Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to cook for my lodger’s friends?

137 replies

Itmustbeaproblemwithyourdoodad · 22/04/2022 17:42

So we’re a household of 6 - me, my husband, our 3 small kids, and our lodger (late 20s, male, family friend we have known for years).

Since lockdown we eat together - I do the food shopping, meal planning and cook most of the meals. Lodger cooks one night a week, DH sometimes cooks at the weekend. Lodger washes up and cleans the kitchen while we’re putting the kids to bed.

I often feel a bit like our lodger is like having an extra child - although it is nice to come down from bedtime to the washing up all done.

This weekend our lodger has friends staying over from abroad and I asked if they were eating out or if he was planning to cook for them. His response surprised me a bit - he asked what I was planning to cook and when I said “probably macaroni cheese” he said “that’s quite easy to bulk up isn’t it?” Making it clear he is expecting, or at least hoping that I will cook for them. He made me feel a bit unreasonable for not wanting to cook for them but I feel like as his guests it is his responsibility to feed them. And that includes food shopping for them instead of just using the food in the cupboard (which he does financially contribute to but he literally never goes food shopping). I just don’t really fancy spending my weekend cooking for 8!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Indicatrice · 13/05/2022 16:11

Newestname002 · 23/04/2022 15:47

@Itmustbeaproblemwithyourdoodad

Also we need to have an awkward conversation about raising the rent as we haven’t put it up in the nearly 4 years he’s been here and it includes all bills and is pretty low.

When are you going to have this ^^ conversation OP? Especially with energy, fuel, food etc bills all rising currently. 🌹

Agreed!

TheDug4 · 24/04/2022 02:08

You have more patience than me.
I would have stopped catering for the mens immediately.

I would definitely increase his rent, too.
Hopefully that will push him out and you can find someone who isn't a cocklodger - without the 'cock' part.

Goldbar · 23/04/2022 16:39

I think you cooking for everyone (or at least meal planning/managing the shopping) the whole time clearly doesn't work now you're no longer a SAHM and are working. Either you divide the evenings (your DH cooks 2 nights, you cook 2 nights, lodger cooks 2 nights and takeaway on the final night) or I'd tell both your DH and lodger to fend for themselves and make something simple for you and the kids. I don't think the real problem is the guests, but the overall allocation of responsibilities.

Cooking for adults is so much more work than cooking for children. My DC had some leftover salmon and boiled noodles and carrots yesterday since I didn't feel like eating (pregnancy nausea)... the whole meal took around 4 minutes to make but clearly not something an adult would enjoy eating. I would hate to feel I had to make a proper, homecooked meal every night.

Newestname002 · 23/04/2022 15:47

@Itmustbeaproblemwithyourdoodad

Also we need to have an awkward conversation about raising the rent as we haven’t put it up in the nearly 4 years he’s been here and it includes all bills and is pretty low.

When are you going to have this ^^ conversation OP? Especially with energy, fuel, food etc bills all rising currently. 🌹

andweallsingalong · 23/04/2022 14:00

Initially I thought his request was out of order, but then... He's one person out of six and cleans the kitchen every night, plus cooks a night a week so actually in terms of sharing the load at mealtimes I would be very happy with this and think him to be doing more than his share so I'd suck up cooking for the guests and maybe ask him to cook for everyone one of the nights.

Might be biased though as if I had the choice I would always pick cooking a large meal over washing up!

Wondering what your husbands contribution is other than cooking once a week as if anyone isn't pulling their weight it seems to be him.

Classicblunder · 23/04/2022 13:28

We use a website called plan to eat which might be of interest to you - you add or import recipes, put them on a calendar and it generates a shopping list. You can sync to Google calendar (probably iCal too) and then just click on the recipe. You could then just tell your lodger/DH on their days to cook what's in there and/or take it in turns to meal plan

PrincessRamone · 23/04/2022 13:20

Sounds like a good resolution OP

Itmustbeaproblemwithyourdoodad · 23/04/2022 13:13

Wow thanks everyone for all the responses. Lots to think about and I agree I’ve let resentment build and been awful at communication. I probably need to do some work on myself and being more assertive.

Yes we have a dishwasher, and washing up recently has been more of a joint effort so maybe I’ve felt like lodger is not pulling his weight. When he’s out or away it doesn’t actually feel like much more work, and a massive bonus is we have leftovers for lunch (saving loads of money as DH usually buys lunch otherwise). So we’ve been thinking for a while that maybe it’s time to stop the communal meals, but I agree that blurting it out like I did was not a great way to break the news!

Also we need to have an awkward conversation about raising the rent as we haven’t put it up in the nearly 4 years he’s been here and it includes all bills and is pretty low.

When we started the cooking rota what I envisaged was that on their cooking nights, lodger and DH would plan and shop for their meals ie share the mental load. But what actually happens is lodger looks in the cupboards and if I haven’t specifically bought ingredients and shown him a recipe, he throws a few tins of beans and tomatoes into a pan with some onions and pasta and the result is almost inedible. So I end up planning and shopping for his meal too and to be fair it wouldn’t be much more work to actually cook it myself (and it would taste better).

DH isn’t much better with the meal planning but I guess I feel like we’re more of a team as we share the childcare and other household jobs. Neither of us has much spare time so feels like quite a fair division of labour. Also I’m more comfortable telling him when he’s pissing me off so don’t let the resentment build in the same way!! He’s also the default night parent and that’s something I try not to take for granted.

Anyway, we all had a chat this morning and agreed that lodger will pick up a takeaway for tonight (and we’ll pay our share) and that we will review the communal cooking and either do our own thing after this month OR the men will share the shopping and food planning a bit more.

OP posts:
Classicblunder · 23/04/2022 12:32

I don't think it's just about him being a lodger - if my DH invites friends round that are primarily his friends, I expect him to take the lead and organise the food, sheets, towels etc. Of course I help host but I would be quite annoyed if he expected me to sort out dinner completely with no effort on his part.

mcmooberry · 23/04/2022 12:13

Having had a couple of lodgers I would just say bulk up the macaroni cheese as he sounds like a great lodger as finding one with 3 small children would not be easy. His friends will hopefully be lovely people and you'll have a great evening. Very cheeky of him to ask of course but it's a cheap easy (and delicious!) meal. Although never tried a vegan version to be fair.

frazzledasarock · 23/04/2022 12:11

Quite frankly I’d happily clear up after dinner if someone else did the cooking. Doesn’t take much effort to stack the dishwasher. And wipe down surfaces.

Noisyprat · 23/04/2022 11:52

From the OP:

'His response surprised me a bit - he asked what I was planning to cook and when I said “probably macaroni cheese” he said “that’s quite easy to bulk up isn’t it?” Making it clear he is expecting, or at least hoping that I will cook for them. '

He evidently then went quiet, ie he sulked like a man child.

He expected OP to just do it. This IS entitled behaviour. Why didn't he say to the OP 'is it ok if my friends eat with us on Friday, I'll get it all and cook'. Even my DP wouldn't assume like this. Family friend, relative, whatever - doesn't matter - you don't expect, you look to yourself first not assume someone will sort it out. Sorry but this is typical male behaviour.

Triffid1 · 23/04/2022 11:43

I've only read your posts so apologies if I'm repeating what others have said but surely if it works well for you all to eat together with him doing the washing up, that' fine to continue. As for his friends coming over, well, he should pay for their food on top of whatever he already pays to contribute to food costs and if there is more work to be done to cook for more people, then he should help to do that. I have had similar when, for example, family members are staying and want to invite friends over. It's a bright, "sure, no problem. You'll need to get to the supermarket or I can add extra to the online shop if you give me the money. On the day, can you make sure you're home in time to lend a hand with the cooking and preparation?"

I think unless there's a specific reason why you no longer want to eat communally with him, that you've allowed MN outrage to potentially negatively impact a positive and happy relationship with your lodger.

PrincessRamone · 23/04/2022 11:38

I agree @pixie5121

Particularly as the OP describes the lodger as a family friend we have known for years

It doesn’t sound like this is a normal short term lodger situation. This is a long term family friend who has also now been living essentially as one of the family for years. Essentially part of the extended family and contributing with both money and effort. They are now supposed to revert to knowing their place and just having a transactional financial relationship.

pixie5121 · 23/04/2022 11:25

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Classicblunder · 23/04/2022 09:53

It's so weird that they even want to have dinner with you and your kids rather than go out just them!

PrincessRamone · 23/04/2022 09:39

I think you are being unfair to the lodger. You’ve had an arrangement that has worked for you all for years, and it sounds like he’s pulled his weight.

Now you want to change it. Have a proper sit down meeting with him about what changes you want to make and see if the changes are suitable for both parties. Don’t be surprised if you lose your lodger.

As for the guests, I can understand his confusion. If you have all eaten together for 2 years (presumably also when you have friends over?) why would he expect different? If you wanted it to be different this time then you could have said so clearly when you were first asked.

Midlifemusings · 23/04/2022 09:23

He contributes money for the shopping and does the washing up and cooks for the family once a week - given that OP wanted this arrangement during lockdown as having him do the washing up was helpful to her, I am not sure why so many are attacking him. It seems this is what they arranged.

It is challenging to have a lodger who buys all their own food and does all their own cooking in a shared home. You need to be sure they have fridge, cupboard, and kitchen space and it can mean trying to coordinate meal times and who will cook when. For example if he is to cook dinner for his two guests for three nights - that may be somewhat inconvenient for OP / DH who also need to cook for their family. For a lodger who has been 'part of the family' it makes sense to eat meals together and if OP feels his financial contribution and washing up and cooking one family meal doesn't fairly make up for her / DH cooking the other 6 nights, then fair enough, they can have that discussion.

I don't get all the hate being directed at the lodger.

katepilar · 23/04/2022 09:20

laalaaland · 22/04/2022 20:42

It sounds like the communal meals / treating the lodger more like family is really nice and works for all of you. What doesn't work is the roles. So instead of stopping the shared meals, why not suggest altering the rota? Take it in turns to do the food shopping, and /or he cooks twice (or more) a week and you wash up on those days, whatever would remove the resentment for you.

I like this idea.

I dont get why people are judging what arrangements you have with your lodger, OP. Its absolutely fine if you like communal meals.

grapewines · 23/04/2022 09:19

Maybe you'd feel less resentful if your husband did more of the cooking and cleaning up. I suspect he'll get his chance now. The lodger is unlikely to clean up after your family meals going forward.

gannett · 23/04/2022 09:16

starfishmummy · 23/04/2022 09:12

Hes a CF. When he asked if they could stay would have been the ideal time to remind him that he has a commercial arrangement with you and that does not include you having to accommodate and feed extra people.

Do CFs do all the washing up every night?

God some of you are unpleasant.

OP should absolutely revisit the arrangements if they're no longer working for her but there's so much bile on this thread about the lodger. Do you all speak like that to the people in your life you presumably like?

starfishmummy · 23/04/2022 09:12

Hes a CF. When he asked if they could stay would have been the ideal time to remind him that he has a commercial arrangement with you and that does not include you having to accommodate and feed extra people.

SScoobiedoo · 23/04/2022 08:58

So your lodger washes up - while you put your feet up????

No????

So what's the advantage - perhaps DH could see to the DCs, lodger wash up and you put yoru feet up.

katepilar · 23/04/2022 08:55

beetr00 · 22/04/2022 20:18

@Itmustbeaproblemwithyourdoodad

www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/best-ever-macaroni-cheese-recipe

Just fyi OP, for this occasion only (for ease),

microwave, in a jug, all ingredients, the flour, butter, milk, garlic, mustard, cheeses, all together (in 2-3 minute bursts and whisk each time)

Combine with cooked pasta and pop in oven

Bulk out with garlic bread, baked potatoes, salad, on the side?

that sounds a lot more complicated then to cook the sauce properly on the hob.

Cheesechips · 23/04/2022 08:53

I think you blurred the lines a long time ago but he could have asked you in a more direct way and not just assumed you would cook for his friends. You seem lovely and he's a lucky lodger. I'd personally just make extra this time but have a chat about arrangements going forward.