Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I pay rent??

85 replies

Ema1986 · 22/04/2022 22:52

Ive been with my partner for 8 years and we have 3 children together. 9 months ago we moved into a house (for which the mortgage is in my partners name only). I am unable to get a mortgage and so the house is in his name. The deposit for the house was also his. Prior to moving in we agreed that we would get a deed of trust stating that the deposit (and a larger proportion of the equity) would go to him, and that a portion of the equity would be mine (in the event of separation). Since then, I’ve gone part time in work (3 days per week) to support with childcare costs. Before this we both earned the same. Currently, we pay the mortgage/bills proportionate to our salary (so I pay 40% and he pays 60%). Last month I was pushing for the deed of trust to be done (we have been here for 9 months now after all), and my partner flat out refused the document. He has back tracked and is now saying the house is his, but that I would still need to continue to pay ‘rent’. I’ve basically told him that I will pay half of all the non-mortgage bills (gas/electric,water etc) but I’m not paying a penny towards the mortgage nor in rent. I don’t think it’s fair for me to continue to pay towards the house when he has told me I now no longer have any financial interest in it. I also don’t think it’s fair to take ‘rent’, leaving me without an option to be able to save now that he no longer wants me to be part of the house. I need some financial security for me and the kids). I’ve worked out that if I pay half the non-mortgage bills, and he pays the full mortgage, we both have the same amount of money left over each month even though I work part time and maintain the house. Am I being unreasonable here??

OP posts:
RaspberryChouxBuns · 23/04/2022 16:34

This is grim and financial abuse OP. Be careful.

BritWifeInUSA · 23/04/2022 16:31

How is he a “partner” if he’s treating you like a house guest he can get rid of whenever he wants?

You say you want “financial security”. Usually the best way to achieve this is by marriage. Especially when children are involved. If he threw you and the children out tomorrow, you could probably keep yourself going with your part-time job but what about the children?

He won’t marry you. He won’t even let you have any of the house equity, but he’s happy to have you pay some bills. That’s not a partnership. Not even close. I’m sorry to say he sees you as a bedmate who pays some of his bills. If you’re happy with that, carry on.

DaizyDee · 23/04/2022 16:26

It sounds like there are other issues here. I'd be booking a couples counsellor.

DinoWoman · 23/04/2022 16:25

Oh, and slowly deduct the 'rent' you've already paid over the last 9 months from your bill payments.

DinoWoman · 23/04/2022 16:23

What a pig. I just don't think I could stay with someone that would do this. Get your ducks in a row and LTB. And don't pay a penny in rent!

ChoiceMummy · 23/04/2022 15:57

Ultimately, why would he make himself financially vulnerable for no gain?
He's not married and thus wishes to preserve his finances. Not unreasonable and I'm sure that any parent of boys would be hoping that they sons are also secure.

Equally, this makes you incredibly financially vulnerable. And not a position that any of would want to be in nor encourage our daughters to be in.

Are you unreasonable not to contribute to the house over your head? Yes, I think that you are (I understand why) but ultimately if it wasn't his home you'd be paying this money to benefit someone else and I don't think that it's "fair" to freeload off your oh in that way.

However, if you're the one who's sacrificed 2/5of your earning for the childcare savings this needs financially being rectified, perhaps with you being given the equivalent of 1 days salary from your oh, but then you contributing half towards the mortgage or a rental figure.

This is a nightmare scenario tbh. And needed sorting before moving into the mortgaged house.

Was some of the savings used as a result of you not working? I'd be inclined to calculate how much again your reduced hours etc has saved him and show him a breakdown.

Ultimately though, I don't see any middle ground here for either of you and wonder if this may be what breaks the relationship. Though I'd be making sure that he's aware of how much he'd be paying in child maintenance before this! As that reality check along with spiralling cost of living may sober him up.

Whatsmyname100 · 23/04/2022 12:41

Clymene · 22/04/2022 23:09

If he won't marry you, I'd leave. You're subsiding his mortgage and are in a really vulnerable position

Exactly, please wise up op. You are in such a vulnerable position. He could just kick you out and that's that. I think he's disgusting really, you have 3 kids together and he thinks so little of you to not ensure that you have a secure home. This would make me want to leave.

Merryoldgoat · 23/04/2022 12:28

What a complete prick.

that would be the end for me. You’ve significantly disadvantaged yourself by having children without being married and going part time.

you can’t change the past but make plans to live without him asap.

serenghetti2011 · 23/04/2022 12:20

He doesn’t sound like a nice man. I would not like this selfishness in a partner. You’re good enough to live with and have 3 children but not share lives/money/home etc horrible attitude!! He’s an ‘I’m alright jack’ isn’t he long as he’ll have a home he’s not really bothered about you and what might happen in the future. Sorry op not a nice man

user1471538283 · 23/04/2022 12:05

He either marries you or you leave. I would be very nervous in your position. He could evict you and you wouldnt have anything.

CareBearsCare · 23/04/2022 11:38

I was a SAHM (zero income) and been on the mortgage/deeds. It's combined household income that counts.

Yanbu to insist that if you pay towards the mortgage then you need to have a defined percentage of the house

LuaDipa · 23/04/2022 11:31

420Bruh · 22/04/2022 23:09

Pick your hours back up at work and start making plans to leave. You don't want to find yourself 8 years down the line with no interest in the property (who pays repairs decor etc etc?) that you call a home.

This.

He’s horrible and greedy and you deserve better.

Grandville · 23/04/2022 11:28

If it wasn't for the children and resulting part time hours, I would agree with him. He has saved up the entire deposit and OP couldn't be on the mortgage even though she earned the same as him? Implies OP is terrible with money and that would put me right off. Why should anyone get to live for free?

However OP did give up full time work to care for joint children and that needs to be recognised. OP's solution of either original agreement or paying half utilities only is entirely fair.

Goldbar · 23/04/2022 10:54

If you pay him rent, he needs to pay you childcare to cover the increased share of childcare hours you do. £15 per hour is the going rate around here, plus overnight rate if you're the one that gets up with the kids in the night.

MinnieMountain · 23/04/2022 10:26

I was a SAHM when we took out our current mortgage. Unless you have a bad credit rating there’s no reason for you to not be a co-owner.

You’re being completely reasonable.

Elsiebear90 · 23/04/2022 10:18

You’ve put yourself in a really stupidly vulnerable position here OP, three kids, no marriage, no financial security, no property, no full time job, with a man who lies to you and is clearly trying to screw you over.

So many women do this and I have no idea why, it’s just depressing to keep reading. My advice would be to leave him as you can’t trust him and he’s not viewing your as a partner, he’s out for what he can get and that’s it.

cherrypiepie · 23/04/2022 10:12

No that's awful. I'd be hurt and angry that he has changed his mind in something that he had agreed. I also think it would be a dealbreaker for me as he has let you down so terribly.

Do not pay towards the mortgage. I'm in similar situation and don't pay. I'm fortunate in that I can save the money that I would put towards mortgage.

UserError012345 · 23/04/2022 10:05

Remind him that if you split, child maintenance will be steep for 3 kids.

What a bell end.

UserError012345 · 23/04/2022 10:03

He should have told you before you moved in together that was his intention. Then you could have knowingly made a decision to rent or not.

He will have to accept that he's forgone his right to rent and if he doesn't then you need to decide if you stay or move out.

Chatwin · 23/04/2022 09:53

Is there a reason you're not married? He's absolutely taking the piss and you're in an extremely vulnerable position.

I would be demanding marriage, or at the very least this deed to trust, wills, life insurance and any other legal protection - or leave him.

Same1977 · 23/04/2022 09:49

Go back to work full time and split childcare.Pay rent as should you be loving somewhere for free ?

Legoninjago1 · 23/04/2022 09:44

This is dreadful OP. Don't accept this.

thebeespyjamas · 23/04/2022 09:38

Ema1986 · 22/04/2022 22:52

Ive been with my partner for 8 years and we have 3 children together. 9 months ago we moved into a house (for which the mortgage is in my partners name only). I am unable to get a mortgage and so the house is in his name. The deposit for the house was also his. Prior to moving in we agreed that we would get a deed of trust stating that the deposit (and a larger proportion of the equity) would go to him, and that a portion of the equity would be mine (in the event of separation). Since then, I’ve gone part time in work (3 days per week) to support with childcare costs. Before this we both earned the same. Currently, we pay the mortgage/bills proportionate to our salary (so I pay 40% and he pays 60%). Last month I was pushing for the deed of trust to be done (we have been here for 9 months now after all), and my partner flat out refused the document. He has back tracked and is now saying the house is his, but that I would still need to continue to pay ‘rent’. I’ve basically told him that I will pay half of all the non-mortgage bills (gas/electric,water etc) but I’m not paying a penny towards the mortgage nor in rent. I don’t think it’s fair for me to continue to pay towards the house when he has told me I now no longer have any financial interest in it. I also don’t think it’s fair to take ‘rent’, leaving me without an option to be able to save now that he no longer wants me to be part of the house. I need some financial security for me and the kids). I’ve worked out that if I pay half the non-mortgage bills, and he pays the full mortgage, we both have the same amount of money left over each month even though I work part time and maintain the house. Am I being unreasonable here??

I think you do have a financial interest in the house via habit; contract via habit. So you've been helping to pay off the mortgage debt and so even though you are not on the documents (great as you are not liable for the huge debt of a mortgage) you have been contributing and a judge should deem this an interest in the equity.

So I would continue doing it, keep all records, and if he tries to shove you out of the equity he shouldn't be able to.

I would speak to a solicitor about this and get the facts as I was taught this over ten years ago and never ended up qualifying a solicitor. This was contract law and it was fascinating. Speak to a contract solicitor.

NameGoesHere · 23/04/2022 08:26

He’s playing you for a fool.

Cheesechips · 23/04/2022 08:21

He's being unreasonable, selfish and greedy. If he doesn't change his mind I'd leave him. No reason for you not to on the deed just because the mortgage isn't in your name. Talk about selfish! You're the mother of his children for goodness sake.