Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to cook for my lodger’s friends?

137 replies

Itmustbeaproblemwithyourdoodad · 22/04/2022 17:42

So we’re a household of 6 - me, my husband, our 3 small kids, and our lodger (late 20s, male, family friend we have known for years).

Since lockdown we eat together - I do the food shopping, meal planning and cook most of the meals. Lodger cooks one night a week, DH sometimes cooks at the weekend. Lodger washes up and cleans the kitchen while we’re putting the kids to bed.

I often feel a bit like our lodger is like having an extra child - although it is nice to come down from bedtime to the washing up all done.

This weekend our lodger has friends staying over from abroad and I asked if they were eating out or if he was planning to cook for them. His response surprised me a bit - he asked what I was planning to cook and when I said “probably macaroni cheese” he said “that’s quite easy to bulk up isn’t it?” Making it clear he is expecting, or at least hoping that I will cook for them. He made me feel a bit unreasonable for not wanting to cook for them but I feel like as his guests it is his responsibility to feed them. And that includes food shopping for them instead of just using the food in the cupboard (which he does financially contribute to but he literally never goes food shopping). I just don’t really fancy spending my weekend cooking for 8!

OP posts:
notwhatineednow · 23/04/2022 06:00

If you stop the family meals, how is it going to work? I'm not surprised he went silent, that's a huge rejection of a friend who must have felt like part of the family, with no other solution on offer. If you said that to me as a young woman I would have wondered what I did wrong and think I wasn't wanted there.

We used to have lodgers and we all ate together if they wanted to. As we're sociable people this worked for us.

Having people trying to prepare different meals in the kitchen in the evening us much harder than chipping in together.

The problem in this situation is that the balance isn't right, and you're being taken for granted.

I mean, it's your home, if you don't want to cook for someone that's your perogative! But I wonder if there is a solution where other people share the responsibility more? Could you have a chat with your lodger/friend and explain that things have changed since you've gone back to work, and you don't have the time to cook for everyone all the time. Maybe ask him if he'd like to get more involved with cooking or if he'd prefer to cook his own meals. Or maybe you could all eat together on the weekends but not week days or something.

What about your husband, is he doing his fair share?

SScoobiedoo · 23/04/2022 05:53

Also does doing the washing up mean filling the dishwasher - a brainless activity where you can happily listen to the radio or podcast to pass the time - or is he up to his elbows in suds and saucepans ?
Planning, shopping for and cooking a meal is not comparable in the slightest.

SScoobiedoo · 23/04/2022 05:43

I have decided on, usually bought for and cooked the evening meal every night for nearly 40 years - and I fucking resent it - just saying.
Don't fall into this trap.

Zonder · 23/04/2022 05:37

Lodger obviously feels like part of the family because you have treated him like that. Personally I think it's lovely because you have also clearly benefitted with the clearing up and him cooking on a Friday.

Personally I'd continue this because to go back to how it was two years ago is quite pointed (and he clearly felt this from how he went quiet when you suggested stopping eating together). When you say stop the communal meals you're actually just saying we don't want you to eat with us any more, and changing the dynamic of the set up. I would feel far less welcome now if I were him.

I think with the visitors too I would have gone ahead and cooked one meal for them. How long are they staying?

Kiopa · 23/04/2022 05:07

Do you actually want to stop the communal meals when it's just him? I didn't get that impression from your other posts. If you do then fair enough, but if you do enjoy eating together and him doing the washing up then don't stop that just because of the guest thing. I think you can just say to him 2 extra people just means more work cooking and you don't want to do that of a weekend. If they're staying two nights you could suggest a compromise of them cooking one meal and you cooking the other or just sort out times when you'll be cooking so they can cook after/suggest they get a takeaway.

StoppinBy · 23/04/2022 05:01

frazzledasarock · 23/04/2022 04:08
if his feelings are hurt that’s on him for assuming his landlady is his personal chef.

I disagree, cooking an extra plate of food when you are already cooking is far less work than doing all the washing up. It's more than a fair trade for OP and I don't see how it can be seen as the lodger using OP as a personal chef.

Silencedoesnotprotection · 23/04/2022 04:57

A simply reordering or the boundaries is necessary.

It's hard with friends or friends of family but vitally important to your health and well-being.

Monty27 · 23/04/2022 04:45

Tell him he's on shopping and cooking and cleaning duties for the whole family whilst accommodating his guests.

grapewines · 23/04/2022 04:36

Sure. This whole situation could have been avoided had she acted like a landlady from the beginning plus said no to the guests staying over. Lesson learned.

frazzledasarock · 23/04/2022 04:08

if his feelings are hurt that’s on him for assuming his landlady is his personal chef.

Meal planning and cooking is probably one of the most tedious parts of adulting. I’d be knocking the regular meals on the head and asking everyone to pitch i with cooking and H should sort out his own vegan meals on days your meals can’t be easily adapted.

Coming home from work, sorting out the kids and then cooking a meal for a family and two entitled adult males is miserable. Do you actually get any downtime on weekdays?

grapewines · 23/04/2022 03:36

I just saw your last update, personally, I think you likely hurt his feelings and that's why he went quiet. He has now gone from part of the family to excluded.

Agree with this. You blurred the lines. It's your right to say what you did, but if I were him I'd be hurt. Things are likely to be awkward now. In his place, I'd be looking for another place to stay. Awkwardness where you live is the worst feeling.

But at this point maybe him living elsewhere is best for you too. Just don't blur the lines with the next one.

TheDug4 · 23/04/2022 03:23

Bonkers.

StoppinBy · 23/04/2022 03:06

I just saw your last update, personally, I think you likely hurt his feelings and that's why he went quiet. He has now gone from part of the family to excluded.

If I am honest, I wouldn't be giving up the current deal, an extra meal for the washing up (when he is paying for his own food also) is a great swap in labour for you/DP.

DP needs to put in more though as his diet is making things far harder than before.

StoppinBy · 23/04/2022 02:55

I would happily add an extra meal every night to have someone do the cleaning up afterwards so I don't think that's an issue here at all.

I however would not be cooking for his friends and think it's rude that he just expected you to do that.

Have a chat about it with him and explain that he will need to cater for his friends as it's too much extra work and expense.

I assume that you/your DP will be responsible for kitchen clean up on those nights though.

SpindleInTheWind · 23/04/2022 02:51

FatFucker · 22/04/2022 20:35

Absolutely not is food part of lodgers!! Where on earth did you get that idea from?

Magna Carta?

KettrickenSmiled · 23/04/2022 02:37

LittleOwl153 · 22/04/2022 21:42

I suspect you are feeling a bit put upon all round OP. You cook dinner 5/6 nights a week, deal with 3 small children and work too... and then you are feeding a lodger and vegan DH too.... sounds like both men need to shoulder a bit more of the work!

This, with knobs on.

KettrickenSmiled · 23/04/2022 02:29

JennyJumpup · 22/04/2022 18:56

I think by definition, meals are supposed to be provided with lodgings.

So the favour you would be doing him is allowing his guests to eat with you on this one occasion.

Unless a couple of cups of extra macaroni would break the bank, I think it would be gracious of you to do this.

Good grief people on here are mean!

In 19th century lodging houses, or mid-20th boarding/holiday houses, sure.

But this is 2022, & meals are certainly not 'provided'! A lodger is paying for a bedroom on the house, & reasonable sharing of communal rooms. They certainly don't get menu planning, shopping & catering included! - hence the well-known cliche of Fridge Frustration, labelled shelves etc - the more common food arrangement is petty squabbles about who nicked somebody else's last bit of cheese etc ...

PP aren't being mean Jenny.
They are rightly outraged by the breathtaking entitlement of a young man imagining he can order his landlady to provide domestic labour to friends he ought to be hosting himself. It's not about a couple of cups of macaroni ffs.

KettrickenSmiled · 23/04/2022 02:17

He made me feel a bit unreasonable for not wanting to cook for them

You can cut that feeling out right now missus!. YANBU.

OK?
Right. Now brace yourself, & tackle him. "lodger, I'm a bit bamboozled that you imagine I'm some kind of personal chef. I'm not your mum - I'm your friend & landlady. I'm happy to include you in family meals, but if you invite friends to dinner - YOU are responsible for feeding them. And that includes shopping & cooking - I am not your servant, young man."

Good luck & enjoy the macaroni cheese :)

JennyJumpup · 23/04/2022 01:59

OP's lodger sounds great - he is paying for the food he eats, he's washing up most nights, he sometimes cooks, he's nice to have around...is it worth OP cutting off her nose to spite her face?

I agree, and he is a family friend to boot.

Thank you to all who corrected me re. meals being included with lodgings. I thought I had read up on the matter, but I guess that was quite a few years ago.

pixie5121 · 22/04/2022 21:46

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

LittleOwl153 · 22/04/2022 21:42

I suspect you are feeling a bit put upon all round OP. You cook dinner 5/6 nights a week, deal with 3 small children and work too... and then you are feeding a lodger and vegan DH too.... sounds like both men need to shoulder a bit more of the work!

pixie5121 · 22/04/2022 21:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

littlefireseverywhere · 22/04/2022 21:33

I think there’s 2 separate issues. Lodger joining dinner every night seems to suit you all. Think about how convenient it is to have a lodger you like & get on with. You could suggest that x nights a week you each do your own thing. He clearly likes eating with you.

For the friends, I’d suggest that you invite them for one night then suggest they all do their own thing the rest of the week?

but with

VivaLaRaza · 22/04/2022 21:18

I agree that the lines here have been well and truly blurred. Just say you don’t feel like cooking for all of them and that, while they’re here, it’s best that the three of them make their own arrangements for dinner. You also need to decide if you want to stop communal meals altogether or, perhaps, cut them down. I think once a week, or even weekends, would be a good compromise if it’s something you don’t want to stop altogether.

40Jem · 22/04/2022 21:14

I think you set yourself up for this when you agreed to have his guests stay. I think having them to stay does mean including them in meals as that is the current set up with your lodger. If you didn't want to host them, then you really should have said no to them staying. If your lodger normally cooked for himself , it would be a different matter. Seems a shame to stop the communal meal arrangement that was working well. I would have just told him no more guests after these and carried on as you were.