Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to lend friend £50?

121 replies

CordeliaChasex · 22/04/2022 16:58

Context: left an abusive relationship last August. Ex was a coke addict and borrowed money off me constantly for various reasons/excuses. I was a mug and felt like one, hated myself for saying yes.

Now: made friends with a guy at work. He seems nice, bought me a cinema ticket when I was feeling down and I had a nice time. He's also complimented me a lot. Don't know if there's anything romantic there. We've probably been friends for about a month at most, before that we were colleagues.

Today he messaged me asking to borrow £50 and it's set all these alarms off in my head. He wants to borrow until Monday (payday). Affording it isn't the issue, I'm more suspicious of why he's asking me and what this means.

Am I being overly suspicious or is this weird behavior on his part?

We are both doctors but I'm part time, so he earns probably £5k a year more than me on average.

I think that's all the relevant details.

FWIW, I really don't want to lend him any money. I'm just feeling put on the spot/guilty and unsure how to say no.

OP posts:
ZealAndArdour · 23/04/2022 01:31

Don’t give him any money OP.

Also absolutely flabbergasted that some of the people on here no nothing of how poorly paid and poorly treated junior doctors are. They’ve only been campaigning about it for fucking years. I earn much more than a junior doctor as a band 7 nurse. Junior doctors have a rubbish contract, rubbish hours, rubbish money, rubbish work/life balance, rubbish treatment from rota teams and consultants and very little autonomy over where they live or work.

daisychain01 · 23/04/2022 01:27

As for the 'charming' posters dissecting the OPs finances, I have no words.

That's about as low down as you can get.

daisychain01 · 23/04/2022 01:21

Why not give him the benefit of the doubt till payday on Monday.

Yeah, let's be apologists for sponging users who can't manage their money so put upon a decent colleague who they think will be a soft touch and buckle to their request for £50 rather than 'make a fuss' like women have been conditioned to for generations. Saying no, makes a strong person not a bad person.

It will feel empowering for her to say no I can't and see how he slinks off into the distance instead of saying Sorry that was an inappropriate request, I apologise for putting you in such an awkward position (which is what he should do if he had an iota of decency).

daisychain01 · 23/04/2022 01:14

Vikinga · 22/04/2022 17:44

He could at least have explained to you why he needed that money.

This would be my thought.

Why now, and why £50?

he could easily wait until payday but chose to put you in a very awkward position, abusing the privileged position of friendship. He would plummet in my estimation of a friend.

"no I'm not in a position to lend you £50" without any further apology or qualification, shows him you are a woman of your word and taken no shit from anyone.

KettrickenSmiled · 23/04/2022 01:07

@avamiah it seems to have escaped you that our OP is also a doctor, who we put our trust in. So I'm trusting her by bolstering her instinct & resolve on this matter.

And you've skated very conveniently past the fact that, far from not 'doing anything to OP', this colleague has embarrassed her & made her feel so uncomfortable that she - a far-too busy doctor, ffs, has felt compelled to reach out to the mumsnet vipers because she now feels in a quandary about a pushy & inappropriate request.

That's quite enough 'done to her' to be going on with. No need to compound it by risking not getting paid back on monday & all the ensuing awkwardness that would impose. Or advertising herself as a soft touch to a man she barely knows.

Can you not bother @ing me again until it's to send me £50 please?
Because I'm going to get tetchy if you keep recommending ridiculous actions that only benefit Mr Cadging but compromise OP. I might even start imagining it's due to sex-based preferentialism, & you really don't want to be tackling me on that particular little hornet's nest.
TIA

PS she's already said no.

BungleandGeorge · 23/04/2022 01:01

OctopusSay · 22/04/2022 17:18

Take home of £1700 pm equates to less than £25k pa, for what is really a FT job. What kind of doctor are you?

F1 Dr isn’t fully qualified, they are still under supervision and have restrictions on practice eg don’t have the prescribing rights of registered drs. Mind you I’m not sure the pay goes up that much when they do qualify, it’s really not that great below consultant/GP partner level

I’d have leant a tenner maybe but £50 would have said no without hesitation or guilt. People who take advantage do know who to target..

avamiah · 23/04/2022 00:53

KettrickenSmiled · 23/04/2022 00:47

Eh?

@KettrickenSmiled,

What?
Why not give him the benefit of the doubt till payday on Monday.

And yes he is a doctor who we put our trust in and he hasn’t done anything to OP from what she has said.

KettrickenSmiled · 23/04/2022 00:47

avamiah · 23/04/2022 00:33

Lets be honest here and say that if you can’t trust a doctor then who can you trust?

Eh?

avamiah · 23/04/2022 00:37

If payday is Monday then I would personally lend him the £50 and wait till monday for him to pay it back.

If he doesn’t then there is a problem but give him the benefit of the doubt.

avamiah · 23/04/2022 00:33

Lets be honest here and say that if you can’t trust a doctor then who can you trust?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 23/04/2022 00:27

It's more than a lot of people, but for five years of uni on a really competitive course, and working a job where most decisions could kill someone, it isn't great.
It isn't great at all.
I'm shocked. 😲
I appreciate your efforts and large student loans you are left with to help others.
You're obviously intelligent and could have had any career.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 23/04/2022 00:23

No definitely not.

He might be daddling in cocaine too, he must have borrowed money from everyone close to him now he is asking a new friend/colleague.

Smells of desperation.

Sarkymarky · 23/04/2022 00:18

For all of you that have slated me I was trying to give OP some constructive advice about the relationships that OP gets into. I am not victim blaming I was just suggesting that OP should take care about trusting people for her own well being. If it came across as anything else it was not intended in that way.

KettrickenSmiled · 23/04/2022 00:15

FinallyHere · 22/04/2022 21:05

Good decision, OP

Is it only me who suspects that the poor pay rates for doctors (while tabloids suggest they are overpaid and lazy) just another symptom in the running down of the NHS, in order to build the case for privatising it ?

Nope. It's asset stripping by stealth - drain the existing talent off into the encroaching private sector, & discourage emerging talent from applying.

Who cares if there are no more UK medical staff? We can hire 'em from the the States! Just sign here, Ms Patient... oh! can't afford to? Fuck off & die then.

Seraphinesupport · 22/04/2022 21:44

i was a carer.... i earnt 1600 a month :S doing same hours. Wtf is that shit

LadyCordeliaFitzgerald · 22/04/2022 21:39

I wouldn’t worry too much about attracting the wrong type of men. You’ve spotted the red flag here and balked. Well done for that.

The secret to attracting the right type of man is to ruthlessly throw the wrong kind back in and not waste time on them.

Sadly there’s an abundance of the crap kind. They try it on with anyone and everyone.

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 22/04/2022 21:21

There is a document online that shows the average surgical trainee pays £20,000 to become a consultant surgeon NOT including uni fees.

Any country serious about maintaining a free healthcare system would be also serious about attracting and keeping the best medical talent in their healthcare system. It’s immoral that doctors and nurses get into their own personal debt to ultimately improve the quality of our NHS system. I can’t believe you pay that amount for your training but this is Tory UK (although Labour introduced the student fees to be fair to the Tories) so nothing should surprise me anymore.

Genuine thank you for all the work that you do. One of my children has a serious medical condition and the work that his care team do under increasing pressure due to staff shortages is truly humbling.

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 22/04/2022 21:14

me4real · 22/04/2022 21:09

Doctor's pay mightn't be a massive amount at first (still a lot more than many people get) but it definitely rises to it later.

I think it’s irrelevant to say it’s still a lot more than other people get. “Other people” don’t get into £80k worth of student loan debt to get their average salary. “Other people” don’t work 60 hours a week for their average salary.

CordeliaChasex · 22/04/2022 21:13

me4real · 22/04/2022 21:09

Doctor's pay mightn't be a massive amount at first (still a lot more than many people get) but it definitely rises to it later.

It's more than a lot of people, but for five years of uni on a really competitive course, and working a job where most decisions could kill someone, it isn't great.

OP posts:
me4real · 22/04/2022 21:09

Doctor's pay mightn't be a massive amount at first (still a lot more than many people get) but it definitely rises to it later.

me4real · 22/04/2022 21:06

He has more than enough money to live on- a lot more than most people. Something weird is going on if he can't manage his finances.

And he hasn't known you long enough for this to be at all appropriate @CordeliaChasex . Mind how you go with him, keep your eyes open.

CordeliaChasex · 22/04/2022 21:05

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 22/04/2022 21:02

I’m shocked that people are shocked at OP’s salary- WTF does everyone think the sustained but ultimately unsuccessful junior doctor strikes were for?! Why do you think NHS workers hate Jeremy Hunt?

Less and less of our brightest 18 year olds choosing to go to uni to become a doctor - and I don’t blame them. £60k+ in debt, 3 more years of studying than their peers who choose accounting, banking, law or engineering. And while their peers who land professional jobs in the City walk into £40k+ salaries in their first graduate job (increasing to £60-150k after 2-3 years), the junior doctors are on mid 20s salaries with less pay increases, constant training required, more uni debt but comparable (or longer) work hours. And to top it all off, the camaraderie and respect that used to come with being a doctor is gone - patients blame doctors about not being seen (when ultimately the lack of sufficient funding and staff shortages mean the NHS is in crisis), and colleagues throw you under the bus for mistakes which are easy to make when working 24+ hour shifts.

And yet the public perception is that doctors are wealthy. Most of the wealthy doctors are senior consultants who also work privately or locum.

And I pay:

£50 pa to the GMC.
£10 pa for medical defense union.
£6ish pm for BMA (trade union).
£550 for part A of my surgical exam, an exam with a 30% pass rate.
£90 for a surgical course.
£300ish to fly to Scotland for a conference to add to my surgical training portfolio (essential to get max points at interview, and you need 3!).
£10-£30 pa for membership to various royal colleges.

There is a document online that shows the average surgical trainee pays £20,000 to become a consultant surgeon NOT including uni fees.

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 22/04/2022 21:05

Good decision, OP

Is it only me who suspects that the poor pay rates for doctors (while tabloids suggest they are overpaid and lazy) just another symptom in the running down of the NHS, in order to build the case for privatising it ?

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 22/04/2022 21:02

I’m shocked that people are shocked at OP’s salary- WTF does everyone think the sustained but ultimately unsuccessful junior doctor strikes were for?! Why do you think NHS workers hate Jeremy Hunt?

Less and less of our brightest 18 year olds choosing to go to uni to become a doctor - and I don’t blame them. £60k+ in debt, 3 more years of studying than their peers who choose accounting, banking, law or engineering. And while their peers who land professional jobs in the City walk into £40k+ salaries in their first graduate job (increasing to £60-150k after 2-3 years), the junior doctors are on mid 20s salaries with less pay increases, constant training required, more uni debt but comparable (or longer) work hours. And to top it all off, the camaraderie and respect that used to come with being a doctor is gone - patients blame doctors about not being seen (when ultimately the lack of sufficient funding and staff shortages mean the NHS is in crisis), and colleagues throw you under the bus for mistakes which are easy to make when working 24+ hour shifts.

And yet the public perception is that doctors are wealthy. Most of the wealthy doctors are senior consultants who also work privately or locum.

ManateeFair · 22/04/2022 20:43

Can people stop being so bloody rude and nosy about the exact details of the OP’s salary, ffs? It’s really not the point of her question.

OP, it’s inappropriate for a colleague to ask to borrow money from you, even if you’ve recently become friends. If he’d asked you to lend him a fiver for a meal deal on the go because he’d left his wallet in his locker, fine. But £50 until pay day?! Absolutely not. As others have said, he has probably either borrowed money from closer friends/family before and they’ve started saying no to him - or perhaps they all know what he’s spending his money on and think he’s reckless with his cash and needs to rein it in. Either way, tell him no and if he asks you again, tell him not to ask you again because it’s making you feel uncomfortable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread