a button. How is this right?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Testina · 27/04/2022 12:51

These threads always have the “it should be taught in schools” comments.

It is. To me in 1980s, to my children in 2020s.

But anyway… even if you can’t understand how compound interest works, you know that you have to pay the credit card back. And you know from the very first statement that interest has been added. And the second. And the third.

It’s not the lack of education driving this. It’s the lack of personal responsibility.

Two things I’d like to see change:


  • less access to credit, as OP suggests

  • less options for just wiping out debt - I know far too many people who have basically used a get out of jail free card, and learned nothing from it

CookieMachine · 27/04/2022 12:42

Unfortunately, there are too many people whose parents are not in a good position to teach their kids financial sense, and it can lead to a downward spiral easily. At the same time, just because parents are sensible doesn't mean kids will be.
I know I will be teaching my kids about money. At the same time, I don't intend to give them access to much until they can prove themselves.
The best way of learning the value of money is to earn it, in my opinion. But its important to give everyone basic financial education.
The one way to give everybody a level starting point is if school curriculum included classes on financial literacy.
Flip side here are the macroeconomic biases - how does the school curriculum find a balance between spending vs saving,when both have across value in macroeconomics.

MangyInseam · 26/04/2022 23:40

I think that in some ways the question of whether it's schools or parents that should teach how to manage things like credit, is the wrong question.

The people who really benefit from all this debt are the people who are collecting the interest payments. Our economy is built on the continuous escalation of our consumption, and debt is an integral part of the scaffolding of that in order to enrich the few people who own the majority of the world's assets.

There is no real interest in helping people reduce their reliance on credit, because then they would have to live within their means and consumption would go down. The economy would grow more slowly, and we can't have that.

It's difficult to put too much blame on individuals when for decades now the people have been encouraged, both through advertising, through changes in lifestyle, and also by the structure of their local economies, to use credit to function, and to feel the need to buy whatever the advertising people tell them they need.

Xenia · 26/04/2022 23:09

Sounds like it is in hand. I was just never like this. Even as a teenager I had a note book in which I wrote everything spent - ever 20p on a bar of chocolate! I recently found one from age 17 and always been a bit like that. I don't use credit at all (other than a mortgage on the house).

BeerLoas · 26/04/2022 23:03

@Halloweenadoodle important thing is you have a handle on it now and are taking steps to sort it. Good on you I say.

Kennykenkencat · 26/04/2022 20:06

I think the world turns on credit and if you are sensible you can make credit work for you.
The problem stems from people not being realistic in their spending habits and using credit to get bargains or stuff that they really don’t need that by the time they have finished paying off the credit card, with interest at even a low percentage rate for a credit card the bargain begins to look extremely expensive.

I wonder whether there is a calculator that shows the actual amount if you put say a family holiday on credit card and paid it off over the next 10 months or the cost of a shopping trip put on credit card and paid off over the next year

And then comparing it to how many hours / days/weeks etc you will spend working just today off the interest.

Would people be put off spending and the actual cost would make people stop and think about costs.

I think credit cards and loans have become a normal household expense for a lot of people

A case of paying a set amount towards your credit cards each month without really looking at interest rates or what you have bought.

Manekinek0 · 26/04/2022 19:11

@Halloweenadoodle you'll feel amazing when you pay it off. I was embarrassed about the debt I got into but I'm pretty proud of myself after years of chipping away at it. The MSE forums are great if you ever need any encouragement.

maddiemookins16mum · 26/04/2022 19:04

I know how you feel. It comes over you in waves and makes you feel sick. Have you looked at CAP - the debt support charity? I was exactly where you are 12 years ago, I worked out it would take me 77 years to pay my debts at the rate I was paying them.

yellowsuninthesky · 26/04/2022 17:26

I do think a lot of people keep up with the Jones's by using credit. They certainly buy expensive cars on credit. I have always wanted to live within my means, other than the mortgage - there aren't many people who can save enough to buy a house outright.

yellowsuninthesky · 26/04/2022 17:25

People need money, and are offered so much at the click of a button

and yet, because I don't use my credit card often enough they reduced my credit limit. In December I had a new gas boiler and I wanted to pay for it by credit card, so I applied to increase the limit again. I was turned down (husband paid it on his card). Then I got a letter saying because I hadn't used it for a while they were going to close my account altogether. Well, they could have increased my credit limit again when I asked.

It doesn't seem to me that they are giving credit away.

Although - while I've been typing this, it has occurred to me that they like giving credit away to people who use it and pay interest and get themselves into debt. Not people like me who use it occasionally eg for consumer protection or for cashflow reasons and pay it off each month.

Halloweenadoodle · 26/04/2022 16:35

Im in a lot of debt.
Its bad spending habits and the freedom that i could buy whatever i wanted with a credit card... then it became two then three.

I now have a £20k consolidation loan (even just typing this gives me the heebie jeebies) and a credit card with £900 on it.

My parents are money savvy both having large businesses but i grew up with them spending 100s like its nothing and ive somewhat tried to continue into my adult hood with me buying lots of stuff that i couldnt necessarily afford.

Im not a victim here i know exactly what i was doing.

2022s plan is to pay off the cc and get the loan into the 17s. Maybe even 15s if i can stretch it.

The shame is the hardest part it churns my stomach daily. No one knows in my life how much i am in debt but me. (And now a bunch of random strangers on the internet). No one talks about these things and i can see why people take their own lives over it.

Chaoslatte · 26/04/2022 15:06

ColouringPencils · 24/04/2022 11:51

I haven't RTFT, but every single month for years I have received an email from PayPal that says 'Congratulations! You have been accepted for PayPal credit!'. I had one credit card about 20 years ago, paid off about 15 years ago. I have never asked for PayPal credit. AIBU to think it should be illegal of PayPal to try to get me into debt in this way?

Marketing emails are opt-in.

ToastofLandon · 26/04/2022 13:30

Userg1234 · 23/04/2022 10:06

Sorry but no. It's not the credit card companies or the banks fault. People are spending money they don't have. Yes some don't understand interest rates, but every one knows that you have to pay the money back. Unfortunately, people are no longer prepared to wait to save for things. They want them now. Because they "deserve" it.

If you walked in to the bank with a gun and took £5k you're a crook. You take a credit card and blow £5k your a victim?

THIS 💯

AnotherTroyforHertoBurn · 26/04/2022 13:27

Experian messaged me a few times this week, once was to tell me that I was eligible to apply for 38 credit cards.

Today I was told I can apply for six loans.
Don't need any of it Thank God, but I can see how people are tempted.

ColouringPencils · 24/04/2022 11:51

I haven't RTFT, but every single month for years I have received an email from PayPal that says 'Congratulations! You have been accepted for PayPal credit!'. I had one credit card about 20 years ago, paid off about 15 years ago. I have never asked for PayPal credit. AIBU to think it should be illegal of PayPal to try to get me into debt in this way?

newnamethanks · 24/04/2022 11:33

49.9%!? That should be illegal. You'd probably get a better rate from a dodgy backstreet moneylender. But don't.

L1ttledrummergirl · 24/04/2022 11:28

We actually had to buy a car in October, possible because instead of repaying debt, we had been able to put money by.
Hence the need to save for the cooker.

Fortunately we have several exterior doors so we've locked the broken one and ignored it until the new one arrives, by reassigning the money we will get it sooner. They take ten weeks to be made so I guess if we didn't have the money we would just have to manage without using it for longer.
In short, we would manage.

Tangled123 · 24/04/2022 10:53

@littledrummergirl What would you have done about your door if it broke before your cooker and you didn’t have the money saved? Would you still have waited to replace it? What if it was a car that broke and you needed it fixed to get to work?

I remember doing Key Skills Application of Number alongside my A levels in 2006/7. It was meant to take the stuff we learned in GCSE Maths and apply it to real world situations. As part of it, we had to do coursework on how much it would cost us to university and how we expected to finance it. I remember being shocked at how expensive it would be, and I was sure my numbers were wrong. I think the optional nature of the subject put people off (and the tiny amount of UCAS points available), and most of my class didn’t bother with it. I think that if we only taught subjects students cared about, they would only be in school a couple of days a year though.

My school also offered a Learning for Life and Work GCSE but no one in my year picked it.

Personally, I use my credit card a lot. I’ve always had enough in savings to cover what I spend, but it helps me split big payments over two pays instead of a huge chunk leaving my account at once, gives me an extra month to pay for things like insurance and education, and gives me a bit of a safety net at the end of the month when funds are starting to get low. It also means I can take advantage if I see something on offer that I need anyway.

A work colleague got into a lot of debt at 18, and is still paying for it at 27, so I do think more financial education and life skills could be taught in schools. A whole subject would probably be too boring, but elements could be better incorporated into others. Meal planning and shopping on a budget could be done in Home Economics, for example.

Gingerkittykat · 24/04/2022 01:03

freeandfierce · 23/04/2022 11:16

I'm struggling to get my credit limit increased! Been with my bank over 30 years, was overdrawn a couple of times in my 20's ( in my 50's now). Pay my credit card off in full every month and have a very good credit score. I earn nearly 40k but I can't get an increase above 1.5k. so annoying as I fly to Australia annually where all my family live but can't pay for my flights using my credit card as it's normally 2-3k. In the past my H (now ex H) paid on his and I transferred the money to him. Now I'm divorced I don't have that option. The credit card company won't advise me why they won't raise my limit (it's with Lloyds). Seems crazy when I have all my savings with them, a healthy current account, not been over drawn or made late payments for nearly 30 years and have very good credit rating. Guess my option is to apply for a different one?

That's bizrre. I've spent a few months repairing my credit rating, managed to get £15 credit with PayPal and a phone contract and then was given a £5000 limit when I applied for a card and I have a lower income than you.

It's probably worth applying for a different credit card, mine was with Tesco bank but if you go onto the Money Saving Expert website they have a soft checker for credit cards to show what you are likely to be offered.

starlingdarling · 24/04/2022 00:22

I don't remember learning about compound interest but my GCSEs were in the mid 00's. I was genuinely gobsmacked years later when I learned the difference between saving (as an example because I can't remember the actually numbers) £20 a week for 40 years and £40 a week for 20 years (explained in the context of starting a pension).

EducatingArti · 24/04/2022 00:08

PaperTyger · 23/04/2022 11:10

It's a huge bug bear of mine.

Children,teens struggling with maths concepts they won't ever learn or need but basic cc stuff, budgets etc... don't work.

Then they go onto low paid job with no skills on how to manage Money, budget and even invest.

Interest rates including compound interest and what happens when this is repeated month to month or year to year is part of the GCSE maths curriculum though.

starlingdarling · 23/04/2022 23:59

@BoredYummyMummy it's a bit long but this is from the OU website for the module

Setting the context. An introduction to the module themes. This includes some major world trends, such as ageing populations and the march of technology which are changing the demands on our money. You’ll look at the behavioural traits we all have that influence the way we interact with our finances, firms and each other.
Income. What influences pay, including worker power and gender issues. How the tax and benefits system affects your income and can be used to relieve poverty and reduce inequality. The way income flows between the different sectors of the economy.
Expenditure. Why we spend on what we do from rational choices about meeting our needs to the social factors and marketing influences that work on our more subtle desires for belonging or displaying our worth. In small teams with your fellow students, you’ll explore the world of symbolic advertising. Using cash-flow and budgeting to control your household’s spending.
Debt. Understanding the good as well as dark side of debt. How to identify the best ways to borrow and be aware of hidden costs. Using a household balance sheet to check whether you are vulnerable to debt problems. How household debt contributes to economic growth but perversely can bring down economies.
Savings and investments. Why low-risk products promising amazing returns simply don’t exist. Choosing the right products for different types of goals. Navigating the risk-return trade-off, with strategies for managing stock-market risk. Why saving matters to the economy.
Housing. How, in many countries, homes are more than just a place to live and may be driving a wedge between younger and older generations. Using the economic model of supply and demand, you’ll explore what influences house prices and analyse different solutions to making homes affordable.
Insurance. The role of insurance in building your financial resilience – your ability to withstand and recover from shocks and life events. The principle of risk-sharing and how it is being undermined by Big Data and other technological changes.
Pensions. The implications for you personally and society as a whole of saving for a pension and the ageing population. How saving for the long-term means battling our behavioural traits. The way different pensions work and what that means for the choices you make and the risks you run.
Caring and sharing. The short-term and long-term consequences of decisions about having a family and the social norms that surround unpaid work. The choices households and society face about caring for the elderly.
Personal finance in context. What does it mean to be ‘financially capable’? What are the options for society if all individuals and households are to enjoy at least a minimum level of well-being?

Dexy007 · 23/04/2022 23:17

Haven’t RTFT.

I agree there was or is inadequate (no?) financial literacy education - a couple of hours a year at school might help but would kids really listen? Not sure.

I think you should need to literally grow your credit limit - like a statutory cap of £500 at age 18 (or whenever you get your first card) and you should only ever be able to increase that if you pay it off in full at least by the end of the year, that kind of thing.

maybe by the time you’re 21 you have a limit of £5k because you’re in full time work and your credit report shows you have paid off in full most months and the banks can literally see you are managing your debt sensibly.

baby steps.

yes your credit limit will always be influenced by your salary and outgoings but I do think you should need to prove you can handle it.

BeerLoas · 23/04/2022 22:27

I know a lot of people got into trouble with cards whilst a student/shortly after Uni in the 90’s plus huge overdrafts. Most of them first generation graduates whose parents were blue collar workers. They didn’t get advice from their probably money savvy parents as their parents had never had credit cards/overdrafts thrust on them like lots of teens/early 20’s did at that time, plus all the stores desperately signing everyone up to cards. All the banks then behaved like sign up a student and get a customer for life - yes because they get into so much debt. More education is needed but banks have an ethical responsibility.

Menora · 23/04/2022 22:13

WhereWasThatFrom · 23/04/2022 20:52

OP, are you saying that if you had been taught about interest rates and long term impacts/credit scores etc you wouldn't have borrowed the money? My guess is that it wouldn't have made any difference at all and you would still have spent it. You will have been receiving statements and unless you made a conscious decision not to look at them ( which would hardly have been the banks fault) you will have seen what was happening but choose to carry on spending.

However

I'm fully in favour of financial education in schools ( Martin Lewis is on the case)

Also, I think most banks go out their way to mislead people. As an example the use of 'representative APR' is useless for the 49% of customers who get a higher interest rate than that advertised. Why would any reputable company use such an unhelpful term if it wasn't in their own interests. Unfortunately banks have too much political power and have little desire to act in the best interests of their customers.

I wouldn’t have borrowed the money if I had really understood it. A lot of it came with incentives. Free car insurance. 6 months payment holiday. 5 years to pay back the house deposit. Free money for getting your mates onto your catalogue account. Vouchers when you spend X money. Cash back (Egg credit card).

No one in Bay Trading when I was 20 told me what the card APR was when they sold it to me. I am glad things have changed now. but it all did really ruin a lot of people early on and I think dismissing it as we are all just greedy is offensive. I was 20 and had come from a family who didn’t talk about money and were bad with money. I didn’t know anything about money. I would never allow my kids to know nothing but it happened to a lot of us and don’t dismiss it as we are stupid or greedy. Klarna is ok if you understand how it works, but I think many are naive sadly