Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Regarding ex and allotment

37 replies

Beachtrip · 22/04/2022 15:11

I have two dc. Junior 7&9.

History:
I divorced their dad years ago, at the time there were restraining orders on him (this has since expired), we have a rigid court order, we do hand over in public etc.
things have settled somewhat in the last few years. (I still get bullshit texts and accusations but it appears calm enough in front of DC)

Question:
We have an allotment, and it's flourishing. It's our garden as we don't have one at home.

Ds would like to show it to his father. I've said no.
I don't want him there. It's my/our space. It's our lives that don't include him.
It's out of the way and not public.
If it were a garden there's no way I would let him in to see and I don't think DC would ask.
They can send him photos but I don't want to physically walk there with him and have him spend time there.

Aibu? Is this a me problem?
(I can become quite conflicted on things regarding their dad and massively over think)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YouHaveYourFathersBreasts · 23/04/2022 09:36

Completely reasonable and fair. I have/had similar arrangements with my ex. He’s never known any of our addresses, the children know to never ever tell him or his family them. He’s tried to get it out of them and me. Don’t know if he’d do anything about it, I think it’s a control thing. Our home is our safe space anyway. I would say your allotment is an extension of your home. It’s sad for your child in the sense that the allotment makes them happy and they want to share that with their dad. But he doesn’t deserve a part in that due to his behaviour.

Franklyfrost · 23/04/2022 09:23

Your son will benefit more from having a safe space and activity and from having a mother who also has that safe space and activity than he will from showing his dad that space for 20 min. Just because things have settled down with the ex that doesn’t mean you invite him back into your private lives to start again.

Soultrader · 23/04/2022 08:53

How does your dd feel about it? If her dad is a twat to her and the allotment is a safe space for her then she may not want him there.

sirensscreech · 23/04/2022 08:44

Daddy doesn't come into our house and he's not coming into our allotment. Repeat as necessary.

Make it a statement not a discussion

BenCooperisaGod · 23/04/2022 08:40

Nooooooo. I have an allotment, and it is my safe happy space. Since the pandemic, it has taken on additional meaning to me and the family. I totally understand why you would be territorial about it.

Also it can be an isolated lonely place, where i am often on my own, so for personal safety alone it be be a hard no.

Lindy2 · 23/04/2022 08:31

It's your allotment not your ex's. He therefore has no need to see it.

It's your private space so tell your son that he can take some photos to show his dad but he can't visit it, the same way as he can't come into the house.

bcc89 · 23/04/2022 08:25

Ignore the posters saying to tell your son that "daddy was bad" so he isn't allowed. What the hell?

Just tell your son that it's your garden and you've said no, but you could take some pictures together and if he asks again, repeat that you've said no. Don't blame the council, don't make up an excuse. No means no. You're the parent. If he was asking to show his dad his bedroom, you wouldn't even be questioning this. Your property (whether borrowed from the council or not!), your say.

HikingforScenery · 22/04/2022 19:24

Dont do it OP. Photos/videos with no identifying signs should be enough for now.

spongedog · 22/04/2022 19:22

WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 22/04/2022 17:41

Maybe as a compromise of sorts you could buy a few seeds.and some small pots so he can grow stuff with his dad? Or make a little photo album up?

Although it will benefit your ex, it wouldn't be for him, it would be for your ds.

This idea seems a good way to allow DS to share his love of the gardening and produce with his dad - at his dad's house. Perfect for a father's day present! (Enough time now for DS to be decorating pots etc) and everytime DS (I really mean ex but cant remember the silly symbols to get the strikethroughs!) asks about the allotment you can direct him back to his special project for Daddy.

SquishyGloopyBum · 22/04/2022 19:08

Is his dad pushing this for you think? Odd for a 7 year old to repeatedly ask.

You are right go say no. I'd say that visitors aren't allowed by the council, it's for the allotment users only.

DisforDarkChocolate · 22/04/2022 19:05

I'd say no too, I'd also bet shoeing his Dad is something his Dad has put in his head.

Photos, ones that make the area hard to identify are an excellent compromise. It sounds like your son isn't aware of how difficult his father is and what this means, you may need to look at age appropriate ways to explain this too him soon.

billy1966 · 22/04/2022 19:01

Absolutely not.

Keep the space private and safe.

picklemewalnuts · 22/04/2022 18:42

Daddy behaved very badly when you were little, so he isn't allowed to come to our spaces anymore.

EL8888 · 22/04/2022 18:21

@gogohm restraining orders are granted for good reasons. How does she need to build bridges?!

WildBlueAndDitzy · 22/04/2022 18:11

Beachtrip · 22/04/2022 17:33

I have, and do frequently, say this, but I can also understand that he wants to share the things he does there with his dad.

His dad is a prick, and is a grade A twat towards our daughter but DS has a good relationship with him so far and wants to show his dad the things he planted and see the pond life etc. so I feel sad that I'm uncomfortable with it. Ds is 7 and can't quite get his head round why I don't want it.

Boundaries OP. Something is going wrong if you're having to repeatedly say you don't want to hear about it. Once should be enough. I know DC will push boundaries it's part of their learning but don't let this become something he wears you down about until you give in. It's a red flag your ex's dynamic with the DC. It's as harmful to grow up the arsehole-parent-pleasing golden child as it is to grow up the scapegoat. Both DC need to understand boundaries.

Ifitdoesntmakesense · 22/04/2022 18:05

I’m not suggesting it’s a public amenity! Her son wants to show his Dad, doesn’t matter whether she doesn’t like him that’s irrelevant here and OP says any issues are in past & he is fine around the children so don’t see any issue.

RandomMess · 22/04/2022 18:02

I think you tell DS age appropriate truth.

Dad was very unkind/hurt Mummy so now he isn't to be near our house and that includes the allotment because of what he did.

WildBlueAndDitzy · 22/04/2022 18:00

I would def agree with you if it was your personal private garden but I don’t see what harm it does to show him an allotment plot.

the ex isn't a nice person and is still being abusive to OP. At the very least I wouldn't trust him not to steal the harvest if he has access to the plot. It may belong to council but OP pays to rent the plot, once rented the plot isn't a public amenity for everyone to use, it's the plot holder's. It's OPs private space and she shouldn't feel she has to give access to someone she doesn't like and who is a threat to her wellbeing. It would cause her unnecessary stress and spoil her enjoyment of the place, even if he didn't do anything. Her DC being proud of it doesn't trump that. DC can talk about it and show pics, it's not depriving the DC to say no to ex visiting.

GroggyLegs · 22/04/2022 17:55

Dealwithit · 22/04/2022 17:37

The answer is no. This is our private space. Adults have boundaries the garden doesn’t just belong to you it’s mummy’s and mummy says no. You can take some things we grow or photos but no to anything else.

Absolutely this. Very clear, no negotiation.

If idiot ex knows exactly where it is, which plot etc. it's an unnecessary layer of worry for you that he'll sabotage it or something.

WildBlueAndDitzy · 22/04/2022 17:52

No, it's sensible. Once he knows where it is he could turn up at any time, you don't want this because he's not part of your life.

Also DC is wanting to offer something they can't deliver: to show the ex your allotment. It's you who'd have to show the ex, so DC is offering up your time not just their own, asking you to spend time voluntarily with someone you had a restraining order for and who is still being abusive towards you (don't minimise those texts, the fact you're used to worse is irrelevant). If DC is old enough to understand, I'd be explaining to them why spending time with such a person is not an appropriate thing for you to do or for them to ask you to do. An early lesson in having good boundaries.

Horst · 22/04/2022 17:51

Our allotments are all fenced in and locked. Completely forgot about those that are just empty spaces. Hope yours is a fence one op.

Ifitdoesntmakesense · 22/04/2022 17:49

As it technically belongs to council & it isn’t your garden so not quite the same thing as allowing him onto your property your son could tell him where it is & he could go down without you & see it although he wouldn’t know which plot is yours unless he sees pics, what are you worried he’ll do? Vandalise it, turn up unannounced? Sounds like your son is proud of it & just wants to show it off. I would def agree with you if it was your personal private garden but I don’t see what harm it does to show him an allotment plot.

gogohm · 22/04/2022 17:46

I would double check that it is private land - our local allotments are council owned and people have the right to sit on the benches and walk down the paths.

I get what you are saying but would it hurt to mend bridges for the sake of your son? And yes my ex comes into my house, we exchange a dog rather than kids (kids are adults so sort their own arrangements out)

Horst · 22/04/2022 17:45

Tell him the site manager said no. Say it’s to do with too many people being on and now only those names or within the household are allowed on site due to incidents or something.

Id be more than willing to play nasty site manager.

but seriously a lot of alloments don’t like lots of people being brought into site anyway as other plot holders get worried about break ins and thefts and then ponder if it was that chap sally brought on that one time as it hasn’t happened for months till he came by.

WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 22/04/2022 17:41

Maybe as a compromise of sorts you could buy a few seeds.and some small pots so he can grow stuff with his dad? Or make a little photo album up?

Although it will benefit your ex, it wouldn't be for him, it would be for your ds.