Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel sorry for Amber Heard even in light of evidence

331 replies

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 22/04/2022 13:55

I always loved Johnny Depp. Was really wanting to take his side, but the evidence being presented is making that impossible for me. But as much as I want to support women, I cannot warm to Amber Heard. is it patriarchal brainwashing? Is it that they both seem spoiled and behaving badly? Or something else?

OP posts:
ENoeuf · 24/04/2022 09:52

I just don’t get it - well I do, it the same with Meghan M - some bloke everyone fancies turns weird and the woman is blamed. Basically, if he’d picked meeeee, I would have saved him.

StormzyinaTCup · 24/04/2022 09:48

Firstly, the fact that he continues to harass her through the courts. And secondly the monologues he delivered in court, I mean he was asked a direct question and went off on a rambling story about his history of being friends with Elton John and got annoyed when he was interrupted. He seems incredibly narcissistic- but then who wouldn't be, he's been fawned over for so long. Even the court laughs at his jokes which seems really inappropriate to me.

To be fair he has had to wait 6 years to put his side of the story and to provide his evidence in full.

There has been audio evidence that she has hit him, gaslighted him and demeaned him. She is not a good advocate for speaking out on domestic violence.

This was the quote both from the Sun and Women's aid just after JD lost his U.K. trial:

A spokesperson for the Sun said: "Domestic abuse victims must never be silenced and we thank the judge for his careful consideration and thank Amber Heard for her courage in giving evidence to the court."

Charity Women's Aid said everyone who experiences domestic abuse "deserves to be listened to and believed".
"This also applies to survivors who do not fit the image of the 'perfect' victim - and regardless of the high profile of the alleged abuser. There is no excuse for domestic abuse."

Men who claim they have been victims of domestic violence need to be listened to as well.

TigerLilyTail · 24/04/2022 01:16

I agree there is evidence that he abused her, just as there is evidence she abused him. The texts from his assistant calling him a lost little boy, for example. He’s not a boy, he’s a grown man and father of two.

I think this trial will not go the way JD expects and his career will crash and burn, and he will only have himself to blame for it. If he had just kept his head down for a few years and come back with some amazing acting projects, it would all have been forgotten. His hubris will be his downfall.

Meltinthemiddle · 24/04/2022 01:14

I am no johnny Depp fan but I'm sorry Amber is absolutely toxic and I do not believe she is an innocent victim in all this. The constant filming and recording is clearly a set up for whatever motive she has. She is often heard gas lighting him and trying to push for a reaction. Yes he reacts and shouldn't do but she knows exactly what she is doing. She does not strike me as someone who is scared of him and in an abusive relationship. There's just something not right at all.

DressingGownofDoom · 24/04/2022 00:58

Echobelly · 23/04/2022 17:45

TBH, it sounds like both of them have been awful, but I note that the dominant narrative on social media is in support of Depp - good old misogyny!

The SM comments really surprised me, so many people saying 'there's no evidence he abused her!' When there is MOUNTAINS of it! Video and audio footage, admissions coming from his own mouth!

Obviously they both contributed to their troubled relationship but two things really get to me about him. Firstly, the fact that he continues to harass her through the courts. And secondly the monologues he delivered in court, I mean he was asked a direct question and went off on a rambling story about his history of being friends with Elton John and got annoyed when he was interrupted. He seems incredibly narcissistic- but then who wouldn't be, he's been fawned over for so long. Even the court laughs at his jokes which seems really inappropriate to me.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 24/04/2022 00:03

Well said @Kanaloa Star

Kanaloa · 23/04/2022 23:54

Sorry it might have been a bit much 😂 just can’t imagine looking at a case like this and thinking ‘hmm what team am I?’ And then choosing a violent misogynist because you fancy him.

And that’s why it is, isn’t it? He was cute in the 90s (and to be honest after then too) he used to do this fantastic soft-boy type of thing. But I mean just get yourself into Matt Damon instead and stop choosing a team in a domestic violence court case like it’s a Twilight movie.

KettrickenSmiled · 23/04/2022 23:51

FFS @Kanaloa - gobsmacked by your post.

In a good way Wine

Kanaloa · 23/04/2022 22:48

Murdoch1949 · 23/04/2022 19:13

Heard is a vile, bullying ex wife, jealous of Depp's fame. He is a damaged man, through mother's abuse, and his own addictions. I don't think he had been physically abusive to her but she has to him. I also think that she has faked injuries, as make up artist said, and she lied about applying make up to hide bruises (manufacturer testified that the make up was not marketed until years after the alleged assaults). Team Depp, if you hadn't guessed.

Team ‘can’t wait to rape the burned corpse of my wife’ 😂

Why are you team anyone? They’re two extremely damaged and damaging individuals who (regardless of what they’ve been through) sound like thoroughly unpleasant people.

But I guess he was cute in the 90s so that’s the important thing. Maybe if you’re really lucky and very young and pretty he’ll fantasise about murdering and raping you to his equally creepy pals.

Murdoch1949 · 23/04/2022 19:13

Heard is a vile, bullying ex wife, jealous of Depp's fame. He is a damaged man, through mother's abuse, and his own addictions. I don't think he had been physically abusive to her but she has to him. I also think that she has faked injuries, as make up artist said, and she lied about applying make up to hide bruises (manufacturer testified that the make up was not marketed until years after the alleged assaults). Team Depp, if you hadn't guessed.

ancientgran · 23/04/2022 19:12

I think you'd know if you'd given 7 million dollars away and it would be easy to demonstrate so I don't think proving it beyond reasonable doubt would be difficult.

I think it is awful for someone to come from a foreign country and lie in court under oath, well it is awful for anyone to do it and if it didn't give some sort of advantage why do it? It is very disrespectful to the UK legal system. I really don't think that should go unpunished.

I'm maybe starting to understand why people dislike her.

prh47bridge · 23/04/2022 18:59

ancientgran · 23/04/2022 18:35

If she said that under oath and it wasn't true isn't that perjury? Should she face consequences for that?

Perjury prosecutions for evidence given in civil cases are rare. To get a conviction, it would be necessary to show to the criminal standard (i.e. beyond reasonable doubt) that she knew the evidence she gave was untrue and that the evidence was material to the case. It would probably fail on the basis that, whilst it may have been a significant factor in persuading the judge to believe her, whether she made this donation was not an issue in the case.

ancientgran · 23/04/2022 18:35

prh47bridge · 23/04/2022 11:42

He did, but remember that it was only to the civil standard, not beyond reasonable doubt. Also, one of the reasons the judge in the UK believed Heard was her statement under oath that she had donated the entire divorce settlement to charity. It appears this was a lie. That doesn't necessarily mean the judge was wrong, but I wouldn't regard it as proving beyond doubt that Depp is a wife beater.

If she said that under oath and it wasn't true isn't that perjury? Should she face consequences for that?

LetitiaLeghorn · 23/04/2022 18:24

I didn't hear the evidence in the Depp-Heard trial in the UK and the judge did, so I would suppose his judgement is more likely to be accurate over mine.
But judges are not always right and can be easily influenced. How about...
“Remember Mrs Archer in the witness box. Your vision of her probably will never disappear. Has she elegance? Has she fragrance?" Living with her, how could Archer ever be “in need of cold, unloving, rubber-insulated sex in a seedy hotel.”

Echobelly · 23/04/2022 17:45

TBH, it sounds like both of them have been awful, but I note that the dominant narrative on social media is in support of Depp - good old misogyny!

TheKeatingFive · 23/04/2022 17:43

The other point I would make is that the judge decided the case on the balance of probabilities, the standard used in the UK for civil cases. Some people seem to want to take this judgement as proving Depp was a wife beater beyond reasonable doubt. That is not the case.

The judgement references 12 incidents where he believed Amber had been assaulted, 3 of which he judged she was reasonably in fear of her life.

If you don't think that's pretty damning, that's up to you, but it does make me question why the actual fuck you'd be defending this wifebeater (I can legally call him that).

then there's also the video evidence of violent meltdowns, the depraved texts about what he'd do to her burnt out corpse. Plus the other disgusting language used about his ex partner.

it paints a picture, y'know.

anyway, it doesn't really matter in that he's totally finished now. The court cases have done him no good at all.

prh47bridge · 23/04/2022 17:32

Maddiemademe · 23/04/2022 16:44

He admitted he head butted her. Sorry am I missing here that physically head butting someone isn’t an assault? I don’t like either of them but fan girl crap for him is something else!

No, he did not. He admitted an accidental clash of heads. His version of events is that she was hitting and scratching him. He tried to stop her by getting her into a bearhug. This was only partly successful as she continued kicking him, then claimed he had headbutted her. He is adamant that he did not, but accepts there was probably an accidental clash of heads.

prh47bridge · 23/04/2022 17:30

TheKeatingFive · 23/04/2022 16:59

Oh and the ruling by the Judge regarding The Sun? Yeah he just didn't know what he was doing

I know right, crazy. I've just seen that he was refused permission to appeal because there was 'no real prospect of success' so presumably the fan girls think the entire U.K. judiciary is against him.

I am certainly not saying that the judge did not know what he was doing. That does not mean he was right in deciding that Depp was a wife beater.

Libel verdicts are almost impossible to appeal unless the judge has made an error in law. The judge did not make any such error. Depp's lawyers tried to argue that the judgement was perverse, but the bar to make such an argument is very high. They had to show that no-one could possibly have arrived at that judgement based on the evidence. Even if they could show that every other judge would have come up with a different verdict, that would not have been enough. It was clearly open to the judge to come to the conclusions he did based on the evidence presented, so the attempt to appeal was rejected. That does not necessarily mean the original verdict was correct, nor does it mean that the judges in the Court of Appeal would have arrived at the same verdict if they had heard the case.

The judge largely accepted Heard's evidence, rejecting evidence from police officers, medical practitioners, one of her friends and others that disagreed with her version of events, and rejecting contemporaneous documentary evidence that disagreed with her. He found her a credible witness. However, we know that part of the reason he accepted her version of events was her statement, made under oath, that she had given the $7M divorce settlement to charity. It appears that statement was a lie. Would the judge still have accepted her evidence if he had known that? We don't know.

The other point I would make is that the judge decided the case on the balance of probabilities, the standard used in the UK for civil cases. Some people seem to want to take this judgement as proving Depp was a wife beater beyond reasonable doubt. That is not the case.

The judge in the UK case refused to make a third party disclosure order against Heard. Whilst that decision was correct, it meant she was able to limit her disclosure to evidence that favoured her. She did not have to disclose any evidence that undermined her version of events. In the US case, she will have been forced to disclose everything requested by Depp's legal team, regardless of whether it helps or hinders her case. This case may therefore include significant evidence that was not included in the UK case.

The judge in the UK case knew what he was doing. He is a very good judge - one of the best. But he is not infallible. He may have been mistaken. Juries and magistrates get it wrong in criminal cases, where the prosecution has to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. Judges will, therefore, get it wrong in civil cases where the standard of proof required is much lower.

TheKeatingFive · 23/04/2022 16:59

Oh and the ruling by the Judge regarding The Sun? Yeah he just didn't know what he was doing

I know right, crazy. I've just seen that he was refused permission to appeal because there was 'no real prospect of success' so presumably the fan girls think the entire U.K. judiciary is against him.

NippyWoowoo · 23/04/2022 16:48

Maddiemademe · 23/04/2022 16:44

He admitted he head butted her. Sorry am I missing here that physically head butting someone isn’t an assault? I don’t like either of them but fan girl crap for him is something else!

Shocking. Multiple people on this thread have talked about the fact that he admits several times to cutting off his own finger, yet still people are saying she did it.

Oh and the ruling by the Judge regarding The Sun? Yeah he just didn't know what he was doing 🙄

Maddiemademe · 23/04/2022 16:44

He admitted he head butted her. Sorry am I missing here that physically head butting someone isn’t an assault? I don’t like either of them but fan girl crap for him is something else!

ApertureGLaDOS · 23/04/2022 16:43

KTheGrey · 23/04/2022 14:28

@BridgesofMadisonfan I also think that trial was a farcical miscarriage of justice. Follow the evidence. He has witnesses, tapes of verbal abuse, a cut off finger and photos of his face beaten up. She has photos with messed up metadata and friends trying to interfere with the administration of justice.

Hang on - didn’t he admit to cutting his own finger off? I am so confused with all of this.

StormzyinaTCup · 23/04/2022 14:30

He does have a substance and alcohol problem and that is pretty clear, however, they have not (yet) provided any proof that he was violently abusive towards her. At the moment it's looking like her legal team are expecting people to make a connection without proof ie, alcohol and substance abuse = 'wife beater'.

There may well be more to come from her legal team of course but at the moment nothing has been shown as proof that he was violently abusive towards her.

I believe (but happy to be corrected) that unlike the U.K. trial she will have to provide full disclosure in this US trial.

There is also some questioning as to whether the photographs that were used in the U.K. trial had been manipulated. The Virginia judge ruled in Nov 21 that the metadata that wasn't originally given to Depp's team in the UK trial, be handed over so that it can be forensically examined for any signs of manipulation. There may be something in this or there may not.

KTheGrey · 23/04/2022 14:28

@BridgesofMadisonfan I also think that trial was a farcical miscarriage of justice. Follow the evidence. He has witnesses, tapes of verbal abuse, a cut off finger and photos of his face beaten up. She has photos with messed up metadata and friends trying to interfere with the administration of justice.