Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours and fence

57 replies

Pandy37123 · 22/04/2022 14:08

Probably a very dull AIBU but me and dh are at a impasse and I’m not sure if I’m being unreasonable or if he is.

We live in a semi detached with fences separating our garden from neighbours each side. One side is detached and the other side is attached to us. Our deeds say that the fence between us and the detached neighbours belong to them. The fence is on their border and we don’t have a fence on our side. The fence between us and the house attached to us belongs to us. The fence at the bottom of the garden is ours too.

We have been in our home for 8 years and get on with neighbours on both sides. Detached neighbours are both retired and have raised their family in their home. They are very well known and respected in the street. They always ask after my children, check the house when we are away, take in packages etc.

Last week our neighbours (detached side) advised that the fence has failed on their side and that they have a contractor coming out to see it with a view to replace the whole thing. They gave us a knock when the contractor arrived and asked our opinion on fence height etc. as they planned on reducing the height and wanted to confirm we were happy with the level of privacy.

Anyway on Wednesday morning we awoke to find next door neighbours had pushed a copy of the quote through the door. It was broken down by the contractor to show two amounts - our contribution and the next door neighbour’s contribution. The price is £4,000 which doesn’t look too bad as it a 40m fence and includes VAT. I spoke to the neighbour and detailed that our deeds show that the fence is theirs however they say their deeds detail repairing fences are shared responsibility and the previous two owners have always gone halves. I believe them and don’t think they are trying to pull the wool over our eyes.

Now to the AIBU - dh says I am a complete idiot to even consider paying. He says ourdeeds clearly state they have responsibility and the fence is on their land. I understand his point of view but do not want to be arguing/jeopardise the relationship we have with our neighbours over £2,000. If the fence came down (it’s on its last legs) and the neighbours didn’t put one back up we would have to put a fence up so that the children were safe. We will have to take the money out of savings and I’d rather spend on it something else but this feels like general house wear and tear and not worth the potential damage to the relationship.

Who is being unreasonable and/or is there an approach where everyone wins?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wonkygorgeous · 24/04/2022 12:19

Two points jump out.

Surely if your deeds do not mention shared maintenance of the fence then theirs are meaningless. How can they insist you cover half if your deeds make no mention of it?

Your deeds relate specifically to your house. Their deeds relate specifically to their house. Unless both were built at the same time by the same builder who put identical guidance into both sets of deeds I can't see how one persons deed for their house can have any legal bearing on another's home.

The second point is that even if your deeds do state shared maintenance, it's just that. Maintenance. Maintenance of a fence involves painting it and making good if there are rotten bits. It doesn't involve completely replacing it. That would come under 'replacement' not 'maintenance' in my opinion.

TheHouseElf · 23/04/2022 13:26

A bit much for your neighbour to spring this upon you and expect you to be able to pull £2k out of thin air at short notice, and shady of them not to have made that position clear when 'consulting' with you so 'nicely' in the first place.

It may be a priority for them, but doesn't make it one for you. As previously advised, check the legalities of this, and also whether just a section has 'failed' and is in needed of repair, rather than the whole length. Also, agree to get multiple quotes.

SparkyBlue · 23/04/2022 13:24

We had something similar and ourselves and the neighbours went halves for the section between our back gardens. You only have to read on here to see that you can't put a price on good neighbours . In contrast fence gate happened across the street and six years on there are still issues from it and a coolness between neighbours of 30 odd years who had never fallen out before. The same person did all the fences and he was filling me in on the drama across the street .

tuliplover · 23/04/2022 13:03

I'd split it. It's to your advantage as you say. There is no obligation to even have a fence, so if it falls over and they don't care to replace it you can't make them.
Agree with you it's in respect of keeping good relations.
I needed the brick walls, which my surveyor said were dangerous, replaced when I moved to my house. The deeds did not specify who was responsible for which side and the walls had been there longer than any of the owners. I asked both sides if they knew, snd if they would share the costs. One was very rude, the other was 95 and said happy for it to be replaced but could not afford to contribute. I replaced them and paid in full. I picked the design and height and had the 'good' side facing me. I did tell both sides what it would be and neither objected so I got what I wanted. Worth the extra money no question.
If your husband os do get up he can deal with it all, but if it had been an unwritten agreement previously it makes sense to continue.

Crazylazydayz · 23/04/2022 12:53

The best way to resolve this is to get copies of both of your registrations (or all 3) and copies of the relevant deeds. It will be £9 for 3 registers www.gov.uk/get-information-about-property-and-land/search-the-register

and £21 for the deeds www.gov.uk/get-information-about-property-and-land/copies-of-deeds

£30 is a small outlay vs £2k.

As pp state it is possible each house has different responsibilities. However, the extract you have included looks like a more general covenant so you need the deeds to confirm.

£4k sounds about right for the fence. If you do decide to pay remember you can expect to be consulted over type of posts, fencing and height as you are paying 50%.

Alwayscheerful · 23/04/2022 12:34

Sellers questionnaires supplied via conveyancing solicitors often ask who is responsible for each boundary? ( deeds often have a "t"? Mark on the plan
but further questions sometimes ask about historic contributions towards boundary fences.

Can you refer to your sellers questionnaire?
Are you happy for them not to replace the fence? Might you prefer Shrubs or hedges?

NothingIsWrong · 22/04/2022 20:48

I would love to remain on neighbourly terms, but definitely could not produce £2k out of thin air like that! It's a significant amount of money.

ILoveMyMonkey · 22/04/2022 20:47

*their not there

ILoveMyMonkey · 22/04/2022 20:43

2K is an awful lot of money.

What kind of posts are there currently? If they are the concrete ones you slot panels into that is super easy to do yourself and would save you ££££.

I would be reluctant to pay out without seeing what the actual problem is on there side - it might be that just one panel needs changing or that the problem can be easily fixed.

McPie · 22/04/2022 20:34

Why would you even consider parting with £2000 for a fence that is not even on your property? Your neighbours lost the right to any one covering half the cost all those years back when they erected it soley on their property!

NamelessGhoul · 22/04/2022 17:09

Maybe compromise and ask for more quotes? I've just paid £1280 for a 16m Post and rail thats 6ft high.

Penners99 · 22/04/2022 17:02

If that wording is not in YOUR deeds, then you (legally) don’t have to pay

femfemlicious · 22/04/2022 16:29

Is this a quote for all their fences or just the fence that separates your house from theirs?. Is your garden 40m long?

GabriellaMontez · 22/04/2022 16:21

Last week our neighbours (detached side) advised that the fence has failed on their side and that they have a contractor coming out to see it with a view to replace the whole thing.

Failed? Does that mean fallen down? Have you seen it? Can it be repaired? Does the whole thing really need replacing? That's a lot of money...

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 22/04/2022 16:16

I think there is a lot to be said for good neighbourly relations. I do the fences both sides of my house, despite technically only being responsible for one, because we have heavy duty electric cable down the side that isn't ours, and occasionally getting new fence panels is a perfectly acceptable tax for me on that.

I paid 1800GBP for 12M of rail fencing and a double gate about 10 years ago (and they had a hell of a time getting the posts in!) just outside the M25, and they did an excellent job, so the quote seems reasonable to me. I would recommend concrete baseboards and posts though, so if the panels get damaged you can just slide new ones in.

Plus if you were to put in your own fence it would cost you at least that, and she's been around to chat with you that the fence is acceptable, so honestly, I would do it personally.

Limoux · 22/04/2022 16:14

No-one has to replace the fence- you dont have to have a fence.
You need at least 3 quotes.
If you haven't got £2k then you haven't got £2k.

Kat1953 · 22/04/2022 16:06

I wouldn't be paying 2000£ for anything without doing due diligence first. Especially in current times, so on that basis yabu

DelurkingLawyer · 22/04/2022 16:04

The thing about her deeds (or completion of registration document, we are referring to the same thing) is that they reflect the terms she agreed with her vendor when she bought the house. That agreement may claim to place obligations on other people including you as neighbours, but so what - they and you weren’t parties to her agreement with her vendor.

That is why it is important to know what your equivalent document says. The way that reciprocal obligations are placed on everyone is that all the agreements between vendors and purchasers contain the same obligations and they are all binding on all subsequent purchasers even if not buying from the original vendor. Or not….depending on what your documents say.

Arucanafeather · 22/04/2022 15:37

I would do this too. In fact we do go halves annual on hedge management with our neighbour which strictly speaking they should pay.

Blinky21 · 22/04/2022 15:34

We had similar recently, we contacted our solicitor who dealt with the house sale who found documentation that showed that despite what the deeds said a more recent agreement was in place that meant responsibility for the fence was joint so we split with next door. I would personally pay it if you can afford it, it gives you control over the situation and you can't put a price on a good relationship with neighbours

RewildingAmbridge · 22/04/2022 15:33

Do the posts and gravel boards need replacing? Our garden is 100ft and we just replaced the side and back, our ad hoc gardener did it because the parts and gravel boards were solid so it was just replacing the panels. It cost about £1300 including his labour, we just had the panels delivered.

Pandy37123 · 22/04/2022 15:31

We three would be good neighbours 😬

OP posts:
Sunnysideup · 22/04/2022 15:26

I think you actually need to check your deeds. That does say you are liable for half. They are correct. So now you need to check yours. And not just rely on memory,

AccommodatingAlice · 22/04/2022 15:22

AgentProvocateur · 22/04/2022 14:35

I can see I’m in a minority here, but I’d pay half. When my neighbours fence blew down years ago, we went halfers to get a decent fence put up. It’s lasted more than 15 years. You’ll benefit and if they’re decent neighbours, id pay half.

This is how we’ve always done it in the houses we’ve lived in too.

FrangipaniBlue · 22/04/2022 15:21

I read that ad your neighbour is responsible for maintaining it but liability for the cost is on you both. Ie they arrange, you reimburse.

It's possible your solicitor has told you that you are responsible for the other two, which would be correct...... but what they possibly missed is that your other neighbour is responsible for reimbursing you equal costs.