Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Scott Morrison didn’t say anything wrong?

158 replies

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 21:28

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-61171449.amp

I heard this being discussed on Shelagh Fogarty this afternoon. I don’t think he’s said anything wrong. What do you think?

OP posts:
Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 22:22

Anyway I read his comment as ‘We’ve been blessed to not have to watch our kids struggle’ rather than ‘thank God we have able bodied children, I’m not sure we could’ve loved them if they had been disabled’.

I can’t help but feel all the in-fighting over terminology and nit picking over people’s well intended words actually detracts from the main mission of improving quality of life for disabled people

(I’m disabled, I wish I wasn’t)

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:21

Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 22:19

Kind of ironic!!! 🤣

Please expand on this

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 22:20

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:17

Correct, I am intolerant of religion, mainly because it's still full of dark ages nonsense and its adherents are those who continually put their foot in it by using offensive outdated language that demeans, belittles, and 'others' people they believe are inferior. Well spotted.

And no, I have no need to 'examine my prejudice'. I've examined religion well enough to see it for what it is.

I just wonder if you would’ve been so open with your critique had this been another religion. Always Christianity where people suddenly feel bold enough to say things like this, isn’t it?

OP posts:
Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 22:19

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:17

Correct, I am intolerant of religion, mainly because it's still full of dark ages nonsense and its adherents are those who continually put their foot in it by using offensive outdated language that demeans, belittles, and 'others' people they believe are inferior. Well spotted.

And no, I have no need to 'examine my prejudice'. I've examined religion well enough to see it for what it is.

Kind of ironic!!! 🤣

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:17

Discovereads · 21/04/2022 22:06

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

you are coming across as intolerant of religion, specifically Christianity. Suggest you examine this prejudice.

Correct, I am intolerant of religion, mainly because it's still full of dark ages nonsense and its adherents are those who continually put their foot in it by using offensive outdated language that demeans, belittles, and 'others' people they believe are inferior. Well spotted.

And no, I have no need to 'examine my prejudice'. I've examined religion well enough to see it for what it is.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:14

Discovereads · 21/04/2022 22:04

would not have exposed him as a dinosaur who still inherently believes that disabled or ND people are 'lesser'

He was just acknowledging that ableism is something he hasn’t had to face as a parent of abled children imho. Not that he believes himself they are lesser. You’re stretching to reach that conclusion by simply one word of “blessed” in place of “that” which would have made it all ok to you.

This doesn't make any sense.

If you replace 'blessed' with 'that', then he would have said "Jenny and I have been that", which is nonsensical.

I'm not 'stretching' anything. The point is that he could have easily made exactly the same point he was trying to get across without having to use any sort of term, word, or phrase that implies one child being superior/inferior by comparison. For a senior politician it shows a startling lack of self-awareness, a poor choice of language, and really doesn't reflect well on him at all.

Trying to play it like he only used that term because it has religious meaning really doesn't make it look any better, in fact, all it does it make him look even more out of touch.

Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 22:09

I can see both sides here but I think we really need to stop jumping on people for making a throwaway comment that, yes could be perceived in an offensive way, but maybe it just came out wrong and he worded it clumsily. I don't think he should be vilified for that.

And I say that as the mother of a physically disabled child. I don't feel any less blessed that my child is disabled but on the other hand I would love it amd feel even more blessed if he was miraculously healed one day and he didn't have to go through multiple surgeries, pain, frustration, injuries, intensive physio every day. That's the reality of it.

giggbig · 21/04/2022 22:08

Of course ND or doable children are undesirable.

🤔

carefullycourageous · 21/04/2022 22:08

I think what he said is not acceptable, it implies a hierachy of desirability of children.

CrowUpNorth · 21/04/2022 22:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I wouldn't change a thing about my boys. For a start both of them are very caring and not trying to get a rise from people.

Discovereads · 21/04/2022 22:06

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

you are coming across as intolerant of religion, specifically Christianity. Suggest you examine this prejudice.

BlancmanegeBunny · 21/04/2022 22:06

His choice of words was very poor and open to negative connotations.

I am blessed to have a wonderful disabled child.

UhtredsLatestPaganHussy · 21/04/2022 22:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

'doable'?

Even you're going to post trash at least try and make it intelligible.

Discovereads · 21/04/2022 22:04

would not have exposed him as a dinosaur who still inherently believes that disabled or ND people are 'lesser'

He was just acknowledging that ableism is something he hasn’t had to face as a parent of abled children imho. Not that he believes himself they are lesser. You’re stretching to reach that conclusion by simply one word of “blessed” in place of “that” which would have made it all ok to you.

Thecanaryislands · 21/04/2022 22:04

A friend of mine went through the adoption process. They had to fill in a form scoring multiple questions from 1-10 how willing they were to accept a ‘less than perfect’ child. For example, from 1-10 how willing are you to have a child with fetal alcohol syndrome/autism/physical disabilities/blind/deaf/sexually abused. She said it felt awful, because obviously everyone wants a perfect child.
No-one (or very few people…I did hear a woman in the radio once who had adopted 2 children with significant additional needs) would choose to have a child with additional needs. I don’t think he meant other people were cursed or that the children with additional needs weren’t a blessing……but the point is, no mother prays that the child growing inside them is going to be born with complex additional needs. Everyone wants a healthy child. That’s normal.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:04

Discovereads · 21/04/2022 21:58

This is what he said
”: "Jenny and I have been blessed, we've got two children that don't - that haven't had to go through that."
"And so, for parents with children who are disabled, I can only try and understand your aspirations for those children."

he was only acknowledging his privilege as a parent of able children. He’s not inferring that disabled children are undesirable. “Blessed” literally means privileged (by God) to the religious.

If you give him that very generous benefit of doubt, that 'blessed' means privileged, then he is literally inferring that parents of disabled children are not 'blessed'.

So why hasn't 'God' blessed them then? Presumably it's something that they have done that his displeased this 'God' that he has forsaken them and lumbered them with a disabled child, rather than blessing them?

ITSupport · 21/04/2022 22:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheOriginalEmu · 21/04/2022 22:02

QueenOfHiraeth · 21/04/2022 21:56

I read his words as saying his family were blessed in not having to deal with the stresses and issues that families with ND/disabled children have to face which is totally different

Yes, I think that’s how he meant it. Trouble is the way he said it wasn’t the most sensitive and I can see why people are offended by it.
As a disabled person with disabled kids, I’m as blessed as he is to have my kids. I don’t think he meant anything bad, just had choice of words which as PM he should really do better with.

HeartShapedBox · 21/04/2022 22:02

This reply has been deleted

Deleted as it repeated a deleted post.

MangyInseam · 21/04/2022 22:01

the80sweregreat · 21/04/2022 21:53

The lbc phone in about this was interesting today as a few of the callers who had children with special needs were not that appalled by what this man said. I was expecting more of a backlash , but the callers she had on were very pragmatic about it ( and had first hand experience of what it was like to bring up a child with different needs for many years too )

In my experience parents whose children do have significant special needs are like this - very pragmatic and quite aware that it can be a serious burden, and that feeling that way is in no way incompatible with loving your kids.

My cousin is going to have to take care of her severely autistic daughter and who will care for her once my cousin and her family can't is a real concern. And it makes their lives hard on a daily basis. She would be the first to agree that it would be a blessing not to have to deal with that.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:00

wasn't poor*

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:00

QueenOfHiraeth · 21/04/2022 21:56

I read his words as saying his family were blessed in not having to deal with the stresses and issues that families with ND/disabled children have to face which is totally different

That's another obvious interpretation, and as stated by others further up the thread, even as an ND person myself his language isn't all that appalling because it's the sort of thing we hear all the time. That doesn't mean that his choice of term was poor and ill considered though.

He could have simply said "my wife and I have not had to go through that with our children", which would have made his point succinctly, and would not have exposed him as a dinosaur who still inherently believes that disabled or ND people are 'lesser'.

Discovereads · 21/04/2022 21:58

This is what he said
”: "Jenny and I have been blessed, we've got two children that don't - that haven't had to go through that."
"And so, for parents with children who are disabled, I can only try and understand your aspirations for those children."

he was only acknowledging his privilege as a parent of able children. He’s not inferring that disabled children are undesirable. “Blessed” literally means privileged (by God) to the religious.

ScarlettDarling · 21/04/2022 21:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@ITSupport What an insensitive and cruel comment.

QueenOfHiraeth · 21/04/2022 21:56

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 21:48

It's the inference that if you are 'blessed' to have NT/able bodied children, then those who are parents to ND/disabled children must be cursed. Totally old fashioned and has undertones of religious dogma.

Or you could just draw the other obvious inference, which is that it's preferable to have NT/able bodied children, and ND/disabled children are undesirable, which is just pain ordinary offensive.

I read his words as saying his family were blessed in not having to deal with the stresses and issues that families with ND/disabled children have to face which is totally different