Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Scott Morrison didn’t say anything wrong?

158 replies

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 21:28

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-61171449.amp

I heard this being discussed on Shelagh Fogarty this afternoon. I don’t think he’s said anything wrong. What do you think?

OP posts:
Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 07:12

But it wasn’t ‘outright offensive’ was it? Are there no shades of grey any more? Outright offensive would’ve been what @ITSupport said earlier in the thread. I get a bit tired of the worst possible inference being taken from normal speech.

Very few (if any) people would actively choose a disabled child in the abstract aka if they could pick the characteristics of a future child. That isnt at odds with having a disabled child and loving them and valuing them every bit as much as an able bodied child.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 07:07

If you’re comparing Scott Morrison’s comment to Hitler and his eugenicist death camps, you’ve absolutely lost the plots and have no business in debate

Just as well I'm not then, isn't it?

That was entirely a point about the difference between politicians saying things people do not agree with, and saying things that are outright offensive to specific groups. It was to emphasise the difference between the two. At no point have I made any comparison between Morrison, or anything he said, and Adolf Hitler, and I'm a bit confused as to how that thought would even enter your head if I'm honest.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 07:04

What he said would have been exactly what 99.9% of the population would say

I disagree. I think that most people would realise that bringing up the fact you have two able bodied children is in no way relevant to the issue, and would have had the sense not to say anything about that at all.

It relates to disability. Any disabled person is entitled to an opinion

Agreed, and I did not mean to imply that this is a matter exclusively for the parents of disabled children to offer an opinion on, though I can see why my post might have suggested I thought as much. Apologies, I should have made that much clearer.

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 07:03

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 04:37

but people will find offense in anything if they want to

Maybe Morrison should have thought about the language he was using then, and given the perpetually offended no ammunition?

Funny thing about offence. It's not within the gift of people other than the intended target to decide whether something is offensive or not. That's why I don't, as a white person, generally go around telling black people whether they should be offended by something or not, and I wouldn't dream of telling them that they are probably just guilty of looking for offence where none is intended.

Morrison's comment relates specifically to parenthood, and implies that parents of NT/able bodied children are 'blessed'. By definition, that comment also relates to parents of ND and disabled children, so I really think unless you fall into that demographic, it's not for you to judge whether what SM said is offensive or not.

Plenty of people in this particular demographic are unhappy and offended by what he said, so that in and of itself is a pretty good indicator that what he said was offensive.

I’m not even sure they are, it seems to just be people taking offence on their behalf.

I'm disabled, I wish I wasn’t, my disability causes me pain and interferes with living a normal life. I wouldn’t want this for my kids, and I make no bones of that.

OP posts:
Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 07:00

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 23:41

There's a gulf between 'not being offensive' and not saying this that someone else doesn't like. Surely you don't need me to spell that out?

As a politician he's invariably going to say things that some people won't 'like', that goes hand-in-hand with politics and is true of all politicians. He still absolutely has a duty of care not to be outright offensive. That's true of all people, not just politicians, but it's especially the case with elected officials and those in positions of responsibility.

Presumably you think there was nothing wrong with anything Adolf Hitler said in his speeches then? After all, what does it matter if he was offensive. By your logic that's just people 'not liking' what he said.

Of course Morrison has a duty of care. To suggest he doesn't is ridiculous.

If you’re comparing Scott Morrison’s comment to Hitler and his eugenicist death camps, you’ve absolutely lost the plots and have no business in debate.

OP posts:
Innocenta · 22/04/2022 06:58

For some reason the site ate my post. I was saying that on a topic related to disability, Amy disabled person is entitled to an opinion. It's weird to try and gatekeep it to just parents of disabled children, and honestly makes me think you want to silence the disabled people commenting on the thread who are disagreeing with you...

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 06:54

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

but people will find offense in anything if they want to

Maybe Morrison should have thought about the language he was using then, and given the perpetually offended no ammunition?

Funny thing about offence. It's not within the gift of people other than the intended target to decide whether something is offensive or not. That's why I don't, as a white person, generally go around telling black people whether they should be offended by something or not, and I wouldn't dream of telling them that they are probably just guilty of looking for offence where none is intended.

Morrison's comment relates specifically to parenthood, and implies that parents of NT/able bodied children are 'blessed'. By definition, that comment also relates to parents of ND and disabled children, so I really think unless you fall into that demographic, it's not for you to judge whether what SM said is offensive or not.

Plenty of people in this particular demographic are unhappy and offended by what he said, so that in and of itself is a pretty good indicator that what he said was offensive.

It relates to disability. Any disabled person is entitled to an opinion.
hattie43 · 22/04/2022 06:38

@carefullycourageous

Well clearly a lot of people were unhappy with his remarks as Morrison has had a backlash, it is not what '99.9%' of the population would say.

Also, the way we talk about things evolves.

Morrison is a clumsy arse, he is always offending people. I think generally he should be more careful.

I agree language has evolved ... but only to be not allowed to say anything at all. I'm sure he has offended the wokerati but then who doesn't . How many times does the conversation go on hearing the news of a pregnancy , oh congratulations what are you hoping for , oh we don't mind as long as they're healthy . I am sure he didn't mean to offend , any child is a gift but I'm sure people would prefer the child not too have disabilities. You'd have to be some kind of selfish to be happy a child has a potential life of pain , surgeries , limited abilities etc . Parents will love any child but I'm sure before the arrival they'd hope it was healthy . Having seen first hand my aunts struggle I can see the impact not just on her but the subsequent children that came after . They are the ones who suffered with reduced personal attention , no quiet spaces , where they lived , the holidays they couldn't take the meals out they couldn't have etc etc . There is very little respite for families and that should change to give more support .
carefullycourageous · 22/04/2022 06:26

hattie43 · 22/04/2022 05:57

Why do we have to micro analyse every single word someone says these days and put our own interpretation on it to fit our own agenda .
What he said would have been exactly what 99.9% of the population would say .

He felt blessed / lucky he hadn't had to cope with disabled children as would 99.9% of the population .

My aunt had a disabled child and he has determined every single thing her family has done . Would she have preferred he be able bodied , absolutely she would . There is nothing wrong with that .

Well clearly a lot of people were unhappy with his remarks as Morrison has had a backlash, it is not what '99.9%' of the population would say.

Also, the way we talk about things evolves.

Morrison is a clumsy arse, he is always offending people. I think generally he should be more careful.

hattie43 · 22/04/2022 05:57

Why do we have to micro analyse every single word someone says these days and put our own interpretation on it to fit our own agenda .
What he said would have been exactly what 99.9% of the population would say .

He felt blessed / lucky he hadn't had to cope with disabled children as would 99.9% of the population .

My aunt had a disabled child and he has determined every single thing her family has done . Would she have preferred he be able bodied , absolutely she would . There is nothing wrong with that .

LimeSegment · 22/04/2022 05:46

He is so tone deaf and constantly brings his own family in to it, as lovelacementioned above, he once made a speech about how now he understands rape is bad because he asked his wife and she explained it to him 🙄 Just one reason the 2021 Australian of the Year Grace Tame, advocate and sexual assault survivor, hates him.

I actually agree that on paper what he said wasn't that bad, if a bit tone deaf. I think why people are interpreting it another way, is that knowing how religious he is and the type of religion he follows (evangelical Christian), its easy to think he probably did mean it in a bad way. He probably does think God blessed him and cursed others.

TravelDreamLife · 22/04/2022 05:44

Oh, yes. Forgot. National DIsability Insurance Scheme. My DS is on it. I've been told to expect a 50% cut in his plan later this year after SCOMO set his razor gang onto it. Apparently he'll be 10 then & should have all the tools he needs for life by then.

SD1978 · 22/04/2022 05:40

The wording used was wrong- absolutely- but I defy any parent, way back at the beginning, given a choice between a child with no concerns, and one with, would jump up and down and say ooh, me, me please. Are we grateful for the children we have? Absolutely. Would we wish things easier for them in the future if they didn't have to face the challenges some of them do? Absolutely. Does this mean they are not loved? Not at all. It was offence for the sake of taking offence.

TravelDreamLife · 22/04/2022 05:39

You're just hurting your brains interpreting what ScoMo says. He does this so often it's almost a national sport. He even forcibly shook a woman's hand who has just lost her home in the bushfires while she tried to tell him they needed help, not a pollie photo op. Wasn't listening to a damn thing she said.

Look up some of the times he's made gaffes on women's issues.

He's just clueless.

StrangerYears · 22/04/2022 05:31

ScoMo is well known for being an arse.
He was in Hawaii when Australia was burning (Jan just before Covid). He does not seem to understand what is important.
He is an arse of the highest order.
The NDIS (disability support financial aid) has been severely cut under his rule.
People are really struggling to get financial support for their kids. My mate has lost 50pct of previous support for her son with severe needs.
Most people here with children who have additional needs are pissed off to the highest order.
our Australian of the Year is a Para-Olympian (in a wheelchair) - you think its going in the right direction, Then...wham- ScoMo opens his mouth.

He was know as 'Scotty from Marketing' as all is did was talk, but even his marketing skills have been lost

LovelaceBiggWither · 22/04/2022 05:26

Man's a wanker who shouldn't be allowed to speak in public as he says such ghastly things. This is the man who had to ask Jenny if rape was bad and he apparently now knows it is because she told him to think of their daughters being raped...

Combining this blessed nonsense with the underhand slashing of NDIS funding and he looks very bad indeed.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 04:37

but people will find offense in anything if they want to

Maybe Morrison should have thought about the language he was using then, and given the perpetually offended no ammunition?

Funny thing about offence. It's not within the gift of people other than the intended target to decide whether something is offensive or not. That's why I don't, as a white person, generally go around telling black people whether they should be offended by something or not, and I wouldn't dream of telling them that they are probably just guilty of looking for offence where none is intended.

Morrison's comment relates specifically to parenthood, and implies that parents of NT/able bodied children are 'blessed'. By definition, that comment also relates to parents of ND and disabled children, so I really think unless you fall into that demographic, it's not for you to judge whether what SM said is offensive or not.

Plenty of people in this particular demographic are unhappy and offended by what he said, so that in and of itself is a pretty good indicator that what he said was offensive.

starrynight21 · 22/04/2022 04:08

He said he was blessed to have his two daughters and that they didn't have the struggles which disabled people might have. The Australian of the Year, who has a disability, got very angry , taking it as an insult to all disabled people. I don't personally think that ScoMo said anything insulting - but people will find offense in anything if they want to.

GCautist · 22/04/2022 04:06

I don’t know who he is but I feel as a multi-disabled person and the mother of a ND child and with a ND partner, that I have a voice in the matter.

As a disabled person i understand how cutting it is when others use language that make you feel devalued and when society is set up to exclude you, that just exacerbates the hurt and exclusion. I understand why interpretations of the comment are assuming it’s covert negativity.

That said I won’t pretend I don’t hate having disabilities or that I’d rather I didn’t have any . I hate the pain and discomfort of chronic illness and the restrictions it places upon my life and the lives of my family. I also don’t feel my being neurodivergent is a gift on the whole, although there are elements I do believe I benefit from. I actually really like who I am as a person but others don’t and many of the autism issues I struggle with aren’t related to society or socialising so I can’t say society changing would help make my autistic life better. I worry for my child growing up as their experience mirrors mine from decades before (I pinned my hopes on my mum saying my child is a different person and will have different experiences - still waiting for that as so far they’re identical) and I worry about the misery they may experience if that continues. My partner has adhd and I see how he struggles daily with it and he wishes he didn’t have it. He has no control over it and medication makes him physically unwell. He can’t win. None of us are savants, we’re not making world changing inventions or technological advances, we struggle through life with a lot of support from our families. If I could then I probably would choose to be able bodied and neurotypical and I’d want the same for my family too. That’s not ableism, it’s not a response to ableism. It’s wanting an easier life.

PomPomtheGreat · 22/04/2022 03:34

This comment might have gone down differently over here if he hadn't cheerfully slashed NDIS and wasn't a huge subscriber to the prosperity gospel cult. And locked up asylum seekers for years while constantly burbling on about Jen and the girls and how important their future is.

www.abc.net.au/news/2022-03-06/biloela-family-speaks-on-fourth-anniversary-of-start-of-ordeal/100885888

And if he hadn't had to be allocated an empathy coach when he became PM because he's so tone deaf and completely unable to look past himself and his own family.

MummyGummy · 22/04/2022 03:21

RichPetunia · 22/04/2022 02:45

Let's be realistic. Would you rather have a child with or without special needs? To say you are blessed to have a child without special needs is just giving thanks and acknowledging your relief that everything's gone smoothly and to plan.

I would without a doubt rather have MY child, not some idealised fantasy child.

It’s an insult and completely insensitive to parents who love and are as grateful for their children as anyone else, regardless of their abilities.

ArcheryAnnie · 22/04/2022 03:10

I'm disabled. I'm posting at 3 am because I'm in too much pain to sleep. I wasn't born disabled, but I am aware of a lot of the language issues about how we speak about disability. Nevertheless I would consider myself blessed if these bloody conditions went away. Doesn't mean that I am cursed, or worth less than other people.

DailySheetWasher · 22/04/2022 03:09

It's hard for me not to be biased by how much I hate SM.

But even trying to put the best possible spin on what he said I'm left wondering why he felt the need to point out his kids don't have special needs... why is that relevant and how is that in any way an empathetic response to someone who does?

And, have others have pointed out, his government is wholly responsible for many of the struggles parents of SN children face in accessing support, thanks to its mismanagement and cost cutting of the NDIS.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 02:57

I think “well what about the other poor buggers, did they not deserve to have someone looking out for them?

It's always amused me when athletes and sportsmen leave the field after a victory and immediately credit 'God' with giving them the strength/ability/fortune to win. Presumably God isn't a fan of the vanquished opponents then, or perhaps they didn't pray hard enough, or maybe God just had a bet on you winning and didn't fancy losing a few bob?

Ozgirl75 · 22/04/2022 02:53

He has always worn his religious beliefs very openly and actually although he isn’t all that popular over here at the moment, I understand he’s a very warm and caring person. The family who lost three of their children in a terrible accident have spoken about how he has given them a huge amount of support behind the scene s.
Equally, we all say things that can be construed differently. Personally I think saying you’re blessed not to have a disabled child is awkward as it does suggest that people who have a disabled child haven’t been “blessed” but equally I find it a bit weird when people say “someone was looking out for me when I overslept and missed that plane that crashed” because I think “well what about the other poor buggers, did they not deserve to have someone looking out for them?” but equally I think it’s just one of those things that people say.
I honestly don’t think he would have meant it in a “thank god I don’t have to deal with this” - they’ve been through their own issues with infertility etc as well.