Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not let DC play rugby

37 replies

NoRugbyMom · 23/04/2022 07:27

Rugby is a big thing where we live. Kids play it at school and the local club puts on events at school to encourage new players. A lot of my DC’s friends and classmates already go. It is non contact at the moment but that will change as they grow.

Having read about professional players developing MND, dementia etc I don’t want my DC to play. I know improvements have been made to how the game is played and the way injuries are treated but there are still risks.

DC would like to go because all he friends do but I have managed to make excuses so far and encourage other sports.

AIBU to not let DC play rugby?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
blobby10 · 30/08/2022 12:23

My three children all played rugby - and have all had their fair share of injuries, none of which were rugby specific - snapped ankle ligaments, dislocated shoulder, broken collarbone. All could have been done playing football or walking or falling down the stairs at home. Eldest now involved in coaching and at Mini and Junior Club level there is SO much protocol for return to play after head injury. DS2 snapped an ankle ligament going over on it during one match, stopped playing whilst at uni and never got back into it

DD plays semi professionally and has (so far) done ankle and shoulder ligaments, thumb ligaments and fractured collar bone. She's had two returns to play for knocks to the head in 10 years and both were what used to be called 'minor' ie no loss of consciousness, confusion, blurred vision etc but a literal knock to the head from a knee. Not allowed to train/raise heartrate for 2 weeks then gradual return to physical exercise before gradual return to play over 2/3 weeks after day 21. And it was seriously enforced.

flowinguphill · 30/08/2022 11:31

Thanks for this conversation, I was looking for something specifically along these lines re teen playing rugby at school, to find out whether my concerns were justified. Has anyone heard of or tried this? Seems like a logical idea to me - www.rezonwear.com/

fUNNYfACE36 · 28/04/2022 18:15

.. And you cannot choose ti withdraw your child from a games lesson you dont like

fUNNYfACE36 · 28/04/2022 18:14

Rugby tackling starts from Year 8 onwards at our state school, i believe. I think they hg ave to tackle below armpit level now, but i am not sure it saves a lot of injuries. I saw a kid whose face had collided with someone else's rugby studs the other day. He needed several stitches to thr face.

fizzandchips · 25/04/2022 13:01

Non contact is absolutely fine, but otherwise it’s a no from me and I say this as a mum who watched her son play rugby until Upper 6th. My heart was in my mouth during every game. I hated the fact there was an ambulance and paramedics on stand by as the level of risk was so high. Other sports do carry risk, but if Rugby were invented as a new game it would not pass a risk assessment. Instead of saying concussion use the correct term - traumatic brain injury. People need to stop downplaying “mild concussion’”. You are absolutely right to have reservations and concerns.

bellebeautifu1 · 25/04/2022 12:28

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/04/2022 08:59

Yanbu. I think both rugby and football are facing an early dementia time bomb in the near future.

Our small town has also had a couple of young lads paralysed. One sadly died. Such a waste.

I am in the rugby mecca New Zealand, and where I am in the country grassroots rugby is decreasing here, parents are much more apprehensive on letting their kids play rugby and they are picking up other sports. Granted its a lot less dangerous than what it was 10+ years ago as they have tightened up the rules but at the end of the day you still have tackles, line outs etc. The amount of concusions I have heard over the years from kids playing rugby is unbelievable.

Touch rugby is massive here for the girls which I think is quite empowering, its safe (no contact) and suits those who dont want to play what are peceived to be the more feminine sports (netball etc)

Angrymum22 · 25/04/2022 12:24

There have been a number of significant rule changes in rugby aimed to address the head injury aspect. Interestingly they are now being adopted in professional football. There are probably just as many head to head contacts in football but because body contact is not an aspect of the game they go unnoticed.
Full contact doesn’t happen until U15/16 and even then there are still elements of the adult game that are not allowed. Unlike football where they play the same rules as the adult game.
My DS has played rugby since age 6 and has had a couple of bangs to the head but no more than in general play in the play ground. At junior school he would have a yellow slip most weeks informing us he’d bashed heads with someone in the playground.
Coaching nowadays is focused on minimising head injuries, if they do suffer a concussion there is a strict two week no contact rule.
The ex rugby players now making the news played 20yrs ago when rugby was quite a different game. They were also professional players.
DS plays for school and now he is 17/18 they are not allowed to play Sat and Sun so does not play club rugby until later in the season when the school season is over. They have only small sessions of contact training during the week.
Although it looks brutal most of the contact is away from the head. The time they are at risk is during line outs when they are lifted in the air and running into tackles ( it’s complicated to explain but it’s generally when they are not well drilled in tackling technique) many of the old styles of tackling that would put them at risk are now illegal resulting in penalties and sending off.
The benefits are tremendous for boys who enjoy physical sports. It’s like gang warfare without weapons. But off the field they may be best of friends with the opposition.There is a tremendous sense of belonging and as another poster mention no size or shape is excluded.
I think I am most impressed by how much respect they give the match officials. Only the captain can approach the ref. They have to be addressed as Sir or Miss ( there are plenty of women refs at club level) and the refs word is law. And you can be sent off for dissent even if you mutter under your breath. Repeated dangerous play is penalised so the player actually learns by his mistakes.
As you can gather I’m a rugby mum, who like you was very reluctant at first but watching my son build in confidence and dedicate himself to his sport has been great. He socialises with similar boys at school who take sport seriously. Drug taking is just not part of their culture and DS has strong views on it. Unfortunately they do like a beer or two. When out and about they look after each other. As DS says they are family and that includes anyone he knows through rugby.

JustLyra · 25/04/2022 12:23

All sports carry a risk.

my DS doesn’t currently play rugby because I won’t allow him to play under the coach who coaches his age locally. The man is dangerous.
He did used to play and I’ve no doubt he will again. He plays at school.

It needs to be the other way around x% of rugby players go on to develop this disease

I agree with this. It’s a much more realistic, and reasonable, way to look at it.

Sparklingbrook · 25/04/2022 12:23

I was glad my two didn't choose Rugby. The ones that did missed so much school from injuries. There used to be someone else with a broken collar bone every week, always someone off for physiotherapy following some bone break.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 25/04/2022 12:20

All sports carry some risks, statistics as with anything can be skewed and interpreted as to which side of the fence you are on.
I have no idea of the numbers involved but I don't think its helpful to say x% of people with this disease played rugby. It needs to be the other way around x% of rugby players go on to develop this disease.

Brainwave89 · 25/04/2022 12:12

My daughter played rugby at a good level. Precautions were quite tight and justifiably so. As with all safety decisions I think you have to look for balance. Rugby was very empowering for my daughter and she gained huge confidence from doing it. The health benefits are also significant. If rugby is not acceptable then what about football? It is also associated with dementia and other contact sports such as hockey and (the roughest of all for women in my experience) Lacrosse? I think you are right to be a little cautious but you do have to ask what they will miss out on as well.

Pickabearanybear · 25/04/2022 12:05

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

senua · 25/04/2022 11:59

Having read about professional players developing MND, dementia etc ...
What relevance have some professional players to your DC? It's like saying Ayrton Senna died in a car crash therefore I'll never let my DC drive. There's a big difference between someone who does it for a living, pushing boundaries to get a competitive edge, and yer average kid.

yellowsuninthesky · 25/04/2022 11:51

I think (state) school rugby should be tag only. Clubs (should) have properly qualified coaches and should be well informed of the risks. Plus it is a choice to play it at club level, which it may not be at school.

Private schools may have properly qualified coaches too, so the issue is slightly different.

edwinbear · 25/04/2022 11:48

DS (12) has played since he was 2, DD (10) started last September, they both play for a Club and school. I echo others than the sportsmanship, teamwork and inclusivity in rugby is quite exceptional and we highly value that. There is no disagreeing with the referee, no parents shouting at the kids/ref, it's a very respectful sport and the skills DC have taken from it have carried across into their schoolwork and other sport.

There is risk when they start contact, but if they are well trained, they learn how to tackle safely and crucially, how to fall when tackled. This doesn't fully eliminate the risk entirely and DS ended up with a concussion this season. The protocol for return to play is very stringent - DS was seen by 3 doctors and was off all sport for 3 weeks, including swimming/running as there would be a tiny risk of him falling poolside for example and hitting his head again, which was deemed an unacceptable risk.

I'm comfortable with the risk personally, but we reassess at the start of each season. DS is slight but fast, so plays on the wing or full back, I'd feel differently if he was on the front row. He could do with putting some weight on before the start of next season as even though he's usually the fastest man on the pitch so doesn't get caught, on the occasions he does, the kids are much bigger and bring him down hard. He absolutely adores the game and would be furious if I tried to stop him playing.

imovethestarsforno1 · 25/04/2022 11:39

im probably in the minority here but my almost 9yo plays rugby and boxes. My gragrandad and great grandad were professional boxers and a cousin plays rugby at county level my grandad and great grandad did both end up with dementia but i dont feel that boxing was entirely to blame for that. I let ds do these activities because he enjoys them and it links him to his history. As pp have said any sport is dangerous my mum is wrecked from years of ballet and ive had no end of injurys from aerial acro.

ResentfulLemon · 25/04/2022 10:55

My opinion is skewed slightly because my dad has MND. He wasn't a rugby player, but now we're in the MND community the amount of men who used to play rugby who now have MND tells a scary story. Statistically they and other high contact sport players seem to make up the largest common denominator of those struck down by this tortuous and evil disease.

It may be a small risk, but frankly as anyone who knows someone with advanced MND will tell you you'd do anything to avoid increasing your chances of developing it.

There's nothing that could persuade me to allow my children do any contact sport where heavy head contact is a probable outcome of playing rather than a rare one.

Giraffesandbottom · 25/04/2022 10:09

Make sure he wears a scrum cap and a mouth guard and he will be fine. And a cup!

all the best sports contain risk

Simonjt · 25/04/2022 09:54

Rugby is a brilliant sport with a very healthy team spirit, negative team spirit is very much frowned upon.

All sports carry a risk, I would be more concerned about head injuries in football, especially as the FA are still in denial.

I played at a high level professionally, I now play a lower level part time. No significant injuries here, no concussion. I did break my arm playing a sport, tennis!

Haggisfish3 · 23/04/2022 09:01

I totally agree op. My ds is perfect shape and build for rugby but there is no way he will be playing it. I also think the brain damage from it (and possibly football) will be revealed over the next few decades.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/04/2022 08:59

Yanbu. I think both rugby and football are facing an early dementia time bomb in the near future.

Our small town has also had a couple of young lads paralysed. One sadly died. Such a waste.

fUNNYfACE36 · 23/04/2022 08:57

I don't think that you will have the option to withdraw them from contact rugby at school when they get to secondary

KangarooKenny · 23/04/2022 08:55

I knew of more injuries from football than rugby when my DS was playing both.

Carpy88999 · 23/04/2022 08:54

Pretty much every sport is dangerous and the benefits always outweighs the negatives! Unless we're talking extreme sports like cave diving I'd never ever stop my kids from partaking in sports.

SoggyPaper · 23/04/2022 08:47

DS broke his wrist snowboarding. I dislocated my elbow after a bike accident.

participation is Sport increases the risk in injury. But coaching and awareness di increase the risk.

my experience of rugby has been that it’s incredibly inclusive and very social for them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread