Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a flat rule about other people's kids?

134 replies

hitrewind · 23/04/2022 08:44

I don't have kids – I have a DSS who I love to bits but play no 'parental' role in his life (we have our own relationship that we chose and defined when he was young).

Over the years DSS's friends have, of course, come over to play / spend time and occasionally their parents / my DP have asked if I could drop them home, or be home with them while DP goes to work.

It's always been moments when I was going out anyway (when I'm asked to give a lift) or staying home anyway (when I was asked to watch the kids for a bit) so I've felt a bit shit saying no.

But I don't have children of my own, haven't really been around kids much in my life, and I feel really uncomfortable taking responsibility for someone else's child, especially when 90% of the time the parents have never even met me.

DSS is another matter – I have no issue being 'the adult' for him – but when it's a child who I've only met once getting into my car, I can't help but imagine situations where I get into an accident and their parents blame me, or the child doing something I didn't predict and something awful happening.

So I've said to DP I just have a flat rule about 'no other people's kids'.

It feels like the right thing to me, but I've always felt a bit awkward about saying no – especially when I'm driving that way anyway, for example – since I know logically that the chances of something bad happening are low and other people do it all the time.

AIBU to have a flat rule like this? Am I being ridiculous?

OP posts:
Trinity69 · 24/04/2022 18:11

I haven't read the whole thread yet but ignoring the fact that you don't have children....I have kids in my house, the parents of which I've never met and have no contact details for....its part and parcel of having kids in your house. I'm aware DSS isn't YOUR child but that's not relevant to the not knowing the parents....my kids are always bringing friends home or going to friends houses and most of the time I've not met the parents.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/04/2022 08:28

So rather than heading home myself when I'm ready to, I'm now babysitting and taxi-ing, and the friend's parent is at work so not in easy contact if anything happens. I just feel out of my depth.

Yanbu in this situation.
Why can't he drop them both off at the friend's, DM can arrange collection from the friend's house.

Sally872 · 24/04/2022 07:33

*So an example: I'm at their place, DP has to go to work (he works evenings) and DSS's friend has been over all afternoon. DSS's friend's mum texts to say she's having to work late, so DP asks if I can stay with them until the mum finishes work and then drop the friend home, since he'll be at work by then.

So rather than heading home myself when I'm ready to, I'm now babysitting and taxi-ing, and the friend's parent is at work so not in easy contact if anything happens. I just feel out of my depth.*

Missed this initially. This is unacceptable because it is imposing on your evening. I think suggesting you are put of your depth may sound disingenuous as there isn't much to it. However having your evening used like that is not acceptable. If this comes up again I would say "sorry I have stuff to do at home. Girlfriends mum will have to sort her a lift when she finishes"

ScaldedBy · 24/04/2022 01:44

YANBU. I have my own kids. 4. I hate being responsible for other people's kids. I don't like kids much in general (my own are different). As a result my kids never often had play dates outside of school. Happened very rarely but not much. They did sports and things with friends but I was just dropping off and picking my own kids up. So they interacted and now they're older it hasn't affected their friendships at all. I wouldn't want to be doing it in your situation and I don't think you're unreasonable for not wanting to.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/04/2022 00:39

No issues with refusing lifts.

Not wanting to be in sole care of 14 y.o's is OTT.

zoeFromCity · 24/04/2022 00:30

tuliplover · 23/04/2022 20:49

It is up to you but I feel if you have a partner with kids you must take on the adult (not necessarily parental) role, and this inevitably includes other kids. After all you may need to take several kids to football practice etc - I've done that with kids I don't even know the name of.
If you can avoid it much of the time that's your choice, but feel it's unfair and selfish to have a 'rule' about it.

Why would oher kids be inevitable? Actually, the OP is evading other children quite well, just feels a bit pushed into them.

And, what should be the selfish part of having a rule? At lest it makes her position predictable and clear to the actual parents of children involved. If she was evaluating each situation individually and randomly agree, it would be more mess for everyone.

tuliplover · 23/04/2022 20:49

It is up to you but I feel if you have a partner with kids you must take on the adult (not necessarily parental) role, and this inevitably includes other kids. After all you may need to take several kids to football practice etc - I've done that with kids I don't even know the name of.
If you can avoid it much of the time that's your choice, but feel it's unfair and selfish to have a 'rule' about it.

SillySallySassySausage · 23/04/2022 17:43

I have several of my own kids and I sort of secretly have this pact with myself too. I don't "do" other peoples kids and I will never voluntarily put myself forward for it (and likewise don't expect others to have mine!)
I'm fine with having them bob in when they're playing with my kids but I very rarely arrange actual play dates. No sirreeeee.
I mean, some times it's unavoidable and I suck it up, but I just find other kids fucking unbearable and I need a considerable length of time between contact.
Yanbu!

Unsureaboutit9 · 23/04/2022 17:30

I don’t think not giving lifts to teenagers is unreasonable but I think your reasoning is OTTx you’ve been around this kid for years so you HAVE been around kids. I’m assuming it’s not causing any problems with your DP?

Boood · 23/04/2022 17:24

Some people really don’t like the idea of a woman setting and protecting boundaries so that her life works the way she wants it to. It’s not supposed to be our lot.

TheRussianDoll · 23/04/2022 17:14

When DS was at primary school, he’d regularly have friends round. I remember one of them used to just help himself to the “tuck” cupboard. I’d say “You can both choose one treat from the cupboard to have, whilst I get tea ready”. One day, the boy cleared out the cupboard! He then had his food, went on the trampoline for twenty minutes before his mum collected him and the next day she roasted me in the carpark at school drop off because he’d been horrendously sick, in the car, on the way home. Apparently, it was nearly all chocolate! It wasn’t till I went home and checked the cupboard that I saw how empty it was.

I was furious but didn’t say anything. His mum threw me filthy looks thereafter. If he’d been sick in my then, new car, I’d have been really cross. Whose fault was that? My son wouldn’t have gorged himself stupid.

NatriumChloride · 23/04/2022 16:53

LuckySantangelo35 · 23/04/2022 12:48

@Poppinjay

heaven forbid a woman be perceived as inflexible!! She should be bending over backwards to accommodate the whims of children and men

What a silly comment! 😂😂 What’s your back story, Lucky? Fed up of being a wife/parent? 😂🤣

Indicatrice · 23/04/2022 15:01

They’re all taking advantage of you, including your DP.

Say no and also assess if you are doing much for your DSS as well.

You are not a babysitter.

DrDinosaur · 23/04/2022 14:41

The children are 14 years old. Old enough to negotiate a ‘fall out’ without adult intervention. The adult only needs to be there in case of major disaster (like the house burning down), and presumably to deter them from having sex.
OP doesn’t have to do anything she doesn’t want to do, but if the reason she doesn’t want to do it is fear of the ‘responsibility’, she’s being ridiculous.

TimBoothseyes · 23/04/2022 14:05

DrDinosaur · 23/04/2022 10:51

You can do what you like OP, but yes you are being ridiculous. What are you afraid is going to happen if you are alone in the house while DSS is playing with a friend? Or if you give a child a lift?

How is the OP supposed to respond if the children fall out, start arguing, get stroppy? Baring in mind neither of those children are hers and in a house that she doesn't live in. It's different if it's your own child and their mate but a lot harder if they're not. So it's really not ridiculous at all not to want to have sole, unpaid responsibility for children that are not yours or that you are not related to don't you think?

Wouldyabeguilty · 23/04/2022 13:48

I understand your reasoning and you are dead right to set the boundaries you feel comfortable with.

BoredZelda · 23/04/2022 13:47

Where's the angst, exactly?

Probably form the fact you felt it necessary to post about it. I mean, nobody in your life has called it an issue, you haven’t said that your partner complains about it, it doesn’t seem to be causing any problems in your life, so why are you bothering to ask about it?

If it works for your family, then that’s fine.

picklemewalnuts · 23/04/2022 13:28

I think it's inappropriate that the dad and the other person's mum want to assume you will step in.

Your DP should be taking the girl home, or her mum collecting her.

The other child's mum can't assume you will step in to supervise her child so she can stay late at work.

Poppinjay · 23/04/2022 13:14

heaven forbid a woman be perceived as inflexible!! She should be bending over backwards to accommodate the whims of children and men

I think there's a significant amount of projection there.

Most people can find a reasonable middle ground 🙄

ZenNudist · 23/04/2022 13:04

Kids are people too. Fair enough dont go out of your way but to not drop them off when you're going that way or not watch them when you are in the house anyway is awkward and unnecessary. Do you apply the "no lifts" rule to adults too?

mycatisannoying · 23/04/2022 12:51

Personally, I think j you're being unreasonable and odd. I suspect that there's more to it though, and anxiety is an issue generally for you. So I am sorry for that.

0nTheEdge · 23/04/2022 12:50

The further information regarding their age and the fact it's a female friend change things IMO. If your DSS was on his own could you have left (in your example) so he was on his own? Considering you don't live there, I think it is unfair to expect you to chaperone or taxi them around.
What would have happened if you weren't there? If the friend's parents were unable to get them would your DP dropped her home before work? Or would both kids' parents be happy for them to be left alone for a while? I don't think your are being unreasonable, but if I didn't have plans I would probably be ok to sit in with them a while, but then I also have a history of being taken advantage of 😁

LuckySantangelo35 · 23/04/2022 12:48

Poppinjay · 23/04/2022 09:53

Qualifications and certificates are require for people who are paid to look after larger numbers of children regularly and for long periods. Even then, you can do it for up to two hours a day without them.

If you did it, you would soon feel just as comfortable as any parent who sometimes looks after their children's friends.

You have every right to say no but it will make you look unreasonable and inflexible at some point. You seem happy to be perceived that way if it comes to it, so I guess there isn't an issue.

@Poppinjay

heaven forbid a woman be perceived as inflexible!! She should be bending over backwards to accommodate the whims of children and men

TheRussianDoll · 23/04/2022 12:41

@Peanutbuttercupisyum

Please, in your wisdom, define “normal”. I consider myself normal. I will, if needed, do what I can to help people. I was recently looking after a four year old because there was no one else to. I found it really hard. He wanted his mummy. Much as I tried to occupy/comfort him, he was not consoled. He barely knows me.

After the weekend, I felt terrible. For him. For me. I wouldn’t put myself forward for it on a regular basis because I know my limitations.

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/04/2022 11:51

In that scenario at 14, you should have just gone home when you wanted. You aren’t a stepmum. The friend could stay over.