Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel sorry for Amber Heard even in light of evidence

331 replies

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 22/04/2022 13:55

I always loved Johnny Depp. Was really wanting to take his side, but the evidence being presented is making that impossible for me. But as much as I want to support women, I cannot warm to Amber Heard. is it patriarchal brainwashing? Is it that they both seem spoiled and behaving badly? Or something else?

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 22/04/2022 19:55

Hutchy16 · 22/04/2022 19:31

You aren’t even close to right…the uk ruling was about whether or not the paper had acted appropriately in their reporting…do some research.

he lost his Disney contract immediately after she claimed he was abusive, trial by social media has cost him so much.

i am genuinely surprised at how little you understand about this case and yet here you are posting about it…I bet you also get your medical advice from Facebook

No, the UK ruling was not about whether the Sun acted appropriately. It was a libel trial. The Sun used the defence that their allegation that Depp was a wife beater was substantially true. "Acting appropriately" is not a defence in a libel case. The judge decided that Depp is a wife beater and that most of Heard's accusations were true.

There are reasons to think the judge in the UK might have got it wrong. For example, one of the reasons he decided to believe Heard's evidence was her claim (made under oath) that she had given the $7M divorce settlement to charity. It now appears that claim was false. Note that I am not saying he did get it wrong, just highlighting one of the reasons some people might question the judgement.

However, the ruling was absolutely not about whether the Sun acted appropriately. It was about whether they could convince the judge that, on the balance of probabilities, Depp is a wife beater.

TheKeatingFive · 22/04/2022 19:46

You aren’t even close to right…the uk ruling was about whether or not the paper had acted appropriately in their reporting…do some research.

it was about whether they could call him a 'wife beater'

the judge concluded that was accurate.

there's a link to the whole judgement upthread.

i suggest you read it as it obvious that you're the one that needs to educate yourself

Kanaloa · 22/04/2022 19:40

And honestly you can’t cry over someone calling you a fucking baby when you said to your friend you wanted to rape their burned corpse after drowning them. I mean come on?

Anyone trying to ‘side with’ either of them is looking pretty pathetic and overlooking the fact that they both seem very abusive and manipulative individuals and just because Johnny Depp was cute in Edward Scissorhands and you loved him in 21 Jump Street and he does a good job of playing the sweet, shy, reserved type doesn’t mean he’s somehow a lovely man in real life.

Kanaloa · 22/04/2022 19:38

Jinglebin1 · 22/04/2022 18:34

Many people siding with AH show themselves up as knowing nothing and making conclusions based on a few headlines. Listen to the recordings. She admits it. She calls him a f'in baby for complaining she hit him. She tells him his knife hes trying to harm himself with is too dull then tries to make it about her. She smirked at a witness, her own pa, recalling her aggressive behaviour.
She stares intently at Johnny during court but he cant look at her.
Theyve both done things wrong, but I dont believe hes ever laid a finger on her. Hes more likely to hurt himself than anyone else.

He said he wanted to drown her then set her on fire then rape her burned corpse. Said it openly to a friend. Like not even ashamed.

I think they’re both extremely toxic people and it’s unfortunate that they ended up in a relationship but this silly babying of a grownup man insisting he’s ‘more likely to hurt himself than anyone else’ is just contrary to the facts. He sounds extremely violent and very misogynistic. Good men don’t joke about raping the burned corpse of their much much younger girlfriend.

WeeBisom · 22/04/2022 19:34

What I find strange is it’s like the whole multi million pound U.K. case never happened. The judge found (in an extremely long and detailed judgment) that it was true that Depp was a wife beater. All of these issues are being brought up and re-litigated as if we have never heard of them before. Depp was found to have chopped off his own finger in a drunken rage and smeared abusive messages on the walls with his blood. The crap in the bed? It was found to be the dog. Johnny was said to be an inconsistent witness who was deluded about the extent of his drink and drug problems.

In this lawsuit, Depp is suing Heard for defamation for saying she was a “victim of domestic violence.” I would be very surprised if Depp wins this case. The evidence he abused her is very strong. And in the USA he has to prove she lied about this … he doesn’t get the benefit of the burden of proof like in the U.K.

As for Heard’s counterclaim , she is suing Depp for saying her domestic violence and sexual violence claims are fake and a hoax. Note , there is nothing here about her being an abuser… the case is not about who really abusers who, and are they just as bad as each other ? Amber could very well have been abusive to Depp, but this is not what the case is about. The two questions are … is it true that Depp domestically abused heard? And, is it true that heard made up the domestic/sexual abuse claims as part of a hoax or fraud?

I think people get tripped up on this case because Depp is beloved and sympathetic and Heard is not very well liked. We WANT to believe Depp is a victim. And also, it seems unfair to solely castigate depp when amber appears to have behaved poorly and treated him in an abusive way. Unfortunately, pointing out that heard abused depp too doesn’t do anything to disprove that Depp was abusive. Which is the central issue in the case.

noodlezoodle · 22/04/2022 19:32

People upthread have shared the verdict of the UK libel case - it is fairly horrifying reading. People saying they don't believe he abused her may think differently if they read why the judge found it substantially true that he is a 'wife beater' and The Sun can refer to him as such.

Despite having lost that case, he is now bringing another case against her and I suspect this will go the same way. She is countersuing him, but ONLY because he sued her. He is the instigator in all of the legal stuff and I have no idea why his judgement is so poor because all it's done is drag both of them through the mud.

I think they're both fairly awful but having read the evidence from the previous trial I can't help but feel sorry for her.

Hutchy16 · 22/04/2022 19:31

TheKeatingFive · 22/04/2022 19:15

She tried to ruin his life with false accusations

not what the U.K. ruling concluded

it cost him millions of dollars in movie contracts

he did that all by himself. His own words, in the public domain, demonstrate a disgusting attitude to women for starters

You aren’t even close to right…the uk ruling was about whether or not the paper had acted appropriately in their reporting…do some research.

he lost his Disney contract immediately after she claimed he was abusive, trial by social media has cost him so much.

i am genuinely surprised at how little you understand about this case and yet here you are posting about it…I bet you also get your medical advice from Facebook

LetitiaLeghorn · 22/04/2022 19:18

anonacfr · 22/04/2022 18:47

Ex-c*nt is such a hideous thing to say. How will kids react when they hear him refer to their mother in that way.
Vanessa (considering she is a huge star in France) has always been so low-key and discreet as well.
She must be so gutted.

I agree it's a horrible word. Gross. But people use it a lot on here and say its not that serious in in common usage where they live. I mean he throws around the f word all the time, so maybe he uses that word too. Whatever, an angry text by a foul mouth guy isn't that surprising, is it?

TheKeatingFive · 22/04/2022 19:15

She tried to ruin his life with false accusations

not what the U.K. ruling concluded

it cost him millions of dollars in movie contracts

he did that all by himself. His own words, in the public domain, demonstrate a disgusting attitude to women for starters

Hutchy16 · 22/04/2022 19:10

She tried to ruin his life with false accusations, it cost him millions of dollars in movie contracts. So many women suffer at the hands of abusers, and it is people like her who add to those who stay quiet about it.

She is a disgusting human being who either needs to be cast aside by Hollywood, or get herself into rehab/mental facility if she can’t tell lies from the truth

whynotwhatknot · 22/04/2022 19:07

Oh i forgot shit in their bed

classy

either way i dont get why she keeps all her acting jobs and he doesnt

Phrenologistsfinger · 22/04/2022 19:07

Mumofsend · 22/04/2022 14:22

I think this is an example of a hideously toxic relationship. Both were abusive. I don't think either was any more a victim than the other.

This

burnoutbabe · 22/04/2022 19:05

Gingersay · 22/04/2022 16:46

My understanding of the whole lawsuit against her is they both signed a NDA when they signed off on the divorce saying they wouldn't talk about the other. She has breached this by writing the op-ed in Washington Post therefore defamed his character. Whether its true or not she still breeched the agreement why do we need to go through all the mudslinging it just makes a mockery of the whole thing!

Well then he could sue her for breach of contract or even misuse of private information but he could only do that if he says it's true. If its untrue, then it's defamation. And the defence to that myst be "but it's true" and not "well she also hit him/she provoked him". It's only -is it mostly true that he was abusive to her. Which the uk case said was true.

whynotwhatknot · 22/04/2022 19:04

have i missed something all the witnesses say shes manipulative she punched him or hit him sorry and it was on record why is he getting all the shit

he threw a table yeah i get that but am i supposed to side with heard wbecause shes a woman

StormzyinaTCup · 22/04/2022 18:59

It does appear that AH legal team are having a bit of difficulty in trying to join the dots. Nothing they have bought as evidence so far, either written, audio or visual has provided any conclusive proof that he was at any time violent towards her.

I would also agree with JD that the photo of his table was, to quote him, "an interesting composition".

It's an interesting case.

Libertaire · 22/04/2022 18:56

If ever two people in this world deserved one another, it’s Depp & Heard.

The lawyers are obviously enjoying an absolute bonanza at their expense, and good luck to them, I hope they enjoy their new sports cars, boats, holiday homes etc that Depp & Heard kindly paid for.

Giraffesandbottoms · 22/04/2022 18:53

What I will say is that the way Depp speaks about women is fucking hideous

anonacfr · 22/04/2022 18:47

Ex-c*nt is such a hideous thing to say. How will kids react when they hear him refer to their mother in that way.
Vanessa (considering she is a huge star in France) has always been so low-key and discreet as well.
She must be so gutted.

Hadenoughofthisbullshit · 22/04/2022 18:46

Jinglebin1 · 22/04/2022 18:34

Many people siding with AH show themselves up as knowing nothing and making conclusions based on a few headlines. Listen to the recordings. She admits it. She calls him a f'in baby for complaining she hit him. She tells him his knife hes trying to harm himself with is too dull then tries to make it about her. She smirked at a witness, her own pa, recalling her aggressive behaviour.
She stares intently at Johnny during court but he cant look at her.
Theyve both done things wrong, but I dont believe hes ever laid a finger on her. Hes more likely to hurt himself than anyone else.

Seems pretty likely that he hurt this dude:https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5700283/amp/Johnny-Depp-attacked-crew-member-day-drinking-smoking-set-new-film.html

Jinglebin1 · 22/04/2022 18:41

Also AH took pictures of Johnnys cocaine use (which he has never denied) that feature more of her belongings than his, plus a tampon applicator for snorting. A sext about a bj was also presented as evidence, in which her team tried to make it seem violent when he even specifies "without injury" in it. AHs defence is so pitifully weak that its embarrassing.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 22/04/2022 18:39

roxyro · 22/04/2022 17:44

What type of woman covertly films her husband for years? The type looking for a big payout/blackmail. I believe he’s behaved badly and I also believe he was deliberately goaded into a lot. She secretly filmed him. Nasty woman.

He's confirmed he recorded her for years too I think?

TheKeatingFive · 22/04/2022 18:38

Many people siding with AH show themselves up as knowing nothing and making conclusions based on a few headlines.

well, I just read a lot of the judgement from the other case, so no.

Listen to the recordings. She admits it.

this particular case isn't about her treatment of him. Its about whether she defamed him by saying (indirectly) he abused her

but I dont believe hes ever laid a finger on her. Hes more likely to hurt himself than anyone else.

the judge in the other case came to a very different conclusion

Mamabananananana · 22/04/2022 18:37

I think that they had a toxic marriage, they both acted poorly and shouldve left it at that.
BUT she couldnt, it seems.

i agree @Scianel , what a shocker that a 20 something, previously lesbian, wasnt going to be The One for him? Ill bet he regrets it now ...

youvegottenminuteslynn · 22/04/2022 18:36

Lesperance · 22/04/2022 16:44

Didn't Vanessa Paradis come out and say that he was a good guy in the London libel case? I feel sorry for her, and her kids.

She presumably didn't know until today that while being nice about her publicly, he referred to her privately as his French extortionist ex-cunt.

Jinglebin1 · 22/04/2022 18:34

Many people siding with AH show themselves up as knowing nothing and making conclusions based on a few headlines. Listen to the recordings. She admits it. She calls him a f'in baby for complaining she hit him. She tells him his knife hes trying to harm himself with is too dull then tries to make it about her. She smirked at a witness, her own pa, recalling her aggressive behaviour.
She stares intently at Johnny during court but he cant look at her.
Theyve both done things wrong, but I dont believe hes ever laid a finger on her. Hes more likely to hurt himself than anyone else.