Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dh and I were discussing the tory party. He really dislikes what they stand for.aibu to.ask .. .

267 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 22/04/2022 09:21

Ask if you.vote tory and would be planning to continue to do so.. why and what do you like about the party?in the circles we mix in no one votes tory that we know of so cant ask in real life.. but there must be many who vote this way.

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 23/04/2022 10:44

And as for the idea of well 'he got Brexit done' what a raging success that's been. 20 mile queues at ports, farming and fishing decimated as is a lot of exporting in any companies with trade outside the UK. GDP vastly down, I have 3 friends who all had nice little cottage industries- all had to stop because exporting no longer works and UK trade not enough to make it pay. The idea too that well he paid furlough and self employed during covid so did most other places Here they paid office and shop rents too -- and not loans!!

Blossomtoes · 23/04/2022 10:43

Crikeyalmighty · 23/04/2022 10:38

I can't quite get beyond the fact that so many women on here are fine with the current bunch of Tory's constant fraud, dodgy contracts non tendered , to mates, fining people massive amounts for not following rules whilst ignoring them themselves and telling complete bullshit about worldbeating- take for example the idea you could travel about again far quicker than anywhere else-- news to me as we went to Majorca in June last year from being based in Denmark and I had already had all my jabs too, perfectly full supermarkets etc. No party is perfect and I'm not keen on the ultra left either but the fact is we have a bunch of self serving alley cats in charge at the moment, happy to lie, happy to bullshit.

But they say they know what a woman is. So basically they can get away with any corrupt, immoral and dishonest behaviour and some women will still vote for them. It’s like they’ve written themselves a blank cheque.

Crikeyalmighty · 23/04/2022 10:38

I can't quite get beyond the fact that so many women on here are fine with the current bunch of Tory's constant fraud, dodgy contracts non tendered , to mates, fining people massive amounts for not following rules whilst ignoring them themselves and telling complete bullshit about worldbeating- take for example the idea you could travel about again far quicker than anywhere else-- news to me as we went to Majorca in June last year from being based in Denmark and I had already had all my jabs too, perfectly full supermarkets etc. No party is perfect and I'm not keen on the ultra left either but the fact is we have a bunch of self serving alley cats in charge at the moment, happy to lie, happy to bullshit.

Andouillette · 23/04/2022 09:22

CharityShopChic · 23/04/2022 07:53

I will vote COnservative if they are the party in my area which is most likely to give the SNP a kicking. Because I loathe and despise Sturgeon and her nationalists more than anyone else.

Me too! I most likely would anyway but it's an added incentive for sure.

tomatoandherbs · 23/04/2022 08:45

@Hrpuffnstuff1

i agree in principle
but I have ZERO judgement if a struggling single mother looks at her situation strategically in order to secure the most she can.

CharityShopChic · 23/04/2022 07:53

I will vote COnservative if they are the party in my area which is most likely to give the SNP a kicking. Because I loathe and despise Sturgeon and her nationalists more than anyone else.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 23/04/2022 07:50

Winter2020 · 22/04/2022 23:05

@tomatoandherbs
If for example a family receives 20k of benefits (housing/council tax and income) and then one of the adults gets a job paying 19k - is it possible to say what the total houseehold income would be then? How much better off would they be for taking that job and working full time?

Sorry despite you saying I wouldn't know how to work it out.

Better off working!
It doesn't matter, everyone should work if they can, the comparison to benefits is irrelevant, it's not an argument. Where the ethical morality in deciding not to work.
Somehow, some Brits have ended up with a warped view of what it means to provide.

tomatoandherbs · 23/04/2022 06:43

Ah yes you did!

under UC you will never be “worse off” earning
it might not be much more
but it will always be more
plus!! 85% back on al your childcare costs. This is brilliant for me!!

tomatoandherbs · 23/04/2022 06:42

You aren’t taxes anything up to £12,250
aury you knew that?!

tomatoandherbs · 23/04/2022 06:41

In short
under UC (not necessarily under tax credits because their totally different approach is end of benefits if more than 16 hours worked), you will always be better off working

tomatoandherbs · 23/04/2022 06:40

@Winter2020
gov benefit calculator will give you a very strong indication
you can input as many different scenarios, earnings etc as your imagination allows!

lightisnotwhite · 22/04/2022 23:36

For me they got Brexit done, Teresa May faffed about. It’s not perfect but it’s a starting point. Not because I’m racist or anti anything but because Europe got too big. 28 counteries - 8 paid in.
They paid self employed earnings super quick during lockdiwn. They paid my ferlow quickly too Lockdiwn was painless.
They didn’t impose martial law or police state lockdown.
they got the vaccine out really quickly and for free. Then boosters. Then second boosters.
They support many single issues I want to remain.
They said that women were women

i don’t mind they chance it. Labour pretend they have all the answers when clearly politics are not an easy fix but a bit of a cluster fuck worldwide.

it will take 6 months of a Labour government to admit there’s no great solution (hence they Labour aren’t actually offering one) and a bit of tweaking tax doesn’t make up for a robust idea about where the counteries headed.

Winter2020 · 22/04/2022 23:05

@tomatoandherbs
If for example a family receives 20k of benefits (housing/council tax and income) and then one of the adults gets a job paying 19k - is it possible to say what the total houseehold income would be then? How much better off would they be for taking that job and working full time?

Sorry despite you saying I wouldn't know how to work it out.

Winter2020 · 22/04/2022 22:45

@tomatoandherbs

Quote: It is very simple really. If you receive UC, you have a work allowance ie a amount you can earn without your benefits being reduced. Once you hit the work allowance, you lose 55p for every pound (very recently was 63p)

If you earn over the 12k odd tax threshold as well as losing your 55p of benefits because you earned more I assume you lose 20p to income tax and 13p national insurance (as well as student loan and pension deduction if applicable) so you lose 88p of each £1 at least?

It's good to hear that you can keep several hundred pounds before deductions from benefits but if the above is correct and you keep just 12p in the £1 then little incentive to work more if you earn within the taper amount. That would mean for an extra hour earning £10 you would take home £1.20 more?

ilovesooty · 22/04/2022 22:18

Blossomtoes · 22/04/2022 21:44

Boris has done a LOT of good which people are happily forgetting atm

All right, I’ll bite. What am I happily forgetting?

I'd be interested to know more about this LOT of good too.

Blossomtoes · 22/04/2022 21:44

Boris has done a LOT of good which people are happily forgetting atm

All right, I’ll bite. What am I happily forgetting?

Leafstamp · 22/04/2022 21:20

I’ll be voting Tory next time having never done so before. This is because they are the only party who know that a woman is an adult human female. Any party that can’t state this cannot possibly be on women’s side.

Kendodd · 22/04/2022 21:17

You have no idea whether the campaigns for Brexit influenced voters' choices, nor do you have the metrics to use as evidence.

Actually I think Dominic Cummings actually did really extensive research on this. He found Turkey joining the EU lie and £350 million NHS lie worked best at persuading people to vote leave. He didn't mention the single market or customs union because his research showed that the public (and most MPs) didn't have a clue what they are.

Notmoresugar · 22/04/2022 21:16

I will definitely vote for them again.
Boris has done a LOT of good which people are happily forgetting atm.
He needs to concentrate on what's happening in Europe and avoiding WW3 instead of all this crap.

Yes, he has made mistakes but he is the best man and leader for the job.

God only help us all if Keir Starman and Angela Rayner get in. Their only level of expertise is in consistent mud-slinging, not politics.

tomatoandherbs · 22/04/2022 21:07

@Winter2020

It is very simple really. If you receive UC, you have a work allowance ie a amount you can earn without your benefits being reduced. Once you hit the work allowance, you lose 55p for every pound (very recently was 63p)

The first £344 is untouched if you are getting housing costs as part of your Universal Credit award, or housing costs from the Local Authority because you are in temporary accommodation
The first £573 is untouched if you do not receive housing support

XingMing · 22/04/2022 20:56

@CounsellorTroi so you are the bot here, with the mechanistic responses.

Like a few PPs, I vote Tory without enthusiasm. I think they have moved round on sexual politics to be first to give the go ahead to same sex marriages. The front bench of politics looks more diverse because the Tories have had more women and more minorities than any Labour opposition. Dianne Abbott is too stupid to flutter any radar.

And, because I have worked for 48 years, and saved, I have a home and a pension, and I think I deserve what I have worked for. To elaborate a bit, DH started a company, has kept it going for 35 years and some of those years we have taken 0 from the work, while paying the staff, because we know what's important. Fewer than 10% of entrepreneur's businesses continue after the founder's retirement or death... not talking about big companies, just John's Plumbing or Jaswinder's cashflow software programme.

The big-swinging. heavy- hitting anti-capitalists here, who treat every local one-man plumbing business the same as Goldman Sachs because they seek a profit at the end of a year's work to bung something away for the pension. It's the same reason that 35,000 people a year are ready to pay a dodgy geezer a huge sum to get them into a safe country. Whatever its short-comings, and it's a long way from Paradise I agree, a relatively free wheeling capitalist economy tends to make more money for more people, So on balance, I am just a Tory.

Winter2020 · 22/04/2022 20:41

Following on from this I would love to hear that people are always now better off in work.

Does anyone work in benefits and can say?

Suspect it's like you keep the first £20 and then deducted from benefits so if you have to pay for the bus you are worse off but I would live to hear people are significantly better off in work?

I think the system is kept complicated enough that it's hard to tell. All smoke and mirrors.

Winter2020 · 22/04/2022 20:16

desiringonlychild2022
@Winter2020 was he on minimum wage? How can he be working all those hours and for it to be less?

Full time and reasonably newly qualified primary school teacher with stay at home partner with small child.

At a guess from memory I'd say his full time wage was about 22k at the time. I'm not even saying his wage was low but if it had been lower e.g. work 9-5 in an office for 18k at the time - we would have been given the difference in top ups.

When you are talking about non working families the "pittance" of benefits involves most rent being paid, most Council tax paid - that's most of what people spend their wages on paid before disposable income. Then free prescriptions, free school meals - no commuting costs/might not need a car. More leisure time.

I'm not particularly saying and don't think that people on benefits get a lot but things are also tough for a lot of working people and many work bloody hard to be very little better off.

I think the people that have it really tough (benefits wise) are single adults. A lot extea for those that have kids but for single adults it's very tight. Hard for single income (low income) working households too.

desiringonlychild2022 · 22/04/2022 19:48

@Winter2020 was he on minimum wage? How can he be working all those hours and for it to be less? I am not sure what it is for a family of 3 but my SIL gets a few hundred pounds. Absolute pittance. If it wasn't the fact she is living rent free and her mum pays for all food, bills, clothes etc etc, she would not be able to survive..hence it is a concern what happens once my MIL needs to go to a care home and the house needs to be sold.

Winter2020 · 22/04/2022 19:19

@desiringonlychild2022
Quote: "@Winter2020 I honestly dont understand the obsession with benefit claimants. Aren't the vast majority of people claiming UC in work or single mums who can't afford childcare? Other than people like my SIL but you could argue that she has mental health problems/undiagnosed disability. I do not know how people survive on benefits, the idea that people choose it is ridiculous to me."

I expect you earn a lot more than benefit claimants then - you have said you don't know how people survive on benefits. So I expect you feel you have little in common with benefits claimants.

I (and many many others I am sure) have had my partner in the past working 6/7 days running himself into a breakdown while I was a stay at home mum to a young child (with no entitlement to claim anything which is fine) but seeing on online benefit calculators that if we earned any less it would be given to us because no family would be expected to live on less. Why should one family work themselves to the point of illness and another be given or made up to the same. Work should pay. That's why the "obsession" with benefits. Working yourself silly shouldn't pay the same as doing fuck all for a family without disabilities.

This was around 2014 so I can only hope that the system has improved and work does pay.

Yes lots of people survive on what people get on benefits - when they are working!