Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brides & Grooms expecting wedding guests to pay for their own dinner

209 replies

ohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhy · 22/04/2022 09:50

I run a wedding catering company - based on a food truck and catering to the less formal weddings. I'm now seeing a trend where brides and grooms are emailing me and are telling me that they expect the guests to pay for the dinner themselves on the day 😮

I'm turning down these events as a matter of policy - largely because I think it is the most cheapskate move ever. But also because I could arrive and find they have 50 guests, 5 food trucks and half of them have brought a picnic instead, and I lose money.

AIBU to think most guests would baulk if I presented a card reader for their dinner at a wedding?

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/04/2022 14:45

Why is it okay to have a paid bar at a wedding, where guests have to buy their own drinks, but not okay to ask them to pay for food?

It's food truck food, we're not talking about 100/head presumably.

I remember being shocked when the trend for cash bars started taking off in my social circle; but the thing with drinks is that different options can vary hugely in price, people can (and will) consume vast amounts and, from the basic point of needing a drink, you'll always be able to get a jug of tap water and there are often jugs of squash for the kids, with the freedom to pay for whatever 'upgrade' you may want.

Food - basic sustenance - is not really considered a luxury and, rightly or wrongly, is considered a more central part of what you're being invited to join in with than the higher-priced drinks options are.

Added to that, people know that the bar is a separate facility that is permanently there and offered as an extra by the (third-party) venue as standard, without the B&G needing to get involved. Whatever food is there will have been and organised by the B&G, so it seems really off to plan what your guests will eat but not pay for it for them. It might be different if, say, you were having a wedding somewhere with no food facilities on-site but with options such as food vans, chip shops or whatever in the village/vicinity for people to go and sort themselves out for a meal (or bring a picnic) - and you made this clear to guests in advance.

etulosba · 22/04/2022 14:40

Is food truck a new name for a burger or chip van?

Vikinga · 22/04/2022 14:38

I think if a couple told guests not to give presents but instead to contribute towards the wedding/meal that's fine. It wouldn't bother me.

WhatNoRaisins · 22/04/2022 14:36

OP what would you potentially do if say the guests or at least a significant number simply refused to pay up after they had eaten? If you were to go ahead I'd be thinking very carefully about how any contract is worded or deposit taken so it's not you out of pocket.

Wouldyabeguilty · 22/04/2022 14:28

I think it is the cheapest, tackiest, scabbiest thing ever to invite someone to a wedding and expect them to pay for a meal. You invite someone to come to your special day you pay for them to eat. How can you expect people to come, give you a cash gift and then you buy your own dinner. Absolutely MORTIFIED for any couple who deems this acceptable.

ohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhy · 22/04/2022 14:13

CavernousScream · 22/04/2022 12:37

It sounds like a great way to cater a wedding (not charging the guests though, that’s rude). How do people normally do it? Just hire you for enough food for all the guests or do they have several food trucks and ask you to supply say a third or something? I’ve been to weddings with ice creams vans or a fish and chip van for the evening, but not something where a food van has done all the catering!

Normally we charge for a package deal, with the per head price coming in lower if you have more guests. We have a minimum charge, which covers them for the first 65 guests.

We let people come back for seconds too; some people have none and others have two portions so it all evens out roughly and the option of an "unlimited" package works out well.

We are specialist caterers though, so usually we're either doing the canapés after the ceremony or one course of dinner. If it's part of the dinner, then usually there's another food truck there doing the other course, or a buffet, grazing table etc

OP posts:
VeganGod · 22/04/2022 14:08

*holiday out of it

VeganGod · 22/04/2022 14:07

If people can’t afford to pay for their guests food, then they should probably be having a much cheaper wedding. People aren’t that bothered about other people’s weddings unless its someone really close to them, why would anyone think others would want to pay to eat there? And most likely not food they’d choose to eat if paying for a meal. It’s their ‘event’, so they should pay for it.

We were invited to a wedding abroad years ago. Included in the invite was a poem asking for cash not gifts, a price for flights, a price for kids club/babysitting service (which the kids would have to go in at times when the bride and groom didn’t want children around) and a suggestion that we may want to contribute to the cost of food as ‘as you can imagine, weddings are expensive and we haven’t wanted to leave any of our family and friends out’. They expected guests to pay thousands to be there, give a cash gift on top, pay to have their kids looked after by a stranger and then pay to eat on the day. The grooms mum said to me, ‘people shouldn’t mind paying for the food, they’re getting a holidaying of it after all ! 😂 Yes, that they had paid for themselves and was probably not the destination they would choose. She really thought the bride and groom were giving everyone so much. I was just ConfusedShock People don’t seem to see how cheeky they sound once they’re in ‘wedding mode’.

We didn’t attend. 😂

Peoniesandpeaches · 22/04/2022 13:59

Honestly if it meant I got to have something I genuinely liked then I’d happily pay for my own meal at the wedding. I have some food allergies and often at weddings the solution is to simply omit parts of my meal but we’ve had caterers upcharge the couple for this. I think scaling back on presents and paying for your meal could be the way forward for a lot of weddings.

dreamingbohemian · 22/04/2022 13:58

Clymene · 22/04/2022 13:30

But the OP's point @dreamingbohemian is that food trucks are at places where you can take your own food. So if people don't want to pay a tenner for a pulled pork sarnie, they might bring their own food.

Which means the OP is going to end up out of pocket. I'd imagine you need to clear at least £500 to break even on a wedding.

Yes that's why I said the OP was reasonable to turn down the job. That's a separate question as to whether it's wrong for guests to pay for food in the first place.

Nancydrawn · 22/04/2022 13:56

Yes, this very much isn't an American thing.

In fact, Americans are generally aghast at the idea of a cash bar (something that's rubbed off on me since I've been here). Some weddings are dry by request, but otherwise people tend to provide what they can. Many wedding venues allow people to arrange their own alcohol as long as a bartender is hired, in which case it can be a couple kegs and someone to pour, which is under $500 for about 300 beers. Or venues go full out with open bar packages sold by the hour. But the one-glass-of-bubbles-and-then-we-charge-you model is very uncommon in the States.

milveycrohn · 22/04/2022 13:52

I see the difficulties with the OP possibly losing money on this.
Secondly, I think if this is explicitly stated on the invitation, then guests are not suddenly put in a difficult situation, and having to pay when they did not expect to.
The suggestion of someone else to ask guests to all bring a pot luck dish dounds fine, but there could be issues over insurance/ food allergies, etc.
Personally, I think it better to have the wedding you can afford. Although most weddings these seem to operate a paying bar, but have free allocated wine for the table.

SenecaFallsRedux · 22/04/2022 13:47

This seems to be a thing in the US, but I wouldn't just ask guests to pay for their own meal.

I'm not sure where in the US you are talking about, but I live in the US, and I've probably been to over a 100 weddings in my lifetime (I'm pretty old), and I have never been to a wedding where guests paid for their own alcoholic drinks, much less the food. Cash bars are a no-no where I live; cash food, pearls would be well and truly clutched.

Of course, I have been to many weddings where there was no booze at all (Bible Belt) and also a few where only sandwiches and cake were served. I went to one where we were asked to bring a dish or bottle of wine instead of a gift.

When people give a party, which is what a wedding reception is, they need to have one they can afford. The more modest ones I have been to were often the most enjoyable because it was not about the big show, but about the people.

Dixiechickonhols · 22/04/2022 13:43

Even if it’s a cheap wedding and guests know it’s them to pay, from a food truck owners point of view it’s not attractive unless b & g guarantee minimum spend.
So eg wedding at local cricket club - cheap bar and invite says fish & chip van will be there at 7pm if you want to buy food. Told there’s 100 guests. She needs to cater for 100 otherwise she’s letting guests down potentially. But she doesn’t know if she’ll sell 100 meals or 50.

ivykaty44 · 22/04/2022 13:39

interseting

I was invited to a wedding once along with my dds who the bride and groom didn't know. The format was to be 120 guest and the bill split equally... thus my two children and me would count as 3 guests. Needless to say I declined this invite as a single parent I couldn't afford to pay for many rounds of drinks and wine etc added to the bill

Had I been presented with a food truck and a credit card machine - id have thought I just pay for what I have and a beer truck would be the same.

I had a friend who had a wedding and the room hire was free with a minimum spend of £2000 behind the bar and the wedding buffet.

A truck charging £2000 deposit and then returning this to the bride and groom after a minimum spend of £2000 would be acceptable and stop then hiring a few trucks

Clymene · 22/04/2022 13:30

But the OP's point @dreamingbohemian is that food trucks are at places where you can take your own food. So if people don't want to pay a tenner for a pulled pork sarnie, they might bring their own food.

Which means the OP is going to end up out of pocket. I'd imagine you need to clear at least £500 to break even on a wedding.

WhereWasThatFrom · 22/04/2022 13:26

I can see that it wouldn't work for you as a caterer but I don't think there is anything wrong with getting guests to pay for food IF everyone knows about it. Maybe if they said they didn't want any gifts at all but ask that guests pay for their own meals then that would be fine by me.

SummaLuvin · 22/04/2022 13:11

AllOfUsAreDead · 22/04/2022 11:59

This is just wrong. You shouldn't have your guests paying for food.

If you can't afford to have 100+ people at your wedding or even 30+ people, then you don't have them. Simple as that. A marriage should be based on more than a 'perfect' day for a wedding. Bet those brides and grooms will be nit picking about chair covers and all other kinds of bullshit, but won't feed their guests.

You have a wedding based on what you can afford. Not based on what you've seen on Instagram, but expecting it all for free. Feed your guests and have a good time, all the other nonsense like favours, chair covers, napkins etc is crap no one will remember or care about.

I feel quite differently.

It's one thing if a couple have extravagant flowers, exclusive venue, and expensive outfits and then ask you to pay for food because their budget doesn't cover it - I would resent this.

But if it's a case of a couple being really strapped for cash then I would happily pay for meal to celebrate with them if their budget would mean they could only host 10 guests 'properly'. PP have said this too.

dreamingbohemian · 22/04/2022 13:11

But that's not what the OP is talking about. She's talking about planning an expensive wedding and expecting your guests to pay for it.

That's NOT what the OP said. She didn't say if they were cheap weddings or grand.

I would agree that spending a fortune on a wedding and then asking your guests to pay 100/head for their dinner would be incredibly rude.

But the more likely scenario is people are on a really tight budget and are in a low-cost venue, and food-truck meals would be what -- 10/head? How much do you charge OP?

If I go to a really modest wedding and I know the couple don't have much money, I absolutely do not mind paying 10 quid for a pizza. I don't see how that's any different to paying 10 quid for drinks or 10 quid to make some potluck dish.

TheBatKeeper · 22/04/2022 13:08

How frightfully common.

DeyHuggee · 22/04/2022 13:08

Clymene · 22/04/2022 12:56

But they didn't book a catering food truck did they @DeyHuggee?

I don't have any issue with a pot luck wedding. I'm happy to contribute to food or as I said, go to the pub with the bride and groom and pay for my own food and drink.

But that's not what the OP is talking about. She's talking about planning an expensive wedding and expecting your guests to pay for it.

Yes and I agree as I have said with OPs stance, it's entirely sensible! But just some of the general comments on the thread about it.

Thatswhyimacat · 22/04/2022 13:02

Problem is that everyone on here says oh, have a tiny wedding if you can't afford it, immediate family only, just go out to dinner with two witnesses etc, and then start threads being offended because their husband and four kids weren't invited to their friend's daughter's wedding.

Crazykatie · 22/04/2022 12:58

As a wedding caterer you have to have a minimum spend or it’s not worthwhile organizing, they may just as well have a house party and get auntie to do the food.
Two of the weddings I’ve been to recently had Sausage and Mash, that worked well, it doesn’t have to be complicated, fancy decorations and complex settings cost a lot to arrange. Make sure who is paying and get a decent deposit, if the couple say they are paying themselves make sure they have the means to do that, they will have paid for the honeymoon up front, don’t get caught.

Shinyandnew1 · 22/04/2022 12:58

There is a huge difference between

1-saying money is short but you want to see your friends and family and would be hugely appreciative if they could bring a platter to the hall you hired as that’s all you can afford. Be clear that it’s them you want to see and you do not want presents.

2.getting married in a posh catered house which is usually well-known locally as being expensive and telling your guests at the last minute that they will have to be a large sum per person, in order to eat there, and expecting gifts/money. That is just pretending you can afford it but expecting others to subsidise you at their own personal expense!

1 is fine, 2 is totally cheeky twattery.

Rewis · 22/04/2022 12:56

Hmmm. If I paid for food from a food truck and not give a present then it night end up being cheaper for me.