Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dh and I were discussing the tory party. He really dislikes what they stand for.aibu to.ask .. .

267 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 22/04/2022 09:21

Ask if you.vote tory and would be planning to continue to do so.. why and what do you like about the party?in the circles we mix in no one votes tory that we know of so cant ask in real life.. but there must be many who vote this way.

OP posts:
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 22/04/2022 18:56

Blossomtoes · 22/04/2022 18:45

You have no idea whether the campaigns for Brexit influenced voters' choices, nor do you have the metrics to use as evidence. I would hazard an educated guess the reasons for Brexit carry inter-generational deep-seated motivations. The reasons are varied, a tad more nuanced than self-interest

But we do. That £350 million for the NHS on the bus was taken at face value by thousands of people. They voted for Brexit up in Sunderland despite having very few immigrants and their major employer warning them it was like turkeys voting for Christmas.

Ah, so what about the other 17 million.

JennyJumpup · 22/04/2022 18:50

My brother in law is a diehard Tory.
According to him the other parties would bankrupt the country and stifle entrepreneurship.

Blossomtoes · 22/04/2022 18:45

You have no idea whether the campaigns for Brexit influenced voters' choices, nor do you have the metrics to use as evidence. I would hazard an educated guess the reasons for Brexit carry inter-generational deep-seated motivations. The reasons are varied, a tad more nuanced than self-interest

But we do. That £350 million for the NHS on the bus was taken at face value by thousands of people. They voted for Brexit up in Sunderland despite having very few immigrants and their major employer warning them it was like turkeys voting for Christmas.

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 18:42

@Winter2020 I honestly dont understand the obsession with benefit claimants. Aren't the vast majority of people claiming UC in work or single mums who can't afford childcare? Other than people like my SIL but you could argue that she has mental health problems/undiagnosed disability. I do not know how people survive on benefits, the idea that people choose it is ridiculous to me.

FinallyHere · 22/04/2022 18:33

@caringcarer

Conservative party have more traditional values…. believe in Brexit, so the UK can trade independently of rest of EU block. This means many decisions like purchasing Covid vaccines can be done more quickly as don't have to wait for 27 other countries to agree before anything can be done.

This illustrates exactly what I mean about Tory 'spin' currently outsmarting TVs other parties.

No country in the EU had to wait for the others to make a decision before anything could be done.

The UK went ahead, they could easily have done with within the EU

Many EU countries did move together. Their vaccine programme started after the UK's but in percentage of the public fully vaccinated they caught up the UK

In absolute numbers of deaths, the UK did not do such a great job, either.

The government chooses the stats they refer to very carefully and then repeat them over and over again. Unless you really have good research skills and an understanding of the area, it's easy to be misled.

The Tories are also very good at covering bad news. Time and again the PM does the dead cat manoeuvre and everyone gets distracted by 'whatever dead cat they flung on the table '

Most people don't spend that much time on politics. They start from a position so eloquently set out by @BuanoKubiamVej
and have very limited bandwidth to follow individual issues.

The Tories do currently seem to have the edge on keeping many people inside just enough.

Who would have thoughts that an accomplished lier would have been so successful ?

Winter2020 · 22/04/2022 18:31

@Crikeyalmighty
“There seems to be this idea that anyone who doesn't vote Tory is some kind of massive lefty who thinks we should have unfettered immigration and thinks everyone has a right to do sweet fa and get tons of benefits”

How about we agree that neither Conservative nor Labour voters fall into simplistic stereotypes? That in itself seems quite an achievement for this thread.

It seems to me that the Tory/Labour divide of 70+ years ago is completely irrelevant to todays politics where the vast majority of voters are pretty centre e.g. almost all voters want public services and welfare provision and actually the differences are much more in the detail.

The voting Conservative/Labour question and closed minds take up valuable debating that could be put into discussion of actual policy on the issues that matter today.

I think both Conservative and Labour voters actually have a lot in common e.g. on this thread alone both Conservative and Labour voters saying they want good support for people on benefits but not a blank cheque that removes incentives to work. Both sides have said that here.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 22/04/2022 18:19

Crikeyalmighty · 22/04/2022 17:16

There seems to be this idea that anyone who doesn't vote Tory is some kind of massive lefty who thinks we should have unfettered immigration and thinks everyone has a right to do sweet fa and get tons of benefits. I think none of those things- and nor do many centre left voters. I believe in a strong private sector, a strong public sector and good social support for those that genuinely need it and a tough stance on those who are taking the piss year in and year out. However you can't sit there and say it's all the fault of labour- the Tory's have been in power 12 years!! Where's the strong programmes of free modern skills training for able bodied long term , unemployed - where was leadership pre covid for making many jobs far more flexible, where's the childcare support for helping families with 1-3 year olds with childcare-- some of these things make a huge difference but the Tory's were too frightened of stating they needed tax rises to cover it off or actually bring in laws about non Dom or corporation tax amongst big multi nationals doing vast amounts of business , but paying tax elsewhere. Worst of the lot though is Brexit. Basically killing off business in farming, fishing and anyone with decent international mail order and vastly reducing GDP. When someone on twitter states they are pro Brexit if I click on them , they are usually have a very UK centric job that's not really affected in an obvious way or are rich elite. I cannot vote for a party that actually originated this and lied to people about its benefits purely in self interest , regardless of whether the population that actually voted for it voted slightly that way.

  1. You have no idea whether the campaigns for Brexit influenced voters' choices, nor do you have the metrics to use as evidence. I would hazard an educated guess the reasons for Brexit carry inter-generational deep-seated motivations. The reasons are varied, a tad more nuanced than self-interest.
  2. Nor are you, because of a global pandemic able to separate the economic effects of Brexit from the existential pandemic.
It's just another uneducated thinly veiled attack, which is another reason for the political status quo.

And as for Twitter, with its, rainbow, and Ukraine flags, please give me strength. The postulated virtue signaling makes one want to vomit.

FinallyHere · 22/04/2022 18:15

Trying to see the bigger picture, I suspect that in relatively recent times, the party with the most sophisticated 'spin doctors' get voted into power.

Lots of people praising the Tories for 'knowing what a woman is'. Giving the tories their vote on the basis of this single issue.

And yet, and yet, the legislation which has allowed the accused in criminal cases to self id their gender, so that we have a verdict recorded as 'she was accused and convicted of rape' followed by a sentenced of incarceration in a women's prison

all happened under Tory rule. And continues under Boris, even if he says he knows what a woman is.

He said 'guidance and the rules were followed at all times* and look how that turned out.

I don't see how that means we can trust the Tories as a whole to support women's rights. I don't have a solution, as I don't trust Labour, or the LibDems either.

I would like to see proportional representation so that everyone's vote mattered. I still don't know for whom I would vote. In my current constituency, the sitting Tory's majority is ten times the total of other votes, so it's a bit of an uphill battle.

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 17:59

@Winter2020 I agree with you about second homes. The majority of people who leave homes empty in London don't live in the UK, they treat it as a bank account in the sky. Increasing council tax would not deter them, they consider it a pittance. Result of low interest rates I suppose. You could ban non residents from buying homes here like new Zealand but it doesn't seem to have helped much, their house prices have grown more than the UK over the past few years.

Housing is a global problem..the best solution I have seen is in my home country Singapore (the state building subsidized housing to sell to citizens hence 89% home ownership rate) but that took years to implement and the state owns 90% of land. No easy solutions I am afraid and definitely can't leave it to the private sector.

But definitely more social housing would probably help

LetitiaLeghorn · 22/04/2022 17:58

I watched the programme Blair and Brown: The New Labour Revolution. In it Blair said that he didn't agree with the Tory party but he recognised the fact that many of the electorate thought of them as the party of aspiration. And that's they have continual appeal. He said he tried to replicate that in the Labour Party but felt it never really stuck.

MangyInseam · 22/04/2022 17:56

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 17:36

@MangyInseam it isn't just a one way route into the UK. Britons do frequently emigrate and I once read a stat that more Britons leave than the number of immigrants coming in. Also we have an ageing population. Btw the main reason why our birthrate is higher than our European counterparts is because immigrants tend to have more children than natives. In view of the ageing population, I don't view higher immigration as a significant problem. It is probably more ecological than trying to have more babies. If you look at places like Scotland it is pretty sparsely populated.

What is tricky in the UK is our planning permission laws (which stifle house building) and our expectation of US style taxes for Scandinavian services.

IMmigration issues are oly going to get worse in the next 50 years. There is likely to be mass environmental movement.

In any case it really doesn't matter what you and I think. People don't trust the LP to give straight answers. Not because they are trying to pull one over, as they might expect from the Tories, but because they think the LP is trying to push an ideological agenda. They don't like that and that affects the LP at the ballot box. If they want to get votes they need to figure it out.

Winter2020 · 22/04/2022 17:51

Re: discouraging second homes
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-60575264
Wales has introduced laws to allow Councils to charge 300% premium on Council tax (so up to 4x standard Council tax I believe). They should keep raising it and other areas (Devon/Cornwall/London/national parks) should join them.

The number of second homes (empty homes - not rentals) would plummet if they came with a grand or two of Council tax bill every month and the extra money could be put into providing homes for people to live in (whether rented or for sale).

The second home owners in the article saying they can’t afford the additional Council tax - that’s exactly the point - sell up!

Empty second homes are immoral when there aren’t enough homes for people to actually live in. People buying several homes in order for some to be empty do so at a huge societal cost and they should pay the price of their selfishness.

We rent out our house (permanently to a family) and I would also never turn it into air b&b whatever money was on the table. Air b&b is also destroying communities. It needs to be regulated by requiring planning consent which should be withheld in residential areas.

If I ever had the money for a second home or to leave our home empty I would not because it is immoral. (I am not talking about buy to lets which provide a home for a family but empty homes). If you want to have regular holidays in an area buy a designated lodge/caravan on a holiday site not a building meant to provide a permanent home at the expense of local people. But some people won’t make this ethical choice for themselves and it needs to be regulared through taxation or law or both.

Sorry if off topic but if someone could actually offer to sort out housing I would be listening whether red or blue.

Lack of housing is destroying lives/communities and aspirations.

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 17:36

@MangyInseam it isn't just a one way route into the UK. Britons do frequently emigrate and I once read a stat that more Britons leave than the number of immigrants coming in. Also we have an ageing population. Btw the main reason why our birthrate is higher than our European counterparts is because immigrants tend to have more children than natives. In view of the ageing population, I don't view higher immigration as a significant problem. It is probably more ecological than trying to have more babies. If you look at places like Scotland it is pretty sparsely populated.

What is tricky in the UK is our planning permission laws (which stifle house building) and our expectation of US style taxes for Scandinavian services.

MangyInseam · 22/04/2022 17:22

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 17:14

@MangyInseam the immigration process is difficult/expensive for most and on that basis, the whole world would not immigrate here... We take in far fewer asylum seekers than our European neighbours and I have just outlined the fees required for workers to get long term residency here. Fees of £10k means that generally the people who tend to immigrate here from outside the EU (other than asylum seekers/family members) either earn a lot or really want to be here.

This is not really relevant when people have the impression that what is being advocated is, at least theoretically, open borders. The LP needs to be able to articulate what their vision is to people clearly. What is the end point, or how do they see the situation in 50 years? How many people can they see living in the UK?

MangyInseam · 22/04/2022 17:20

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 16:31

@MangyInseam I am very traditional in my personal life myself which is not unusual in middle class lefties. I married my university boyfriend and would not live with a man out of wedlock. Interestingly, richer and middle class couples do not divorce 50% of the time. It is much lower. But still not uncommon.

Society has changed and I don't think you can change it back..what is done is done. I actually think the current UC system actually supports single mothers staying single which can't be intended!

And the mobile workforce is because of regional inequality. Northern graduates would not leave home if they could get good jobs in the north. A lot can't. We live 3 miles away from my MIL because she lives in London, we do not choose to move to the home counties where we can get a bigger home as we want to be close to her. Good thing we can afford it. A lot of people can't. My husband's sisters left London for a reason!

Differences in the economic profile of different areas has always spurred economic migration, be it across small areas or across oceans.

However, traditionally, going back even to the middle ages in places like the UK, people overall moved a lot less, and actually quite a lot of the labour force wasn't even allowed to move, which of course we would not accept today on the basis of individual movement rights within nations.

It was the rise of industrialization and changes in the early 20th century that created a much more mobile population, more like what we know today. But it's really important to understand that the mobile workforce has been something that, more than anyone, is beneficial for capitalists, the people who own big businesses. For much the same reason the elite tend to favour free worldwide movement of capital in the banking system, they also tend to push for laws and social structures that make for a mobile workforce - one that can be redeployed and retrained at will.

This strongly advantages the elite, but it is much less of a clear benefit for the workers. It tends to leave their communities more hollowed out, and also it means that workers from less economically successful regions will migrate into their communities. It can as a result of both these things leave workers and their communities more dependent on help from the state because their communities are less self-sustaining - and that is both in the communities with work and those without.

This is why, traditionally, the labour movement and the Labour Party was always very concerned with the movement of Labour. It was a major reason for EU skepticism in the LP historically. The move to being not only pro-EU, but actually denigrating those who aren't, and saying they aren't fit to vote Labour, is a major change, almost an about face. And it should not surprise anyone that for wc people it looks like they are being spit upon for maintaining the exact same concerns that relate to their own economic and community success that they always have.

People can't always articulate it but it has left a bitterness that it will be difficult for many people to forgive, and it affects how they see the LP on almost any issue.

Crikeyalmighty · 22/04/2022 17:16

There seems to be this idea that anyone who doesn't vote Tory is some kind of massive lefty who thinks we should have unfettered immigration and thinks everyone has a right to do sweet fa and get tons of benefits. I think none of those things- and nor do many centre left voters. I believe in a strong private sector, a strong public sector and good social support for those that genuinely need it and a tough stance on those who are taking the piss year in and year out. However you can't sit there and say it's all the fault of labour- the Tory's have been in power 12 years!! Where's the strong programmes of free modern skills training for able bodied long term , unemployed - where was leadership pre covid for making many jobs far more flexible, where's the childcare support for helping families with 1-3 year olds with childcare-- some of these things make a huge difference but the Tory's were too frightened of stating they needed tax rises to cover it off or actually bring in laws about non Dom or corporation tax amongst big multi nationals doing vast amounts of business , but paying tax elsewhere. Worst of the lot though is Brexit. Basically killing off business in farming, fishing and anyone with decent international mail order and vastly reducing GDP. When someone on twitter states they are pro Brexit if I click on them , they are usually have a very UK centric job that's not really affected in an obvious way or are rich elite. I cannot vote for a party that actually originated this and lied to people about its benefits purely in self interest , regardless of whether the population that actually voted for it voted slightly that way.

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 17:14

@MangyInseam the immigration process is difficult/expensive for most and on that basis, the whole world would not immigrate here... We take in far fewer asylum seekers than our European neighbours and I have just outlined the fees required for workers to get long term residency here. Fees of £10k means that generally the people who tend to immigrate here from outside the EU (other than asylum seekers/family members) either earn a lot or really want to be here.

MangyInseam · 22/04/2022 17:05

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 16:24

@MangyInseam mainly cos anyone who has immigrated in the last 10 years or know someone who has know it's no walk in the park....my colleague paid £10k in fees for herself and her kids to get ILR/citizenship. How many native Britons are able to do that? I am married to a Brit but I wouldn't say it was easy and straightforward either..

For asylum seekers, it's 1000000X harder. My British friends all know it is not easy!

I'm not sure what you are getting at with this, it doesn't seem to really relate toanything I said?

Everanewbie · 22/04/2022 16:41

I read an interesting book about this a while ago, and it went into detail about how one side of the divide can't fathom why someone would vote the other way, and assumed that they were inherently evil etc. The book theorised that basically it comes down to your personality type and how you determine what fair means to you. To some people, fairness means that everyone should have the chance to eat the same food, get the same education and have the same opportunities. The fact that wealthier people have more of these things is abhorrent to them and inherently unfair. Others would argue that someone with greater wealth has worked hard to earn the privilege of better food etc. and feel that there endevours are well rewarded by providing their children with better education, life chances etc. and why on earth should they have to give that up, or give up a large proportion of this to supplement less industrious, less hard working and less innovative people and families.

My personal view is that this is a spectrum, and that people completely on one pole of what i've described are both extremists and that most people fit somewhere between those extremes.

Personally, I strongly believe every child should have a right to live in a heated house, have food on the table and receive an education. I also believe that people that suffer from illness should be supported until such time that they can once again support themselves. However I also strongly believe that hard work and innovation must be rewarded and taxation should not be burdensome to the point where high achievers leave the country or do not see the point in entrepreneurial risk. People that have been successful have every right to ensure their children receive a first class education if they decide to spend their money on that. So I would say that I come out as centre right, which in general terms reflects what I thought I was voting for in 2019 when I voted for the Conservatives. But that was before the most disgusting act of oppression that was the covid overreaction where my party of choice took the lead from a communist dictatorship. But thats a different story.

So in direct answer to your question OP, my suspicion is that Conservative voters probably have a slightly different idea to you of where that fairness point lies, and are unlikely in general to be evil.

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 16:31

@MangyInseam I am very traditional in my personal life myself which is not unusual in middle class lefties. I married my university boyfriend and would not live with a man out of wedlock. Interestingly, richer and middle class couples do not divorce 50% of the time. It is much lower. But still not uncommon.

Society has changed and I don't think you can change it back..what is done is done. I actually think the current UC system actually supports single mothers staying single which can't be intended!

And the mobile workforce is because of regional inequality. Northern graduates would not leave home if they could get good jobs in the north. A lot can't. We live 3 miles away from my MIL because she lives in London, we do not choose to move to the home counties where we can get a bigger home as we want to be close to her. Good thing we can afford it. A lot of people can't. My husband's sisters left London for a reason!

MarshaBradyo · 22/04/2022 16:30

MangyInseam · 22/04/2022 16:12

I do think immigration is an issue for Labour. One where they aren't helping themselves. They are too ready to say too little so people who basically think any border control is racist xenophobia will be placated.

I don't think the party really believes that at all, but they won't acknowledge the elephant clearly, which is that as things are in the world right now, if there were open borders there could be an endless stream of people who would want to settle in the UK. And there is not the infratructure to house them or care for them, there isn't the social infrastructure either, and it's very arguable that environmentally speaking there isn't the space.

So the question clearly becomes, how do you manage that, what do they see immigration looking like over the years, what do they see the country looking like. How do they see people becoming integrated? How many people should there be? How many people can fit?

People don't feel like Labour will answer those questions clearly, and so they suspect the LP wants to keep their views quiet because they will be unpalatable. And they don't like it when asking the question gets them accused of bigotry.

Good points. This could shift in the near future and become a key part of policies, defence too could be seen to be more important.

Labour could find that hard to be clear on.

As an aside I’m appreciating the considered posts rather than usual berating and insults we get on these threads

Dogmum40 · 22/04/2022 16:29

I genuinely have no idea who I would vote for, over the years I’ve voted for all parties in one election or another but as another poster said I’m politically homeless!

The only thing I think is good about the conservatives is the comment Boris made on female gender and through that comment he seems to understand womens rights and that we actually have a say but I can’t vote for conservatives on that one comment he made, I just don’t think I’ll bother this time 🤷‍♀️

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 16:24

@MangyInseam mainly cos anyone who has immigrated in the last 10 years or know someone who has know it's no walk in the park....my colleague paid £10k in fees for herself and her kids to get ILR/citizenship. How many native Britons are able to do that? I am married to a Brit but I wouldn't say it was easy and straightforward either..

For asylum seekers, it's 1000000X harder. My British friends all know it is not easy!

MangyInseam · 22/04/2022 16:23

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 16:04

@MangyInseam honestly with a divorce rate of 50%, I would not encourage any woman to be a stay at home mum. I would prefer a system where grandparents looked after kids and that was how I was raised but many people don't have that option due to living far away from family.

People in the past used to survive on 1 income, but their lives were a lot simpler. They wouldn't have a foreign holiday every year or the pile of Christmas presents that kids nowadays have. I don't think it's a bad thing, I think times and societies change. The UK is a developed economy generally in developed countries, you expect to pay more tax to cover more services i.e. state childcare and healthcare. In developing countries, you expect to save more of your income so that you can cover all emergencies and education and healthcare needs. In China , for example, the savings rate is 50%. But then the services have to be cheap enough to merit saving. In UK, you can save all you like and you would still not be able to save for a grandma's heart transplant even if you never paid a penny of tax.

Piles of presents and overseas holidays, to my mind, are not an environmentally sustainable approach.

But one thing that is interesting is that attitudes to marriage correspond to voting more than a lot of people think. It's really common among conservative voters to point out that one of the biggest predictors of success, including financially, is having a two parent family. So they want taxation, benefits, etc that tend to support families staying together as much as possible (and no that does not mean they think people should stay with abusers) and often also favour divorce laws that protect women who stayed home. They see the kinds of benefits systems that became popular in the 60s and 70s as actually creating a lot of poverty by disincentivising marriage and incentivising out of wedlock pregnancies - and there are economists who will make that argument, it's not just judgy asshats.

The assumption that it is great to have a mobile workforce is one that is certainly part of the problem, with the break up of extended families, but Labour is at least as wedded to that as the Tories. Movement of Labour was one of the major issues with Brexit, one which Labour repudiated very strongly despite despite the fact that it's traditionally a leftist concern.

Personally, my biggest political influence was Shumacker, who wrote Small Is Beautiful, which I would say was a profoundly leftist approach to economics and politics. It also is a perspective that is at least as well reflected in the modern Tory party as it is in Labour, even Momentum Labour.

MangyInseam · 22/04/2022 16:12

I do think immigration is an issue for Labour. One where they aren't helping themselves. They are too ready to say too little so people who basically think any border control is racist xenophobia will be placated.

I don't think the party really believes that at all, but they won't acknowledge the elephant clearly, which is that as things are in the world right now, if there were open borders there could be an endless stream of people who would want to settle in the UK. And there is not the infratructure to house them or care for them, there isn't the social infrastructure either, and it's very arguable that environmentally speaking there isn't the space.

So the question clearly becomes, how do you manage that, what do they see immigration looking like over the years, what do they see the country looking like. How do they see people becoming integrated? How many people should there be? How many people can fit?

People don't feel like Labour will answer those questions clearly, and so they suspect the LP wants to keep their views quiet because they will be unpalatable. And they don't like it when asking the question gets them accused of bigotry.