Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Scott Morrison didn’t say anything wrong?

158 replies

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 21:28

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-61171449.amp

I heard this being discussed on Shelagh Fogarty this afternoon. I don’t think he’s said anything wrong. What do you think?

OP posts:
RichPetunia · 22/04/2022 02:45

Let's be realistic. Would you rather have a child with or without special needs? To say you are blessed to have a child without special needs is just giving thanks and acknowledging your relief that everything's gone smoothly and to plan.

TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek · 21/04/2022 23:44

When I had my babies many years ago I refused the blood test that could show a higher likelihood of the mother carrying a baby that had Downs Syndrome. The midwife asked me why, as it was just a blood test. I told her that my reason was that even if I was having a baby that did have DS I wouldn't be aborting it, and that in fact I considered being pregnant with a baby that has DS as very much a blessing. Of course whether or not a child is NT, they can have all sorts of challenges in their lives, and on rare occasions a child with DS will have severe health problems, as will NT children.

As a student nurse I had a placement in a large house on a normal housing estate, that had been turned into a home for adults with various different, but very severe learning difficulties. One of them had an issue with always chewing at her hands, she eventually, very sadly, died from Septicemia. All of the adults in that home had been given up by their birth families, I didn't know all of their histories, but some had been given up at birth, and others at different stages throughout their lives. I did not - in fact I could not - judge their parents. These were people who had hardly any way of communicating how they felt, and all were doubly incontinent. I loved being able to help look after them (although I hated the small letter politics of most of the staff in that place) but with the best will in the world I would struggle to understand how someone could think that they were blessed to have a child born with such serious disabilities. Those often dreadfully painful conditions, that appeared to offer very little, to no quality of life, could not, in my opinion be a blessing to either the child or the parent. However, I did consider myself to be blessed to have even that small chance to get to know, as much as was possible, the soul that inhabitated that body, and for me to be able to in even small ways, get to show them some affection.

An example being the young lady who later died of Septicemia. She couldn't tell you what she wanted, but if you sat down she would try to climb onto your lap for a cuddle (I think she was about 25 years old then and I was about 34). I was told in no uncertain terms by the other staff there that I must not let her climb onto my lap. The reasons they gave were that a) it wasn't appropriate, and b) she wasn't the most hygenic of people - basically if any of the residents had a itch anywhere on their body, and they could reach it, then they would scratch it, but that is just how it is with people who have such severe learning difficulties, but with the mobility and strength of an adult. Anyway, when I was sitting down and she tried to climb onto my lap for a cuddle, I couldn't even gently push her away, or stand up and walk away - she wanted a cuddle, and even if I had been sacked for breaking safeguarding issues (not that they were ever referred to me as that, but I wasn't stupid, and I had children of my own, so I was well aware of what dangers any of those residents could be exposed to, and in danger of being taken advantage of), I felt that I had to let her sit on my lap for a few minutes, and I had to put my arm around her and give her a gentle cuddle, and I had to keep on gently moving her hand away from her mouth as she was trying to chew it. I did not want to reject her so I didn't. There were other nurses coming in and out of the (living) room, they frowned, but they didn't say anything.

It broke my heart when I had to leave the residents there in the politics of that home. I did make a complaint to the person at my university who was responsible for arranging and supervising those placements, but I heard no more about it, except a short while later I only scraped a pass mark for my community study - which had had many hours of study, research, cross referencing ect put into it by me, and I usually got high 80's or 90's (out of 100) for all of my previous essays and work, but only 46% for my community study. I think that I was being punished for potentially rocking the boat.

Oh dear, I have really digressed. I am very sorry OP for doing so. I don't know which way to vote, because if Scott Morrison has visited homes like the one where I had a placement, I think he is right to not think that as babies they had been a blessing to themselves or their parents. But if he mainly knows NT and ND people who do, or with the right help can, live happy and fulfilled lives, then in muy opinion the vast majority of both were blessings for their parents, and I can only hope and pray that their parents were blessings for them. If I had to choose, then I think it would have been better if he hadn't made a generalised statement like that, but we are all mearly humans, and as such we frequently make the wrong judgement call.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 23:41

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 23:35

I don’t think he has a ‘duty of care not to offend people’ at all, what does that even mean? He can’t ever say anything that somebody else doesn’t like? How reasonable an expectation is that for a politician?!

You’re using your dislike of religion to stretch this way out of proportion

There's a gulf between 'not being offensive' and not saying this that someone else doesn't like. Surely you don't need me to spell that out?

As a politician he's invariably going to say things that some people won't 'like', that goes hand-in-hand with politics and is true of all politicians. He still absolutely has a duty of care not to be outright offensive. That's true of all people, not just politicians, but it's especially the case with elected officials and those in positions of responsibility.

Presumably you think there was nothing wrong with anything Adolf Hitler said in his speeches then? After all, what does it matter if he was offensive. By your logic that's just people 'not liking' what he said.

Of course Morrison has a duty of care. To suggest he doesn't is ridiculous.

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 23:35

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 23:09

No I got that point perfectly well, I just assumed that wasn't the particular point you were making.

Scott Morrison is a prominent politician, I'm not.

If I ever find myself in his shoes I'd like to think that I'd be able to keep my non-belief to myself. It certainly wouldn't have me using ill-advised terms like 'blessed', that when used in specific contexts could be construed as highly offensive.

While I'm aware that I said 'it's adherents' regarding religion, and that could be taken to suggest I meant 'all religious people', what I actually meant is that it's perfectly common to hear someone in a prominent public position say something offensive which clearly stems from their religious belief. At least, I can think of far more of these instances that I can of a similarly prominent public persona saying something offensive which stems from non-belief.

Again, Scott Morrison is in a position where he has a duty of care not to offend people, and if that means keeping his religiosity to himself, that is what he should be doing. My views on religion are neither here nor there, yet I can't imagine how my non-belief would manifest itself in a way that would offend disabled people. Religious people yes, but then if they are going to insist on believing in the ridiculous, then they need to accept that will bring ridicule.

I don’t think he has a ‘duty of care not to offend people’ at all, what does that even mean? He can’t ever say anything that somebody else doesn’t like? How reasonable an expectation is that for a politician?!

You’re using your dislike of religion to stretch this way out of proportion

OP posts:
MissTrip82 · 21/04/2022 23:23

Discovereads · 21/04/2022 22:06

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

you are coming across as intolerant of religion, specifically Christianity. Suggest you examine this prejudice.

You’re coming across as quite ignorant. I suggest you do some reading about Hillsong, the ‘prosperity gospel’ 🤮and Scott Morrison’s behaviour towards the most vulnerable groups in Australian society. You can then reflect on how that fits with your understanding of the teachings of Christ.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 23:15

Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 23:01

I wonder if he used the word "privileged" instead of "blessed" people wouldn't be offended?

Yes, because using any term at all carries an inference.

As I've already said, if he was determined to relay his own experiences, he could have simply said 'My wife and I have no experience of this' or similar. Better still, he could have just realised that having no experience of it whatsoever he can't really say anything of relevance at all about his own situation, and it would be best avoided bringing it up entirely.

It's one of these scenario where a politician has been asked a question about humanity, tried to empathise and make themselves look human and normal, and made a complete hash of it.

What he actually said was not enormously offensive in so far as these things go, but it was still offensive and ill-considered.

UselessASD · 21/04/2022 23:13

The comment seems odd as a response to a person with a disabled child asking in the run up to an election about the policy on support fir disabled people. was that the point, to talk about how strong parents are and side step any actual promises (not an Australian so don’t know if this is an election issue this time)

as for the comment I took it to mean that he feels blessed not to deal with the struggles that parents of some disabled children face.

as a disabled person I am not offended by the concept. I wouldn’t have read into it that my parents were less blessed or cursed.
id prefer not to have the health conditions that I do. I’d prefer my parents weren’t concerned about my safety now and in future.

language is tricky. Even writing this post some may be offended that I used disabled person rather than person with a disability or maybe additional needs.

Starseeking · 21/04/2022 23:11

His choice of words was unfortunate, but I don't think any harm was meant by it, it sounds like he was acknowledging his fortune in not having extra stress due to supporting DC with additional needs.

My DC has a diagnosis of autism and GDD. At 4, they are not toilet trained, and non-verbal, and cannot be anywhere unaccompanied. My DC doesn't sleep well, so I am usually up 2-3 broken hours every single night, for the last 4 years. Exhausted doesn't quite cut it as a description.

My DC has been under SALT, OT, Physio, ENT, Audiology and Ed Psych at various points of their short life so far.

I've just been through a process of applying for EHCP, during which the needs assessment was originally turned down by the LA. I also had to view various settings to try and decide which would be best for DC.

I have a slightly older DC with no additional needs who I didn't have to battle through any of the above for. Life is much more straightforward and simpler for this DC.

As well as this I am a single parent due to my emotionally abusive EXDP, and I work full-time in a senior level job, so it's only me attending every single appointment and keeping on top of all the professionals (to be fair I also did that by myself when I had DP, as he was useless in that department).

So while very DC is a blessing, it really is a lottery for which DC have additional needs. I think that's what he was trying to express.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 23:09

Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 22:58

No, you've completely missed the point. The irony is you criticising everyone with a faith for being demeaning, belittling, othering and superior whilst being exactly that yourself. Your criticism of others is exactly what you are criticising others for!

dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/irony

No I got that point perfectly well, I just assumed that wasn't the particular point you were making.

Scott Morrison is a prominent politician, I'm not.

If I ever find myself in his shoes I'd like to think that I'd be able to keep my non-belief to myself. It certainly wouldn't have me using ill-advised terms like 'blessed', that when used in specific contexts could be construed as highly offensive.

While I'm aware that I said 'it's adherents' regarding religion, and that could be taken to suggest I meant 'all religious people', what I actually meant is that it's perfectly common to hear someone in a prominent public position say something offensive which clearly stems from their religious belief. At least, I can think of far more of these instances that I can of a similarly prominent public persona saying something offensive which stems from non-belief.

Again, Scott Morrison is in a position where he has a duty of care not to offend people, and if that means keeping his religiosity to himself, that is what he should be doing. My views on religion are neither here nor there, yet I can't imagine how my non-belief would manifest itself in a way that would offend disabled people. Religious people yes, but then if they are going to insist on believing in the ridiculous, then they need to accept that will bring ridicule.

Kanaloa · 21/04/2022 23:02

I should say my son is relatively high functioning, but I still wouldn’t presume to go around saying ‘oh it’s a gift, why are you moaning,’ since I’ve seen the struggle.

Kanaloa · 21/04/2022 23:02

People do love to squash anyone who says things like that though. Can’t count the amount of times someone has forced their way into a group I’m part of to patronisingly say ‘oh no hun autism is a GIFT not a struggle! We should be thankful.’

Normally the parents of high functioning children or high functioning adult diagnosed people themselves. Very rarely the mother of a profoundly autistic adult who will need care all their lives. It’s very patronising and arrogant.

Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 23:01

I wonder if he used the word "privileged" instead of "blessed" people wouldn't be offended?

Kanaloa · 21/04/2022 22:58

I don’t know. I have a ND child but I wouldn’t take offense from this. For me it’s like saying I’ve been ‘blessed with strong healthy children.’

I’m not saying sickly children or children with a physical illness are undesirable and horrible and I hate them. I’m saying that the ideal for most people is to be healthy and not have to have struggles/medical issues.

I don’t think anyone would choose for their
child to struggle through physical disabilities and difficulties or developmental delays. We all want our kids to have as easy a life as possible.

Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 22:58

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:32

'Dark ages nonsense' is a concise way of referring to the parts of religion that require suspension of disbelief, i.e. the parts involving deities, magic, miracles, and so on, the parts that most people don't accept simply because they have the common sense to recognise the ridiculous for what it is.

If pointing out that religions absolutely require acceptance of the incredulous and ridiculous, and also that using the term 'blessed' to create a hierarchy of desirability in human beings is 'ironic', then I think you need to go check the definition of 'irony'.

No, you've completely missed the point. The irony is you criticising everyone with a faith for being demeaning, belittling, othering and superior whilst being exactly that yourself. Your criticism of others is exactly what you are criticising others for!

dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/irony

Butchyrestingface · 21/04/2022 22:50

I have a mild disability. My parents cashed in their winning lottery tickets the day they got me, the lucky, lucky bastards.

Scott Morrison can go fuck himself. 🖕

Dinoteeth · 21/04/2022 22:46

I think he worded it clumsily but we all hope for a healthy child who'll eventually become independent.

I can't imagine anyone would choose to have a child who needs 24/7 care and who'll never become independent.

BTW those families who do have to deal with children / adults with complex needs deserve far more support and restbite than they currently get.

Innocenta · 21/04/2022 22:39

I think it's very understandable for people to be sensitive about a comment directly relating to children.

But that said, as a very seriously disabled adult, I do find it rather ludicrous to pretend that disability is just a neutral thing in life. I suppose that may be true for some people (good for them, if so!), but living with serious illness and severe disability is really, really hard, full of embarrassment and pain and difficulty. And I say that as someone very privileged in many ways, married and with access to relatively good medical care. At a certain level of illness and disability it isn't society, it isn't anything external: it's the impairment itself, and there's nothing wrong with honestly acknowledging that there isn't anything good about it.

Sandra2010 · 21/04/2022 22:36

As parent of disabled child I was a bit pissed off with the inference that she's not a blessing. However, I was more confused as to why he answered a question about disabled children with his own wife and neurotypical children. I mean, why even bring his own family into that? They're not relevant to the question and shouldn't have been part of his non-answer.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:34

Should read -

If pointing out that religions absolutely require acceptance of the incredulous and ridiculous, and also that using the term 'blessed' to create a hierarchy of desirability in human beings is offensive is 'ironic', then I think you need to go check the definition of 'irony'

Scautish · 21/04/2022 22:33

You must be a really special level of thick as fuck of you are unaware of the huge and positive impact ND people have had on society. Really, really fucking thick. This world NEEDS ND people and the incredible technological advances made in the last few centuries would not have been possible without them.

jesus the ableism on this site is beyond depressing.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:32

Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 22:26

Can you not see it?

You've said you're intolerant and unwilling to examine your own prejudices and that religion is "dark ages nonsense" while labelling anyone with a faith as offensive, demeaning, belittling, superior and othering.

'Dark ages nonsense' is a concise way of referring to the parts of religion that require suspension of disbelief, i.e. the parts involving deities, magic, miracles, and so on, the parts that most people don't accept simply because they have the common sense to recognise the ridiculous for what it is.

If pointing out that religions absolutely require acceptance of the incredulous and ridiculous, and also that using the term 'blessed' to create a hierarchy of desirability in human beings is 'ironic', then I think you need to go check the definition of 'irony'.

ImustLearn2Cook · 21/04/2022 22:31

When I take his comments in context of the difficulties, far too many children, adults, families dealing with disability, encounter when seeking support, medical diagnosis/assistance, funding etc. then I do think it is offensive.

I know of cases where parents have their child on a waiting list to see a paediatrician through the public health system and are informed it will be 1 year or more before they can be seen for an initial consultation. That is terrible.

When you are a leader of a country and federal funding is inadequate for supporting people with disabilities then a statement like that is like rubbing salt in a wound.

MangyInseam · 21/04/2022 22:29

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 22:22

Anyway I read his comment as ‘We’ve been blessed to not have to watch our kids struggle’ rather than ‘thank God we have able bodied children, I’m not sure we could’ve loved them if they had been disabled’.

I can’t help but feel all the in-fighting over terminology and nit picking over people’s well intended words actually detracts from the main mission of improving quality of life for disabled people

(I’m disabled, I wish I wasn’t)

Yes.

There seems to be a real desire to assume people mean the worst thing.

People do not always say things as if they had a speech writer, and a talented one, producing their every word and checking it for any possible reading that could be negative. No one can speak that way all the time.

Moppincraxy · 21/04/2022 22:26

Can you not see it?

You've said you're intolerant and unwilling to examine your own prejudices and that religion is "dark ages nonsense" while labelling anyone with a faith as offensive, demeaning, belittling, superior and othering.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 22:23

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 22:20

I just wonder if you would’ve been so open with your critique had this been another religion. Always Christianity where people suddenly feel bold enough to say things like this, isn’t it?

Yes I absolutely would have. I hold all organised religion in complete contempt. Christianity comes up more frequently simply because it's the predominant religion of the English speaking world, but they're all pretty much of a muchness.