Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel sorry for Amber Heard even in light of evidence

331 replies

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 22/04/2022 13:55

I always loved Johnny Depp. Was really wanting to take his side, but the evidence being presented is making that impossible for me. But as much as I want to support women, I cannot warm to Amber Heard. is it patriarchal brainwashing? Is it that they both seem spoiled and behaving badly? Or something else?

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 23/04/2022 08:18

Whatafustercluck · 23/04/2022 07:39

I think they're two people who should never have been in a relationship so mutually destructive. Depp's addictions were clearly so out of control that there was nothing vaguely attractive left in him. That level of lack of control is deeply dangerous. She seems pretty rotten too to be honest. But as more evidence is shown, it seems a foregone conclusion that he was abusive to her, regardless of whether she was too and it was mutually abusive. You can't be heard to say "I headbutted you, that doesn't break your nose" and say you are not physically abusive.

I've always admired his acting, but have never really understood the fascination with JD. He's weird and arrogant as fuck. Combined with multiple addictions I don't know why anyone would believe him to be a good choice of life partner.

For clarity, Depp maintains that it was an accidental clash of heads, not a headbutt, and that he used the term "headbutt" in the recording simply because he was talking to Heard and that is how she characterised it, so saying it was an accidental clash of heads would have caused another argument. According to Depp, the alleged headbutt happened when Heard was physically attacking him, hitting and scratching, and he got her in a bearhug in an attempt to stop the attack. This was not entirely successful as she continued kicking him, then claimed that he had headbutted her and broken her nose.

I'm not defending him, just pointing out that his use of that sentence does not necessarily prove physical abuse.

ParisNoir · 23/04/2022 07:49

Whatafustercluck · 23/04/2022 07:39

I think they're two people who should never have been in a relationship so mutually destructive. Depp's addictions were clearly so out of control that there was nothing vaguely attractive left in him. That level of lack of control is deeply dangerous. She seems pretty rotten too to be honest. But as more evidence is shown, it seems a foregone conclusion that he was abusive to her, regardless of whether she was too and it was mutually abusive. You can't be heard to say "I headbutted you, that doesn't break your nose" and say you are not physically abusive.

I've always admired his acting, but have never really understood the fascination with JD. He's weird and arrogant as fuck. Combined with multiple addictions I don't know why anyone would believe him to be a good choice of life partner.

Completely agree with all of this. Its very possible (and likely) they were BOTH abusive. I dont know why people are making this out to be: one is clearly the devil and the other is an innocent angel. They both sound toxic AF and the two of them together was the perfect storm for a horrifically damaging relationship. I also dont get the worship of JD- he's not attractive and comes across as thick as shit, only interested in drugs and highly misogynistic. She comes across as a lying toxic narcissist. They are both thoroughly unpleasant people from what Ive seen.

Menora · 23/04/2022 07:46

Neither are coming across well. I have been of the mind that their relationship was mutually abusive and very toxic. This doesn’t mean she deserved to be abused, and neither did he. I really think he should have walked away from her and built a new life, rehashing this out in court is not helping him. I believe that he was abusive when intoxicated and I also believe she was abusive and also exaggerates. His defence are building up a picture of a mild mannered man who spent all his money on amber and her friends living rent free in his property, who struggled with addiction and was vulnerable to her abuse and her defence are building their defence that he was abusive when intoxicated and had a serious substance abuse problem.
I don’t think he will win.
I do feel uneasy with AH ‘evidence’ presented which doesn’t seem to tally with witnesses accounts (not JH) - not many people saw her with bruising when she said she had it.

Whatafustercluck · 23/04/2022 07:39

I think they're two people who should never have been in a relationship so mutually destructive. Depp's addictions were clearly so out of control that there was nothing vaguely attractive left in him. That level of lack of control is deeply dangerous. She seems pretty rotten too to be honest. But as more evidence is shown, it seems a foregone conclusion that he was abusive to her, regardless of whether she was too and it was mutually abusive. You can't be heard to say "I headbutted you, that doesn't break your nose" and say you are not physically abusive.

I've always admired his acting, but have never really understood the fascination with JD. He's weird and arrogant as fuck. Combined with multiple addictions I don't know why anyone would believe him to be a good choice of life partner.

MangyInseam · 22/04/2022 22:56

The two questions are … is it true that Depp domestically abused heard? And, is it true that heard made up the domestic/sexual abuse claims as part of a hoax or fraud?

It's also possible he was abusive and she is making things up.

I tend to think that's likely.

LolaStrange · 22/04/2022 22:49

Veol · 22/04/2022 20:20

Neither of them seem to be an ideal spouse.

I rtft and one of the last comments was the truest lol

Momicrone · 22/04/2022 21:38

What, an actress!

ScaldedBy · 22/04/2022 21:21

In saying that I'm not a fan of him either but she is an attention seeker.

ScaldedBy · 22/04/2022 21:21

Based on her behaviour prior to divorce up until now I have never felt sorry for her. She loves the media attention and will say or do anything to be in it. Negatively or positively she'd be loving all the press about her right now...

Hadenoughofthisbullshit · 22/04/2022 20:54

WeeBisom · 22/04/2022 19:34

What I find strange is it’s like the whole multi million pound U.K. case never happened. The judge found (in an extremely long and detailed judgment) that it was true that Depp was a wife beater. All of these issues are being brought up and re-litigated as if we have never heard of them before. Depp was found to have chopped off his own finger in a drunken rage and smeared abusive messages on the walls with his blood. The crap in the bed? It was found to be the dog. Johnny was said to be an inconsistent witness who was deluded about the extent of his drink and drug problems.

In this lawsuit, Depp is suing Heard for defamation for saying she was a “victim of domestic violence.” I would be very surprised if Depp wins this case. The evidence he abused her is very strong. And in the USA he has to prove she lied about this … he doesn’t get the benefit of the burden of proof like in the U.K.

As for Heard’s counterclaim , she is suing Depp for saying her domestic violence and sexual violence claims are fake and a hoax. Note , there is nothing here about her being an abuser… the case is not about who really abusers who, and are they just as bad as each other ? Amber could very well have been abusive to Depp, but this is not what the case is about. The two questions are … is it true that Depp domestically abused heard? And, is it true that heard made up the domestic/sexual abuse claims as part of a hoax or fraud?

I think people get tripped up on this case because Depp is beloved and sympathetic and Heard is not very well liked. We WANT to believe Depp is a victim. And also, it seems unfair to solely castigate depp when amber appears to have behaved poorly and treated him in an abusive way. Unfortunately, pointing out that heard abused depp too doesn’t do anything to disprove that Depp was abusive. Which is the central issue in the case.

Very well said

Veol · 22/04/2022 20:20

Neither of them seem to be an ideal spouse.

IReallyLikeCrows · 22/04/2022 20:20

youvegottenminuteslynn · 22/04/2022 18:36

She presumably didn't know until today that while being nice about her publicly, he referred to her privately as his French extortionist ex-cunt.

Wow! Calling her that is beyond disgusting. What we seem to have here is a dyed in the wool misogynist who is vile about all the women who've been unlucky enough to get entwined with him.

Sandra2010 · 22/04/2022 20:18

I have no sympathy for either of them. They seem to have been in a mutually abusive and toxic co-dependence spiral. Equally at fault, equally victims of their own making.

StormzyinaTCup · 22/04/2022 20:15

Yes, she is counter suing him for $100m

IReallyLikeCrows · 22/04/2022 20:14

She is countersuing.

TheKeatingFive · 22/04/2022 20:12

I read she was countersuing - is that a mistake?

I don't know, I've never heard that, but that doesn't mean it isn't true

youvegottenminuteslynn · 22/04/2022 20:11

It's ex-cunt that makes it so demeaning though. Not just 'she's a cunt' (which is often used) but the fact that his ex is reduced to her genitals. For some reason it really offended me (and I swear all the time)

This is exactly why I felt it was such a horrible phrase, this nuance feels different to calling someone a cunt.

anonacfr · 22/04/2022 20:09

LetitiaLeghorn · 22/04/2022 19:18

I agree it's a horrible word. Gross. But people use it a lot on here and say its not that serious in in common usage where they live. I mean he throws around the f word all the time, so maybe he uses that word too. Whatever, an angry text by a foul mouth guy isn't that surprising, is it?

It's ex-cunt that makes it so demeaning though.
Not just 'she's a cunt' (which is often used) but the fact that his ex is reduced to her genitals. For some reason it really offended me (and I swear all the time)

IReallyLikeCrows · 22/04/2022 20:08

I tended to err on the side that she was a victim and he was an abuser, full stop. Now, I think that both of them were abusive to each other in different ways. She was seen bruised when she finally left him. Did he do that? I don't know. Probably? Who knows.

He, however, is making a fool of himself with this case. My understanding is that it's all to do with the article she wrote about being a victim of domestic abuse. His name is not mentioned. Of course, most people will think she is talking about him. She either definitely or probably is talking about him, but given free speech in the US and how he could have just kept his head down after the UK case and tried to rebuild his career, suing her was a really bad idea. I've seen a bit of him giving evidence and heard some on the radio and he looks and sounds like an ageing addict who is full of self-pity and why me, why me, why me.

Neither of them is a particularly likeable character but it's very interesting that on social media it is all about what an evil bitch he is and poor Johnny Depp who would never do a bad thing and oh I've just loved him forever and Amber Heard deserves to die.

Maybe if he hadn't pissed so much money up the wall, maybe if he had got some help with his addiction issues, he'd have enough money to get him through the hiatus in his career and be clear-headed enough to know that this too will pass if you're a white actor in the US who is prepared to wait for your time to come again. cf. Mel Gibson. Oh and I think he's said at this trial that her behaviour had led him to drink and drugs again which is almost certainly bullshit given his lifelong relationship with illicit and licit substances.

Butchyrestingface · 22/04/2022 20:08

TheKeatingFive · 22/04/2022 20:07

I don't want her to win her case against him. And I really, REALLY don't want him to win his case against her.

she isn't bringing a case against him though.

he is suing her for defamation for saying she was a victim of domestic abuse.

I read she was countersuing - is that a mistake?

Anyway, better if she's not. Then he can lose in high style and that be the end of the matter (hopefully).

TheKeatingFive · 22/04/2022 20:07

I don't want her to win her case against him. And I really, REALLY don't want him to win his case against her.

she isn't bringing a case against him though.

he is suing her for defamation for saying she was a victim of domestic abuse.

Butchyrestingface · 22/04/2022 20:04

I think they're a gruesome twosome. Although their joint apology for flouting Australian pet immigration laws was comedy gold, I'll give them that.

I don't want her to win her case against him. And I really, REALLY don't want him to win his case against her.

If the case comes down to which of the two the jury believes looks like less of a strung-out, unwashed cokehead, I'd say he's fucked.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 22/04/2022 20:03

@Hutchy16

You aren’t even close to right…the uk ruling was about whether or not the paper had acted appropriately in their reporting…do some research.

Oh dear, you're the one who has got it completely wrong about that I'm afraid!

Here's an overview for you so to get you started on your research journey:

Depp’s case was that the article made seriously defamatory allegations which bore the meaning that he was guilty of serious domestic violence against his former wife. The defence maintainedd_ that the evidence showed the claimant “was violent towards Ms Heard on multiple occasions” during their relationship, and thus the “wife-beater” claim was justified.

They relied on 14 alleged incidents of serious physical assault against Heard which had occurred between 2013 and 2016. However, Depp consistently deniedd_ the “reputation-destroying and career-ending” allegations.

The case was heard over the course of 16 days at London’s Royal Courts of Justice in July 2020. Importantly, neither Depp nor Heard was on trial. And this wasn’t a criminal trial either. In this libel dispute, there were two central issues: the meaning of the articles complained of; and whether the imputation conveyed by them (that the Hollywood actor engaged in unprovoked attacks and violent conduct against his ex-wife) was true in substance and fact. Mr Justice Nicol heldd_ that the meaning of the words complained of was as contended for by The Sun, namely that Depp was violent to Heard, “causing her to suffer significant injury and on occasion leading to her fearing for her life”.

The judge also expressly acknowledged that Depp proved the necessary elements of his cause of action, that his reputation had been damaged. But, under UK defamation law, if a defendant proves that the published words are “substantially truee_”, they will have a complete defence: they cannot be successfully sued regardless of the gravity of the allegations. In this case, the judge found that the great majority of alleged incidents of violent physical assault against his ex-wife were proved to be substantially true and dismissed Depp’s claim.

Philisophigal · 22/04/2022 20:03

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

TheKeatingFive · 22/04/2022 20:02

The Judgement is worth reading. It seems that many, many incidents were submitted as argument and the judge gives significant attention to all of them in their conclusion.