Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel sorry for Amber Heard even in light of evidence

331 replies

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 22/04/2022 13:55

I always loved Johnny Depp. Was really wanting to take his side, but the evidence being presented is making that impossible for me. But as much as I want to support women, I cannot warm to Amber Heard. is it patriarchal brainwashing? Is it that they both seem spoiled and behaving badly? Or something else?

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 24/04/2022 12:28

StormzyinaTCup · 24/04/2022 12:25

Thats what needs to be determined. Or has already been determined in the U.K.

So am I right in thinking from your posts you have already made your mind up?

You don't seem to be reading that poster's posts properly.

The poster said it has already been determined in the UK - they clearly mean that the civil case her established there were over 10 incidents of domestic abuse against Amber Heard by Johnny Depp therefore he could not claim damages for being labelled a 'wife bearer' by The Sun. That's a fact, it was the outcome of the civil case.

The poster also said the case in the states currently is based on whether Johnny Depp committed domestic abuse against Amber Heard. Again, it's a fact that that is the basis of the case.

StormzyinaTCup · 24/04/2022 12:25

Thats what needs to be determined. Or has already been determined in the U.K.

So am I right in thinking from your posts you have already made your mind up?

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 12:00

However, that doesn't mean she is not also an abuser herself

no and no one ever said it did mean that, so I'm not sure the point you're making.

Both cases thus far are about whether it is accurate to describe Depp as an abuser (wife beater)/Heard as the abused.

Thats what needs to be determined. Or has already been determined in the U.K.

StormzyinaTCup · 24/04/2022 11:55

but the case is him suing her for implying he abused her.

I'm well aware of what the case is about. What he says though is obviously relevant otherwise he wouldn't be permitted to bring it up.

I expect she will win the case if her evidence proves that her Op Ed piece was accurate. However, that doesn't mean she is not also an abuser herself.

I will wait until I have heard everything to decide whether they are as bad as each other (I expect they are) and whether I have good reason for calling them both domestic abusers.

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 11:46

The judges role in a civicl defamation case is to determine whether or not the legal definition of defamation has been met. It isn't to determine guilt or innocence.

Quite. Where have I said otherwise?

The U.K. case was about whether the press was allowed to call him a wifebeater. It was ruled that that was accurate, not defamation.

This case is about whether she's defaming him in calling herself a victim of domestic abuse.

Midlifemusings · 24/04/2022 11:39

@TheKeatingFive

No, you missed the point. The judge was dismissive of what Johnny said about Amber abusing him because it really wasn't relevant to the defamation case (about whether or not he abused her) and she didn't look into Amber's stories with a fine tooth comb because again it didn't matter - all she had to do was feel there was sufficient evidence that at some point Johnny had physically assaulted Amber. This case wasn't about guilt or innocence of each event. It wasn't a criminal case. The judge was only looking at it through the lens of the defamation case. She completely ignored inconsistencies and other details - because they didn't matter for this particular case.

And American judges are really not some impartial, infallable beings. Watch a few youtube videos of judges acting badly. You will see that the idea that a judge said it means it must be true - doesn't hold up at all. The judges role in a civicl defamation case is to determine whether or not the legal definition of defamation has been met. It isn't to determine guilt or innocence.

ENoeuf · 24/04/2022 11:12

‘So if it turns out they are both victims and as bad as each other then is it OK for one party to keep their career and the other one doesn't? Only one party is allowed to speak up about domestic violence and the other is silenced?’

but the case is him suing her for implying he abused her. Not him accusing her of DA or accusing, what, some unnamed force not letting him accuse her? So I’m sort of glad you’re not on the jury 😂

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:54

I'm really glad some of you aren't on this jury.

Who are you talking about here, posters like me or posters who are saying things like 'oh, but she doesn't look like a victim' and she wore a tie one time?

So if it turns out they are both victims and as bad as each other then is it OK for one party to keep their career and the other one doesn't? Only one party is allowed to speak up about domestic violence and the other is silenced?

There's absolutely nothing stopping Depp from writing the kind of Op Ed that Amner wrote. No one is trying to silence him actually.

As for careers, that's far beyond the court case and up to studio executives. They aren't under any obligation to hire anyone for anything, so the idea that an individual is entitled to parts is flawed to begin with. Careers wither and die for all kinds of reasons.

NippyWoowoo · 24/04/2022 10:51

StormzyinaTCup · 24/04/2022 10:48

I'm really glad some of you aren't on this jury.

So if it turns out they are both victims and as bad as each other then is it OK for one party to keep their career and the other one doesn't? Only one party is allowed to speak up about domestic violence and the other is silenced?

She tried to get the court case thrown out, she didn't want to provide full disclosure, she didn't want people to know she didn't give to Charity as she said she would and she is on tape as saying ......'no one will believe you Johnny'.

Is he silencing her or is she trying to silence him?

She said what she said and he's suing her for it. Nothing stopped him from speaking 'his truth'

StormzyinaTCup · 24/04/2022 10:48

I'm really glad some of you aren't on this jury.

So if it turns out they are both victims and as bad as each other then is it OK for one party to keep their career and the other one doesn't? Only one party is allowed to speak up about domestic violence and the other is silenced?

She tried to get the court case thrown out, she didn't want to provide full disclosure, she didn't want people to know she didn't give to Charity as she said she would and she is on tape as saying ......'no one will believe you Johnny'.

Is he silencing her or is she trying to silence him?

Midlifemusings · 24/04/2022 10:41

@PaperTyger

Amber is also an actor and her sister lived (rent free) in one of Johnny's penthouse suites for most of the time Amber was with Johnny. I think they also had separate bedrooms given some of the trial notes that refer to Amber's bed or Johnny's bed. I think they both lived a great deal of their own lives (probably a good thing given how volatile they were when together).

I also saw that the makeup company that made the palette that Amber said she used throughout her relationship with Johnny to cover her bruises as it had a mix of colours that she could alter for all the different days / colours has released a statement that the make-up palette she referred to wasn't released until after the end of the relationship.

I don't believe most of what she says. I do think they were both physical with each other at various times.

PaperTyger · 24/04/2022 10:31

Same I'm not a fan of JD at all.
I certainly appreciate some of his roles.

It's an interesting dynamic, I wonder truthfully what being in a relationship does actually mean to him. I suspect due to his life filming it does mean really, part timer relationship, doing what he wants most of the time, then checking onto his relationship,on his terms, lots of mate's time... sitting morose... drugs...some fun
...away again... family again.

I can't imagine it was anything like what most of us would be used too eg day to day living.

ENoeuf · 24/04/2022 10:26

Exactly this - he isn’t bringing a case against her for abuse. He’s trying to clear his name. Through a little poor me I’m so cute and charming act from what I can see so far.

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:22

Depraved.

sorry I can't work this today!

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:21

but I'm prepared to hear him out.

You should read the U.K. judgement. Grim.

and his texts. I presume you have read those. Deprived.

StormzyinaTCup · 24/04/2022 10:20

Just to add, I'm not a fan girl (although he did make some good films early on) but I'm prepared to hear him out.

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:19

Whoops fail.

of course it doesn't excuse her, I never said it did. They both need to take responsibilities for their actions.

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:19

That doesn't excuse her being abusive though

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:18

He is using this court case to be able to put his evidence across that he believes he is also the victim of abuse and that certain aspects of what she is claiming are untrue.

But that's not what the law is for. If he wants to do that, he needs to file another case.

This case is solely about whether Heard is justified in calling herself a victim of abuse. What he's doing is trying to silence her.

Efortyjive · 24/04/2022 10:15

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:00

Basically, if he’d picked meeeee, I would have saved him.

yes, this is the key insight

The fan girls don't feel they have to engage with 'what if I was the burnt out corpse he wants to fuck' because they feel with certainty 'he would be different with them.'

All Amber's fault basically. She should just have managed the violent, narcissistic addict with no impulse control better.

That doesn't excuse her being abusive though, from the evidence given its not like it was all reactionary to his behaviour. That said I agree his texts and other behaviour are deplorable. It can be true that both are abusive and together make an absolutely toxic combination that bring the worst out of each other. I suspect misogyny is a big part though, people are so used to men speaking like that about women that it barely registers to some, whereas an abusive woman is more shocking.

StormzyinaTCup · 24/04/2022 10:14

None of the court cases are about him as a victim of abuse however.

They are about silencing or undermining her right to acknowledge herself as a victim of abuse. Or silencing others referring to him as an abuser.

He is entitled to do that too.
He is using this court case to be able to put his evidence across that he believes he is also the victim of abuse and that certain aspects of what she is claiming are untrue.

There is a reason that AH tried three times in two years to get this case thrown out as unnecessary and U.K. trial outcome on its own should be sufficient and that is probably because if a US trial went ahead, as I mentioned up thread, she would have to provide full disclosure which was not a requirement in the U.K. trial.

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:11

But i can't understand what no ones talking about the abuse against men.

Its not that it's not a worthy topic, but the court case isn't about that.

Its about whether Heard is defaming Depp when she referred to herself as a victim of domestic abuse.

Meltinthemiddle · 24/04/2022 10:09

ENoeuf · 24/04/2022 09:52

I just don’t get it - well I do, it the same with Meghan M - some bloke everyone fancies turns weird and the woman is blamed. Basically, if he’d picked meeeee, I would have saved him.

I definitely don't fancy Johnny Depp. But i can't understand what no ones talking about the abuse against men. Yes she may have been abused but so may have he by the evidence.

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 10:00

Basically, if he’d picked meeeee, I would have saved him.

yes, this is the key insight

The fan girls don't feel they have to engage with 'what if I was the burnt out corpse he wants to fuck' because they feel with certainty 'he would be different with them.'

All Amber's fault basically. She should just have managed the violent, narcissistic addict with no impulse control better.

TheKeatingFive · 24/04/2022 09:55

None of the court cases are about him as a victim of abuse however.

They are about silencing or undermining her right to acknowledge herself as a victim of abuse. Or silencing others referring to him as an abuser.